We hadn't tried Joe's in years, so we decided to stop in while we were on that side of town. The waiter was amazing. He was going into his senior year in high school, but had the best manners and customer service skills I have ever witnessed from a younger server. He went over the specials, made suggestions, kept the drinks full, and checked in often. He also offered us to-go drinks when he brought us the check. The food was very good. It came out hot and fresh and had a good flavor to it. We had the garlic cheese bread with red sauce for dipping, and the Joe's special thin crust medium 12 inch pizza. read more

Joes Pizza - Garlic bread with cheese and red sauce - Pizza Near Me - Herrin, Illinois

See all

Ok so I've been here a few times now so I feel comfortable about this review. The place is nice it's has an atmosphere. The pasta is amazing the Italian sausage and beef was great. The servers always smiling and happy to help. The one con: was the Chicago style pizza it taste good but, it was just thick crust pizza the layering was not right and lack of ingredients was a shame to Chicago style. The layers they had were cheese sausage and sauce. Every pizza I have had in Chicago was layered ingredients then cheese then sauce. Then the lack of ingredients the places I eat at in Chicago there was a bit of sausage in every bit. I am biased because I'm from up there. read more

See all

Food is delicious. Service is okay, but pricing is confusing. An 8 inch cauliflower crust is a $5.00 up charge, while a 10 inch cauliflower crust is a $3.00 up charge. This makes no sense. Why am I charged $2.00 more for 2 less inches of pizza? read more

Working in the area and looking for a thin crust pizza place. We literally travel all over the country and love trying local spots. This pizza was a great pizza. Thin crust and great cheese. Very impressed. My wife's favorite pizza spot Fries Green Beans was amazing read more

See all

The Herrin location really surprised me after trying another location that has since shut down. I'd eat one at their Marion store and hated it but the Herrin restaurant was night and day better. We had good service during a lunch rush, split a Greek pizza between two people and all I can say is Yummety-Yum-Yum-Yum!!! We've been back a few times and with family and enjoyed the different dishes and continued to have good service during busy dinner rushes. read more

I tried to call in an order 3 times and was asked to hold each time, then hung up on. went to order in person and waited 15 min before anyone talked to me. after waiting 30 min for a simple carryout, I left. they were not busy and I can see why read more

The service and meal were superb! My husband and I shared a Joe's Special thin crust pizza and were very satisfied with the taste and quality!!! We will be back for sure! read more

Stopped by Joe's on a recent visit back home to see family. We were a party of eight and the staff quickly cleaned and pushed together tables on the main dining room. The other option would have been a private area in the back of the restaurant, which I'd recommend if you have a big party--and call in advance to reserve it! The little ones in our group were entertained with Joe's Kid's Menu coloring sheets. We started out with a delicious bruschetta appetizer that was covered in fresh tomatoes and great for sharing. The kids snacked on an 8" cheese pizza, served with stuff breadsticks. On to entrees. The pizza: we got deep dish. It was crispy on the outside and covered with gooey cheese and fresh tomato sauce. It's A LOT of food, and you'll be full by the second piece. Sandwiches. Also big portions. The Italian sausage was the standout--one of the best items we tried. The Italian beef was pretty standard. Juicy and flavored perfectly. Don't be afraid to swap the fries with fried green beans! Pastas: cooked perfectly and covered with house made sauces, fettuccini or tomato. I loved the angel hair, it wasn't too heavy and was far from bland. The service is quick and professional and the space is comfortable for a date night or a family affairs like ours. You should check out downtown Herrin's newest spot! read more

See all

Joes was pretty good , we tried the toasted ravioli which was good but the Alfredo Pasta sauce was sub par. I love me a good Alfredo sauce and was just not impressed with theirs . The pizza was great and service was amazing. read more

Nasty food! Stuffed Shells with this horrible red sauce that is sweet. Some of the food is ok, a just ok. What restaurant for pick-up doesn't give out silverware? You need to call Gordon Ramsey cause what we had was FOUL!! P.S. check what you get they are vert forgetful, what happened to the pop we ordered?? 1-5, I give this place a 1.2 Should replace this garbage with a Portillo's!!! read more

Ordered the stuff crust pizza and Mac & cheese.. food is always good but seems like they always forget something.. this time it was the ranch.. I called right after it was delivered.. was told it was would be brought right out.. 30 min later called back and they acted like they had no idea I had called. Fir the premium prices they charge for their product they need to work on customer service.. they have lost my business and everyone I talk to.. read more

Outstanding service and the most awesome food around we've been in herrin for a year now and we eat there at least once a week if not more

Last 2 time everything was soggy. Water was standing in in the order and next time we ordered sub sandwiches and bread was so soggy it couldn't be held and I hate soggy buns on anything. Orders were delivered and we only live 5 blocks away. read more

This is our first time at Joe's and I must say, we were impressed. Lots of room inside. Nice atmosphere. Service was very good and attentive. And the pizza was very good. We got the Chicago meat lovers. We can't wait to come back and try something else. read more

Joes Pizza - Chicago Meatlovers - Pizza Near Me - Herrin, Illinois

The pasta sauces are probably from Kroger, and the bruschetta is clearly a dessert, not an appetizer: outlandishly sweet. The pizza, however, is excellent as long as you dine in. Take out or delivery pizza has been NOT as ordered. There seems to be some obsession in the kitchen with thin crust. When a hand tossed crust is asked for it arrives correct as long as one is seated in the restaurant. Every time I've ordered for take out or delivery, despite asking for NOT thin crust the pizza has arrived incorrectly made. This is a hit/miss restaurant. read more

Best pizza in the area. Friendly service and great for dine in or take out. I really recommend their cousin tavio (Margherita pizza) on a cauliflower crust. read more

So good! I had their pizza daily lunch special and it was awesome. 8" 2 topping pizza, salad, and a drink for $7.99. Can't beat it. I'll definitely be back ! read more

It is our anniversary, a special occasion. I am a bed-bound vet, so I don't drive. My wife doesn't drive. We ordered a medium Joe's deluxe, chef salad, and fried mushrooms. The pizza was cold, as was the bottom of the box, and the mushrooms were cold and burnt. We ordered online. The girl said they would remake the order, but we would have to drive to pick it up because we ordered our meal online. My wife said the salad was OK. We wanted something special for our anniversary. Joe's is expensive and not worth another penny of our limited funds., read more

When Joe's first opened we tried their Chicago style pizza. Let's just say no one from Joe's has truly tasted Chicago deep dish. This was not deep dish! The sauce was too sweet. A true deep dish takes longer than a few minutes to arrive to table. So years have passed we decided to give them a try again. This time going with pasta. Since their red sauce is sweet we went with shrimp Alfredo. The Alfredo sauce tasted like water. Literally like water as water has no taste. Actually I prefer water over the tasteless sauce I was served. When asked if their chicken parm was fresh or a frozen patty. We were told they were frozen patties and the cooks would have a fit if they had to make a fresh patty. I will have to say the staff were extremely friendly. That was the highlight of our dinner. read more

So glad to have a place like Joe's here in Herrin! Just had a quick sandwich for lunch, So Good! I love their salads, but nothing beats their fried mushrooms! read more

Great small town pizza! I came from out of state and this is what she ordered. One Hell of a deep dish!

Really nice place with good food and a nice clean and bright dining room. The pizza is the star but the other food, pasta, salad and sandwiches are all really good. The service is also top notch. The servers (all of them) are constantly stopping to ask how they can make your stay more pleasant. Never does your drink sit empty or do dirty plates stay around with this crew on duty. Highly recommend this oasis in Herrin. read more

This is unlike any other pizza I have ever had! The deep dish pizza with the sauce on top is one of my favorites! Very good and I keep coming back! read more

We were in the area for an event that got rained out. We were looking for a local place and Joe's sure hit the spot. Very diverse menu, with something for everyone. read more

We've only been once to Joe's once when it opened. However they have great food, service, and are very clean. Would highly recommend Joe's Pizza! read more

Joe's has the best salad, pizza and pasta around. We used to make a special trip to Benton but now we get to go to Herrin anytime we want! Great service great food great atmosphere.A place for large families too read more

We has our dinner delivered. The Italian beef was good but no peppers. The club was ok. The fries were cool and rubbery. For the price we weren't impressed. read more

I've ordered from Joe's Pizza in Herrin numerous times and have been pleased; however, today I ordered a thick crust Meat Lover's pizza and it was not thick crust and only had a little sausage on it. Disappointed!!!! read more

Very disappointed in my last two visits! When they first opened the pizza was great but now it seems they have changed the sauce and use cheap cheese! Their sandwiches lack meat as well. read more

I found this restaurant thanks to Yelp. I was greeted by the friendly staff when I walked in and sat myself at the bar. I asked for a dark beer and the bartender told me about a local brewery in Murphysboro called Big Muddy and suggested their Saluki Dunkeldog. It was very good beer. He also suggested that I consider ordering their Thursday night special "all you can eat" spaghetti dinner with salad, garlic butter breadsticks and a soft drink for six dollars and some change and I accepted. I was glad that I did! The pasta sauce was fairly sweet, but that is just how I like it. The breadsticks were the best pizza place breadsticks that I have ever had. I was full after the first serving, but I had to order another plate of spaghetti because I enjoyed it so much. Herrin is lucky to have this excellent restaurant! They also serve Chicago style and stuffed crust pizza! They also serve some wonderful fried portobello mushrooms! Check it out, you won't be disappointed! read more

I would not eat here again. Two of our party found black hairs in our food. Asked to speak with the manager which proved fruitless. The taste was good until I found the hair and then I could not eat anymore. The other person in our party found the black hair at the bottom of his salad. Will not return again!! read more

Delish! The sauce on the pizza is slightly sweet and tasty. The servers are super nice. I've been to the restaurant twice and had it delivered once and really enjoyed myself. read more

OK try them when they oepn up Large pizza and bread sticks. The bread might ask why it was so boring no flavor as for pizza it looked good cheese pepperoni sausage this this should be good took a bite and disappointed filled my brain the crust was like cardboard how could this be I ask my self but I digress. the toppings was flavorless how can one can kill pepperoni flavor but you all did. And price not worth the bite I never came back. read more

Was just at Joes had a table in back room. It is seat yourself. Manager comes up to me asks how many in your party I said 3 he says I need to give this table to another party that came in they have more people. The table I had was only open table. I said your kidding me you want me to leave so you can give this table to somebody else. He stated whatever but you have leave this table read more