Pasta has to be good for me to enjoy it having been raised in an Italian family. The penne with vodka sauce hit the spot last night. The creamy flavor of the vodka sauce hit the spot and the penne was cooked just right. Overall, it was a delicious meal though there was no ambience. Wait staff was adequate. read more

Casa D'amici - Penne with vodka sauce hit - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

Pizza slice was cheap ($3) and a good size. Line gets busy at the end of the night but moves fast. Really a no frills type experience but does a great job after a night out. read more

Casa D'amici - Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

The pizza is good if you're looking for a big thin style slice. No issues with the pizza itself - it's delicious. We ordered a cheese and a pineapple/bacon and they sent a cheese and a pepperoni. When door dash and casa were contacted, we ended up having to just order another pizza. I feel like they should have corrected their mistake - pretty disappointed with them not making it right. read more

my dad and i love coming here! there are very nice employees that work here and quick service right away

We are in the area for 2 weeks & had to try out a pizza spot... & This pizza was absolutely flavorful! Me & the Hubby are pizza eaters, and have traveled a lot.. meaning we've tried a lot & we highly recommend trying the Casa Cheesesteak Pizza Pie if you want to try something new! It was still very warm even after doordash, Thank you Night Crew! *not going to lie.... I had 1 & 1/2 slices & My husband ate just about the rest there was only 1 & 1/5 pieces left for next day* hahaha that's how good it was! Oh and the BREAD/CRUST was the BOMB!! read more

Casa D'amici - The Casa Cheesesteak Pie - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

See all

I really tried to like this place. It's good, but not amazing. It's the service that sealed the deal for me though. It's been 2 hours since I ordered and received confirmation. (see photo) I called 30 minutes ago to check on my order. I'm still waiting on my pizza. Their pizza is not worth this long of a wait or the confused individual who took my call. Do not recommend. read more

Casa D'amici - Order confirmation from restaurant at 6:46pm. - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

How is an uncut sandwich with one piece of chicken that's cut in half costing $12?? This place and its sister location on the other side of town are highway robbery. Thanks for my 2oz of protein and half pound of mediocre sub bread. read more

Casa D'amici - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

they said it would only take 20 minutes but it took an hour and 20 mins to get here when they told is was on the way so many times when it got here is was cold and soggy read more

our pizza was 1 hour and 20 minutes late very very cold and soggy there are 7 minutes away yet took 1 hour and 20 minutes to get here. read more

Cashier/all staff is so rude! Don't give them business they all seem like they hate their jobs, not a welcoming environment at all.

I can't for the life of me figure out why there are so many bad reviews. Maybe I just came on a good night? My husband and I just left from a movie on a Sunday night, and it was like 10pm, and we were searching for some place to eat. The whole town seemed to have closed at 6 pm. Beautiful town! We came upon this place, and I am so glad we did! The Garlic knots... oomg soo delicious ! And they were huge! Got two pizzas to go and we were pleased with everything we got. Can't wait to return! read more

I hope they're better at making pizza than they are at designing websites. This is one of the worst online ordering experiences ever. You can literally use the default ecommerce template from Wix or Squarespace and call it a day. read more

I had their pizza - two different kinds- for the first time last night. This is the best pizza in Morgantown. The balance of sauce and cheese is good, and the toppings were fresh. The crust was great. I had take out so I wasn't in the restaurant. The delivery man from the restaurant was very friendly and polite. I've been very disappointed with pizza in this town since I got here a year ago. I work with a lot of nurses and they do take out everyday ! They've gotten me pizza here and it's been very disappointing. This is not Domino's. I'm from New York City - I have kind of a high bar for pizza. I recommend this restaurant. read more

Went on Saturday, 4/29/23, and ordered a make your own calzone and specifically requested to not have any seasonings on top and the cashier even confirmed my order correctly, however, when the calzone was done and handed it to me, it had seasoning on the top! The only excuse that was provided to me was that he told the chef but that "many of the folks who work here, don't understand English"...he did offer to remake it but I could wait but wow, what a response...ended up just throwing it away and going to another local restaurant in town where my food was made correctly as ordered!! read more

Casa D'amici - two slices of pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

Large Caesar salad (not so large for $7? At least not expensive) and casa vodka (sauce good, a touch spicy and chicken, which was dry and tough). Had to ask for plates. Fine for college town fare. read more

Very good pepperoni calzone and pastas. A little greasy but very good. The garlic bread is delicious as well. I highly recommend this place.

Allowing this restaurant to continue using the "NY Style Pizza" tagline is a travesty and should be punishable with the electric chair. Absolutely no flavour in the dough. Overdone crust and underdone toppings. Garlic bread had the texture as if it had been frozen for a few months then popped in a hydrator oven. Probably was. Never eating here again. And spices. Y'all even heard of em? read more

Best pizza in morgantown. Loved eating here when I was in school. Now that I'm out I make sure to stop anytime I am back in town. You really can't go wrong with any of their pizzas. They are always perfectly cooked, with a crispy and great tasting crust. My favorites are just the regular plain or the buffalo chicken pizza. The buffalo chicken has a great kick to it and a really good buffalo flavor. Their homemade ranch is a must with anything you get. I have also had their wings and they are some of the best around. read more

The cheesesteak itself I had was decently good, the problem is that I got sick from it afterwards, so I can't recommend it to anybody.

I have ordered from Casa many times -it's never been good enough or bad enough for me to feel I should write a review. Today was different. I ordered a steak salad and the steak was absolutely awful, very hard and chewy. It also took almost 2 hours for the salad to get here and the steak and fries were cold. read more

Casa D'amici - Steak salad - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

Hello All, I'm a food blogger based in Morgantown currently. I was Casa tonight and ordered three slices of white pizza and one of pepperoni. As it was late in evening and I came in, I asked for 3 slices of white pizza and 1 slice of pepperoni. As it was the down to the last two slices of pepperoni currently available, the lady in charge offered me two slices of white pizza and two slices of pepperoni pizza and I gladly accepted. However, as I get home and open my to go box I realized that she only gave me two slices of pepperoni and one slice white pizza. Terrible service and I feel they lied to me, and I hope that this promising businesses can find more enthusiastic and trustworthy employees who follow through on their actions and words. read more

Pizza was ok, and over priced at $3 a slice. Also the ice machine want working so warm soda.

Really casa!? A fucking feather that was still attached!?! I've eaten here a couple times now and it's always one thing after another. read more

Casa D'amici - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

Ordered at 6:40pm. Delivery time said 7:50pm. Called at 7:50pm to check on delivery and a rude young lady told me it would probably be within 45 minutes. Pizza finally arrived at 8:20pm. And as I expected, it was cold. Will never but from again. read more

Pizza is ok, but I was just in Casa and the person ringing me up wouldn't tell me how much my total was, then when I asked for the receipt he told me to check my bank account. It's a shame that this happened because I was a loyal customer, but I will not be returning after this. read more

My boyfriend is from the Bronx and has been missing New York pizza. This is his favorite place in Morgantown to get pizza. So yummy and classic. We love the size of the slices. The mozzarella sticks are so good and the sauce is garlicy. The tiramisu is one of his favorites. Anytime we miss New York we order here! read more

Order a chicken parm from DoorDash. My dasher was sitting at the restaurant for a good 45 minutes. It's whatever I'm not gonna complain about the wait. When the food got here it didn't look too appealing and tasted a lot worse. Chicken was super chewy, there was no sauce, and barely any cheese. Probably the worst chicken parm I've had to date. Like seriously how do you screw up a chicken parm? It's chicken sauce cheese and bread. Don't eat here. Just get dominos or papa John's. read more

Best pizza in Morgantown and possibly WV. Get the Casa Vodka pizza and add steak. U will not be dissapointed. Also their wings and roni rolls are amazing. read more

The good news is that I was able to get delivery from this place via EatStreet to my hotel, that being said the bad news is that since the hotel is newer it didn't show up on GPS and my driver was therefore lost and my delivery was delayed. The fresh basil/mozzarella pizza was likely delicious when it was fresh and hot since it was okay and I ate it when it was dry and cold. The other slice was okay as well...assuming it would be much better fresh and hot! The salad was also okay but I do have to say that the Caesar dressing was very tasty. I may try this again in the future but likely not delivery. read more

Casa D'amici - Ordered two slices for delivery and this is what I got... - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

See all

I ordered a calzone for myself and pizza for my husband. The calzone had about 5 slices of pepperoni, 3 slices of mushroom and I haven't found any garlic yet. Also , no marinara. I paid extra for all of these items. My husband found 2 pieces of sausage, also paid extra for. I've given 3 chances and have had missing items every time. I won't order again. read more

Casual late night spot for students. Not worth the wait nor trouble the staff requires.

Well, I guess when you order pizza at 1AM you shouldn't have high expectations. We got our pizza in a timely fashion, which was nice...but it was the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. You can get a better tasting slice from your local 7/11. The pizza tasted like it sat out all day, zero flop - hard as a hard, sauce non-existent. We had to order jimmy johns after attempting to eat this mess of a pizza. Barstool pizza score: 2.3 read more

Casa D'amici - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

The cheesecake had mold on it, which is disgusting. After receiving this I then looked at the reviews and apparently they have served moldy desserts in the past and refuse refunds. They just blame the company they buy their pre-made desserts from. This place shouldn't be allowed to continue doing business if this is their norm. I didn't eat the pizza after seeing the fuzzy mold on the cheesecake. read more

Casa D'amici - Moldy Cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

See all

Don't order from here unless you have hours to wait for it. 3 hours for one pizza and a slice delivered. Ridiculous. I would give them 0 stars but it won't let me read more

Disgusting customer service. Sent us an order that was so messed up they completely ignored my sons allergies and when I called to POLITY discus a refund or bringing the pizza back all I got was attitude and laughed at. read more

Great authentic Italian pizza. Quick delivery. Very responsibly priced, lots of variety on the menu. Open late read more

Casa D'amici - Pizza Near Me - Morgantown, West Virginia

See all

Staff was very rude during our visit to Casa D'amici. The food was okay, but the rudeness of the staff made our experience very unpleasant.

Long story short, they stole $20 for me. I've used Casa a few times for delivery, and a few times for a late-night snack. This is about a poor delivery experience. Sunday night, feeling lazy, order a cheesesteak and fries from Casa D'amici. It's a good bargain, not the best food but easily satifies a lazy night in. Order via a service called Eatstreet (similar to Orderup), send in an order and pay via credit card. I've used this service a dozen times before without an issue. 45 minutes later, delivery driver pulls up, and tells me the total he's owed. I explain I've paid for the order, show the receipt, but he explains they're system "One sheet means it hasn't been paid for, one sheets means it has. I only have one sheet." I show him the receipt, he won't budge and asks me to call his manager. Sure, no problem. Oh, but he's busy, so he'd like to take my money and just return it when his manager calls him. Sounds sketchy, but he's getting upset at me (not sure why), so sure. Give him $20 and he leaves. Call the manager, he explains the order is paid for and I ask him to call the delivery guy and return my money. It never happens. Call back, but apparently the manager I spoke to isn't there any longer. At this point, I give up. It honestly was just a series of honest mistakes, I feel like. I get that delivery isn't perfect. But if the delivery driver was less sketchy, if the manager had actually called his driver, or if Casa as a business actually was able proper inform drivers on what orders are/aren't paid for, wouldn't have happened. I jumped through all the hoops I should have to smooth things over, and was treated rudely and impatiently at every turn. Downright horrible customer service. Hope they enjoy the $20 bill, because that's the last time I'm ordering from Casa. read more

Decent food but girl in yellow T shirt with the black long sleeve rolled up on 2/18 12:15 AM she was SO RUDE when my friend asked for a simple 2 slices of pizza... gave a dirty ass look to her co-worker. TOLD the cop outside to arrest her for being rude. read more

Probably your best bet for delivery pizza in Morgantown. Their Vodka Pie is delicious if you want a simple pizza. Most everything they have is good. Unfortunately, the service is atrocious. Delivery always takes at least an hour and the deliverymen are consistently rude. The pizza is good--but draw straws for whoever has to answer the door. read more