Casey&#x27;s Pizza

I have wanted to try their pizza for a long time and last night was the night…read more Wow, did they not disappoint, I only wish I lived closer to make this a regular stop. The food, atmosphere and staff were great. Do not compare this to your local pizza shop that's perfectly round and got even toppings. This had to be one of the best pizza experiences since I toured Italy & Sicily. Go hungry and you will still leave with leftovers

Wow! Simply some of the best pizza in the area. I love me some pizza, if we lived closer this would…read morebe the weekly answer of what's for dinner. First we ordered the garlic knots. So much to say. Actually should be called garlic loaves. They are delicious, with no shortage of garlic, butter and parm. Delicious. Second the pizza was better than it looks and it looked delicious. The pizza is not shrinking like most places and they believe in toppings. We got: 1. EBUT large 2. Spinach and Tomato large 3. BBQ Chicken large 4. Pepperoni large We could have feed 18 people. Honestly some of the best pizza I have ever had. I will be making the trip to try more on the menu. If you live near Shelly Pie GO! Heck if you are passing by and need dinner or lunch GO! Actually if you have to go out of the way GO!

Bar

Fried Beer Battered Cod

See all

Broccoli Bacon Cheddar Puffs

Vincent's Pizza Park

3.9(229 reviews)

1.2 mi

The best pizza since 1953! There is no equal in the pizza game anywhere. Even the takeout wrapping…read moreis unique!

My first time having Vincent's pizza! When I picked it up, took it home, and opened it, I felt like…read moreI was unwrapping a present. I got a small pizza and it was HUGE! Enough to feed 3 people! I was always wary of Vincent's because I was told the grease was outrageous, and honestly, it was greasy but not nearly as bad as I was "preparing" for. The toppings were generous and the pizza was delicious! I ordered takeout (they are cash only - FYI) and it was ready in about 20 minutes. I did eat it a little later after it had cooled and I think that was the right move because I was able to eat it just fine with a fork and knife. Now that I know what I was missing I will definitely be back soon!

Small pepperoni and sausage pizza

See all

Med Pizza, Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, and Banana Peppers

Asti's Italian Steakhouse

4.4(38 reviews)

1.6 mi

Super nice staff. Great service…read more Food was excellent! Plus they offer gluten free options. Which is difficult to find. My gluten free, oreo cheesecake was one of the best desserts I have had in my life. I almost bought a whole pie! Would 1000% come back! Chicken blackened pasta GF 8. 5/10 (Pasta was excellent. Chicken was a bit dry) Crab Bisque 10/10 (lots of crab) Salad 9/10 (very fresh) Oreo cheesecake GF 11/10

Asti's doesn't fit any one category. It's a wonderful venue for celebrations like a shower,…read morebirthday party, etc. it's also a great bar to watch the Steelers (hopefully win) while enjoying a drink and some good food. It's also a good place for lunch or dinner. They can accommodate groups in their party room, back room, or dining area. We had a group of 15 for lunch, and we had a wonderful view of the city of Pittsburgh in the distance. Service is friendly and parking is free.

Nice clubhouse.

Maple-bourbon salmon with vegetables and pasta

See all

4th of July Fireworks 2024 outing.

Fellinis Pizzeria

3.4(5 reviews)

0.1 mi

Late night Pizza! We wanted to try something we hadn't had before. Friendly phone service! Quick…read moreand hot pizza. I liked the pepperoni/mushroom pizza !! The whole Italian hoagie was good as well. They have several other locations. Highly recommend ! We will order again !!

Ordered food from here with a group of friends Sunday. It was my first time. We got a special with…read morea pizza, Italian hoagie, wings, and a 2 liter. I don't eat meat so I personally did not eat the hoagie or wings. The others said the hoagie was good. However it seemed everyone wished the wings were crispy and that they would have been better then. The pizza was okay. Nothing special. The sauce was sweet without a lot else going on. Personally I would have liked the pizza to be cooked another minute or two. I may try it again, I may not. There are certainly a lot of choices around for pizza.

Thursday pickup Special, Xtra Large w/1 topping and a 2 liter for $14 plus tax.

See all

Fox's Pizza Den

2.8(13 reviews)

0.1 mi

Can't beat the big daddy at Foxes Pizza Den in Turtle Creek PA quick and easy pick up right near…read moreKeystone Commons

UPDATE REVIEW : 12-19-2019 Giving Fox's another try despite…read morefor something different. It was easy fast and simple to order online & pay. We chose to pick up. The order was very good. The pizza was a little too toasty for my taste. The Italian hoagie was good or descent in a generic kinda way. The Stromboli was okay lacking something that I can't put my finger on. I would recommend in desperation but I won't be a soon repeat customer.

See all

Pizza Palermo

2.1(29 reviews)

0.2 mi

Pizza Palermo has the best VEGGIE HOAGIES!!! I ever had. The veggies are so tender and juicy ty so…read moremuch

I ordered my pizza on line and asked for well done. it arrived in 15 minutes and the bottom crust…read moreof my pizza was gummy falling apart and needed cooked. It's a thin crust there's no excuse for it to not be fully cooked! Just terrible!

Pizza Palermo

Philly Cheesesteak

See all

Bread Sticks

Papa Johns Pizza

2.5(2 reviews)

1.7 mi

New to the Braddock Hills, Forest Hills area. We saw an add to try the new bowls! I was pleasantly…read moresurprised. A really nice clean store, friendly service. The chicken Alfredo Bowl was very good, a bit to greasy, but good flavor and taste. Plenty of chicken and cheese and vegetables. The Italian bowl was a bit to zippy for my taste but for those that love spicy it's good! Highly recommend!

Order a pizza for delivery around 6:30pm and waited for it to come and around 9:16pm they just told…read moreme they canceled my order for delivery

Your choice of crust covered with our signature pizza sauce, real cheese made from mozzarella, and pepperoni...

Juicy all-white meat chicken, lightly breaded with hints of parmesan and pepper and oven-baked to a crispy golden brown...

See all

Eight sweet bites of OREO® Cookie wrapped in our original fresh dough and drizzled in icing...

Pizza Hut

1.3(40 reviews)

1.5 mi

I will never order from Pizza Hut again. Their service and customer service are absolutely…read morehorrible. They are scamming people who order through Uber Eats and DoorDash by sending out old, stale food that should not even be served. I paid good money for a fresh meal, but instead, I got food that looked and tasted like it had been sitting out for hours. The worst part is that my 4-year-old daughter got sick after eating it. That is completely unacceptable. I tried to reach out to their customer service, and instead of owning up to it, they were rude and unhelpful. Pizza Hut should be ashamed of themselves for serving unsafe food and treating paying customers this way. I wouldn't recommend this location to anyone. Save your money, time, and health -- go somewhere that actually cares about quality and customer safety.

I ordered a pizza through the Pizza Hut app and despite coming on time via DoorDash, the pizza came…read moreabsolutely SWIMMING in some sort of watery liquid in the center to the point where the entire center of the pizza seems almost raw and doughy and the cheese and toppings are dripping right off. I tried to call the store 5 times to complain but there was no answer. This store CONSISTENTLY does not answer the phone.

See all

Domino's Pizza

1.9(59 reviews)

1.3 mi

Just loucy Went to wrong address By time I got it was cold Bought there for years Got drivers not…read moreknowing where the hell they at

The delivery was on time. The delivery driver thought I was coming outside to get the pizza.. if…read morethat was the case, I would have picked up! The pizza was good...but I paid for a specialty and it wasn't.

Cheesy pizza From domions

Garlic parm sauce with pineapple and jalapeño. one of the best combo

See all

Bob the Raptor says "Pizza Prey."

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Eric E.

13

8

1

8 years ago

Perhaps if you're a "local?" This spot seems to have great potential as a lovely out-of-the-way place to perhaps grab a bite to eat. However, inexplicably, they seem to enjoy making it clear that it's locals/regulars only welcomed here. The ordering experience should best be left to those without any questions. This is made remarkably more difficult because they have a minimal web presence. However, we chose to overlook these faults of theirs. That was, admittedly, our mistake. Our party decided to pop in, despite 'knowing better' than to even try to "customize" any menu items based on previous, horrible experiences along this trip in the Pittsburgh, PA area. This time, we simply asked what was included on the given menu offering. None of us have "restrictions," per se, we were merely curious. Violation! The waitstaff actually let out an exasperated sigh upon our very first question. We've travelled through countless countries without issue, but this simple question was enough to present an issue. Is this customary in the United States of America? Is it merely localized to Pittsburgh, PA? Why were we subjected to such treatment for merely asking a question? While, yes, your establishment chose to fully earn this solid, poor two-star rating, this singular experience will not mar our overall trip. Hopefully, this will prove to be a learning moment to your staff. Each and every chance to offer exemplary service should be made to count. read more

Cheryl L.

0

6

0

11 years ago

Use caution with this pizza shop. I went onto the allegheny county health department site and they had multiple health code violations just issued in January this year. Knowing this, I will not order anything from them. Not a very clean establishment and lacking in maintaining foods at safe temperatures among other things. Please be careful if you eat here. read more

Amanda M.

45

2

0

11 years ago

Absolutely amazing food.. family owned pizza place.. Been around for 30 years..Very reasonable prices, they even offer free delivery, no other place around delivers free, they run their ad in the penny saver every week we order every week.. Always consistent and friendly service... Chocolate chip cookies the are very good. read more

Christina S.

289

4

0

9 years ago

This is our family's new favorite pizza place! Since we moved 3 months ago we have ordered here at least once a week. Their food is great! The white pizza is the best in Pittsburgh! We love it! Their specials make it very affordable for a big family like ours to eat for under $20. read more

V C.

0

5

0

11 years ago

Not from around the area of this pizza shop and was heading to Monroeville. Stopped in to check it out. It looked dirty and the employees were handling food without gloves. NO THANK YOU!! I left without ordering. read more

Jane L.

1

14

0

9 years ago

I like pizza that is hot, cheese ripping apart, crust nice in thick! This is the place to get that! And it's not to saucy, and it's affordable. They gyros are tastes as well read more

Nicole C.

0

7

0

12 years ago

I would never order her again. Bad quality cheap food. Restaurant look dirty. Health dept should show up. Employess are dirty.

Diane S.

0

19

0

11 years ago

If you like unwashed hands handling cross-contaminated food, this place is for you. An added bonus is the rudeness of the staff.

Kelli M.

0

2

0

11 years ago

Its defies reason how one establishment could employ so many rude people. I wont be returning.

Casey's Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Casey's Pizza also viewed

Carol of Casey's Pizza

3.2

(44 reviews)

Located in Penn Hills Shopping Center. A "Sister" store of Casey's Pizza in Turtle Creek, along…read morePenn Ave. Great quality and always consistent quality of food. Delicious pizza, oven baked hoagies, calzones, wings, tenders, salads, pasta, and more. A few tables inside for Dine-in but mostly a takeout and delivery location. Delivery available. Always timely delivery and good drivers. Food is still hot when it arrives. The drivers are always courteous and friendly. The dough is homemade and always consistent. The sauce is flavorful with the perfect amount of tang and flavor. The bread comes from Mancini's Bakery in Pittsburgh. A highly popular and well known bakery with a delicious bread recipe. Highly recommended! A must try! Cheers!!

Great pizza. Great chicken parm. Meatball sub was okay. Too much sauce. Excellent customer service…read moreon both the phone and by the delivery person.

Shelly Pie

4.0

(287 reviews)

I have wanted to try their pizza for a long time and last night was the night…read more Wow, did they not disappoint, I only wish I lived closer to make this a regular stop. The food, atmosphere and staff were great. Do not compare this to your local pizza shop that's perfectly round and got even toppings. This had to be one of the best pizza experiences since I toured Italy & Sicily. Go hungry and you will still leave with leftovers

Wow! Simply some of the best pizza in the area. I love me some pizza, if we lived closer this would…read morebe the weekly answer of what's for dinner. First we ordered the garlic knots. So much to say. Actually should be called garlic loaves. They are delicious, with no shortage of garlic, butter and parm. Delicious. Second the pizza was better than it looks and it looked delicious. The pizza is not shrinking like most places and they believe in toppings. We got: 1. EBUT large 2. Spinach and Tomato large 3. BBQ Chicken large 4. Pepperoni large We could have feed 18 people. Honestly some of the best pizza I have ever had. I will be making the trip to try more on the menu. If you live near Shelly Pie GO! Heck if you are passing by and need dinner or lunch GO! Actually if you have to go out of the way GO!

Pasquale's Pizzeria

3.3

(44 reviews)

Our pizza was so dry! It was like it had been sitting around for a while. They have young kids…read moreworking there with poor customer service skills. Would not recommend.

Usually consistent. Tonight order was wrong and missing items. Pizza stunk tonight as well…read more Bought a full Sicilian.

La Bella Pizza and Gyro

4.2

(21 reviews)

Our go to pizza shop went out of business. We were looking for a new neighborhood/family run pizza…read moreshop. We drove past La Bella Pizza and Gyro on Saw Mill Run Blvd and decided to give it a try. We ordered and picked it up. It was clean inside. The pizza was done pretty quick and the owner friendly. He said he hoped we liked the pizza and recommended that we try the gyros next visit. We did love the pizza, tasted like garlic butter was brushed on the crust! Yum!

Pizza dough soggy and raw, uncooked for sure. Obviously can not handle busy nights. Was told 45 to…read more50 min delivery time and received a cold pizza 1.5 hrs . Yuk!!

Pizza Marsala

3.1

(64 reviews)

What a great and highly underrated spot! The employees there are very friendly, contrary to some of…read morethe reviews on Google and Yelp. Today, I got the cheese calzone, fried dough, and cannolis. They were all delicious. Their calzones are only around $10 for a plain cheese. And, the portion is quite big too. It's not too doughy and their dough is flavorful and delicious. It looks like they top their calzones with a good bit of butter. It may look a bit soggy on the bottom, but the flavor is still excellent. Their sauce is lightly sweet and goes perfectly with the cheese. It's packed well and is the perfect amount of cheese for a calzone. Would have liked a bit more ricotta specifically and maybe a side dipping sauce, but still amazing! The desserts are pretty good too. Some of them are (as expected) not made in house, but others like the cinnamon rolls and fried dough are. When I ordered, I initially switched one of my desserts for the other. But, they just gave me the other dessert for free! Very considerate. The cannolis, although partially premade, were still quite tasty. Good amount of filling, great texture, adequate amount of chocolate chips inside, crispy outside, and nice chocolate cover. Their fried dough is also tasty and similar to a funnel cake. Would have maybe liked a sweet sauce (like caramel or chocolate) with the fried dough, but I had some leftover caramel to use so no issues there. All in all, a very good stop for pizza in Monroeville. It seems extremely underrated, and I was the only person to be in the store at the time (and my order was the only one for pick up at that time, which was Labor Day weekend). This place needs some more pizza and calzone loving visitors!

so after waiting 2 hours for my delivery I knew my food was going to be cold. I did call after 1.5…read morehours to see where it was and he assured me it was out for delivery. 35 minutes later he brought it himself and apologized and offered me only free dessert next time!!! My pizza was cold and old. it was a white pizza that was supposed to have tomatoes on it but there were none. the wings were only warm and there were tomatoes on the hoagie that I asked for no tomatoes. I did ask for EXTRA CHEESE and there was no cheese at all!!!! this is unacceptable! I think I should be entitled to a full refund. Never again:(

Pizza Palermo

3.1

(124 reviews)

Pizza Palermo has been a favorite for years. The food is excellent…read more Unfortunately, there are a couple of staff members now who really have turned me off from going in. One man, one woman, possibly related? The guy is especially miserable. He always has something snarky to say. Most recently he told me to "use your words" as I was waiting patiently for him to finish kneading dough! Definitely not customer service oriented.

This has usually been our favorite pizza place since we stumbled upon it last year, which is why…read morethis experience was so disappointing. I ordered about two days ago and spent around $65. Unfortunately, the food arrived very cold and tasted old. The pizza was very well done and didn't seem fresh at all. The wings were especially bad--the BBQ sauce was watery and were very hard. Too hard in fact for my family to even finish. Ohhh and the friessss-ugh you shouldn't even sell these to be perfectly honest. Overall, the meal just wasn't good. I didn't call the same day because I wasn't feeling well and my family started eating before I saw what was delivered, but I still wanted to share this experience because it's not the quality I'm used to from them. I really hope this was just an off day, because we've had great experiences here in the past. I'd love to see them get back to the standard that made us loyal customers. I also asked for plates and napkins which were options available on the menu and did not receive them. Also which I thought was very strange is that the delivery guy approached the door and then turned to leave when he heard music (the kids were having a 60 second dance party) and then didn't actually deliver the food until 5/10 minutes later. The entire experience is a 2/10. I highly doubt we will be ordering again for a long while.

Pesaro's Pizza

3.5

(20 reviews)

Good enough. This place is nearby and under new ownership (apparently?) so we gave it a try and…read moreordered some pizzas and a salad. The pizzas were generally good but could have used a little more browning in the oven, particularly for the vegetable toppings. The dough was somewhat thick, but not otherwise noteworthy. The greek salad was fine but uninspired: it was overwhelmed by pita wedges but the vegetables were generally fresh. The shop itself is entirely set up for takeout, complete with coolers full of bottled soda. All told, this is a decent place to pick up some pizzas if you're nearby and not looking for something exceptional.

My fiancé and I called for takeout on a Friday evening and was told it would be about 30 min wait…read more We had a coupon for $22 large pizza & breadsticks, and we also got an order of mozzarella sticks. We topped our pizza with pepperoni & banana peppers. We really enjoyed the pizza - the crust was fluffy which I love. The mozzarella sticks were basic but tasty. The breadsticks were good; they were soft but I wish they'd had a little more seasoning. Would definitely order again - it's a solid meal, and it's close to where we live!

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

3.5

(155 reviews)

I go to Anthonys to get the pizza, wings and the best salad anywhere. Their house salad has the…read moremost refreshing dressing I have ever experienced. I really enjoy the coal fired pizza, it is unique and memorable. Prices are fair and service has always been good

Just had a terrible experience at this restaurant after patronizing it for 2 yrs. I did not know…read moreWashington County Health Department allowed restaurants to have dogs in the establishment. The waitress walked a customer through the restaurant to the patio area. The customer had the dog on the table and then walked the dog to relieve itself in the grassy area next to the patio. I could not eat the rest of my food. Joc___n told other customers I was upset. One of the customers started taking photos of me, pointing and laughing with the 2 other patrons at her table. This woman then came over to my table and was verbally abusive. It was a nightmare experience. BTW: had ordered the 2 meatball appetizer and it was delivered to me in less than 2 minutes. Obviously, it was already prepared and heated in a microwave! I have actually defended Anthony's when other negative reviews were posted on the Peter's Township site. I now get the bad reviews. At least I know I am not alone in having a terrible experience at this establishment.

Luciano's Pizza & Six Pack To Go

3.3

(60 reviews)

My family has been visiting Luciano's for a long time now, and we always have a good experience…read more This particular visit, we came on a rainy Friday evening in May. Luciano's is located in Bethel Park in the middle of a quiet neighborhood. There is indoor seating, as well as carry out available. It is not huge on the inside, but there are probably at least 10 tables. On this day, it was not too crowded and we got a table right away. Our server was attentive to us and did a good job at taking our special request order correctly. Whenever we needed something, she provided it quickly. There were four of us total, so we decided to order the two Large 16" Pizzas special for $36.50. We were able to order one of those as a Traditional Pizza Half Plain and Half Pepperoni, and then a White Pizza, with a special request of putting the tomatoes on top of the cheese instead of underneath. We also got the Zucchini Planks to share as an appetizer. We enjoyed the zucchini before the pizzas came out. Some of them were sort of small, but there was definitely enough for the four of us to share. It came with a marinara sauce to dip. Our pizzas came out relatively quickly. We have always loved their pizza, and this time was no different. Both the White Pizza and the Traditional were hot and cooked perfectly. The pizza is not Thu. crust, but also not extremely bread-heavy, either. A perfect medium that will satisfy most parties. There was plenty for all of us to eat, and we had some leftovers to take home. I thought the value for what we got was great. With the pizza deal, the bill came to less than $50 for the four of us to eat. And we all had enough to eat with plenty left for leftovers. As usual, we had a great experience at Luciano's. We will definitely be back, as this is one of our go-to pizza spots in the South Hills!

Great pizza! Fast and friendly service. A hidden gem, definately worth visiting! We had the thick…read morecut square pizza and it was terrific!

Paisano's

3.8

(50 reviews)