The top tier pizza this place gives you outweighs criticism. I do dread having to go through the customer service this place offers. The last three times I visited, It almost seems as if they neglected my order until I nudged them about it. Once or twice is acceptable, but c'mon. Again, the pizza this place serves and the quality control is awesome. The community likes this place of course but it's 95% product/location/ambiance and 5% staff. read more

This place was pretty cool. But if I'm keepin it 100, there WAS a dog in the kitchen. I definitely saw the dude on the line pet the dog and then go back to the line. The cook in the pic didn't pet the dog, I don't think. Idk. Maybe. ANYWAYS, I really liked the aesthetic. Except for how dirty the restroom was, I thought the place was great! I didn't even mind having to wipe down my own table and seats before sitting down to eat. WAC 246-215-06570 read more

Old School Pizzeria - Dog in the kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Best pizza in town and an authentically downtown Oly experience every time. Ranch it up!

i wish i could give this place ten stars! We were visiting Olympia and a local friend suggested that this might be among the very best pizza on the entire planet. i took that with a grain of salt, but we decided to try it anyway. I'm not sure how to convey just how tasty this pizza was. The dough was perfectly tasty - salty and crispy! The sauce was tangy and rich. The toppings fresh and tasty. The salad we had was amazing - full of fresh lively vegetables, and the two dressings we tried were both excellent! The air smelled of jasmine and honeysuckle... Seriously though... This was some of the best pizza i have ever had. I felt like a child again - eating something that would forever change my life. My only regret was that i couldn't force more of this into my body... Also, while I am effusing - I have to give a shout out to the staff there too! They were all perfectly fun and engaging - true pizza aficionados - and just generally awesome people! Do the basics right and results can be amazing! I will never visit Olympia and not stop here! Old School Pizzareria is now immortalized! This is the pizza of dreams - in real life! read more

Old School Pizzeria - i usually let the camera eat first - but this was the best pizza i have ever had. waiting was not an option with this one! - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Stopped here for a quick bite on our way to Tacoma. Ordered a slice of olive and mushrooms New York style and a Sicily. Both were quite tasty. The Sicily was flavorful and the crust was crunchy and soaked with olive oil. Plenty of street parking spaces. read more

A friend ordered their takeout pizza and got us the vegan options. It didn't have cheese, but it had interesting creative toppings like roasted cashews and a delicious sauce and crust. We were told they always have a vegan option on the menu, and non-vegans liked the other pizzas as well! I would like to go dine in the restaurant. read more

Old School Pizzeria - Vegan pizza - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Excellent pizza!! Great crust! Good flavor. Cool vibes and interior. I was beginning to think I wasn't gonna find good pizza in OLY after moving here. This place has restored my faith. As a native New Yorker now living in Olympia, this is by far, the best pizza in town. And, I will go so far as to say it's tied for the best pizza west of the Mississippi (the other being Bronx pizza in San Diego). I always try a standard plain slice to test out the goods. This was like a slice from back home. They got the crust just right; crispy, with good flavor. Just the right ratio of cheese and sauce. I'll definitely be back... often. They just need some garlic powder shakers. read more

See all

Simply put, I loved this place. Loved the vibe, the prices, the food, the arcade games. I am from New York and these slices held up Not only was the pizza great but the toppings took the flavor even further. Loved the fermented chili flake condiment the most. If you live here or are visiting, it's still a multiple visit kind of place Slices tried Plain with roasted garlic cloves, delicious! Pepperoni, delicious! Kromer (bacon, goat cheese, marinated spinach), delicious! Sicilian, good! The tap water was somehow better than average too read more

See all

I love this pizza! New York style cooked over a open fire perfectly made. The selection of pizza and beer is so WA and I love it. The only pizza my wife request. read more

Between the vintage 80s/90s throwback decor that feels authentic to the time, the legit NYC style pizza, and great beer on tap, this place feels like a blanket on my soul. My favorite restaurant in Oly. read more

Old School is a really cool pizza place with big comfy booths and tons of nostalgia. You can get pizza whole or by the slice here depending on your hunger level. I got a "one ton" pizza, and my partner got the pomodoro, which is one of their vegetarian pies. We both really enjoyed our pizza -- it's really good standard thinner crust pizza. Not Neapolitan, or NY style, or any of the other specific regional styles. They do technically have a vegan pizza, but it doesn't have a cheese substitute -- there's just no cheese. The menu lists cashews, but don't get confused -- it's not cashew cheese, it is actual whole cashews on top of the pizza. If you're in a rush, definitely get a slice rather than a whole pie, which can take a while, since they have to actually bake the pie. I'd say it's nice to go in a group, but keep in mind that they play the music pretty loud in there, so you're not going to hear someone sitting at the other end of the table. Overall, fun cool place with good pizza, definitely worth visiting. read more

Great food, great service and great staff! Easy to get to with directions on website! read more

Pizza was seriously incredible. We had a previous favorite restaurant before going here....we aren't going back to them lol. The flavors were so good, I could have cried. My husband and I fought over who would get the last slice. read more

Old School Pizzeria - Best pizza - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Great vibes and delicious pizza. The staff were super nice and helpful. Highly recommend. read more

We stopped here before going to a play. Really busy plus the food was good! We split 2-pizzas and had a pitcher of beer.

Heavy sigh... My first pizza from Old School was delightful. Amount of toppings? Check. Distribution of sauce and cheese? Just right. Not overcooked, not undercooked? Check. Just moved to Oly and was searching for my new go-to places so I thought, great, excellent pizza place - all set. Or so it seemed. The 3-4 times since then have been no where near that first experience, sadly. There are two main issues. One, attention to the making of the pizza. Either the cooks are careless or, more likely, poorly trained. Sauce needs to have good even coverage - within an inch or inch and a half of the crust edge. Cheese distribution is even more important. If it is not touching the crust as a way to anchor the cheese as it melts, everything just pools to the center as it cooks. That leaves the enjoyer of the pizza (me) having a couple of first bites that are okay and then over half of the pizza concentrically with dry crust that has no toppings. Where did the toppings go? All gooped up in the center. I had to throw out half of my large two topping pizza due to it being tasteless crust only. I've worked in the pizza world for longer than perhaps I should have so, while I waited for my pizza, I watched the cook on the makeline and knew I was doomed. Making a pizza is not an art - the artistic elements have to do with your dough ingredients, sauce seasonings, selection of quality ingredients, and such. Constructing a pizza is a skill that anyone can learn, they just need instruction and consistent attention to that construction. Secondly, again, either an issue with the cook(s) or a management decision to noticeably decrease the quantity of the toppings. For a two item pizza, I should be able to taste the sausage let alone SEE it. Aargh. So, so disappointed. My brain, unbidded, went to the thought of asking for a job application so I could get in and make my own pizza as well as support the staff to do the same. Alas, almost no one can make a mortgage payment as a pizza chef and by the time I retire I won't be old school cool enough to work there. Back to making pizza at home I guess. Love you folks and support your presence but what happened to my first time experience?? OR, just tell me who the best cooks are and I'll make a personal request next time I call. read more

I tried the pepperoni and the Don Ho slices. Both were good. The slices are large. Maybe took 5 minutes to get my order. The walls are covered in old posters which adds to the decor. The staff was friendly and explained the menu upon entering and questioning about their options. Drinks are not Pepsi or Coke products and they have lots of beer choice in fridges. Bathroom has a lock on it, you have to ask staff for the code. read more

See all

Nothing pretentious here, just the best hand tossed pizza and garlic knots in Olympia. read more

Old School Pizzeria - View of inside 11/16/25. - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

See all

I've been here a million times, some nights the knots are just perfect. Not (pun intended) to anything ...(which is a moving target for every person I realize). And tonight was it. It was packed and still they were perfect. So hats off to those bakers/chefs who reach into the fire to bring joy to the people. read more

Old School Pizzeria - Knott just bread! - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

See all

This is a place for twenty year olds. The music is loud and the customers are loud. The pizza is fine, not particularly outstanding. Never again. read more

Best pizza I've had since I moved here. I'm from NY so this is biased, but this place was incredible. Great representation for a NY style pizza. The ambiance inside is amazing as well. Will be coming back for sure. read more

Old School Pizzeria - plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Best pizza ever!!!!!!, Amazing service. I love how decorative, it's absolutely the coolest place i've ever seen + great PIZZA

I absolutely love this place. Being an East Coaster and living in the west for 40 years this is definitely old-school pizza. For me, it was just perfect and we will definitely be returning many times. There's nothing like the smell when you walk into a pizza parlor. read more

See all

Super chill pizzeria, amazing customer service, great music and of course delicioso pizza. Came here on a recommendation from my tattoo artist. The vibe and pizza was a perfect end to my afternoon and evening in Olympia. read more

pretty good fuckin pizza i spilt bleu cheese all over my bbc jeans but its okay cuz it was bomb asf. awwesome style of the restaurant but 75 cents for sauce is tax ashellllllll read more

See all

Updating my review to five stars. I am from Brooklyn so I am a tough critic for pizza in this style. That said, nothing in this area is anywhere near as good as they are. I have been here countless times. They are open late on weekends, have dedicated parking spots in the lot next door, reasonable prices, friendly staff and both full pies and slices that are always hot and fresh. read more

I have been going to Old School Pizzeria for years, and until recently, I would rate this place 5 stars hands down. The last time I ordered a pizza with Italian Sausage it was anything but Italian Sausage. Almost tasted like some kind of hamburger mix--horrid. Italian Sausage is Italian Sausage. It cannot be mistaken for anything else. Sorry but have drop the rating to 4 stars. read more

Visiting in the area we stop in for a slice of pizza. Vegan choice doesn't come in a slice. You have to purchase a pie. Music was a big loud! Staff lack customer service! Although the place seems like a local place to grab a slice. At your own risk! read more

Old School Pizzeria - Vegan choice - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

See all

I'm a regular here. The staff is always friendly to me. I came in today with my son and an employee here running the front was very rude and refused to serve me. She had poured a drink I paid for not full and I had asked if she could pour me the full glass. She refused to and gave me a refund and wouldn't allow me to order again. Very aggressive and standoffish for no reason after I had asked if she could make my drink right. read more

Got a slice of pepperoni pizza and a diet cola. A bit cramped, and it took a little while for them to make it, but at least they had some arcade cabinets and pinball while you wait. Best pepperoni slice I've ever had. By contrast... the diet cola (which cost me more than two bucks for a rather small cup) tastes like literal urine and has this aftertaste that stayed in my mouth for twenty minutes after I was finished. Will be coming back for the pizza, but next time I'm just going to grab a bottle of Pepsi from the convenience store that's a five minute walk away from there. read more

Old School Pizzeria - Slice of Pepperoni Pizza ($4.25) - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

We stopped in Olympia hungry and locals pointed us to this pizzeria. I gotta admit when I got here I got surprised and a little bit shocked, the place has a lot of character: very loud but cool music (mostly rock from 80's, 90's) graffiti everywhere with posters on the walls. Yikes!!! The servers are the NICEST persons I have ever met. You order at the counter and then they'll call your name. You can stay and enjoy your meal there or take out. We ordered: cheese pizza, Hawaiian pizza and mushrooms pizza. They're thin and fresh, SO SO yummy!!! Large pizza (18') is huge but enough for 4 ppl. They have drafted beer, sodas and canned beer as well. Oh! They also have two type of salads. PS: check out their little arcade at the back of the place, they have pinball machines and pacman read more

See all

I called in my order and got an 18" Old School Pizza. Took 45 minutes, so I drove down and enjoyed a beer in house. I had the German Pilsner while people watching and enjoying the ambiance of a bustling slice house. My pizza was hot, fresh and delicious. Fresh mozzarella, basil, thin, chewy, crispy crust. So good! I can't wait to eat more Old School Pizza when I pass thru DT Olympia! read more

Old School Pizzeria - Old School and German Pilsner - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Great pizza. Not the greatest service. And the music is not to my taste so I do take out. But all that said the pizza is fantastic!!!!

Two stars because at least they were able to keep the lights on I guess (and I don't typically believe in 1 star reviews). Here's how my experience at Old School Pizza went: "Can I get a pitcher of the Hefeweizen?" "Sorry we're out" "Can I get a large cheese and onion pie with ricotta?" "Sorry, out of ricotta" "Can I get a large order of garlic knots?" "Sorry we're out" Wanted something custom and tasty. But ended up getting a plain pepperoni pizza. It was at least on par with the Costco food court's pizza, so I guess there's a silver lining. Maybe I caught them at a bad time, but lower your expectations just in case. read more

I haven't been here in years. So glad I brought some friends by for slices. Same great energetic atmosphere. Pizza has gotten even better. Restaurant staff was hustling through a busy period, but not too busy to handle a problem with our order with grace and efficiency. Thanks, Old School! read more

Loove dis place!! The decor and music always fye . The pieces are pretty affordable and good. The calzone takes a while to get but it's very yummy chompy. And if saves well (it was pretty big so I saved some) very cool spot with a good amount of seating. read more

A Cold Pint of a locally brewed IPA, a slice of "Don Ho" Pineapple and Canadian Bacon and a slice of Black Olive & Mushroom. These slices come correct, fresh out of the oven HOT cheese that'll scald the roof of your mouth and as importantly folds correctly to be enjoyed head tilted sideways As a Native from NJ I take my pizza seriously and this place gets it 100% read more

See all

This place is always been a favorite pizza joint for me! I've been coming here for years. Great pizza great beers great atmosphere great service this place never leaves you wanting for anything. read more

Old School Pizzeria - Don Ho - ham and pineapple and Olive & Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Ha ha ha. My last review was removed. So here's the short. Went here to get some pizza while on vacation in the Olympia area. It was disgusting. We waited 45 minutes and never received our pizza. My previous review was probably removed because I talked about all of the drug use and gross things that were going on inside and around the establishment. I guess it's "hate speech" to point out wildly inappropriate things. Food, service, and ambiance... best described as water trash! I hope that doesn't offend anyone... read more

This is my favorite pizza in Olympia! You order from the counter, and take your seat and are handed a number. They have great beers on draft, but also a nice selection of cans to choose from, which are unique and awesome. The pizza is pretty fast in preparation and you can order by the slice. I love to try their daily specials even though I am a classic Pepperoni girl. Getting a few by the slice means you get to try all the flavors :) The ambiance is like a funky nod to an arcade with the walls filled of musical icons to enjoy. They do have their own restrooms, and parking has never been an issue at all. The sun does shine directly on the storefront so the inside can get warm in the summer, but the cold drinks definitely help. I do wish there were an awning out front with outdoor seating, but this has never prevented me from getting my pizza craving fix! read more