I live outside of Greenville, off Hwy D going towards Wappapello. Decent pizza is difficult to find here, that's a fact. The only offerings are a gas station here in Greenville and another up at Hwy 34 that offers Hunt Bros. which is "OK" depending on who made it that day. Usually over baked a bit in my multiple experiences.
So I decided to try Casey's over in Piedmont about 25 miles away. No, I don't drive 50 miles just to get a pizza for the most part, but if I really had a craving for one this would be where I went locally (or semi-locally if you think that way!)
They offer online and call-in ordering as well as walk-in, usually 25 minutes for your order to be done and ready for pickup.
I usually buy their mild sausage pizza when the wife is off visiting the kids and I'm "batching" it for a meal or three while she's gone. Recently I convinced her to give it a try and ordered a bacon and beef one and surprise surprise she now likes gas station pizza as well.
The crust is obviously hand-tossed (or rolled, I didn't peek) as its not perfectly round like many pizza joints offerings. The sauce is not overpowering the other ingredients,a complaint that I've voiced on a couple majors in the pizza biz. I love the mozzarella they use, nice and stringy as it should be. Toppings are fresh and abundant.
Next up is their chicken bacon ranch and their buffalo chicken. You can peruse their menu online, this isn't your usual gas station pizza place, for sure. read more