Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    3.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed 4:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 343 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Dwight Pizza - Medium deep dish slice (pepperoni & sausage)

    Dwight Pizza

    4.4(82 reviews)
    8.9 mi
    $

    The wife was hungry on our way back to Michigan from visiting family at Christmas. We pulled off 55…read morelooking to get some food and head back out on the road. We saw a handful of fast food joints and were going to settle on one before I said, "hey, let's check this place out and just take a little break from driving." We stopped in Dwight Pizza and were pleasantly surprised. The food: The Italian beef/sausage combo was out of this world. The sausage was packed with flavor and the Italian beef was delicious. Everything was even better being dipped in au jus. We also split a pizza that came piping hot and loaded with cheese and toppings. The atmosphere: The atmosphere is a no frills diner small town diner feel, but a great place to stop for lunch or dinner with kids. AND I got to watch The Godfather during lunch! :) I loved seeing the owner's memorabilia from his son's successes over the years. Undoubtedly a VERY proud father and it's touches like that, which make family owned/small town places special. The owner: He didn't say he was the owner, but as a business owner, myself, you can tell. He was awesome. Very friendly and it didn't feel like you were stopping by his restaurant, but stopping by his home for a home cooked dinner. He started by asking us if we wanted to have the best Italian beef sandwich or best pizza we'd ever had, so we naturally said, "Both!" We will definitely make a point to stop in on our trips back to Michigan. Three Floyds and Schoops are our "heading down" stops and Dwight Pizza will be our "heading up" stop.

    Excellent tasting pizza, I will definitely be having there pizza again. This was an awesome pizza,…read moredon't let the outside fool you. I will be trying other items off the menu.

    Photos
    Dwight Pizza - From the 'bike.

    From the 'bike.

    Dwight Pizza - Large cheese and sausage

    Large cheese and sausage

    Dwight Pizza - Menu 3-5-2025

    See all

    Menu 3-5-2025

    Maria's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Fire cracker shrimp & meatball sliders

    Maria's Ristorante & Pizzeria

    3.6(164 reviews)
    9.2 mi
    $$

    I've been down around this area for four years. I didn't try Maria's pizza till about a week ago…read more It was so good. I had it a few days later. It didn't cross sauce the cheese. The ingredients were excellent. I'm a big fan of Aurelio's and Cominos pizza but Maria's is a better pizza.

    Blech!! Never ate here before. Never will again! Appetizers were greasy gross. The French onion…read moresoup was so salty I couldn't eat it. There was so much mozzarella (it should be an accent not a big goofy blob) I couldn't eat it. The waitress started to take my bowl away and I explained (she didn't bother to ask) that I couldn't eat it because it was so salty. She said oh sorry about that. That was all. Then the food.... eggplant parmesan. The eggplant was so thick and heavy and extremely greasy. Red pasta sauce tasted like unseasoned tomato goop. The noodles were cold and under cooked. The whole thing was smothered in goopy mozzarella. It was awful. I only.took a few bites and couldn't eat it. My son got the manicotti. He said the same about the sauce (we both have bad heartburn from it) and he said the inside of the manicotti didn't taste like anything and the filling was runny, not firm. He said it was gross. Our waitress never offered to fill our drinks. We were not offered any dessert, not that we would have eaten any. The bill was $90 before tip. We were royally screwed. It was disgusting and I'll never go back.

    Photos
    Maria's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Surf & turf

    Surf & turf

    Maria's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Chicken piccata

    Chicken piccata

    Maria's Ristorante & Pizzeria - Margherita Pizza

    See all

    Margherita Pizza

    Geo's Pizza - Geo's Bread And The Lunch Special Pizza

    Geo's Pizza

    3.3(44 reviews)
    7.4 mi
    $$

    Had pizza from this local place in Coal City. It only has it for delivery and takeout. Geo's Pizza…read moreis about the smallest interior of a pizza place there is. Only has a counter to place an order. The prices are pretty good especially for the various lunch specials. Checked it out at lunch, which turned out to be the best time to come here. It's known for the specials at lunch. These are pretty cheap for a pretty good amount of pizza. Of course they have a lot more on the menu. We got a few things. It's about $6 for the Geo's Bread. This is basically pizza dough seasoned with garlic and salt. Comes with a choice of dipping sauce including garlic butter and marinara. It's about $7.50 for the Lunch Special. You can get a pizza with one topping. It's miniature size so it's not a lot. The Geo's Bread is actually a lot bigger than this particular pizza. It's still a good value to be honest. These specials also include calzones and sandwiches if not wanting a pizza. Got to say it's the best pizza around here. It's a small place that only has delivery and takeout. They're open daily and open even later on the weekends.

    Ordered a pizza. Been a few years since I had Geo's pizza (moved out of area- now back). Geo's…read moreused to be my favorite. This time I was really disappointed. Sauce did not cover crust completely and crust tasted different. Maybe they gave me a gluten-free crust. If so, that was NOT what I ordered. Sad to see an old friend fade away.

    Photos
    Geo's Pizza
    Geo's Pizza - Buffalo chicken added bacon! It was amazing

    Buffalo chicken added bacon! It was amazing

    Geo's Pizza

    See all

    Casey's - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...