I wish I could give them 20 stars just for the service alone and let me tell you we had a huge table full of people I think there was 13 of us just as they opened for the day. I didn't catch the servers name but she was extremely nice , very polite , helpful and she had drinks constantly filled kept a perfect check on everyone and honestly I hope her manager sees this I'm including a photo of her. The food was amazing I'm including photos of done if the plates I could get to easily but ALL the food looked and smelled delicious. The restaurant was spotless, the ladies restroom was very clean. I highly recommend this place . Try it and let me know if you love it read more

See all

This has got to be one of the most expensive restaurants in yelm. Food is ok tbh just a normal Italian restaurant in my opinion. The pizzas are not too bad but again very expensive. read more

The food is good, but like everything else it is ridiculously priced. A small bowl of soup was $7.25, and I had to add $1 to get 1 roll! On top of that they add a "kit chen gratuity" which was only .83, but I don't like that it was automatically deducted. The prices are higher than the one in Lacey. Not sure I'll be back. read more

Casa Mia - Minestrone - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

Food was not that good the prices were crazy for three dishes. It was $100. The spaghetti fettuccine tasted like nothing. The only thing was good in mine was the chicken. It took them one hour to just cook a single pizza and also took them like an hour just to get our food. read more

We had a birthday dinner for our sweet neighbor. All the food was fabulous. Lasagna, squash ravioli, chicken pasta, salads , everything was so delicious and with beautiful presentation. Love the attentive staff and warm environment! The night was perfect! Thank you! Even a special treat for the birthday girl !! read more

It was time for an updated review and Casa Mia didn't disappoint.. They have the BEST pizza's in town! The spicy chicken caesar is still my fav but they have a few delish salads on the menu. Their pizza selection is great, perfect pizza it isn't disgustingly dripping in grease like most places so you can actually enjoy it more. They have really good pastas as well, highly recommend the Chicken Alfredo. I didn't particularly care for their minestrone soup it really lacked flavor. The Bruschetta garlic bread is chef's kiss. I haven't tried any of the sandwiches but they offer a few different ones. The restaurant hasn't changed much over the years, it's still clean, still comfortable, and the service is still good. They are a bit more on the pricey side but in my opinion the food quality is worth it, at least for the salads & pizza's in my opinion. read more

Bruce and I had the ravioli. It was very good. Nice warm bread for dipping. It was very busy, but the crew were on top of it!

Meatballs appeared to be Costco product. Shrimp in the Fettuccine was made with frozen and defrosted bay shrimp. With the income and rising, there are options for homemade recipes from craftsmen chefs are out there. First time to visit. No plans to return. The server was exceptional. I wish them well. read more

Great service. Great food. Even was kind when our kiddos knocked over one of our beers. Great location and staff. We loved eating here. Thank you for an excellent dinner. read more

We came here one night on a whim because no one wanted to make dinner. We walked in around 6 on a weeknight and were sat right away. We ordered the artichoke dip as an appetizer, which was actually really good. I had the spinach ravioli with pesto cream sauce and my wife had the pesto chicken ravioli. We loved both dishes, the only thing I would say here is my dish was extremely heavy on sauce. I mean I LOVE sauce, but there was a lot. Our daughter ordered buttered noodles with a side of meatballs. She said the meatballs were amazing! The service overall was rather good, we didn't wait to long to order and our waitress was pretty attentive. For being in a smaller town like Roy, I was rather pleased with this establishment! read more

Casa Mia - the menu for the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

I have been going there for years and I've had everything from Pizza to ravioli to chicken Caesar salad and all the fresh baked chocolate chip cookies with ice cream and the fresh French bread rolls, I would recommend this restaurant to anyone. And the service is very good even when they're busy. read more

Love the service here, the people here are so nice. The food came less than ten minutes after we ordered and tasted amazing :3

The Good: Outdoor seating available in front or on thier fenced in patio area. Salads are made fresh (ranch is delicious!) House made meat/marinara sauce is very good. Steak is good if you like baked steaks like my husband. Cannelloni is meat filled vs cheese and is incredibly filling and tasty. Meatballs The Bad: Wine-They only have house wine and it is boxed Peter Vella wine. The So-So: White/Alfredo/cream sauce is quite plain & lacking in the garlic dept. Service-Not friendly, not rude, a bit slow read more

Casa Mia - Steak & spaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

See all

Food is ok but over priced for what you get. Service is usually good, open space is loud and hard to hear conversation. There were only two of us and they now add a kitchen gratuity to your bill, before tax. WHAT! Can't say this will be my first choice to go to again. read more

The servers are amazing!!! So nice and attentive! The ambiance is neat! We were confused about the French posters in an Italian restaurant though. The food was really good! One thing I will say, though, if you get the manicotti, expect hot cheese with a little bit of pasta. I almost choked on the sauce because it was all cheese. The cheese pull was real!!!!!! 10/10 if you Looooove cheese! 2/10 if you were expecting a manicotti. read more

Updating 5 star review from 2 years ago Quality of food has become spotty and inconsistent. Pizza is still great sometimes, sometimes just average. It's a pretty high price to get average pizza. My main issue is the arugula salad I used just rave over. Sometimes it has dressing, sometimes it doesn't. Lately it doesn't. When dressing is requested it is a ridiculously scant amount. It is supposed to come dressed in olive oil and have lemons for the acid kick. I never get lemons any more. This latest salad is the worst yet. A tiny splash of olive oil on the arugula, no lemon, and covered in deli meat ham. Called to complain and got the runaround. Ultimately was begrudgingly offered a store credit on the salad. We'll get that salad and go elsewhere for now. And yes, I fully understand staffing and supply chain issues, but I can walk into 3 grocery stores in town and buy prosciutto and lemons. If you can't provide the item listed, at least let the repeat patron know, so they can make the decision not to purchase. read more

Casa Mia - Dry arugula with deli ham. - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

The food, services and experiences is always fantastic. I recently moved back to the area, and I was thrilled this gem of a restaurant survived so many years. read more

Found ourselves in Yelm for the night; it's Thursday and it's 8:30pm. The hotel receptionist suggested Casa Mia, "chicken parmigiana to die for", she said. It's literally walking distance, as is just about everything in Yelm. We ordered a side salad, an antipasti salad and we split the chicken parmigiana! It was all quite delicious and we had more than enough food. Dinner came with rolls. I don't know how a single person could eat the whole thing? Two beers at $4 and a glass of wine for $7, this place is a great value. Our waitress was delightful too! If you are in Yelm around dinner time, you best stop here and enjoy good food, great service at very reasonable prices. read more

Food is always yummy and hot! They are busy, so be patient and kind. Recommend the raviolis of any kind, and the Italian Street sausage and beans is very authentic. The pizzas are also very delish! Food is always yummy and hot! They are busy, so be patient and kind. Recommend the raviolis of any kind, and the Italian Street sausage and beans is very authentic. The pizzas are also very delish! read more

Love this hole in the wall place! The butternut squash ravioli is absolutely amazing and their service is wonderful. Everyone is so kind and friendly. Such a welcoming environment and staff. Will be returning and definitely recommend! read more

The pizza was too greasy. So greasy in fact, it was dripping out the slices. And it turned cold right out the box. The pasta I had another issue with. There was too much sauce and cheese rather than real noodles and they tasted slightly undercooked and similar to boxed noodles at walmart. My last issue is with the salad. The salad had too much dressing and bacon and just looked completely unappetizing even looking like puke. I just did not eat it it was gross. at least the food edible. so if you are looking for a last resort, go to casa mia. but if you are looking for good food, go to pizzeria la gitana. better in so many ways, while casa mia compares to that of poor quality fast food. or to be better simplified, discount pizzeria la gitana. read more

Fast and friendly service. The bread appetizers (garlic and tomato and basil one) were delicious. The chicken in the chicken parmigiana was very fresh, not greasy from too much breading. This was made perfectly. I only wish the spaghetti did not come on a separate plate, it made it hard to eat together with the chicken. Overall a great meal. read more

Sadly our visit to this restaurant was disappointing. The food was bland and inside of the restaurant was extremely cold. The bread that comes out before the meal is a plain white bread with plain butter. Food tasted like it was poured straight out of a can of chef boyardee. Meal for 2 adults, 1 child was $60 plus tip. Was not worth it in our opinion. read more

Food is good, but over priced. Used to come here all the time but they keep raising their prices and making everything an added charge.

Service was great staff is really friendly, it's a cute relaxing chill place to have a nice lunch or dinner, I ordered the spinach and cheese ravioli that was delicious I ended up having to take half of it home as I got so full from the soup. Definitely recommend if you want a nice date night or family night. read more

Oh my gosh, delicious food. They delivered to the tap room. Pizza, BLT, tortellini and dessert. Wow, yum. Very memorable. Thank you.

If you like subpar, worse than Olive Garden, you'll eat at the Casa Mia! Not a fan at all of the food there. You're better saving your money and going to La Giatana for a better meal experience. But, the staff is wonderful! read more

I always order raviolis with meat sauce to go. They graciously bring them out to my car. Never disappointed.

Mmmmmmmmm! Can you just smell that delicious Calzone! Nice cozy restaurant with delicious food and fantastic service! I've had the Calzone several times. The pizza is always good and so is the Meatball Sub. read more

Amazing. There are no words for how good the food and staff are here. One of the best Italian restaurants I have been to in my 32yrs of life. If your in the yelm area stop in and get some good warm food. read more

Got a pizza and another dish- did a call in for a pick up- they said 15 mins. Left after the phone call do I would be there as soon as it was done. All went well got home put pizza on table and it looked old and dried up. We hadn't been there in about a year because the other times- items were missing or soup was broth only. We helped out numerous times during Covid so yes we tried to help our community. There are no more tries if they don't heed to the reviews and change we have no intention of giving our support- too bad they have so many patrons they can afford to not care. Sorry if we expected too much like a good well made food product or to have everything we actually paid for- guess it was just too much to handle. read more

Not disappointed in the food as much as I was in the take out service. Drove to pick up my order. Hostess AND a new manager went over the order with me item by item on the receipt and assured me it was all there. Went home, and it was not all there. I had guests over, and a calzone meal was missing. I called and told them what an inconvenience this was, as we would have to drive both ways to pick up one meal again, and the new manager asked me "what I wanted" in an irritated tone. She offered a couple desserts for the trouble. There were 5 meals paid for, so I told her that. My husband drove to Casa Mia for the forgotten Calzone meal, and the desserts were not ready or packed up for him. Manager told him he'd have to wait AGAIN. Meanwhile, our guest is waiting for dinner. Forget it! Mistakes happen, but this was very poor customer service that added insult to injury. read more

I would give this place a 3.5 if I could. The food was good but it made me and my fiancé sick later that night. This place was almost empty and it took forever to get served. They send out your soda in a small glass then with an additional glass with more soda for you to refill your glass yourself. So because they don't have to keep track of your drinks you don't see your waitress often. My fiancé ordered another beer that never came, BUT the lady noticed this and asked if we wanted the beer or a desert for free for our troubles. So that made up for it. The staff were friendly. There is no place to change your infant in the bathroom so I hope you bring a changing pad, which I do so no big deal I guess. It's decorated nice inside. All around an OK experience, not the best, not the worse. read more

Casa Mia - The inside of Casa Mia - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

See all

They have a sign that said, "Please wait to be seated. So we wait, then she just points to the back and says there's a booth in the back. Then we didn't get a menu for 5 minutes while people that came in after us received menus. Then she brought us the wrong pizza when I told her we didn't order mushrooms. She asked do I just want to pick them off. The staff was very polite and did let us take the wrong pizza with us fir people at home. read more

GREAT pizza! Cheese was super stretchy!Reasonable prices. Will definitely return to try everything on the menu. read more

Casa Mia - Torino pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

I had a great experience with this place! I got a Doordash gift card from my employer and decided to try this place out with it. I ordered an entrée, salad, and dessert. My $25 gift card covered almost all of it. The pasta was so good; great sauce, al dente pasta. Salad was great, nice fresh ingredients. And the dessert, well....I got the Classic Cheesecake with Mango Puree and it was beautifully delicious! Since it was a delivery order, the packaging was important and it was done perfectly. Nothing sloshed around or leaking. I'm a new fan of Casa Mia now. I highly recommend! read more

This place is great. We stopped by on our way to the movie and enjoyed their $5 Anniversary menu. The pizza was excellent. Their little pieces of pepperoni were some of the best I've had. But the Chicken Caesar there was one of the best I've ever had. I'll go back and order that off the regular menu. A memorable experience I'll enjoy again the next time I'm in Yelm. read more

See all

Casa Mia is one of my favorite restaurants in Yelm. To start with, they make the best Caesar salad ever. I crave this salad on a regular basis. Their calzones are gigantic and absolute stuffed full of deliciousness. I also really love their cheese pizza because it tastes clean without all of the distractions of toppings. The sauces on the pizza is very fresh tasting. That is not to say that their other pizzas are not good - because they are! Everything I have eaten at Casa Miss has been spot on delicious. And the staff have always been excellent as well. read more

This was our first visit ! Just as good as Olive Garden if not better and the service was great read more

See all

We had just finished up a terrible pizza from somewhere else and decided to risk carry out from somewhere else again. Not disappointed. Pizza was a little thick (we like that), lots of cheese, lots of toppings. Very flavorful. I highly recommend this place. read more