Maria was amazing to work with, and her pizza and cookies are de-lish!! I had communicated with her…read morea few days in advance, since I heard they were a popular new place! She was so helpful and quick to respond. The pizza crust is so good- a little on the thick side which I like! She added in some chocolate chip cookies for our large group order- it was such a lovely surprise! The cookies were perfect! All the best to this new business!

Clean little corner bar. Burger and wings were excellent. They have a nice tap and canned…read moreselection. Great value for your money!

Diamond in the rough! Phenomenal food with reasonable prices. Family friendly. Had just about every…read moreappetizer and dish with a party of 9. 5 kids all.loved the food and stayed entertained. Solid beer choices including IPA's. Highly recommend and dont judge a book by its cover.

The food was so good and the price was great. Super cute diner vibes I won't forget…read more We had burgers and they delivered.

Simple done right. Want good food and a good price? No frills? This is the place! The service was…read moregreat, the food was great, and that's all I could ask for! Was just passing through, but will be back when we're in the area again!

I ordered the pepperoni pizza for delivery. I was told it would take 30 minutes and it took 60…read moreminutes. The pizza was very good!!! I will order again!

Just discovered this little gem while in Mount Horeb visiting family. This is a great option if you…read morewant that traditional, hand tossed, American pizza. I loved the classic pepperoni pizza. It was the perfect ratio of dough, sauce, and cheese. I loved the flavor of the cheese, the sweetness of the marinara sauce, and the slight spice of the pepperoni. Great flavors! They are not open for dine in but they are open for delivery or takeout. The delivery took about 30 minutes longer than they originally told us but we understand that during these times.

We had been camping nearby, & wanted pizza. Never expected much, when you blindly pick a place, but…read morethey will deliver. That's a plus!! It was delicious! I'm originally from the Milwaukee area. They do know how to make pizza there. Then you move out of Milwaukee, to a small city in the country. People tell you where the great restaurants are. I'm really not sure what they are comparing their choices to. So we ordered a pizza, from the place that everyone raved about in town by us. It smelled really good, started to eat it, I would have rather ate the cardboard box that it came in. The crust was disgusting! The sauce had no flavor, neither did the Italian sausage. That was the first & last place we tried pizza in this area. Back to "Thee Upper Crust Pizzeria", Pardeeville, WI. I cannot Bragg enough about their Pizza. It's the best I have ever tasted! The smell when you walked in made me want to try everything on the menu! Then the pizza! We like thin crust. It was Amazing! The sauce was the best I ever tasted! Just the right amount of spices and the flavor was incredible! Italian sausage, was perfect! They actually use the cheese from our small city. That is really good cheese. Just everything that we have tried there, has been amazing! I have to admit though, I cannot go there & not order their pizza! Anything else we have wanted to try, we take it to go. They package up everything very well. The service is very fast, waiters & waitresses are very polite. We have even had the owner stop by our table to make sure everything was great, & asked if there was anything that he could get for us. Very pleasant people. We actually go there quite often, the food is just that good. From our home, to "thee Upper Crust Pizzeria" takes us 1hour & 38 minutes. That is one way! So it's a drive, but so worth the trip! They do not let you give more than a 5 star rating here, which sucks! This place should have double the stars! And, now I want their pizza...

Ordered food to go. Everything was packed up separately and perfectly! Pick up was ready at the…read moretime they gave us. The Italian beef sandwich (01) with au jus was delicious! Added the fries, but not my favorite. Looks like they use soy oil. We did not care for the baked ziti. Meat sauce had lots of spicy ground sausage. Too spicy for me. Don't care for their red sauce either. And pasta noodles were over cooked. Would definitely get the beef sandwich again. Nice size portion.

Stopped in for a few drinks on Thursday night...sat at the bar and had the best bartender,…read moreJason...talked us into trying the pizza..we also ordered the cheese curds..Holy crap! The pizza was amazing! The crust....mmmm...so as we sat there eating awesome pizza and cheese curds we saw a board with all these different Moscow Mules...I don't like to mix what I'm drinking but Jason made a Moscow Mule for me to try...WOW! So basically we are going back to try out the mules tonight....great tavern, great food, with a fantastic bartender!

If you're in the area you have to give this pizza a try. The crust is the most delicious crust I've…read moreever had, Monday night is pizza night and they always have specials for pizza night! Definitely a good pick!! They also have an amazing assortment of fresh breaded cheese curds, try them all they are absolutely fantastic

The waitress was nice even when my friend was rude. some people you can't take anywhere. Lol…read more Food is delicious! The atmosphere is clean and casual. I've gone in to order to-go a few times and it's always fast service.

Went on a day trip from Madison because it sounded like a neat town. It was pretty boring actually…read moreand virtually dead on a Tuesday. Everything was closed. The one bright spot was Sugar River Pizza, which was open and fairly busy...our server Piper was absolutely wonderful,a real sweetheart with a wonderful attitude and despite waiting close to 45 minutes for the food to come out,made everything right by bringing a delicious Oreo cheesecake for my friends birthday and it was free...her coworker also was super nice but man,it shouldn't take so long for the food to come out!! But I will say the salad was HUGE!!...thanks Piper!

Best cheese curds ever! Love it here. Cave of the Mounds employee recommended it. Glad we came…read more Great service, cozy, cold beer :)

We stopped here for lunch on a Sunday and there were people waiting in the parking lot we shared a…read morechicken sandwich and it was really delicious. My fiance got a spicy bloody and said he enjoyed it. The curds were just okay but I think we got a bad batch. Overall I'm glad we stopped to check this one off the list. Seems like a fun spot!

My brother in law wanted to stop in for lunch here while we were in town. We had a pretty large…read moregroup of 7 people; two kids and five adults. We didn't get immediate seating, but for a Saturday at lunch time that makes sense. They did get us in about 25 minutes later which I didn't think was too crazy. In total we were there for 90 minutes. We were seated upstairs, so we all got to take the elevator up. That was fun. We were kind of seated in a corner booth behind a wall, so I feel like maybe we were forgotten about a little bit by our server. I also think he was the only one working upstairs, so he might have been a bit overwhelmed. But he was very nice and took care of all of our requests. All of our food was decently good. Three of us got the bbq bacon style burger, one got a salad, the kids got the Mac bites, and one of us got the brisket sandwich. I was happy to see that one of the side options was carrots and celery, and they were big pieces of veggies for the sides. Would I come back here again? It's certainly not out of the question. This is my first time visiting this area so I'm sure there are other places to try as well.

Met friends for a mid-week lunch. We all appreciated the tall wooden booths which made our…read moreconversations easy. Between the four of us we ordered a burger, a salad, a bowl meal and a chicken sandwich. I had the Pesto Chicken sandwich with a side of tater tots (many other side choices to choose from). The sandwich was very tasty, even the roll itself, but the chicken was a bit chewy. The tots were awesome! Everyone enjoyed our lunch gathering. Our server was attentive and was happy to take a couple photos for us.

Got takeout pizza to take back to our campsite. It's a good sign when you walk in and there are a…read morebunch of folks wearing high-vis vests. They know what's good. Got a 16 in with pizza and black olives for four adults. The crust is really quite thick... more so than what I'd call NY style. Not a complaint! We just got so much pizza for the money! Sauce was very tomato-y. Not too much on the pie. A generous amount that stays under the perfectly baked cheese. Sausage was top notch. Will definitely get again, sine we come to DL at least once a year.

I'll admit I was skeptical walking in. The restaurant is attached to a hotel that isn't the nicest,…read moreand the entrance had a strong hotel‑cleaning‑supply smell that made me apprehensive. But from the moment we sat down, it was all uphill from there. The Italian wedding soup was excellent, rich, flavorful, and clearly homemade. The pizza was decent, nothing extraordinary but solid with plenty of cheese. We also ordered the lasagna, the spicy chicken dish, and spaghetti and meatballs. The standout was the spicy chicken: the "spicy red sauce" turned out to be more of a creamy, spicy blend, and it was fantastic. Everything came out piping hot, which I really appreciated. They also bring out warm rolls, and those were surprisingly tasty, soft, fresh, and perfect for dipping. Overall, I highly recommend this place. Despite the rough first impression, it turned out to be one of the best restaurants in the area.