Farrelli's was always a favorite of mine. When they opened one in Yelm I was ecstatic. Our first half dozen trips were amazing, food was delicious and service was over the top. Then bam hit a wall. Food not great and service was awful. Got gift cards for Mother's Day this year and decided to try our luck again for date night. The food was amazingly delicious and the service was again spectacular. We got the family special, 16" pepperoni pizza, fire sticks bread sticks and 10 in bone chicken wings for only $50. Needless to say I will be back. Thank you Astrolean (sp?) for great, great service! We will be back!! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Farrelli's classic pepperoni pizza 16" - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

See all

We used to really love the Farrelli's in Fredrickson so we decided to try this one. For a while we were the only ones inside and it still took forever. The food came out wrong and then took forever to make it right. The waitress was nice but way overwhelmed. Took too much time talking to her friends at the bar. Will take a pass anytime we find ourselves in Yelm. read more

The pepperoni pizza deserves 5 stars. Did a Hungry Family Meal Deal and everything was good. Firesticks, boneless wings and 2 pizzas for $75. Our server was solid. But, the overall service was a bit slow. The staff all seem relatively new, there were considerable amounts of people waiting to be helped by the door. Some people turned around and left. I wouldn't have noticed if I wasn't sitting by the door, but it was a bit distracting trying to dine while many folx are waiting for someone to greet them and tell them what to do. read more

I've been ordering food here the last few weeks and their food is always delicious and so fresh!! The wings are always so delicious I highly recommend the sweet chilli garlic ones. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

Matt at Farrellis was absolutely the bees knees! Excellent service, food, and drinks!

Was craving a NYC style pizza and according to Google, this place was going to be as close as we could get without going to Tacoma, so we ordered a simple half cheese, half pepperoni. It was delicious, hit the spot for sure. It wasn't exactly a NYC pizza but it was close enough and satisfied our craving! Delivery was quick too. (Just a heads up, the pepperonis were the little ones lol) read more

Food and service was ok, we wer sat near a family where the kids were loud and we got annoyed by it. Pricey I must say.

A great place to dine in or takeout really love their garlic cheese bread. I really like taking out-of-town family here because it just gives cozy pizza vibes read more

It's your normal chain restaurant nothing out of the ordinary here. Very expensive for what you get. The service is very good management is great. Food wasn't bad it just cost so much for what you get read more

As busy as this place was they got to us in a reasonable timeframe. They let me sample a few beers before I decided. I got fat and happy off of pizza and beer. I think we were the only southern rednecks in the joint, but we were also the only ones eating pizza with a knife and fork. I finished off a 12" and two 24 oz beers, by myself and typically I don't eat the crust. This crust is different. I ate the WHOLE thing. This crust was warm and crisp and fluffy all at the same time. The ambiance is geared towards family. Whether it's nobody wants to cook or baseball team's lunch. I've had pizza all over the U.S. and a couple places in Europe, this place makes the top five. It is on the pricey side, but you get what you pay for. I just wished there was more meat on the pizza. read more

Spaghetti has been around since the 13th century for a reason--it's a classic that doesn't need to be changed. While cavatappi might be a fun option, it shouldn't be forced as a replacement. Please consider offering spaghetti as a choice rather than removing it entirely! For this reason I'll enjoy food elsewhere! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - No spaghetti noodles ! - Pizza Near Me - Yelm, Washington

Did not enjoy our experience at all. Long wait, food was not exceptional. Employees were friendly and attentive. read more

Both food and service were outstanding!! I got mine to go but the ambiance seemed great

Been a few times now and it seems each time, the pizza is burnt, the environment is noisy and the price for pizza that has been overcooked is too much. I'd be fine with paying the prices if the food was cooked correctly. read more

Sam the bartender is 100% best and now Manager of this location. Great service, great food, great place! Highly recommend!

Very good wood fired pizza, quick and friendly service. Fantastic deal on Mondays (a kid meal for every $10 spent). The kids meals are generous including a drink and a kids appetizer. read more

It's okay pizza. Not the greatest. I got regular pepperoni pizza take out and it wasn't even warm and I came earlier than suggested to pick it up. If it was fresh out of the oven then it would have been warm at least but nope, seems like it was sitting there for way longer than the 45 minutes it suggested for pickup. The bottom was burnt and it was tough to bite on. It was my first and last time trying out this place. read more

Been here a few times since we moved to Yelm, always great service which brings us back and the food is good too! I love the casual vibe. We will continue to frequent. read more

This place may be a chain, but don't let that stop you from visiting. When I want a thicker, chewy, tender, savory crust on my pizza, with outside-the-box toppings, this is the place to go. I've dined in and taken away from this establishment on quite a few occasions, and I've never been disappointed. Wait staff is super friendly and seem to really want to be there; food comes out hot and timely and is delicious, and wine pours are generous. Favorite pizza by far is the Double Whammy with added Cheddar! That Mike's Hot Honey drizzle over the top puts this pizza into a class of its own. Favorite salads - Love their Chop Chop and Dad's Bacon & Cheddar Salads. We haven't yet tried their pastas cuz we just can't bypass our fave pizzas, but it's on the list. Pizzas at Farrelli's are your more American standard style, but I'm not mad at that - definitely a step above your Dominos, Pizza Huts or Round Tables. read more

As a franchise company the taste never changes, however they have a monthly change of the month style pizza and never know what it might be. I enjoy the NW style pizza the most, but you can never wrong with the spicy Ahola BBQ Chicken, double whammy, blazin buffalo, james favorite, and the PNW cheesesteak. Service is always good no matter if it's an over packed night. The vibe is always good specially on those sports nights. read more

This place is an okay place to get pizza. Pros- Great service, seated right away and we got to choose our table, happy hour prices are alright ($1 off beers and 25% off pizza and breadsticks) Cons- Flies inside, very basic flavors and mediocre food We ordered 2 appetizers: Firesticks- basic cheese sticks drizzled with buffalo sauce, served with ranch and a sauce called Blue Cheese but was absolutely not Blue Cheese, this was okay. Pub Pretzel with cheese- pretzel was frozen and then heated with poppyseeds and salt which was a weird combo and the cheese sauce was so plain and not flavorful at all. We ordered a Margherita Pizza- small diced tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and a drizzle of of balsamic- balsamic does not belong on a Margherita pizza and the tomatoes should have been sliced instead of diced, I thought the crust was too thin and crunchy but husband thought it was okay. This is a super basic American pizza joint- its okay. read more

Decided to try this location with the fam yesterday. It's the newest location for this pizza establishment located in Yelm close to the Medical Plaza, High School, corner lot. As we entered, we were greeted by a friendly young man, sat and he told my husband, "Happy Father's Day." Another young lady came to take our drink and appetizer orders. She arrived shortly with our drinks and mentioned that she would go look for plates and napkins for our coming appetizer. We waited for a little bit when the 1st employee (the young man) delivered our appetizer, which were farrelli's fire stix (their version of cheesey garlic bread with jalapeño cream cheese, red pepper flakes, and a firey sauce on top). He said he would grab us plates for the appetizer, too. So we waited again, and no one came with plates. I finally walked up to a different employee who looked flustered that I asked her for something we were waiting for, but it wasn't her fault. No fault on her. Then we heard loudly from another employee whom Im sure she asked for help with us and that young lady loudly replied, "Well I can't do it, I'm busy!" The employee who I asked arrived with plates, napkins, and spoons, and she was apologetic and nervous, but we all thanked her. Our original waitress finally came to deliver our personal pizzas, gave freshly grated parmesan on my son's pizza, and then left. We chose 3 different pizzas, the James Favorite, The Italia, and the Northwest Traditional. Not bad. Pizzas were better than the appetizer for sure. Im giving this place a 4 out of 5 because of the food and not the service. We did see that the general manager was walking about, but he never graced our side of the establishment. Things to improve: 1# Offer waters along with drinks 2# ask if someone who doesn't have a fountain drink if they'd like another drink or even a different option. I was empty for the duration of my pizza, and that doesn't sit right with me. 3# have your employees not bark at one another in ear shot of the customers We'll come back, food wasn't bad. read more

See all

I had written a less than satisfactory review about the Yelm store and wanted to let everyone know that we gave them one last shot and this time we were very satisfied with The pizza ! The pizza was delicious and very hot when it came to our table. The cheese had the correct pull and we are going to go back soon. read more

My husband and I came here for date night and I was craving some wings. I didn't realize how not really spicy the wings were going to be. I thought they were ok, my husband enjoyed them; we got the original, shareable size (12). I think the biggest turn off in that dish for me was that my ranch tasted completely like mayo. It was very gross to eat with. My husband and I got the 16' Margarita pizza and it truly never disappoints in my eyes. Baby wasn't too happy though with the wings and "ranch" sauce, so by the time pizza came I honestly lost my appetite. I had maybe a small slice before my husband noticed I was getting pretty nauseous. We sat in the bar section just because there was lots of seating, but it kinda seemed like our waitress didn't really care about us. She checked on us once but that was because she was the one who brought us the pizza and then after that we never saw her again. read more

Not only is the staff super friendly, I was pleasantly surprised with the food. Being new in town, I was in search of a thin crust and they delivered. Their wings are also super good. They bake them and I get them plain. They have a nice crust and they make their own blue/ranch dressing. read more

The pizza is good and the service is generally pretty good. The one gripe I have is how expensive it is. We rarely go because of the cost.

First time here. Visiting family in the area and was brought here for pizza and beer. We had 2 large pizzas, The Deluxe Combo and The Double Wammy. Bothe pizzas were great and I especially liked the fresh Parmesan cheese the added. I also had the Chop Chop salad withe fresh salami. I topped it off with a cold Georgetown Manny's Pale Ale. Great place to bring the family and I saw and advertisement for Trivia Night with prizes. When in town I will definitely come here. read more

Ok we gave a bad rating for Farrelli's in Yelm before, and they gave us a coupon for a free pizza, which was good. Then when we went there yesterday the server asked if we had had a bad experience before and we said yes the pizza came to us just warm. The taste was fine but you want a steaming roof of the mouth burning pizza when it comes out. He said they were going to change our minds and boy did they! The pizza was hot, roof of the mouth burning hot! The flavor was excellent and the experience was awesome! Farrelli's Yelm, you have won us over and we thank you. A lesson learned was if you order a supreme topping pizza ask to have it stay in an extra minute or two long because there's so much toppings it takes a little longer to get that steaming hot pizza we all love so much. Thanks Farrelli's Yelm, we love your pizza and we love supporting local business. read more

Came in for lunch today and had the server Karmen! She was so sweet and kind and made sure we had everything we needed and checked on us the perfect amount! The food is always delicious and we love coming here so glad we have a location close to home! read more

We always have a great experience here. Good prices and great food. We visit probably 3 times a month.

The food was absolutely terrible :( the spaghetti was soggy and gross, the chicken wings were... cold?

If you come in looking for an awesome experience that is what you are going to get. Great atmosphere and just a great place to come and enjoy some quality time with great food and great service. Tuesday night trivia's are a must!!!!! read more

First time eating here total of 5 people which 3 our from my family. The waitress showed up at our table once food. The food over 50 mins to get to our table. Disappointing read more

Unexpected evening meal with 3 kids who were expecting Zoo Lights but because it was sold out turned into pizza! They loved the kid's distraction pack of cheesy bread, carrots and dip, and a ball of floured dough - Grandpa liked it too! Then the pizza came and we were all impressed! Reasonable prices, excellent service (thank you David), and the night was saved. The family side provides a kid safe environment and we felt comfortable even when the 1-year old "vocalized" her excitement a few times. We'll be back. read more

Been to many farrelli's and this one is no exception to the excellent atmosphere. service was fantastic. Alexus was an amazing server. Give her a raise! She was Attentive, courteous, and friendly. The old fashion was on point and the bar is solid. I would have tipped $100 if I could've. Food is a little pricy but worth the price if you enjoy good quality ingredients and pizza. read more

Waited for 20 minutes, no one took our drink orders, we just left. I know they saw us- there were 4 of us. We used to like coming here, will not be returning. read more