Great pizza. You can pretty much design your own. The flavor was wonderful and the service was great. Definitely recommend them.

Just had a terrible experience at this restaurant after patronizing it for 2 yrs. I did not know Washington County Health Department allowed restaurants to have dogs in the establishment. The waitress walked a customer through the restaurant to the patio area. The customer had the dog on the table and then walked the dog to relieve itself in the grassy area next to the patio. I could not eat the rest of my food. Joc___n told other customers I was upset. One of the customers started taking photos of me, pointing and laughing with the 2 other patrons at her table. This woman then came over to my table and was verbally abusive. It was a nightmare experience. BTW: had ordered the 2 meatball appetizer and it was delivered to me in less than 2 minutes. Obviously, it was already prepared and heated in a microwave! I have actually defended Anthony's when other negative reviews were posted on the Peter's Township site. I now get the bad reviews. At least I know I am not alone in having a terrible experience at this establishment. read more

I usually get pizza for takeout at this location and it's still nice and warm when I get home and looks and tastes great. I enjoy going and have a cold beer while I wait and the bartender is very nice and takes time to chat in between her work. This last time the pizza was probably the worst I have had in a long time. When I got home the pie was warm however there appeared to be no pizza sauce and tasted like a breadstick with cheese and pepperoni. It might have been the cook was having an off night but it sure makes you wonder about your options. read more

Love this place so much! The staff is super nice, their salad is UNREAL, and the pizza is so so good! We ended up going with the Hawaiian and caprese pizzas and asked for them to be extra crispy! Highly recommend! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

What a surprise! Stopped for a quick lunch and was pleasantly surprised how delicious it was! I had the meatball sandwich and salad lunch combo- it was Fantastic! Fast service, easy access w plenty of parking. Definately going back soon! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Meatball sandwich- lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

See all

I wanted to try a new place that had Gluten free pizza and I was not disappointed. The crust was thin and crunchy just like I like it. The toppings were just as delicious. I liked that the mushrooms and the onions were sautéed as thats my favorite way to have them on my pizza. We also got the Garlic Romano wings and the sauce was really good but I prefer a little less sauce on my wings when I have them. The ceasar salad was huge and the dressing was just as good as everything else. The only thing I wasn't really a huge fan off was the sweet tomato pieces on top. I dont really like sweet pizza I like savory. The server was super friendly and attentive and the food came out really quickly. There was plenty of seating and the bar area was really nice. I will definitely be back to try other wings and get the Gluten free pizza again. read more

See all

Pizza was pretty tasty, the caprese is top tier and I didn't try the other pizza we had. I heard the other pizza is salty so I'm not sure why it's extra. Pizza prices seemed pretty average and our server was lovely. Glad they had open tables even though it was pretty busy. Surprised this place has low reviews compared to other pizza shops. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Caprese 12" Gluten-Free - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped in recently and had not been there in a long time but will most likely not return anytime soon. The staff was very helpful and friendly but definitely having issues it seemed. The interior of the restaurant was very dark. The pizza that was recommended was the best item we ordered and loved that you could order a split pizza. The thick slice pepperoni and hot honey paired with the white pizza was a win! The Caesar salad had a fantastic dressing but the romaine had a large amount of brown pieces which was off putting. The eggplant appetizer had a horrible texture and taste and the meatballs were definitely not fresh and barely heated through. May return for a pizza in the future. read more

I go to Anthonys to get the pizza, wings and the best salad anywhere. Their house salad has the most refreshing dressing I have ever experienced. I really enjoy the coal fired pizza, it is unique and memorable. Prices are fair and service has always been good read more

The pizza is great! BUT the entrance way to the door is littered with trash. The curb line at the parking lot has wrappers and straws and garbage all over it. Don't the employees see it??? Isn't anybody on top of that? Makes you wonder what the kitchen looks like!! read more

I left a review 6 years ago and here we are still loving it! The pizza is consistently good! Love the chopped salad! The servers are great! read more

Food was great, the wings and pizza were delicious. Service was okay - we were seated right against the kitchen area, so it was a little noisy - but the food was worth it! read more

We used to have an ACFP near us so we would visit fairly often. Since we live in PA now, we hadn't had the opportunity until now. I was very excited to dine at one of our old favs but it did not deliver. The service was fine but the food was very lackluster and seemed like frozen food microwaved. We ordered a variety off the menu and not one stood out. The pasta sauce was very generic. Definitely not what I remembered. read more

If you like pizza, you would love this area. Anthony's Coal Fired, Harry's Pizza, and Fiori's are all within a mile of each other. They're all 5 star to me. Great food, great staff, great service. Try the Paula's Pie and the Classic Italian salad! Mmmmmm. Great meatballs too! read more

Service is pretty hit or miss here, but we love their pizza, especially the meatball & ricotta one! The garlic knots are to die for, too! They have great lunch specials and give a lot of perks (including a free pizza) for joining their e-mail club. read more

We got interested in the "coal fired" idea so decided to stop in. The service was great - quick and unobtrusive. And you can pay at the table with your phone. The dining area is trendy bar like. They have a bar and a few TVs and a lot of pro athlete and movie star pictures. It's a nice vibe while having pizza. We got a simple pizza with two toppings. The sauce is sweet probably sweeter than I like but good nonetheless. The crust has a nice mouth feel. A little crunchy yet soft on the inside. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Beer list - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

See all

Terrible management of takeout orders. They seem to have no system in place. People who placed orders are still waiting 45 minutes to an hour. read more

Jocelyn was incredible. So friendly , so fun. Made the whole experience a great one. This was our first time ever at Anthony's. We just moved from Denver in and we can't wait to come back. The meatballs. The hot honey pizza. And and and the Espresso martini was maybe one of the best ones we have ever had. read more

Manager At the dairy queen was very rude and unprofessional gave wrong order and still made us pay again and had a very bad attitude

We were STARVING and couldn't wait to get home to have our pizza, and this really hit the spot for all of us. I ordered takeout on their website a couple of days ahead. The process was really easy and our food was ready for us when we got there. They have a special where you can get a large specialty pie and a family sized Italian salad for $30. I took advantage of this and ordered Paulie's Pie along with the salad. They have to option to add garlic and basil to the pizza, which obviously I took. The garlic itself was on the pizza but the basil was on the side and I didn't find it until it was too late. The salad dressing also came on the side. Everything tasted really good, and I was very upset at the fact that I had to share because I could've eaten the whole pizza. read more

About a month ago I stopped by to ask if they had a gluten and dairy free pizza, the person I spoke with said they have a Gluten Free pizza crust, but you can bring your own Dairy Free cheese and they will put it on your pizza. Well, we tried it this evening, I ordered in the restaurant and waited for the pies. What a disappointment. Ordered the Paulie's Pie, with Gluten-Free Crust, NO CHEESE, substitute with customer provided cheese and a white pizza regular order. Received a Paulie's pie with ricotta, NOT provided cheese! Called to notify them of the error. After sending pictures of the Paulie's pie, the most they would do is credit one pie?!?!?! BTW, the White pizza had very little flavor. read more

My wife and I haven't had Anthony's Coal Fired pizza in nearly a year. We have passed by many times without caving to our needs. Today, we absolutely needed to have it. So we did, and boy we enjoyed it. We love the garlicky knots and the coal fired crust! Every pizza is unique in its own way, to die for honestly. Oh and the homemade Caesar dressing is my favorite! Thanks for the great food! read more

Stopped on way out of Pittsburgh and needed a slice and something wet to drink. This place is kind of located in an odd spot- half of a building it shares with DQ. What I liked about this is that the walls have a lot of chalkboard paint on the walls with specials and awesome looking drawings behind the bar with the PGH skyline and drawings of sangria and beverages. Anyway- walked in and with games going on sat at the bar so we could watch hoops. Ordered a couple of waters and then some sangria- white is better than red, and the bartender (tattoos?) was very very nice and accommodating. She made us feel at home, chatted with us and while training gave us some free tastes of drinks they were learning - including an espresso martini was very huge. We went with the philly steak pizza - which we have been on a big kick of lately together. This was probably on the higher end of ones we have had. Though I would have liked to have green peppers on it - the caramelized onions and cheese combo was very good and the steak wasn't cubed but more a sliced chunk jaump. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Philly steak pie - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

Many dinners and stops at Anthony's! Have tried about everything on the menu! Pizza, original wings with onions (my fav), salads, meatballs! Happy hour specials... outdoor seating... always friendly staff , especially Max the bartender! See you there! read more

See all

If I could replicate their house salad at home, I wouldn't have to dine here so much, but I can't so I make this salad full of fresh veggies and zesty dressing a part of my weekly food runs! Hard boiled egg, celery, Kalamata olives, red onion, tomato, and red wine vinaigrette are the ingredients in this best ever salad , and I always top it with their Italian tuna! Just a tip, they sell their dressing so you can always get a container to-go if you find that you love it as much as I do! I always ask for some bread on the side to soak up the dressing when I'm done. It's just a must! If I'm feeding a few, I always pick up some meatballs and their eggplant Marino, and I make this salad a large and split everything, and my family is always happy to have this meal. Thanks Anthony's! read more

What can I say Dan Marino you make one hell of a pie. As always the people were kind. As always the wings were on point. As always the pizza was cooked to perfection with that beautiful char Get a one topping pizza with ricotta cheese and pair that with the traditional chicken wings BEAUTIFUL THANK YOU DAN MARINO read more

I am extremely disappointed that Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza is no longer making the arugula salad with peppers balsamic vinegar and Burrata!!!! This was the best salad I have ever had. The cheese was made it. The pizza's are really good too. Come on Anthony's, PLEASE BRING BACK THAT SALAD!!!! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Anthony's coal fired pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

Great spot. Chill environment ordered wings and pizza split with mom and it was delicious. Servers are always good too quality pizza and wings are great alt from Normal wings read more

The pizza and salads are very good but the prices and service is another thing. 2 Beers, 2 Glasses of wine and split a small pizza , over $100! Pizza is good but not for that price. As for service ask for Max he's awesome but the female bartender always seems inconvenienced if you ask her for anything. read more

Good stuff ! They do serve good pizzas and also pretty decent wings. The classic wings does not come with options for sauce - that is one thing that I would recommend having but they were still nice . We got the half n half for the pizza- love it when restaurants let you do that . The margarita was excellent and Philly cheesesteak wasn't bad either . Would suggest others give it a try as well . The coal fired sandwich is the winner though ! Excellent chicken sandwich- great taste of the char grill on the chicken breast. This place has got a nice indoors and outdoors - not sure why it was empty on a Saturday night . For the kind of food they serve- I would expect much more foot traffic specially on the weekends. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Half n half - philly steak and the margarita - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

See all

Dined in, we were not impressed. We have had better pizza with a frozen Digiorno Pizza. The dough, sauce and cheese had zero flavor. The wings were very small and bland as well with very little sauce. For a place that specializes in pizza, we were expecting the items to be bursting with flavor, we were disappointed. The servers/manager are lacking in quality of customer service. read more

The food is always great but as far as the service it is terrible. Every time we go there we get the same waitress and she is more worried about her phone or something else. Went there yesterday ate in but got an order to go. Then I bought a gift card. She never gave me points nor did she give us our take out. She put it with all the door dash orders. Had to ask for refills twice. The terrible service is the main reason not to go back. read more

We ordered delivery tonight through the website and DoorDash delivered a smashed up cold pizza 25 minutes after the delivery window. I called and spoke to the manager on duty tonight ( please forgive me for not remembering her name) she was one of the kindest and most gracious people you could ever speak to on the phone. A third party delivery service messing up their food and she was still amazingly kind in listening to what I had to say. I like their pizza and their manager is great, I would suggest picking it up if you can though. read more

Two words- DELICIOUS pizza!!!! Paulie's Pie. Please, do yourself a favor and order it. It's their signature meatballs (except a bit smaller for the sake of pizza topping), sweet or hot peppers , and lumps of ricotta cheese. It is OUTSTANDING! I typically don't care for pizza with red sauce - this one changed my mind. The restaurant is quaint, nothing super fancy, but clean and the staff is very friendly ! They have an outdoor patio with gas fire pits when the weather permits. The bar has a chalkboard wall that features the specials of the day drink wise. I did order a specialty drink, it didn't blow me away and I found the price, $9.50, to be high. Next time I'll stick with a beer! Go give this place a try ! :) read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Mcmurray, Pennsylvania

See all

Ask for Max - pleasantly surprised! Live in Robinson don't like that location smells like dirty dishwater... in their defense we stopped going about six years ago... maybe it has changed!! McMurray location so good!!! Get square pizza with fingerhots!! Yum - mo! read more

Delicious food and service. Their wings are smothered in caramelized onions. Another favorite is their cauliflower pizza.

Terrible service!!! Pizza never showed up and the waitress said "that was my bad. I forgot to put your order in." BTW, the place was practically empty. read more

This place is fireeeee meatballs so bomb and every pizza is amazing and Jocelyn is the best server ever she's so nice and fast! read more

See all

Pizza was good but the service was terrible. I had to ask to place my food order after my appetizers were gone. Super pricy for the small amount of pizza as well. We probably won't be back just due to cost and lack of service read more

Anthony's is all pretty good. The food is generally excellent, but service can be slow at times. Also, it's not the most enchanting atmosphere. Can be pricey. For example. One meatball (normal size) is about 3.99$. They are good, but that's an outrageous price for a normal size meatball! read more