The wife and I live out in the "boonies" north of Poplar Bluff, inside that section of Mark Twain…read moreNational Forest. We generally only make one trip a month into Poplar Bluff to do our grocery shopping and eat at one of our favorite places. My wife had never eaten at Godfathers before last year, but it's now her favorite pizza place. Due to medical conditions she can't eat much pork, so most pizza toppings are just out of consideration, but once she tried their Loaded Baked Potato pizza she was hooked. We come in for the lunch buffet and the employees make sure to get one of "her" pizzas out on the line ASAP if there's not one out there already as that one and their Taco pizza is what she's after, while I feast on the pepperoni and sausage ones that she can't eat! The dining area is always clean and someone will come through often to clear tables. There's always plenty of plates available and fresh pizza constantly replenishing the buffet. Also pasta, chicken strip and several dessert offerings as well as a full salad bar, no reason to leave hungry.

I used to eat here regularly a few years ago but now whoever is the cook at dinner time makes the…read moreworst pizza Ive ever seen. Came in to try the dinner buffet a couple times and the crust is usually tough old and toppings burnt. Or its not cooked all the way, no in between. The side bar food was old and dried out. Dinner manager always seems angry and mean to her employees. At least the cashiers are usually nice and monkey bread is still good. I wanted to give this place another shot I used to love it but its gone downhill, not worth the price anymore.

Super clerk Heather was awesome and amazing in her balancing skills to attend to my children wife…read moreand all the extra customers by herself while still staying professional and making each of us feel like we were the most important person there. You guys are blessed to have wonder woman working at this location!

i was in poplar bluff for 6 months in 2020 and had their pizza delivered almost every week. and i…read morerecently returned and have been back on my routine. i have never been inside the restaurant. for some reason, the pizza is never browned? lol, but i quickly learned to have the oven or air fryer preheating while it's on the way.

Food on the buffet looked like it had been sitting around for hrs…read more Granted it was late in the evening, but it looked real bad

We were staying at a nearby hotel and called to order a pizza. We were planning on a medium 3…read moreingredient hand tossed. The lady in the phone suggested a large crispy Pharm one ingredient for $12 something. I was curious. She said it was a thin crust with parmigiana cheese. It sounded like it might be good. It was far too salty. That was the main taste. We didn't eat half of it. It's been awhile since we've gotten a Papa John's pizza. Their other crusts might be good, but I don't recommend the crispy Pharm. It's more of a crispy salt. Based on the pizza we got tonight, I would give it a 1, but I've had Papa John's pizza with different crusts that were decent.

Quick. Friendly. Pizza?? Not a fan. $15 got a pizza with not a lot of anything. Toppings and cheese…read morewere minimal. Flavor..Bland at best. Crust was tasteless and the overall flavor was nothing to brag about. If you want good pizza than I'd say try something else. I'd rather of had a frozen Tombstone Pizza. Seriously

There's two Casey's gas stations in town. This is the worse one, and though it looks like any other…read moreCasey's from the outside, the magical thing about this one is that the revenue that runs it appears to be generated almost entirely by roaming Crack heads. Their gas pumps may actually predate civil war.

So felt as though a review was needed, given my recent visit to Casey's General Store. I stopped in…read more strictly to use the restroom. As you will see from the pictures I posted, the restroom was in very poor condition. The cleanliness was terrible. 1st there was fecal matter smeared on the toilet paper that was left out because it was not put back in the dispenser. 2nd upon closer look there was blood, yes blood on the wall and lastly there were no paper towels to dry your hands after you wash them. Poplar Bluff has 2 Casey's General Stores and I visit both sporadically, during work, and they have always been poor when it comes to being clean. So to give a heads up to anyone traveling through Poplar Bluff or currently living in the area as you may already be aware Casey's is not Clean place to stop in and use the restroom if you have an opportunity to go somewhere else, do that as these conditions are completely unacceptable. *,*Now adding something to this review some of you may say that maybe it was after a rush maybe they just didn't have time to get to it. Allow me to say that I stop in randomly throughout the week at both locations and they are both always unsanitary and unkept. However this was the most recent one where it was as bad as it was, and I will not be returning.***

To go order! Asked for extra sauce on the side with my order Order of Spaghetti. Dissatisfied -…read moregot a pile of Noodles and a little bit of sauce/meat on top. Did not get my extra sauce. This St. Louis special recipe actually tastes more authentic from the grocery store bottled jar. Disgusted after I'm sure many people have handle the butter (packets), they tossed them in with my tough microwaved bread sticks and it melted everywhere. Disgusting to put the aluminum packets everyone have touched in the hot bread. Do better!!

Service - TOP NOTCH Food - Amazing , big menu (pizza, great…read moreburgers and amazing specials each night) Ambiance - No frills, just a clean place to eat great food with super nice folks for fair price! This is one of the best spots for breakfast/lunch/dinner!!!

Was looking for fast food and discovered this restaurant . Passed on burgers and tacos. Decided to…read moretry here. Italian personal size dinners at fair prices . Very good quality. Nice service. Delivers order to Tsble. Similar to chains on the west coast but on a fast food scale. First time seeing this restaurant. If in Poplar Bluff and looking for quick dinner but not at a traditional Italian restaurant, try this place. Order a combo dinner plate. Was very good

Food is always great. Husband loves the pizza here. Service was fast and friendly. Everything is…read moreclean and neat. Well be coming back