I ordered delivery, so I can't speak on the ambience and service. What I can tell you is the pizza…read morewas very good, considering it's a local business, and I normally order from one of the major chain pizza places. I had been wanting to try a local pizzeria, so I ordered the Meat Lover's for me and a Cheese pizza (with bacon, green peppers, pineapple) for the wife. Upon opening the boxes, I noticed the pies are much thicker than the major brand pizzas. A very good amount of toppings and sauce (which strangely seems to be lacking on the other brands' pizzas, here in Marion). Baked well, not overcooked at all. On picking up a slice to take a bite, it held its weight well. (Don't you hate when you go to bite into a slice, and all the toppings just slide off onto the plate, leaving you with a greasy piece of thin bread in your hand?) The test was in the flavor: very good. My only (little) complaint is that the overall flavor was a tad bland. Maybe the sauce needed a little more spiciness. Nothing that a little pepper or hot sauce couldn't fix. Wifey and I enjoyed our pizzas. We will order again, or maybe, if we are feeling frisky, drive and go dine in. Recommended.

Amazingly friendly service the girls were perfect, food was delicious best pizza I've had in years,…read moreand I love the old school atmosphere of the decor.

We moved away but when we are in town this is a must try. Our daughters were raised on their food…read more Great food, lots of seating and friendly staff. I recommend everything on the menu but especially Bennie's house salad dressing. My daughters now have their families addicted to it as well. My daughter ask for this on her Christmas list last year lol!

I'm traveling in from Dallas. My husband and I both wanted some grilled Salmon. We choose to go to…read moreBennie's Italian Restaurant. Wow!!! That was a great choice. We had some of the best salmon we have ever eaten. We ordered the salmon and selected the blackened for the flavor. It was absolutely amazing!!! The baked potato and salad were also great!!!!

We hadn't tried Joe's in years, so we decided to stop in while we were on that side of town. The…read morewaiter was amazing. He was going into his senior year in high school, but had the best manners and customer service skills I have ever witnessed from a younger server. He went over the specials, made suggestions, kept the drinks full, and checked in often. He also offered us to-go drinks when he brought us the check. The food was very good. It came out hot and fresh and had a good flavor to it. We had the garlic cheese bread with red sauce for dipping, and the Joe's special thin crust medium 12 inch pizza.

Ok so I've been here a few times now so I feel comfortable about this review. The place is nice…read moreit's has an atmosphere. The pasta is amazing the Italian sausage and beef was great. The servers always smiling and happy to help. The one con: was the Chicago style pizza it taste good but, it was just thick crust pizza the layering was not right and lack of ingredients was a shame to Chicago style. The layers they had were cheese sausage and sauce. Every pizza I have had in Chicago was layered ingredients then cheese then sauce. Then the lack of ingredients the places I eat at in Chicago there was a bit of sausage in every bit. I am biased because I'm from up there.

We have had this place on the list to try for a while now. We finally made our way over to JC on a…read moreFriday evening. We were told to seat ourselves as soon as we entered. Plenty of tables available. The waitress was quick to take our drink order and bring menus. I must say that the menu is extensive and slightly overwhelming. There is truly so much to choose from, so I'm posting pics of the entire menu to help others browse before they arrive. We ended up going with mozzarella sticks and a supreme pizza. We chose the thin crust. Crispy crust, but it wasn't too hard. The mozz sticks were good and I liked the sauce. The server was great. We will definitely be back!

Very good pizza at that little food spot was passing through the area my team ordered some food…read morethey had great service and hospitality 10/10. And pizza was spot on!

Always great pizzas, the latest NY style "Italian trio" was delicious, and the Italian papadias are…read morevery tasty.

Spent over $50 for carry out...pizzas were burnt..cookie was burnt. We order from here a lot but…read moremight wanna start looking elsewhere..tired of getting burnt food as this isn't the first time this has happened!

The better of the Marion Casey's so far. Haven't been to the West Main store for pizza yet, but…read morethis store is hard to beat. The 400 E. Deyoung Street store seriously needs to up their game since their pizza just SUCKS... Court Street is the 'go to' store for pizza. Still have to try the West Main store, but definitely avoid Deyoung...

10/10 looking for a spot to eat driving through, my little brother wanted pizza and my mother and I…read morewere so happy we ended up eating delicious and affordable food. Both of are plates were $5 each and there veryyyyy generous with there soft buttery bread sticks. All of us left stufffeddddd all for $30. Everybody in there was very nice and fast service quick to help or ask you if you need anything ! Great place comfortable community vibe

each thing barely qualifies as that thing... First thing: fettuccine Alfredo: my goodness the sauce…read morewas gross. Isn't the idea to have good food so people come back I can't believe anyone would come back after eating that. Spaghetti meatballs: the spaghetti was mushy and overcooked. Come on people it's not hard to cook spaghetti correctly. Meatballs: lots of breading and very little meat, kind of disgusting. The red sauce was not bad, but with the mushy pasta lasagne was also kind of gross. I can see wife as always are disappearing because no one wants to go back after eating there

Disappointed burned and sloppy last time I ordered I used to get all the time sad reallyread more

As of March 12 2024 the store has no RGM only shift managers. The bathroom is nasty and the food…read moreservice is very slow with poor quality food. Save your money and go somewhere else.