Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    2.3 (3 reviews)
    Closed • 5:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Casey's Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 4,029 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Carmelas Pizzeria - Missing chicken tender order!!

    Carmelas Pizzeria

    3.5(33 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    •$

    I've dined here a few times while visiting family, and have had consistently good food for a great…read moreprice! They offer pizzas, sandwiches/subs, salads, and pasta. The prices here are really good for the amount of food that you get. The smaller salad is $4.95, and is big enough for an entree! I most recently had a combo of a chipotle chicken flatbread sandwich, a side salad, and a soda for $7.99. I had to take the salad home! The pizza here is also pretty good - I mean, it's no Cassano's, but it's a nice hand-tossed pizza. The inside is really big, and we've never had a hard time finding seating for our whole group. There is also a large patio and bar area if you're coming in for a drink. Sometimes it can be a bit loud inside, especially with the country music turned way up... but this is par for the course in New Carlisle so you really can't be too surprised. There are also plenty of tvs if you wanted to watch a sporting event, but not so many that it's annoying. Tasty and affordable, just the way I like it!

    Pizza is still TOP NOTCH, but sadly they were out of LETTUCE (!!) to make my favorite salad last…read moreSunday. They were SERIOUSLY short-handed and the poor guy who was taking orders was running himself ragged, even though there weren't that many people there (maybe slammed w/take out orders??) Service was slooooooooooow, but thorough, and our larger group (eight of us out on the patio...) were all eventually served. Sad I didn't get my favorite Carmela's Mediterranean salad, but sadder for the overworked, overachieving bartender/waiter/who knows what else guy who ran a one man show that night. Good pizza, though!!

    Photos
    Carmelas Pizzeria - Awesome veggie calzone...

    Awesome veggie calzone...

    Carmelas Pizzeria - Salad bar/lunch buffet

    Salad bar/lunch buffet

    Carmelas Pizzeria - Ham black olives and feta

    See all

    Ham black olives and feta

    Papa Johns Pizza - Jalapeño Bacon Cheesesticks

    Papa Johns Pizza

    2.2(6 reviews)
    4.5 mi
    •$

    I saw that N E W PAN PIZZA commercial (I know you know the one I'm talking about that) and I was…read morelike "I WANT IT!" I was really excited because it gave the appearance of being similar to Pizza Hut or even Jets but I hoped for that Papa John's price. Ordered it online, it was still kind of pricey...and the jalapeño cheese sticks also caught our attention so we figured we would give it a shot. Once our order was placed it said it would be about 20 minutes. We got there about 25 minutes later and our order was hot and ready for pick up. The cashier was quick and friendly. Immediately upon looking at the pizza and cheese sticks--I knew I was going to be disappointed and we were bamboozled. The pizza was okay. Maybe it needed cooked longer? I dunno, I'm honestly not a pizza connoisseur lol I just love greasy crispy crunch thick crust and this wasn't it. Jets holds the gauntlet but it's expensive and technically not even allowed in my diet ::tears:: but at least now when we see those mouth watering commercials we can say "been there done that" and not even drool.

    We ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza with extra cheese and light sauce on it. Received…read morethe pizza with way too much sauce; enough sauce for 3 pizzas! And barely any ingredients on it; basically one pepperoni per slice! Couldn't have been extra cheese either. This is the last time we order from Papa Johns. Gave them more than enough tries. Their pizzas are too high priced and aren't worth the price. If you want great pizza go to 571 Bar and Grill or Godfathers!!

    Photos
    Papa Johns Pizza - Pepperoni, sausage and bacon with mushroom onion and anchovies on half

    Pepperoni, sausage and bacon with mushroom onion and anchovies on half

    Papa Johns Pizza - Create Your Own Pan Pizza

    See all

    Create Your Own Pan Pizza

    Casey's - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...