I used to work in Harrison and I ate lunch here every day. Dina is correct, this place is like a Jersey Shore episode in an Italian Deli. Steve makes the fresh mozzarella almost everyday, and Lucy makes the specials. Whenever there is a special there, try it. Lucy makes some great food. This is the perfect lunch place and Steve makes a great cheese spread. Just ask for it because it is not on the menu. read more

Home of the best sandwich I've ever had. Their "Bronx Tale" sandwich, which is chicken breast, sundried peppers, pesto, fresh mozzarella, and hot capicollo currently stands undisputed high at the top of my sandwich podium. I don't think it's possible to have a better combination of ingredients than in this sandwich. Not only is the combination perfect, but the ingredients themselves are clearly picked with care. The chicken breast, clearly made fresh in-house, is not too greasy, which is crucial as it serves to absorb the grease from the remaining ingredients. The pesto thankfully isn't too salty. The star ingredient, however, is the sundried peppers: sweet and not too salty - the perfect complement to the hot capi. It's a popular place, as it should be, but it's clearly a well-run operation, so the line always moves. The sandwiches aren't cheap. However, if you get them on a hero, you're essentially paying for two good-sized sandwiches, so it's not lacking on value. read more

Amazing sandwiches. I got the Bronxtale and absolutely loved it. It's rare to find a place like this!

Such a good place. Staff here is super friendly. Sandwiches are fantastic. Club music is pumping in here. The only reason I wasn't dancing is because I was too busy stuffing my face! I will for sure be a regular here! Why would anyone go to the Quiznos down the street with this place right here? read more

Great Food, Great Service, Great Espresso...need I say more? I have been going to Casa for years and they NEVER disappoint me. The food is always fresh, and the Fresh Mozz melts in your mouth. Come summer time, they have great HOMEMADE Gelato. Check out all the different sandwich combos, and there homemade pesto adds a great kick to your sandwich. Enjoy!!! read more

If you live to eat great food then it's a must go to eat! My wife and 4 kids went there 7.11.15 after we read the write up in the NYT's! If anything it was downplayed in the article....The staff were all very friendly, fun and helpful! They won us as regulars! The Inferno is in my top 3 favorite sandwiches I've eaten in my life! The gelato brought me back in Rome.....I could go on and on......They got it covered: Quality and great service!!! Easiest 5 stars I've ever given! BH read more

Always a great experience at Casa. Food is amazing, Lucy and Steve along with their staff are wonderful, making you feel like family. I highly recommend this place.. read more

Made the 90 minute drive to make it 45 minutes before closing time (4pm) only to see that they'd locked up early. There were still people eating inside but they wouldn't let us in and closed the blinds on us. Super disappointing; don't plan on making the drive again. read more

The sandwiches and food here are great. I love the friendly environment when you walk in. Just wish the phone service was better. Overall love this place!! read more

The sandwiches are good but the rest of the food has gone down hill over the last few years. The sauces are now watery and bland. The veggies don't taste fresh and swim in oil. During COVID-19, I am trying to limit how many stores I go to. If I'm in the area post pandemic, maybe I will get sandwiches, but I won't make a special trip here they way I used to love to. read more

TL;DR: I just had the greatest sandwich I've ever had ... again. It has gotten to the point with Casa where I don't even bother picking a sandwich for them to make me, I simply choose the meat/ingredient that I want. There is absolutely no need to discuss the finer points of what you are going to eat because it doesn't matter, it's going to be exceptional. After two years of eating there, I was prompted to write this because I ordered out for myself and three co-workers. My roast beef sandwich was, as I said, the best roast beef I've ever had and the other three people said the same about their order. Mind you, one of them ordered salami, lettuce/tomato, and mayo on a roll ... and even that was met with high praise. There are many great delis/sandwich shops in this area but Casa D'italia blows them all away. read more

Always clean, always friendly..paninis are great and the cappucinos even better! Check them out if you are ever in Harrison!

Awesome sandwiches and friendly service. People that don't like this place or this kind of food consider "a pinch of salt" too strong for their pallet and probably don't like any food other than boiled eggs and butter pasta. Support your local businesses folks because Cuomo definitely doesn't read more

Absolutely STUNNING. I came here with my two friends, each one of our sandwiches were delicious. The staff was friendly, attentive, and overall made our visit over the top!! The food was unbelievable, can not find better around this area!! read more

Good deli counter for making sandwiches to custom order; could put a bit more cold cuts on sandwiches. Owner very nice. Homemade pastas are good. read more

WOW. Every time I stop by, things are as delicious as can be. The sandwiches are consistently huge, high quality, tasty and a great value. My favorite has got to be the Nonna. It is a massive sandwich and is prefect in every way. A generous amount of breaded chicken that doesn't taste oil-soaked, smooth mozz, yummy bread and the most delicate and tasty ham on it. There is no sauce but it is still quite moist. You will pay $9 for a hero, but it could feed 2 dudes and it is the best quality lunch around. You will not be disappointed The place is clean and the staff is very friendly. read more

Why is this place so expensive. I had high hopes for it, however after coming here to grab lunch for my boss and I. It was a complete disaster. I ordered a chix wedge and the chicken was to totally microwaved from the steam table making it super chewy like a plastic chicken. My boss got a parm wedge and found a aluminum piece in his wedge. I didn't like the snotty people behind the counter rushing me to order. There was only 2 people in here and they were both already served. Idk why the rush and high prices will not be back at all. read more

Worst customer service we have ever had. Family has been a regular at this place for years. However, a recent event has changed all of that. A family tragedy required a last minute large order to feed the family that was arriving in town. Recognizing that it was a last minute order, I called at 8am. in hopes of arranging a 1pm. pick-up. I figured that five hours to prepare a few pans of ziti and chicken parm would be plenty of time. Boy, was I wrong. The employee that answered the phone stated that it would be impossible to accomodate our request (it was going to be a $300 order), and that she couldn't suggest another facility because "she wasn't from here". When I asked if she could please ask one of the other employees she answered "they are all too busy". At 9am.?, I asked. That was when she hung up. As a small business owner, I am acutely aware that we are only as good as our weakest link. Sadly, for Casa D'italia it is the first person that you speak to when you try to place an order. Sadder, the owner's of this place are probably oblivious to the problem. So, if you are looking for a place that serves fantastic food but treats you like dirt, you will love Casa D'italia. But if you appreciate a moderate amount of customer service, stay away. These people are jerks. They have lost a loyal group of customers. read more

Have you ever left a deli and said "that was a great sandwich!"? We do this every time. The bread is superb, ingredients are clearly fresh and of top quality. The staff is friendly to all, the place is clean and bright, and the iced cappuccino is perfect! As soon as I can button my pants again, I'll be back. read more

One of the things that makes the food that comes out of this place so good is that the staff really enjoy serving delicious sandwhiches. It is thier pride in the food they serve that produces such amazing heros. I recommend the Nona, and if you are feeling frisky ask them to add thier hot peppers. It is outstanding, especially if sandwhich star Mike puts it together for you. read more

Best place I've ever been for lunch. So fresh and delicious. Gotta get the chicken cutlet with mozzarella heated on a roll. And staff is super nice. Huge huge huge fan read more

Casa D'Italia is the best deli in Westchester County. They have the best cold cuts, absolute best pastries and the staff is most cordial and friendly. Lucy and Steven are the best!!!! Laura read more

Fresh quality ingredients. It's mostly a take-out spot, but there are few small cafe tables and chairs. Music was a bit loud.

Holy smokes. They have amazing sandwiches and spectacular service to boot. I love this place. Mozzarella is homemade and the bread is delicious. Got the husky special!! read more

If you are anywhere near Harrison and need a sandwich this is THE place to go. Amazing Italian deli with an out of this world staff! The coffee is exceptionally made and they use a delicious roast. Sometimes I'll stop in and grab a snack for later or grab two for a long road trip. I have yet to try the hot food selection, but every time I'm there it looks and smells incredible. The sandwiches are huge and very reasonably priced. Don't miss out on this fantastic culinary gem. Once you try it you'll be dreaming of the next opportunity to indulge. read more

They take their sandwiches seriously. They have clearly given thought to each and every ingredient on their sandwiches, down to the bread. Not your stereotypical deli roll here. Each ingredient is carefully placed inside with care. The finished product is a work of art. Thoroughly impressed with Casa D'italia, down to the friendly staff and speedy service. Go-to lunch spot. read more

The best deli in Westchester, hands down! Great staff, awesome food - the best!!!!

Two words .. Chicken cutlet! Best deli hands down. The rolls are amazing and fresh along with everything else they have. Prices are so reasonable and the customer service it's top notch. The staff is so friendly and the place is so clean! I highly recommend Casa. read more

The chicken cutlet was delightfully delicious. The mozzarella cheese tasted freshly made. You will not be disappointed. Great spot for sandwiches. You'll have to check them out to decide for yourself. read more

This place is so amazing! I've been here many times before and this time I came here with my two friends who have never been. I got the Napolitano and my two friends got the Marco Polo and Vagabondo. Everyone enjoyed their meals and finished every last bite of it! The employees are so energetic and sweet. Very hard to find a good Italian deli sandwich around here but this place is to die for! read more

This is my favorite deli anywhere in Westchester. The sandwiches are DELICIOUS, everything is so fresh. The staff is quick, efficient and fun to talk to. My favorite sandwich is the I Love Lucy which is great. Also I recommend their lattes! read more

Omg this was my first time coming to this place and I can honestly say it's absolutely amazing!!! And the atmosphere is phenomenal everyone is so friendly, helpful, and so nice!!! I will be coming back here again the food is delicious and everything is fresh !!! Thank you !!! read more

Outstanding sandwiches on fantastic bread! Really nice people. Clean and comfortable place for a great lunch. Will definitely be back.

This is the best deli I've ever been to! The cold cuts and bread are always fresh, everyone who works there is great, the place is spotless and what I love the most is that they all wear gloves, and if they are handling the money, they take their gloves off and put a new pair on when they handle the food again. read more

Lucy, Steve, and the crew are the absolute best! The food is amazing and the environment is super fun!!!

If you enjoy an outstanding chicken cutlet, fresh mozz, fresh bread, high quality italian foods, go here. I would be shocked if the cutlet is not in your Top 3 all time. Four stars only because its in Harrison. Hang the Huskies! read more

You will not be disappointed, with everything. It is all quality and delicious. I don't speak until I finish my sandwiches from here. It's a well known fact when I do this, this is something special. read more

How you doing? Wanna be guidos that don't speak Italian. I love it! Food is amazing for a deli in Harrison it def has a little Arthur Ave flavor. 4 stars for the good took one away for the wanna be's. read more

The food is delicious, better than most delis in the area. I order through work quite often and the guys are always super friendly when I call. They are always busy when I place an order but it always gets here at the time specified. If you're in the area I highly recommend stopping by and picking one of their many great options. read more

This is by far my favorite Italian Deli in Westchester and maybe even the world! Great prices and the broccoli rabe is excellent! The staff is always happy and they are as fast as the music that is playing overhead. When you order a sandwich or something from their hot food steam table you are never disappointed and the order is always right!!! read more