I had heard great things about the pizza here, so I ordered takeout. I was taken aback when I arrived to see none of the three workers were wearing face coverings to protect their customers nor did I see gloves. In addition, when the lady worker cut my pizza, she used her fingers to touch a piece of errant pineapple to reposition it on my pizza. I didn't say anything, just took my pizza and left. I wonder if it really was as good as people told me it was. Perhaps once this Covid 19 pandemic is over I'll give them another try. read more

I places an order through doordash, had a little mix up on my order, but Ms. Lori handled the situation with ease, and made sure I received a refund from Doordash for the mix up. And the pizza was great! read more

Great pizza we absolutely love eating here I would of given them 5 stars but seriously kinda expensive for pizza idk

great pizza, fresh salads, and happy staff- great little pizza joint. I like that Casamel's is NOT a corporate chain and delivers a great pizza . Pizza is life. read more

My wife is in a rehab facility across the street from this place, so I said pizza sounds great tonight. So I go in I ordered a med white pizza w/ bacon tomato onion and my favorite anchovies. So as I sat there waiting there was a smell not of garlic like most pizzerias but just an odd smell. I get home pizza was nice and hot but there was that smell again it just turned my stomach I ate 2 slices it just didn't have any flavor, I mean ZERO FLAVOR. So 18$ of garbage. Hey you never know tell you try it, and I'll never try this place again. read more

Tastes amazing! Sauce is some divine. And the bread not too thick. Drove from Berea to get this. Will be back.

Had to stop mid-slice for a review. (Insert greedy pizza lover face) so I've been trying out different delivery pizza near my home and until now found NO PLACE I'd order from again. I don't even want to eat the other pizza when in a pizza emergency. This one has finally allowed me to rest. read more

Casamel's Pizza - Small pizza, sausage onion green pepper. - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

I have a family member who lives around that area and who would always order this for us when she babysat us as kids! Super good and I love that Parma has so many local pizza places that aren't chains. In addition, many pizza joints have disappointing wings but theirs are great!! The garlic Parmesan wings are my favorite and are actually crispy! read more

What a great local gem that delivers too!! I'm always wary of pizza places that aren't chains. I'll find that the sauce is too sweet, or the dough is over/under cooked, or cost too much, or the cheese is waxy, or the mushrooms are canned... Just yuckie overall. This place though! Definitely a mouthwatering surprise. Ate the Deluxe and White BTO specialties. I obliterated my BTO in minutes, no shame. As for the Deluxe, oh my. What big sausage chunks you have ;) read more

this is my family's favorite place to order pizza from! parties, gatherings, or a friday night hangout, we love everything about Casamels. it's way better than the usual chain restaurants, although maybe a little more pricey definitely worth it in taste and quality. read more

I normally really like the pizza, but I'm not sure about them after tonights order. $20 for a large 3 topping pizza SOAKED in grease? No thanks. They did ask me if I wanted a new pizza & I accepted. What I received was an even greasier pizza in its place! I loved their pizza because it wasn't soaked in grease. I told the female manager that was my issue. Also, their $6 "deluxe" salad is all lettuce w/ a tiny sprinkle of toppings. I drove my 2nd pizza w/ salad & got my refund. read more

Casamel's Pizza - Heres their "DELUXE" salad for $6! What a joke ! - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

See all

You can always tell a good pizza place by the quality of their wings. While their wings aren't the meatiest I've had. The sauces sampled(Garlic Parm and Garlic Hot) were above average in my book. Plenty of sauce to dip and decently priced as well. Pizza's pretty good, local mom and pop style, not too greasy, good on toppings, straightforward sauce, and good the next day as well. read more

This Pizza is so darn good. Seriously have had my family coming from Cinci and anticipating Casamels Pies. Wings are delicious also as a matter of fact never been disappointed in anything I have had the pleasure of eating and I have been a fan for MANY years read more

Some of the best pizza in Parma, and I'm a self proclaimed pizza snob. Their salads are a little lack luster but what pizza shop is known for salad. Worth a pie or two if you never had it. read more

Every time we are in town this is our go to place for amazing pizza! We have lived in many different cities and haven't been able to get a pizza that is even close to being as good! read more

Great pizza and friendly people, I only wish I live closer this here, I would get all my pizza from here read more

Casamel's Pizza - This pizza tastes great! I wish I lived closer. - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

I've had food from here many many times! One of the best around!! Staff is ALWAYS friendly and helpful. A woman named Lori has been very kind & patient with all my questions about my food options !! Great job Casamel's!! We will be back read more

Ordered for pick-up yesterday. Food was not ready when I arrived, even though I arrived after the window. Not only did I have to wait, when the pizzas were ready, they had not even made the sub. Then they rushed the sub, and it was not very good. The computers were down and no one knew what to do. They took my credit card information (no crash kit) and told me the total was $38. I had two separate charges on my card, one for $41 and one for $3. Lastly, not one single employee was wearing gloves while handling the food or masks to cover their faces while interacting with customers. Will never go back. Two medium pizzas and a half cooked sub are not worth $45 read more

Just moved to this part of parma and keep hearing what great pizza . Being a large family w 5 kids and normal half a soccer team here , we normally choose the $5 cheap pizza in our area . However tonight I decided on taste over cost . I was truly excited to have a pizza that tasted great and looked edible. We ordered a sheet pizza aka kids pizza , their white pizza aka mom pizza , & wings . Wings were some of the best I have ever ate. Now my normal pizza bill ranges $40 ... tonight our bill was almost $80 . So this will be a treat not a normal pizza night . However might grab me a white pizza , while out picking up our normal $5 kid pizzas . read more

I woke up feeling worse than I have felt in a very long time. Last night I was drinking at Prosperity and met a guy who was just released from Richland Correctional in Mansfield. He had DTA tattooed across his forearm. He explained this meant "Don't Trust Anyone", his personal mantra. He seemed to open up and trust me right off the bat. He bought us shots of gin and next thing I know he is getting belligerent, humping the bar and asked me if I had any crack. I should have never trusted this situation and denied the shots. I slept the entire day away and missed the Lion Dance at the Asian Festival. I still am bummed out about that. I needed some good, greasy pizza today. I wanted a place that I have not tried yet. I don't like any of the pizza in Tremont or in the immediate area so I figured the internet could find me something. I hopped in the car with Maddigan, the best norwich terrier ever, listened to Box of Rain, Ripple and a few other Grateful Dead classics and headed down 176 south to Parma. The pizza is typical mom and pop style, conveyor belt oven. Not much difference between this, Papa Nicks, Antonio's or Gepetto's. I enjoyed it and love to support local independently owned and operated places. I am having a party soon to celebrate quitting my job, (once I finalize getting the new job by being dehumanized and pissing in a cup) and am debating on getting a couple of sheet pizzas from here. It is good for the price. read more

Great pizza. Even better wings (yum garlic Parmesan). Had to give it a 4 star based on prices. A little on the high end compared to other pizza places in the neighborhood. read more

Ordered through Slice, waited 90 minutes called restaurant, was told "It's on it's way"... 30 minutes later I received a text from Slice saying order was cancelled, so called restaurant again and asked about status, was told "It's sitting here (which is weird, wasn't it on it's way?) but we received a notice from Slice saying it's been cancelled...I'm SOL on food of course, but why did the girl lie to me on the phone, unless the delivery driver made it back from the 3 orders (again, supposedly one was mine so how did she make it back so fast?) TO THE OWNER, I don't normally complain, you have great food, but the customer service is in serious need of an OVERHAUL. My experience was so bad that I feel I need to reach out to you. (And will) I can understand if they didn't see the order that came in from Slice originally, but why lie to the customer? I ordered pretty regularly, often twice a week, and I really will miss the product. To anyone reading, my experience is probably unique and non indicative of everyday service, all I can do is convey what happened. Please make your own choices in ordering, I didn't get any food so I am in no way bashing that, Casamel was always my first choice and the food is great, but I can't in good conscious take the chance on ordering again. read more

Casamel's pizza is fresh and delicious! They always have groupons and coupons out there so you can usually score 2 medium pizzas for around $15. The staff is always so friendly and the restaurant itself is impeccably clean. Definitely a great (NON-CHAIN!) pizza option for those in Parma/Old Brooklyn. read more

Don't let the name fool you, as I have had people say that the name doesn't match with what I'm stating that I'm ordering. But I have to say, the pizza is absolutely delicious. It's better than any chain in the area, plus you're helping to support the local small business, so why not? Also, I have to say, the customer service is excellent. Every time that I've gone to this place, I've been greated by warm, smiling staff. Definitely a must try. read more

Just moved to town and got a large pep and sausage pizza with an order of fries. Pizza was delicious some of the best I've ever had in my life. Crinkle fries were really good as well. Can't wait to try more things on the menu! read more

Great food and the customer service is nice. The garlic sauce pizzas are delicious and very satisfying!

I bought chicken wings there ask for BBQ they gave me spicy wings when I called the restaurant I explained to her that I have a severe stomach problem a hyena hernia and I'm unable to eat spicy food she was very rude on the phone did not want to replace the wings and I spent $40 my coworkers and I eat there at least twice a week I eat there once a week in the future I will not order from them anymore you lost a good customer and I went for my co-workers of this and hopefully they won't eat there and either because when you're dealing with the public and someone tells you that the food is not right most places will replace them but they did would not and were very rude read more

Okay so... Apart from the soggy pizza. The customer service was atrocious. I placed an order for 2 LG 1 topping pizzas. 1 sausage and 1 pepperoni. When bigot back home and dished the pizza out to my family my son kept complaining about the pepperoni pizza being terribly soggy. I had a similar complaint with my sausage pizza so I decided to try his. And it was awful. Completely soaked and nearly unedible. So I proceeded to call the place back to see if they could do something about my order. The manager was very rude and I had to go back with her about how the pepperoni and cheese makes the pizza soggy but how this wasn't my 1st pizza experience and this particular one was unsatisfactory. Eventually she replaced my pizza with aedium rather than the LG I originally had ordered. When I got to the place to pick it up the employees were snickering and talking rudely as I was exiting the restaurant. Will never go back again. read more

This place is great. I order take out and party spreads from here frequently. They are as consistent as you can get. One of the best in Cleveland. Try the Stromboli!!! Killer. Super clean and super friendly. Check it out you won't be sorry. That is unless you are from New York , in which case you should go back. Yankees suck. read more

Please don't use the menu on Yelps website, the prices are out of date, go to Casamelspizza.com for the current prices. You would think that a website like this they would keep businesses up to date when looking for prices and good food. The food at Casamels is great, but Yelp in OUT OF DATE!!!!!! read more

I LOVE THIS PLACE! I LOVE THE FOOD AND THE CUSTOMER SERVICE!!. I found the place from a friend that down the road. I started ordering while I am at work and now my entire company orders from them as well. I lived in downtown Cleveland and would drive there in weekends to get their food. I moved to North Ridgeville and now come back for their food. There is no other place Id rather eat. I joke with them when I call and call myself a VIP and now they call me it as well! Makes me feel special but love the food and the delivery reps are awesome as well!! Kudos! read more