Shelly Pie

2

60

1

5 days ago

I want to address some of the negative reviews: I've eaten at Shelly's at least fifty times. It's a style of pizza you will probably only find in Pittsburgh... so choose NOT to compare it to "what you're used to"... second: tell them "how you like your pizza" (underdone, done just right, well-done)... they will oblige! This is a small business and YELP reviews make a difference. Be kind if the pizza isn't what you've "expected" Again, you won't find this style outside of the Pittsburgh area... understand your icons! Third: toppings are not methodically distributed like Dominoes: so the plus side is you often get "more" ... just because there's 10 pieces of pepperoni on one slice and four on another is part of the fun!! Shelly's never gets enough credit because Turtle Creek is off the beaten 'burgh.... Let's support this great iconic Pittsburgh restaurant!!!! One of my biggest regrets moving away from Pittsburgh is moving away from the greatest hidden pizza gems in America... yes I love Pepe's and John's of Bleecker, I love Malnatis and Gino's East... but you can take a Pittsburgh Pizza boy out of the city... you just can't take Pittsburgh Pizza outta the boy! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Wow… reviews like this truly mean the world to us.…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ricardo S.

4

31

123

4 months ago

So as I said, in my other post that I judge a place by whether or NOT my dollars and feet will return, and as I said, my dollars and feet would be back to Shelley Park. I came this evening with a party of eight and they had more than ample space. Our waitstaff, a young lady named tabby was excellent! She took everyone's order with surgical precision, nothing was wrong. Everything came out piping hot, and it was excellent. The food met AND exceeded everyone's expectations and like I said the waitstaff was great. One of the people in my party had another pizza and Isaiah knocked it OUT-OF-THE-PARK AGAIN!! two times in a row kudos Isaiah Kudos. The ambiance was great, they have multiple T. V's with a variety of programming that should appeal to mostly every personality. The playlist was very eclectic and had me tapping my toes. . Like I said last time, I want to compliment the management because the management here have empowered. The staff to be in a word...... Phenomenal. As I said before my dollars and my feet will be here again Shelley pie take care and have a great rest of the day. read more

Shelly Pie - Cheeseburger soup - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Pretzel pizza - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Fish sandwich and fries with a side of pierogies - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Flaming hot wings and the famous fish sandwich - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - A plate of goodness - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Italian Hoagie - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much. We do love the amazing feedback. We really do…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kat Y.

0

24

54

8 days ago

Everything was delicious! We tried pizza with sausage, Reuben sandwich, and white pizza with spinach & tomatoes. It was the best red sauce I've ever had. It had a slight hint of sweetness but not too much. I usually don't even like red sauce pizza. The sausage was spicy and big clumps of it! The Reuben was saucy and delicious. I will definitely be back. Service was great too. It was definitely a hometown feel. read more

Shelly Pie - White pizza & sausage pizza - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We’re so happy to hear…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom C.

4

128

132

1 month ago

Great service from Tabby and the pizza was good....but overcooked. I got a carry out Sicilian for my in-laws and they were very unhappy with how burnt the crust was. I will treat this as a bad day for the pizza chef, because they get it right 99% of the time....but not Thursday. read more

Shelly Pie - Large Pepperoni with stuffed banana peppers - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Single slice - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Small Pepperoni - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Large Pepperoni pizza - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Burnt pepperoni with banana peppers and sausage - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Pepperoni - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Business owner information

Lisa C.

I’m sorry that your pizzas weren’t done to your liking. Anytime there…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Anabel A.

3

187

294

6 months ago

Service: 5-star! Attentive, patient, and welcoming! Fast and accurate service. Restaurant: 4.5 Outside building doesnt look like a restaurant but as soon as you walk through the door in the front, it's a very intimate and warm atmosphere. There is a bar area inside and TVs on the wall if you want to watch college football. Food: 4.5 - LOTS of toppings on the pizza, wedding soup was good. The half point deduction went to flavor. The crust was soft, fresh and doughy but didn't have any distinctive flavor profile. I'm not easily overwhelmed but their pies, especially the EBUT (their supreme) overwhelmed me with the amount of toppings. The Buffalo chicken pizza could've used some garlic/a bit more kick but loved that their pizza isn't dry. LOTS of cheese...more than Mineo's if you thought Mineo's was over the top... BTW, I highly recommend heating their leftover pizza up in a frying pan--the bottom of the pizza gets crispy while the generous toppings are warm/heated/provides flavor. read more

Shelly Pie - Buffalo chicken - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - EBUT (supreme) - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Half mushroom, half cheese - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much for the review.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Julia E.

188

661

832

8 months ago

I have been to Shelly Pie several times and it never disappoints. Ive tried several items on the menu but you really cannot beat their pizza. The dough is AMAZING. My favorite pie is buffalo chicken. I typically order a mini. Any of the other sizes are huge. They do have a kids menu available. If you go on the weekend it can be tough to get a table. Trust me it's worth the wait! I will be back. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much. We really appreciate your kind words.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Raymond H.

0

7

5

3 months ago

The food was amazing and the atmosphere is also amazing. Service was fast and super friendly. We had Donna with an a she was by far one of the best female waitresses I've ever had. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much. We really appreciate your feedback.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bruce G.

Elite 26 All-Star

1

123

31

4 months ago

Pizza is their specialty. You won't be disappointed. Lots of other Italian entrees including pasta to satisfy other tastes. Service is friendly, competent, and makes for an enjoyable meal in a pleasant atmosphere. It's a bit of a climb up to the entrance of the one time VFW but once inside you will feel like family. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you for the wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lm C.

0

3

0

1 month ago

Great dining experience and delicious food! We stopped in for lunch-previously we had only ordered pizza for takeout when in the area-but this visit really impressed us. Katie, our waitress was phenomenal. She was kind, attentive and incredibly helpful throughout our meal. Our food arrived hot and without any delays, which made the experience even better. Katie also took the time to help us sign up for a keychain for future specials. As we were leaving, we dropped the keychain, and she ran after us to return it, which really showed how much she cares about her customers. We'll definitely go back for another outstanding dine in experience. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

We’re happy you enjoyed your visit and that Katie took good care of…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sharon D.

0

6

0

4 months ago

Great pizza! Better than that "other place". On occasion, they have pierogi lasagna which is really good and worth gaining an extra pound or two! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

The thank you for your review. We’ll have to put the pierogi lasagna…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dennis M.

1

76

4

10 months ago

7/30/2025 - 5:30 pm Pizza is excellent and uniquely memorable! We drive a distance for this wonderful pizza. The only place we go for pizza. Our waiter was Diane E and she was very attentive and delightfully humorous. An enjoyable experience we will want to get again...soon! Thanks to all. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

We’re glad you enjoyed your visit and that Diane took good care of…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sarah D.

3

26

1

4 months ago

Definitely a neighborhood, classic pizza joint! As they say, Yinz gotta try Shelly pie!!!!!!!

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Why only 3 stars? Nothing mentioned bad was unsure of the 3 stars.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeannine B.

0

2

1

4 months ago

The pizza we got was the worst pizza we ever had. It was cold. Minimal toppings and had a funny taste. No sauce. Very disappointed read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

We appreciate your feedback. Sorry you were disappointed. It’s…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chardae J.

382

327

383

1 year ago

You either hate Shelly's Pizza or love it! I love it! It's doughy and perfect amount of carbs on carbs and a small pizza will take you a long way after a night out. I love the prices as they're affordable, the people are nice and treat you like they care about the brand, and the diner feel makes you feel like you're welcomed. They also have free parking which is absolutely hard to find now a days. read more

Shelly Pie - Pizza - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julie Anna E.

87

336

1218

2 years ago

Fantastic food! Cheap, family owned and family restaurant vibe. Big place. Full bar. Huge menu- something for everybody. Large cocktail menu as well. The stuffed banana peppers are fabulous and so is their pizza. Great place. Definitely check them out, you can keep coming back and get something different every visit- the menu really is that big read more

Shelly Pie - Chicken Parmesan Hoagie - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Italian Club - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Bloody Mary - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Mike M.

158

477

980

2 years ago

Stop 12 with pizza passport and first time here. Heard the story of the connections to Vincent's and eager to try. Staff very friendly. My slice of pepperoni was large. The dough was thick and slightly floppy and doughy. Heavy layer of cheese and very little layer of sauce. Top layer of pepperoni cooked nicely as some were double layered to where the bottom wasn't as crispy. Eats like my childhood pizza shop with the heavy cheese layer read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much. Hope you got to every pizza place.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joseph S.

7

24

0

6 months ago

Their pizza is so good, and the staff is excellent. Pizza cooked in real ovens. Has an old world classic Italian feel. And fortunately you aren't bombarded with a plethora of loud TVs with blaring sports events. You can actually talk with your company. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maddox G.

0

25

8

11 months ago

Pizza was amazing, accidentally got our name wrong once but made it into a a funny joke. Such a good place to get pizza with humongous crust! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thanks Maddox. I actually saw you taking the picture of the IC light…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kathy R.

0

189

0

3 months ago

Stopped in again. It had been a while. There were 4 of us and we had a wonderful experience, Same great pizza. Same great service. Same super clean and tidy establishment. Those in our party who chose something other than pizza also remarked positively about their meals. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much Kathy.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Karla D.

Elite 26 All-Star

258

3228

18192

3 years ago

First time here. Wha a great little spot. Clean with friendly staff. Food is delish! Sicilian pie and hot cheese balls. Yummers! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much. Why only 4 stars? We will keep trying to get…

Helpful 3

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Lynn K.

1

106

168

2 years ago

Love this local business that is carrying on a Pittsburgh pizza tradition! Arrived on a Friday for dinner and were seated quickly. CJ was our server and she was friendly and efficient with service. We ordered a half mushroom / half pepperoni pie and it arrived and was hot and awesome! Crust was amazing and sauce and toppings plentiful. We'll be making another trip back soon! read more

Shelly Pie - Friday's pie! - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much.

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 1

Oh no 0

William M.

0

38

0

9 months ago

Love it!!! My tomato/spinach pizza was perfect and really delicious. The service was awesome too. Definitely a great place to go for pizza.

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kilt S.

0

5

0

4 months ago

1st visit; lg. extra pepperoni. Elevated my pizza discernment.2nd visit; got free bowl of chili. Win? Yes, good and fresh. Would have liked cheddar and hot sauce, yet it was free. Another lg extra pepperoni, on par, great. Dough fantastic, sauce proper, toppings on par. Filling and delicious. I took home a medium pepperoni, black olives, and onions ( my favorite). Wow!!!! Reheated was great. Cold great. Room temperature when I got home 2 hours later, was delicious. The medium was too big for my fridge. I drove 45 minutes for a return visit. Service is fantastic. Staff is excellent. Atmosphere is nice. A dining pleasure. I shall return! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much. We appreciate your review and all the feedback.…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Donald G.

0

3

0

9 months ago

I have been driving by this place on my way to Walmart from Monroeville for years I finally tried thier Pizza. I always thought the pictures of the Pizza looked strange. Who cares this is the best tasting Pizza I've had in nearly seventy years. Longtime. I ordered a large pepperoni and I could mushroom. I could not believe the size. I will be back but maybe a medium instead. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

We’re glad you enjoyed it. We hope to see you again soon.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steve R.

2

28

0

10 months ago

They are trying to imitate Vincent's pizza. It isn't even close. If you like your pizza raw and not crispy on the bottom then you will like Shelley's. Over hyped and over charged is the way I describe Shelley's. We will never go there again. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

It’s been our pleasure serving you. If you didn’t reach out to a…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Corinne K.

13

215

255

2 years ago

We went for a party at Shelly pie and I loved how they accommodated such a large group! The appetizers--mozzarella sticks specifically were good. The pizza was very filling and distinctly Shelly's. 4 of the large pies fed a huge group. We appreciated the space and the ample amount of seating for our group. Service was super friendly and made us feel like we were dining at our home without any of the work. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much. We are so glad your family had a good time and…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Seth L.

Elite 22

44

183

243

2 years ago

Buongiorno...Went to Shelly's and took my wife for the first time she lost her Shelly virginity ... anyways enough about her amazing time let's talk about me a returning customer ... got myself and my beautiful bride a extra cheese and pepperoni and i was transported back to turtle creek in the 40s when it was run by the Gambinos... i got some "Delizioso" extra cheese and pepperoni pie, that was fantastico! And i tried some of the wedding soup and it was exquisite... Shelly's is a good place with good staff, good service and good management..: every experience i have had was marvelous , it's a hearty pie worth trying Arrivederci read more

Shelly Pie - Pep/xtra cheese Pizza - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

Shelly Pie - Tasty goodness - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much. We appreciate the positive review. I don't…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Peggy R.

0

2

0

7 months ago

Ordered 2 large pizza's last Monday and we were not real satisfied...they were not cooked all the way through and the pepperoni was just thrown on in a pile and cheese only in the very center of the pie...should have called then to complain! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

If you had called us the day of your order, we would have been happy…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kirsten H.

2

5

10

2 years ago

I'd heard of Shelly Pie and wanted to try it for a while. So when my parents mentioned their plans of going to Shelly's for lunch I quickly invited myself and my 6 month old son to join them. We ordered a medium pepperoni, mushroom and sautéed banana pepper, and a small buffalo chicken pizza. The look of the pizza was very intriguing. I love a thick crust, and this has just that the toppings were generous and fresh. The dough was perfectly crisp but chewy. The staff were so friendly and welcoming. It was a lot of food, so we took the left overs home for my husband to try. Heated up, the pizza remains very delicious. I'm excited for my next visit to Shelly's to continue to try more menu items! read more

Shelly Pie - Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza, Medium 16" Shelly's Traditional Pizza - New American Near Me - Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania

See all

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much for the kind review. Love the baby in the…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Helen K.

0

2

0

7 months ago

I've eaten at the restaurant and I've ordered takeout. This time I used Door Dash. I commented to the driver that it arrived much sooner than I expected. It arrived RAW. That's why it was delivered so fast. I ordered a large pizza, half plain and half mushroom and onion. The pizza was really undercooked. The plain side was edible because the crust was so thin that it cooked through. However, the half with the veggie topping was raw; inedible in fact. I have read other reviews that are very positive. I felt y experience last night warranted a post. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

We’re genuinely sorry to see your one-star review and a bit confused…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ryan C.

0

14

3

1 year ago

Their pizza is probably my favorite non-chain pizza I've ever had. Absolutely delicious. However we tried both types of potato skins during our two visits (pizza skins and normal) and they are just not good. Bland flavor and strange texture. But that's the only negative really. Great pizza, this will be a staple of my families over the next few years whenever we are looking for great pizza. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you for the feedback. Also thank you for the review.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Billy L.

1

23

5

1 year ago

Absolutely love Shelly Pie! Doing a job in Turtle Creek I've become a bit of a regular at this fine establishment. The Pizza, hoagies, soups, daily specials are remarkable at unbeatable price. Great selection of beer and they have their own cocktails. The service is always amazing Brittany and Tabby always do an A++ job! The atmosphere is cool an old VFW turned into a modern day pizza restaurant perfect mix of the old meets the new. If you are ever in Turtle Creek or passing through I couldn't recommend this place anymore! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much for all the positive feedback. We really do…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sharon S.

0

21

0

10 months ago

First time here and was very disappointed. We got a white pizza. It looked good but after the first bite not so good. I don't think it was completely cooked. There was a puddle of oil or water all over the top of the pizza. Did not sit well with my stomach - felt sick. Service was ok. Won't be going back. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you for giving us a try. We appreciate your feedback. Just…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nicholas L.

0

4

0

10 months ago

My first initial experience with Shelly Pie was not great! After my displeasure the owner/manager reached out and made things right! My pizza experience this time was fantastic and it goes to show you the small shops still made quality products and care for their clientele! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Hi Nicholas, first and foremost our apologies if your pizza was…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dolores C.

0

45

0

10 months ago

Generous portion for lunch pizza with lots of good toppings. I will return but Sforno's in Jeannette or Little E's in Greensburg are still my favorites for pizza. Betty's in Murrysville is also good. Hard pass on Christophers in Jeannette and probably Fox's in Jeannette. Little Caesar's is good in Florida and downright awful in Norwin. The place in Irwin is also good. Do wood fired ? read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Scott K.

Elite 26 All-Star

138

271

3263

3 years ago

Excellent pizza n more spot. Stuffed banana peppers! All good here! Great spot for family or friends or date nite! If you love Vincents Pizza you'll love Shelly Pie! Highly recommended! Came say enough ! Don't go by, go outta your way to visit this GEM! Seriously! 6 STARS at least!! Plus 2!! read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you so much.

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Era J.

0

1

0

10 months ago

Pizza came delivered uncut and missing dipping sauce. Last time we ordered they forgot the toppings on the pizza. Awful service.

Business owner information

Lisa C.

I’m sorry your pizza came uncut and missing the dipping sauce. What…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Ean C.

3

36

22

2 years ago

I'd say good pies just a step below really good. Really good ingredients but the center is never quite done. Good service the staff is usually pretty attentive. And always seating available as they have a big dining area. read more

Business owner information

Lisa C.

Thank you very much. Please just ask and we can cool it a bit longer…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chris W.

0

2

0

1 year ago

Not worth the high price. They only put toppings on about half the pizza and the crust was burnt.

Business owner information

Lisa C.

It’s been a pleasure serving you. Best of luck with your venture on…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Page 1 of 8

See more reviews

More info about Shelly Pie

912 Penn Ave
Turtle Creek, PA 15145
Directions
(412) 646-2560
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.shellypiepizza.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Shelly Pie open?

Shelly Pie opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Shelly Pie opens at 12:00 PM on Sunday.

What time does Shelly Pie close?

Shelly Pie closes at 8:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Shelly Pie closes at 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon-Thu 11:00 AM - 8:00 PMFri-Sat 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Shelly Pie take Bitcoin?

No, Shelly Pie does not take Bitcoin.

Does Shelly Pie take credit cards?

Yes, Shelly Pie takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Shelly Pie have catering options?

Yes, Shelly Pie does have catering options.

Does Shelly Pie have a drive thru?

No, Shelly Pie does not have a drive thru.

Does Shelly Pie have a happy hour?

Yes, Shelly Pie has a happy hour.

Does Shelly Pie serve alcohol?

Yes, Shelly Pie serves alcohol. Beer & Wine Only

Indoor Amenities

Does Shelly Pie allow dogs?

No, Shelly Pie does not allow dogs.

Does Shelly Pie have TVs?

Yes, Shelly Pie has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Shelly Pie have bike parking?

Yes, Shelly Pie has bike parking.

Does Shelly Pie have outdoor seating?

No, Shelly Pie does not have outdoor seating options.

Does Shelly Pie have parking?

Yes, Shelly Pie has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Shelly Pie wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Shelly Pie is wheelchair accessible.

Does Shelly Pie have free WiFi?

Yes, Shelly Pie has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

We have a full menu comprised of appetizers, soups & salads, hoagies, sandwiches, Italian specialties and pizza. We also run daily specials. Check us out on Facebook or our website, shellypiepizza.com. Thank you! Hope to see you soon. Jim, Mike,Shelly,Lisa and Joe.

History

Established in 2013.

We are simply three friends with varied backgrounds in the restaurant business. Our goal is to work hard to ensure the successful of our business. We try to make every guest happy. If you are not, we ask that you at least give us the opportunity to rectify a situation before choosing to not come back to our establishment. We love to do what we do. We appreciate our staff for all their hard work and dedication to us and the company. We are a family unit that continues to grow.

Meet the Manager: Lisa C.

Shelly Farren, Mike Aiello and Jim Holland, friends for over 15 years, decided to open Shelly Pie on a whim. Their hope was to have a family style restaurant that offered a unique, hearty pizza and homemade italian specialties. It all began when Mike and Jim attempted to purchase what was once the Turtle Creek VFW in 2010. The transaction took a little less than 2 years. It wasn't until May 2012 when they were finally handed the keys to their new place. Their original plans of opening storage units and a refurbished furniture store came to a quick halt when an idea hit them. Their long time friend, Shelly, had just lost her job at an iconic pizza place due to its closure. The 3 of them met and the rest is history! Mike, a prior owner of the Lighthouse Restaurant in North Versailles has a vast knowledge of the food and beverage industry. Shelly has spent most of her life in the restaurant business working in various roles. Jim has more than 20 years in the field as well.

More Info

Health Score

You might also consider

Johnny's Fine Italian Dining

3.8(76 reviews)

1.1 mi

We've been dinning at Johnny's for years! Never had a bad meal! Just had dinner last evening! Rgere…read morewere 10 of us, and everything was delicious, hot, and Luke provided great service! I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Johnny's! Ron is an excellent chef!!

First time at Johnny's, the food service and the atmosphere was outstanding definitely will be…read moreback.!!

Cocktail

Filet cooked perfectly

See all

Spaghetti alfredo

Angie's Restaurant

4.3(14 reviews)

1.3 mi

Our party of six had a wonderful time at Angie's last night. It was the first time visit for all of…read moreus. Walking back to the dining room is more reminiscent of having entered through the wrong door. There was a lot of restaurant clutter to be observed on the way but the seating area was very pleasant as was our greeting and attention given to our dinners. What excellent surprises awaited us as our appetizers and main courses made their way to our table. The spinach calzone was superb with a crust that was perfection. Next came my spinach rolls which were just as good. Lots of homemade pasta dishes were next followed much later by many take home boxes. For about twenty bucks each we just couldn't eat everything. Wilmerding must be proud that this almost forty year old restaurant has sustained its following. It has a bright future as both father and son are the chefs. This family landmark will remain in place for a few more decades.

This place has been a staple in the area for decades. I was in town so decided to give it a try…read more We went in specifically wanting the pepperoni rolls that were very popular back in the day. When you enter the restaurant, there are a few refrigerators like you'd find in a house right in the lobby area. You walk past what used to be a candy counter to get to the dining area. We were greeted right away and sat at our table. The waiter brought us our drinks right away. He also brought us 4 pepperoni rolls they said were extras. They were ok. Not exactly what I remember. They came with a side of sauce which was sweet and had a good taste. I ordered the spinach calzone which is one of their popular dishes. The others got the chicken Parmesan. My dish was ok. The crust was kind of crispy and had a weird texture. I was surprised there was no ricotta in the calzone. It was pretty big. The chicken Parmesan was ok. It came with chunks of cut up chicken, sauce and a lot of cheese. It was a good size. Mushrooms were added to each one, and we got charged $9 for them, which we thought was a little much since we weren't made aware of it. The restaurant has changed hands a number of times over the years, so it makes sense the food is not quite like it was. The service was great.

Counter

Spinach calzone

See all

Menu

Cenacolo Restaurant

4.4(302 reviews)

8.4 mi

•$$$

We came for dinner one night while we were in the area visiting. We had a reservation and were…read moreseated quickly at a table next to the bar. I really enjoy that the pasta is fresh and the menu isn't 40 pages long. It's straight to the point and you know what you're getting based on what is listed under the pasta shape. My short rib ricotta gnocchi was good but I do wish it had a bit more salt to bring more of the flavor to the front. The gnocchi texture was perfect and pillowy. The short rib mixed in nicely with all of the pasta and the sauce. My spouse enjoyed the cannelloni, which was pretty much their lasagna but also wanted a bit more salt. Our server was very nice and walked us through the menu options as well as told us about the seafood special for the night. The bread came out first and was delicious. The salad was also good and I don't usually like arugula. You could tell the ingredients were fresh and I enjoy that they take the time to do that. The space is very cute and you can't really miss it even with it being in an executive building. It's a smaller area but it can seat a good amount of people. We noticed they had a pasta making class so maybe next time we're in town, we can do it. The red sangria had a great balance where it wasn't too sweet. We didn't do dessert but we did enjoy the digestif at the end with limoncello and my spouse ate the amaretti cookies as I couldn't.

They deliver a truly unique Italian dining experience centered around homemade pasta and…read morethoughtfully crafted sauces. Everything is made from scratch, from the noodles to the sauce. The pasta shapes are unlike anything else you'll find in Western PA. They even offer complimentary limoncello and Amaretti cookies to end your meal, which is a really nice touch. They have family style options for groups who want to try a variety of dishes, but the menu is just as fitting for a date night. Bonus: the leftovers taste just as good the next day! The space can get a bit loud with high ceilings and a full house, but the lively energy reflects how much people are enjoying the experience. Service was friendly and helpful with suggestions. The owner even stopped by tables to check on guests. It's tucked inside an industrial park and may be a little tricky to find if you're unfamiliar with the area, but GPS and signage get you there without much trouble. Definitely worth the visit!

See all

Asti's Italian Steakhouse

4.5(35 reviews)

1.6 mi

Super nice staff. Great service…read more Food was excellent! Plus they offer gluten free options. Which is difficult to find. My gluten free, oreo cheesecake was one of the best desserts I have had in my life. I almost bought a whole pie! Would 1000% come back! Chicken blackened pasta GF 8. 5/10 (Pasta was excellent. Chicken was a bit dry) Crab Bisque 10/10 (lots of crab) Salad 9/10 (very fresh) Oreo cheesecake GF 11/10

Asti's doesn't fit any one category. It's a wonderful venue for celebrations like a shower,…read morebirthday party, etc. it's also a great bar to watch the Steelers (hopefully win) while enjoying a drink and some good food. It's also a good place for lunch or dinner. They can accommodate groups in their party room, back room, or dining area. We had a group of 15 for lunch, and we had a wonderful view of the city of Pittsburgh in the distance. Service is friendly and parking is free.

Nice bar

Maple-bourbon salmon with vegetables and pasta

See all

Nice clubhouse.

Olives & Peppers

4.3(326 reviews)

6.1 mi

We've been here twice already in a one week period. The bar is fun. Our latest meal tonight was…read moreLobster Ravioli and Romano Chicken. Chicken was extremely tender and delicious. Our cocktails were great. Irish coffees for dessert fantastic and hot! Pecan ice cream ball was naughty but good. Our Bartender /Server Danielle was great. So friendly and accommodating.

I've heard GREAT things about this place, but we came on a Friday evening, and I truly think it was…read morejust an off night. I had friends that dined that night as well and they also did not have as good an experience as other visits. We started out with the salad, which probably was the best part! Light, refreshing, and tasty. The French onion soup was overwhelming. It had good flavor, but there was so much onion going on that I don't even think there was any broth to name it a soup. My main dish was the Romano chicken. It was the most bland chicken I've ever tasted, the risotto was par cooked and the sauce was not what I was expecting. Lackluster and watery. My friend got a pasta dish that was seemingly all oil. Overall the food was just average. Our server was nice and attentive, the drink was good, and the space is large and inviting. I'm hoping it was just an off night, so I'd be willing to try again in the future.

Great view from table!

Fried zucchini

See all

Caramel pumpkin pie martini

Garbarinos

4.5(202 reviews)

6.6 mi•East Liberty

Seriously what's not to love about this place. From the servers to the food to the ambiance, both…read moretimes we've been here it's been immaculate. Got the pasta with a crispy chicken cutlet again, which could have been a meal on its own-may have been a foot across. House made pasta was delicious as usual. Star of this round was the brussel sprouts, by far the best I've ever had. Have heard people say they can make vegetables take on that meaty taste, and this nails it. And they're huge! Meatballs melt in your mouth.

Food: We ordered the Spaghetti Pesto Alfredo & Rigatoni Tomato Cream…read more The ingredients listed on the menu is what you get. Very simple, no extra effort given beyond the output of a classic italian dish. Each plate proportionately could have fed two people so it felt like we were eating for four. We both left full, but underwhelmed with the flavor profiles rendered. Service: Overall our waitress was pretty absent, having asked us how we were doing only twice, leaving little room for any comments or feedback to be offered. She recognized her absence and offered us a surprise tiramisu (complimentary) to make up for the lack of attentiveness to our table. Seating: A large bar stretches the restaurant accompanied by wooden chairs, tables and a few booths tucked against the parallel wall. The seating is not tight, meaning you have space between yourself and other parties but the wooden chairs/tables were uncomfortable. In 2026, we just expected a little more from a restaurant charging $20+ for pasta plates. Affordability: If you're going out for drinks and an appetizer, you might be able to sneak your bill in for under $50, but otherwise forget it. Each plate is $20+ with options on the wine list reaching as high as $200+ ... We wouldn't describe this atmosphere as fancy, but the prices are trying to be. Comments: Always support local, small business and give every spot a try. We left this restaurant full, but saying we wouldn't be back, and think it's important that you get an opportunity to read an honest review before you spend your hard earned money. Take care, and happy eating!

Bar area

Cannoli

See all

Inside

Arlecchino Ristorante

4.3(256 reviews)

16.8 mi

•$$$

Let's eat together & celebrate my MIL's birthday…read more A little slice of Italy in McMurray South Hills of Pittsburgh. Craft cocktails (OMG...the SPRITZ options) & artisan wines meet an ever-changing Italian menu, all served in an effortlessly upscale setting. Perfect for date night, birthdays, or any special occasion. Pro tip: If you're celebrating, let them know!!! They'll add the guest of honor's name to the menu and the chalkboard above the kitchen. It is such a thoughtful, personal touch. Wine pick: a bottle of Zenato Valpolicella Ripassa (a must if you love red) What I ordered: smoked provolone, casa salad, cacio e pepe, chicken piccata Finished with a birthday chocolate cake...absolutely delicious Save this spot for your next celebration! Enjoy

I was near the neighborhood and looked up on Yelp for a recommendation and this restaurant came up…read moreas a sophisticated option. Parking is tight, but there is valet. I found a spot on the street. The building is a former school, which makes it interesting. It was busy on a Friday, but I was able to find a seat at the bar upstairs. I find it bizarre that sophisticated restaurants have sports screens at the bar. If you're sitting at the bar, there's nothing else for you to look at. Not in the mood for sports? This is not the place for you. I was surprised that an Italian place like this did not have a good Barbera wine on the menu. Bartender gave me some recommendations and I thought I was getting a sip to try, but he just brought the whole glass. I liked it so no worries there. I ordered the breaded zucchini as an appetizer and a meal. There were four pieces. But they are stuffed with goat cheese, and it just felt too rich. It's OK if you're in a group, but in my case, two pieces was all I could handle. For dessert, I had the banana crème brûlée, which was OK . I would not order it again. I wanted actual pieces of banana on my dessert which that one didn't have. Overall, it was an OK experience, but I would not go back .

Sunroom seating

Free oil and bread (tasty)

See all

Pino

Il Pizzaiolo

3.9(289 reviews)

22.3 mi

•$$$

Great service with excellent food. Varied menu, great wine list…read more The pasta is fresh made!!! You cannot go wrong here. Great food in a great atmosphere and very good value.

Wife and I are regulars there for the past 10 years!!! I was treated so poorly by a waitress on…read moreFriday night that I'll never go back!! I had traveled all day and was very tired, had just finished my dinner and my head was resting on the bar so they thought I was inebriated, which I was 100% not. The person berated me, used foul language, and embarrassed my family. We have spent thousands of $$$$ there over the years and love the food, but this was so unprofessional and uncalled for that we will never go back!! Should've and could've been handled differently.

Main dining room

Bread and oil/vinegar

See all

Bellini

R-Time At Rene's

4.3(51 reviews)

1.7 mi

Quite a nice meal here from a hidden gem in East McKeesport. It is a pretty unassuming place, laid…read moreback family food. Fish, meat, and classic Italian-American dishes are served here. I got to try their lasagna, which came with a meatball, bread, and wedding soup. I quite enjoyed this meal. Prices were OK and the portion was satisfying. The lasagna had quite a lot of ricotta and it was reasonably flavorful, but I would have liked a bit more of a flavor from the sauce. The meatball was quite large. Not too flavorful and a bit of a tough texture (almost sausage like), but still good. Bread was very basic but free so can't complain. The wedding soup was quite good. Small cup but flavorful broth and quite a good amount of cheese (I think?) in there. All in all, I enjoyed my meal here. Good little Italian spot in East McKeesport and probably one of the better restaurants in this area.

We ordered fish on a Friday during lent to go. So I can't speak much to the restaurant experience…read moreas I have never dined inside. But they have their to go system set up like a well oiled machine, there is a small takeout window at the bar right inside the door so you never actually enter the restaurant. Rather you form a line and they wait on you one by one. My ordered was packed and ready to go when I arrived. The fish portions are huge, the bread is fresh, my side salad was generous sized!