We love Casa Mia's Crab Cakes but we just had a DELICIOUS STUFFED SHRIMP Special, this needs to be on the everyday menu. We've not had this good Stuff Shrimp since we left Maryland and we've been at the beach for over 5 yrs. We were considering returning Easter Stunday and putting the ham away, before the Stuff Shrimp leaves the menu....!lol read more

My cocktail was terrific. I hand a special which was cookies and cream. slick got a bThis place is always packed. It is the only place to eat a round here. I ordered the salmon which was delicious. It came w it's a salad (Cesar for me) and rice, asparagus, and yellow squash. So good. He ordered the chicken that came with pasta and a salad. If you see me there, stop by and say hello. read more

See all

Crab cakes were excellent Salad very fresh enjoyed the dill dressing Our friend is gluten free and his pizza he said was delicious read more

I went for Happy Hour. Boy did I leave happy. The specials at the bar were plentiful and delicious. Kelsey worked her tail off to take care of her servers and bar customers. She was speedy, friendly and super helpful. It's a neighborhood bar with lots of locals. As a single female, I felt safe and cared for. I'll be back every time I'm in town. read more

I was excited to go back and try this place again! Everything was still really good. The bolognese was filled with meat and the portion was super large (I was able to share and still had leftovers). The bang bang shrimp was great again as well. Even though the service was a little slow, the server was so friendly and nice and apologetic, the whole experience improved. read more

This is my parents' favorite local Italian restaurant. It is a small place, but the food is excellent. I ordered the chickenParmesann which also comes with a salad. The chicken was excellent. It was tender, and the sauce was really good. The salad and house dressing were fresh. My son had the penne with meatballs. His first meatball was hard, so they brought him a new one right away. The meatballs are really good. read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Chicken Parmesan - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

See all

I love this place, being a Baltimore Native, I grew up going to Casa Mia's In Perryhall & Hunt Valley.To have this gem in Myrtle Beach.They have a fantastic happy hour.$10 martinis & $9 bites in the bar area. read more

What a yummy experience. From the moment Donna our server sat us until we left it was a delicious time. Ambience is deco modern with get bar area, booths, tables. Owner from Baltimore so serving the Best Crab cakes south of Baltimore. Cloth napkins, plates for sharing at place sitting. Brick oven from Italy so the pizza fantastic. Menu is well rounded and something for everyone. Highly recommend it- AND ASK for Donna!!! Bar great selection of wines as well. Must try. read more

See all

Great atmosphere! Super nice servers! The food was extremely bland. The red sauce on my pasta was comparable to the canned pasta and sauce that I ate in the 80's as a kid that had no flavor. The chicken piccata was comparable to a cream of chicken soup based sauce-no acidity or flavor at all. The bang bang shrimp was fantastic though! Would eat only that again, that is if I was ever to return, which I won't be. read more

Excellent service and quality food. Stevie was our fabulous waitress that made sure we got our happy hour drinks and food order in. Mussels very tender, pizza tasty and crab eggrolls had lots of crab. Plentiful salads before the entrees. Odd but no bread for the table. Entrees were Lasagne, Bolognese, Salmon and Gluten free ravioli. Had leftovers and were too full for dessert. Def will be back! read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

The food was amazing! The crab cakes are some of the best I've ever had, and I grew up 1.5 hours from Baltimore. ‍

Ehh been a few times not consistent. Good crab cakes for sure. Soup inconsistent and lasagna horrible. Sent an email about our experience. Not going back. read more

If you are from the blue crab state as we are, you know crab cakes . Casa Mia is a Maryland restaurant here in Surfside. The food is authentic and you will not get Maryland crab cakes and crab soup anywhere else in SC. read more

OMG the best crab cakes I've had since moving down to Myrtle! These are legit straight from Baltimore! I thought the happy hippie was good, but this takes all! Wonderful! Will definitely be back! read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Crab cake - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

I think we went the second night open. Very excited because live across the street. It was set up well and clean of course. Lisa was bartending, very pleasant. We found out later that they do have a HH. The menu looked better than any HH around. We got the crab cakes. 10 out 10!!! Best I've had in YEARS and the best in MB. We also ordered a pizza and devoured it. Im looking forward to being a regular. read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Meat pizza, added ricotta. 10/10 - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

See all

Valentine's Day we had a party of eight we arrived. We were informed the kitchen was down due to a propane issue. There were people sitting and waiting for the truck to arrive to fill the propane after we were all seated, they gave us complementary appetizer, which was very nice. We talked for approximately 15 minutes. They took our order and within 10 minutes later everyone had their meal. Everything was very delicious and portions were generous at the end of the meal after dessert was served they brought a rose with baby breath to all of the ladies at the table, which was unexpected, but very, very nice just extending our thank you for a memorable evening. read more

Finally got here with some friends. All employees were nice, including the owner who was outside tending to the pit beef. The cream of crab soup was delicious and reminded me of back home in Maryland. I could taste the hint of sherry, and it had just the right amount of Old Bay, and plenty of crabmeat. $9 for a cup might be a tad steep, however. My one friend really wanted the duck wings, but they were out. She got the calamari and said it was good. My other friend and I got the pit beef, which they do once a month for us transplanted Marylanders. We actually got the beef/turkey combo. The meat had good flavor, but it was cut a bit too thin and seemed shaved or chipped in places, which made it dry. Regardless, we enjoyed, and they had a fixins bar right inside. Also came with a side order of fries which weren't bad, although a bit cold. No issue from the server when we easier for the check to be split 3 ways. There was a very large party sitting parallel to the bar, and my one friend had a mobility device, and it was hard for him to get by as there wasn't really ample room. That area is definitely too crowded. A wheelchair would never have made it through there. Overall, we enjoyed and will try crab cake and pizza next time. read more

We heard about this place from several people so we were looking forward to the crab cakes. They absolutely lived up to the hype. My wife and I split the 8 oz one and it was delicious. Just barely enough sauce/bread crumbs to hold it together, placed on a large water cracker and then broiled perfectly. There were plenty of large chunks crab. It was great. At the table we also got the Gorgonzola walnut salad and the crab cake pizza. The salad was very good with the biggest/best candied walnuts I have ever had on a salad. The pizza was a tasty surprise, big chunks of their signature crab cake on a nice pizza. The slightly sweet tomato sauce was a nice compliment to the crab cake. All the desserts were very good too: key lime pie, blueberry cheesecake, and cannoli. The pie and cheesecake slices were huge, definitely shareable. Cannoli was one of the better ones I have had; crispy shell, creamy sweet filling with just enough chocolate chips to enhance it and not overwhelm. This place is so good there was talk about going back the next day. read more

I will be going back. Table for two, greeted very nicely and seated quickly. Got my drinks right away. Waitress answered a few questions, put in our appetizer's. The fried zucchini was very good. The Misses got the crab cake dinner. Really good. I loved the sauce they had with it on the side. I tried the margarita pizza. I know everyone makes it a little different. This was a basic margarita pizza. Prepared and cooked on a stone. The young man making it seems to really enjoy what he is doing. He tossed, and stretched the dough just right. Added the toppings and put it in the oven. It came out crispy and chewy. I would have preferred it to be on the brick a little longer but that's my preference. He did a wonderful job. The only hit. The glass got empty, and took a while to get it filled. Luckily they were working as a team, and one If the other waitresses helped out. The attention from our waitress was a little bit lacking. But the team made it right. Plenty of people running food out, and helping clearing the used dishes. All the food going out looked so delicious, I need to go back. read more

We took a ride to Casa Mia's yesterday. This is a great place. The service was fantastic and the food was amazing. I had the crab cake sandwich - just like in Southern Maryland. Very much like Jerry's crab bomb. All lump crab. Delicious. They also have a bar with stools and a large pizza oven. I don't think you'll be disappointed. read more

The food is insanely good. The absolute best crab cake I've ever had in my life! The pizza brought me back to NYC which is incredible in South Carolina where most pizza is just barely passable. Joe the owner has done an amazing job with this restaurant. read more

The food here? Absolutely fantastic. Easily some of the best I've had in a while. But the service? Imagine trying to dine in the Bermuda Triangle -- everything (and everyone) just... disappeared. That's why it's 3 stars instead of 5. I get that Friday nights are busy, but somehow every table around us had attentive servers who looked like they were auditioning for "Best Waiter in America," while we apparently got assigned to the magician, because our server pulled off the ultimate disappearing act. It took her 10 minutes just to greet us (long enough for me to memorize the drink menu backwards). After that, she showed up only three more times in the 90+ minutes we were trapped there. I should've rationed my water like I was lost at sea -- turns out that first glass was my only glass. When the food finally arrived, our server pulled off the Houdini of service--POOF, gone. We didn't see her again for another 30+ minutes. By then, we weren't even hungry anymore--we just wanted the check so we could escape like hostages negotiating release terms. Here's the thing: I want to come back, because the food alone deserves fan mail. But bad service is my personal kryptonite. So unless they can guarantee I won't need a search party to find my server, I don't know if I'll risk it again. read more

Best part of our meal was the grouper bites but $19 might be a stretch My husband had salmon it was ok at best and his rice was ice cold , he said he enjoyed the salad only. I had the sub that had meatballs, fried ravioli .....ravioli was freezer burned and not fried ! Meatballs not good I realize they are fairly new but the prices are too high for what you get. We have zero issues paying top dollar for food but it has to be worth it They shoved as many tables in as possible and I get that but it's just not comfortable read more

Food and service was great. Crab cakes the best just like a B-more one IYKYK Very clean friendly service and the setting after you get inside is amazing too. Highly recommend! read more

First time here for lunch. Had meatball sub and fries. Meatballs were way over seasoned and mushy. Fries were way over cooked. Very dark brown and tasteless. My partner had a sub that she said was tasteless. Also over cooked fries. Service was ok. But server spilled food on my partner. I give this place a D+ based on food. Ambiance a B. Place was not busy so everything should have been perfect. We are not likely to return. read more

I was excited to try an Italian restaurant new to the area. The first time we went they were fully booked with reservations. We asked another couple to meet us there. I made a reservation to make sure we weren't turned away. We arrived on time and were seated right away. Took awhile for the server to take our drink order. Then it took awhile for her to take our food order. 25-30 minutes later the salads arrived. The tomatoes were over ripe, but the rest of it was delicious. Our meals finally came and the spaghetti sauce had an odd color to it. I took my first bite and it tasted like macaroni with tomato soup on top. There were no spices what so ever on the sauce. My granddaughter could have made a better sauce in her play kitchen. Very disappointed. My friend got chicken parm and it was burned like it was cooked in the microwave. My husband got voodoo chicken, now that was the best meal at the table. We won't be returning. read more

I ordered the 19 inch Margarita pizza and it was great. This place has great food especially the crab and pizza read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Margarita pizza with fresh garlic - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Food and service were OK but the place was a bit crowded and noisy and our table was a tight fit especially for a large group.

A wonderful lunch at Casa Mia's. I went in wanting pizza but was so excited to see GF Ravioli on their menu that I couldn't help myself. It did not disappoint! The portion size was also quite large! My husband tried the Bronx sandwich and loved it as well! Though it looks tiny from the outside, they offer bar seating, high tops, and a traditional seating area with booths. Everyone was super friendly and nice! We can't wait to come back and try more items. read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - GF ravioli - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

See all

The crab cakes were some of the best I've ever had. What a Maryland jumbo lump should be. No filler and amazing flavor. Our server Donna was great ! Shout out to the bartender for the blueberry lemon drop martini read more

I'm going to keep this one really simple. IT'S HERE FOLKS! THE MD CRABCAKE IS HERE! Incredible service from the chef coming to tables to the lovely Dawn and staff. We had crab dip, both crab soups, and 8oz platters. Going back Sunday. Highly recommend. read more

See all

What in the world happened to this place!!! Had server Donna T. She was rude and very curt. Served us drinks, took 2 steps to leave, turns her head half way as she is leaving and asked us are u ready to order? Had an ice tea, had to ask for lemons twice. Ordered the crab balls, 1lemmon for all four of us. Requested more, Donna stated more? She acted annoyed!!! The lasagna was small and warm!!! 1 pita pizza, chx broccoli Alfredo, diver scallops. Took over 30 minutes for the meals. She held up our meals, due to the scallops taking 40 mins. Unbelievable worst service! NO BREAD FOR US!! All 3 tables around got bread!!! Donna T. did that on purpose to us!!! DONOT go there!!!! read more

Food was great and service was too. We tried this place at lunchtime and sat at the bar. Enjoyed it all. Refreshing place for lunch read more

Crab cakes are full of jumbo lump crab meat Crab dip is wonderful, as well. Plenty of lumps of crab meat read more

This place is my new favorite restaurant and bar. The food is above and beyond delicious. It has become my favorite restaurant. Costis is a wonderful evening bartender.and we had lunch there yesterday and Debbie our server was wonderful. I am a bartender in Pawleys Island . This place blows away any of the restaurants with in a 100 miles . The crab cakes are the best I have had since moving south. Been here 18 yrs. Just go you won't be disappointed. read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

See all

Had supper there tonight made a reservation on line split meatball appetizer we both had surf/ turf filet and crab cake both excellent paired with a Pinot Noir too full for dessert really nice interior and bar area with big pizza oven as u come in if you are near here and want quality food and service this is the place to go! read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - Surf an Turf dinner cooked and seasoned perfectly also came with a side salad which was fresh and huge - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

See all

The Maryland Crab Cakes are real MARYLAND CRAB CAKES, no filler and the lumps of crabmeat can actually be seen! We moved here from Maryland in 1999 and have tried every restaurant that advertised they had Maryland Crab Cakes and left them on our plates, and wanted to tell them to get a can of OLD BAY SEASONING and make them from the recipe on the can. They are good but will not come close to Casa Mia's. Like BRUSSEL SPROUTS? They have them as a starter, cooked in bacon grease, smothered in bacon pieces and I brought have of them home along with the dinner I ordered because they came to our table on a huge oval platter. They are not greasy, just scrumptious. We have been there many times and tried many menu items including their BRICK OVEN PIZZAS, the CRAB CAKE PIZZA is fantastic, just tomato sauce and huge chunks of Crab Meat. It is not cheap, but you get what you pay for and you will not care what the total bill is once you taste their food. OOPS, left out THE CRAB DIP APPETIZER with crackers, carrot and celery sticks enough for two or three. Dottie Deitz read more

The food and staff are excellent , already have plans for a repeat Visit. They have a really good happy hour also. read more

Not a good experience. Photo shows my pizza - cheese wasn't even melted. Very rude people. Maybe it is a northerner thing, but not one person was hospitable there. We will never go back. read more

Casa Mia’s Surfside - I am holding the pizza cheese - not even melted. - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Loved our two visits to this hidden gem owned by a fellow Maryland native. The food and staff were excellent.