i was in poplar bluff for 6 months in 2020 and had their pizza delivered almost every week. and i recently returned and have been back on my routine. i have never been inside the restaurant. for some reason, the pizza is never browned? lol, but i quickly learned to have the oven or air fryer preheating while it's on the way. read more

The restaurant is very dirty. It is super loud, people coughing all over. The cooks look at you when you obviously need something. The food is horrible. read more

Food on the buffet looked like it had been sitting around for hrs. Granted it was late in the evening, but it looked real bad read more

We were told to seat ourselves, okay, great but not one of all the empty tables were clean. Had to ask for them to be clean. No Coke products only Pepsi. The salad on the bar was brown. I asked the server if she would she would eat it and she said no. That's when we decided to leave. This is my second bad experience in a row at this place I will not be coming back. read more

Really weird place that serves super thin crust pizza. They're known for their pizza buffet, and their supreme pizza is oddly addicting.

I ordered a small cheese pizza for carryout and it was ready for pickup within 15 minutes. The staff were friendly and helpful. The small pizza is a good size for its cost, but it's nothing special. read more

Pizza Inn - Carry out box for small pizza - Pizza Near Me - Poplar Bluff, Missouri

Arrived there at pizza inn approx. at 7:00 pm and had a party of 5. Walked in stood for five minutes before a waitress decided acknowledge us to set where we wanted. Well all party of 5 tables were dirty with cups plates and tables where filthy. So we sit down and takes waitress like 10 min to come take our drink order. She gets there finally get dirty cups and takes our drink order without wiping table off that was terribly dirty from last customers. Brings our drinks and attemps to put our drinks on table without wiping off until we ask her to. Very rarely checked on us to see if we needed anything and had to ask for refills. The waitress was in her 20's so not like she older and overworked. My son said he saw her on her cell phone when he up to the buffet. Theres just not any work ethic anymore with most of the younger generation. But they want us to tip high even without doing at least a good service. I myself dont reccomend that place of business for dinner. They werent even very busy and didnt try to keep pizza buffet stocked. Im not one to ususaly say anything but i just felt like i needed to say something because i had my hopes up and they let me down. read more

I had the buffet. It was fresh and delicious. I was even asked if there was something they could cook up for me! Super friendly. Just a great family place to eat and enjoy each other's company. I will be back! read more

My husband and I thought we'd go early right at 5pm. The high school was having a fund raiser. We ordered our own pizzas. Their service was very good. read more

Food was ok for a buffet. Family of 4 was 40 bucks. Service as good. Not bad for a quick pizza buffet dinner.

Pizza buffet was mediocre at best. Not worth the $15 tag. Slow bringing fresh stuff out. Sorry to those who raved this place.... I don't see it. read more

Is my number one Pizza Inn in whole wide world l love there everyone is so nice and so wonderful too . . I love their pizza too .

Great selection of pizzas, everything was clean and the staff was very friendly. I DO wish they had Coke instead of that other brand, but they still get 5 stars from me. Water is better for me than soda anyway... read more

I don't think those are heat lamps above the buffet. Food is cold, unless you get it as soon as it comes out. Ordering off the menu is the way to go...unless you like cold pizza. The staff are pleasant, on point with drinks & reasonably priced. read more

This place has gone downhill. In its day it was the go to place for pizza. Not anymore. Family was in town and wanted to go. Sadly we were disappointed. Not like they remembered. The place was dirty. Had to step around food around the buffet. Never did get cleaned up while we were there. The pizza crust used to be nice and crispy, now you hold up a piece of pizza and it just flops, all limpy! What happened to that good crispy crust Pizza Inn was known for! The pizza was lukewarm, even the new pizza that came out. Over on the dessert bar, it was never cleaned. Old pans were there the whole time, only one chocolate chip pizza was brought out, and it disappeared almost immediately. One lady took half of it. Needless to say, we were extremely disappointed. We were debating on fish or pizza. Later we wish we would of picked fish. Some changes need to be made to keep customers coming back and to keep this long standing restaurant in business! Take a long look inside and start cleaning and making better food!! read more

Excellent pizza and chocolate chip dessert pizza. Have eaten here for years and it has never disappointed whether we ate in or took home

I ordered 2 pizzas well done. Got home & they were both basically raw. Barely cooked. Never again.

So disappointed, usually our favorite place. No service at all, got a salad bar had no lettuce, cheese or tomatoes. Never asked what we wanted to eat, just brought us a ticket. Did not get any pizza at all, one pitiful trip to salad bar and was $25!!! Time to find new pizza joint! read more

The best pizza I've ever had. Lovely staff who were always attentive. There wasn't a single bad pizza. The cleanest restaurant I've ever seen. Just all in all one of the best places in Poplar bluff! read more

I love Pizza Inn is best pizza place in whole wide world . I love there pizzas every body is so nice and wonderful there too. read more

Pizza Inn - Pizza Near Me - Poplar Bluff, Missouri

Always a great place to eat. The lunch buffet is where it's at. The chocolate chip dessert pizza is the greatest thing ever created!

Called to order pizza I was going to pick up. Drove all the way in town and the clerk said we couldn't get the pizza we ordered in giant size. But when I called to order she said I could get that size. Hmmmm. So why didn't she call me back before I drove all the way in. So we decided to order 2 of a smaller size but told we'd have to wait 25 minutes. Ridiculous. So we left. They lost our business. read more

Pizza was good and staff were friendly and frequently checked to see if we were ok. However, the bacon on the salad (that the girlfriend got) wasn't fully cooked and she wasn't able to finish it. Hence the reason for the 1 star off. The manager promptly took off the salad cost. Every other aspect of the meal was well done and thorough. read more

Worst pizza in the bluff. Buffett is dirty and not kept fresh. Service is bad. I am confused about how they are still open.

We passed by the Pizza Inn while traveling across the country and were amazed by the friendliness of the staff. The crust was fantastic and crispy. The Hawaiian pizza had large slices of ham and enough pineapple to satisfy our fruit cravings. The pepperoni pizza was delicious as well. Would definitely recommend this restaurant next to your pizza craving hits. read more

I love thier Pizza! Their buffet is always good. i like their taco pizza and their supreme the best. Great dessert pizzas too.

We used to have two locations of Pizza Inn locally but they have been closed for several years now. We always enjoyed eating there so when I saw this one on Yelp it was carved in stone that we would give it a try. It was fantastic! There was a huge array of pizza on the buffet as well as tater tots, chicken nuggets, and mini corn dogs. Everything we tried was just great! There is also a nice salad bar and an assortment of dessert type pizzas. Price was a very reasonable 8 dollars and something. The owner/manager? came around while we were enjoying our meal to ask if everything was alright and thanked us for coming in. This is a great place to eat! read more

This place is good. Pizza crust is crispy, and there are many options at the buffet. The staff was super friendly. There's also an arcade side so if you have kids, there's something for them to do. Only negatives...it didn't seem super clean, and it's kind of dark inside...like a dungeon. But the service and pizza were great. read more

Just a heads up! We (Pizza Inn) are now under new management since July and there are a lot of good changes brought here and more to come! We now accept tips on credit cards, we have a new arcade, and the bathrooms are remodeled! We have buffet everyday 11am-2pm and 5pm-8pm. Saturday's, buffet is open all day 11am-9pm! Come in and let us serve you! read more

The desert pizzas are delicious, and they will make your favorite upon request. However, the other pizzas, like pepperoni, meat lovers and cheese, are too dry. There is not enough sauce. read more

The buffet is a bargain. My personal favorites are the cheeseburger and taco pizzas. For dessert definitely go with the chocolate chip pizza. read more

Great place to eat with your family. Buffet is constantly being restocked. Excellent!!