My wife bragged this place up, so we ordered 2 pizzas. Both were overdone, and quite frankly, gross. It cost $60 for two of the worst pizzas I ever tasted. read more

For a small town, this place has great New York style pizza! My friends and I were pleasantly surprised. I didn't try them but my friends also spoke highly of the wings. House made ranch was good as well. read more

See all

From a pizza standpoint Cantoni's has Sicilian thick crust Italian thin crust, as well as cauliflower. The wife and I got a large thin crust pizza with bacon, spinach, and black olives. The crust was excellent and the best part. Service was great, and the prices are very reasonable. We will surely go back to samples or Calzones. read more

Cantoni's Pizza - w slices from our Thin crust pizza with Bacon, spinach and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Fairmont, West Virginia

Delicious pizza! Made fresh with good ingredients. My husband loves the white pizza. I really like the calzones and regular pizza. Give it a try! read more

Some of the best food you can get! Enjoy stopping here to eat. Been very consistent! Will keep coming back. read more

Best pizza in Fairmont, great calzones and sandwiches, and solid wings for a pizza joint. read more

See all

Cantoni's is the best pizza in Mon, Marion and Harrison counties. Easy to order online, selected pick up/carry-out for a XL cheese pizza. I arrived a little bit early and the pizza was ready. Staff was polite. Parking lot is small and shared with other business so it was a bit congested. The pizza was spot-on! Ingredients fresh and delicious. Crust is thin, which is my preference. The sauce is flavorful, the commercial places can't even compete. Loved it! Best pizza in the area. read more

Love their pizza. Order it every time we make a trip to Fairmont. Pepperoni is spicier than most pizza places, so has a little kick. Sauce and crust are really good. read more

Stopped for the night in Fairmont WV and were looking for a pizza place. This came up with 4 stars and is certainly worthy of it! Great Sicilian white pizza and a huge salad my husband and I split. Glad we have a cooler with us..tons of leftovers read more

Cantoni's Pizza - Sicilian white pizza! We added meat - Pizza Near Me - Fairmont, West Virginia

Pizza was decent but the large was the size of a medium if best . Almost embarrassing. Wings were from the midget wing family too . Also almost embarrassing . read more

I ordered a chicken parm pizza and it was the best pizza I have ever had. Topping Pie

the Regular Calzone was just okay & the Garlic Parmesan and Buttered Old Bay Boneless Wings were decent but really greasy

Best New York style pizza in WV. They use the little pepperonis cup and char. You won't be disappointed.

Make better pizza. The last one I had was so salty I couldn't eat it. And the pizza dudes in seemed to have there own schedule as far as time is concerned read more

Nice authentic Italian style pizza. Hand tossed dough made fresh daily. These people really know how to make a pizza. They pile the cheese and toppings of your choice on and they do it right not too much, not little. I love their pizza so much but I have never tried any of their other menu items. Oh their cheesy bread is the bomb too. read more

I feel.very wronged after waiting for 20 minutes to be in suspense of if they do anything for military. They do not support Military here...I am an out of Towner but this is kind of sad. Military Discounts do not affect the bottom line...it is a symbol of support and leads to increased business from military members and their families. The worst thing is they waited for a long time to tell me after I asked and talked about it behind my back... Why? read more

When is a 13 inch pizza considered a large? Ordered one to watch the game and was disappointed Good pizza but not what I was expecting read more

Great pizza! I'm from NY and find it hard to get a decent slice and this place comes close to standard pizza from up north. I only order from here or pizza al's when I'm WV. read more

Pizza was so salty we could barely finish 1 slice each! Would much rather drive to Morgantown Wv (20 min away) to pick up from Pizza Als which is WWWAAAYYY better read more

Pizza is bad! Terrible crust. When we complained they offered free pizza next time, twice and did not happen.

This used to be the best pizza in town but, unfortunately, they are starting to skimp on portions. Their large pizza's are now the size of what used to be medium's. And they raised their prices. Talk about throwing salt in the eye. Such a shame. Their pizza is still very good but when you don't feel like you're getting your money's worth, it doesn't matter how it tastes. Here's, hopefully, a helpful hint: why not offer a special every now and again. For being a franchise, you'd think they'd offer promotions. C'mon man!!! read more

Best pizza in Fairmont but since opening the inside has greatly been run down, bathroom dirty looks like no one cleans its a new facility and looks like 5 yr old dirty bathrooms. The back of the dinning area looks like a stock room, But pizza is the BEST! And the Price us as great at the Pizza (6$) or (8$) can't go wrong read more

I really enjoy this pizza! By far my favorite in the area. Anytime I come to visit Fairmont from out of state, a trip to Cantoni's is a must! I like the traditional pepperoni pizza. Large slices and the crunchy little pepperoni really give it appeal. The calzones are also a great addition to any order. The staff is great and even offered up plates, silverware, and napkins to help us enjoy our dinner at the hotel. Love this place! read more

Everything we got was so delicious! The white pizza is the best I've had! The calzone is huge!!! The kids of course loved the cheese bread. Will definitely be back again! read more

This is not NY style pizza and you'll be disappointed if that's what you're expecting and you get this instead. They sell typical hand tossed pizza crusts that you would find at Papa Johns or Dominos, except those pizza crusts actually hold up. We ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and sausage and it was pretty awful. The middle of the pizza was so saturated with liquid that when we went to pick up a slice, the middle crust, along with cheese and toppings, detached from the outer crust and was stuck in the crust swamp in the center of the box. We're still curious as to what that liquid was. We asked for a little extra sauce, but there was less than a normal amount on it instead. Pepperoni is greasy, but it couldn't have been grease because there wasn't a lot of pepperoni to begin with. Idk, just don't do it. I'm annoyed that I spent even a penny on that. HARD PASS. read more

Everytime I've ordered from here the quality of the pizza has been exceptional. Even my 76 year old mother loves it, and she's as picky as you can get. read more

The only authentic, New York / Italian style pizza in Fairmont. Generous with the toppings. A nice place to stop in for lunch or to call in a takeout order. They do not deliver, but the pizza is worth driving to pick up. The salads and other side dishes are also generously constructed and worthwhile. If you're looking for a good pizza, skip the chains and get this one. read more

Use to Oder nothing but this pizza, but stopped for a couple reasons. They don't put the sauce close enough to the edge which leaves too much crust. I want pizza not crust. Then they raised their prices. The pizza is really good but not for the price. Haven't bought anything there since the prices increased. They never offer any specials. read more

Cantonis used to be my favorite pizza spot. There's a few reasons I stopped ordering. To begin with most times they don't take the sauce or toppings up to the crust. The prices increased, and whereas before I thought it was a good value for the amazing flavor. Hope whoever owns it sees this and starts offering some specials ! I'll definitely come back read more

Absolutely vile. Employees don't wash their hands. Cockraoches. Rude owner. Pizza is very bland and the ingredients are not at all fresh. Avoid at all costs. read more

Hands down, the BEST pizza you can get in Fairmont! I don't care if it's not from a wood stove, the crust is thin and crispy on the bottom, but soft on the inside with great flavor. It's truly New York style pizza! Inexpensive too...a large pepperoni was under $12 tonight. read more

Wow, My new favorite pizza joint is Cantoni's. SuziQ's is gone, and Cantoni's popped up on Fairmont Ave. The pizzas and garlic knots are our favorites, but very thing we have had is really good.(cheese stick bread,wings, subs) The complaints are the wait time when we call is always 20 mins but in reality is 25-50 mins and parking is limited. But the food is worth the trouble. read more

Hand's down the best New York style crust pizza in Fairmont. Thus, in my opinion, the best pizza in Fairmont. It's also quite inexpensive. I think a large one topping pie comes to under $14 with tax. I can't give it more than 4 stars though because, while it's always tasty, the pies haven't been consistent. They seem to skim on ingredients from time to time. Once, after taking a pie home, I opened the box to find it was about 2" smaller than normal. I called, and the manager/owner just wanted to argue about how they're always the same, and always the right size. Well, we measured it, and it was, in fact, 2" too small. I assume it was maybe the same amount of dough, and the crust seemed a bit bigger, but I'm sure since it was considerably smaller we didn't get the same ingredients we usually pay for. We've ordered many times since then, and the pies have, again, been pretty consistent, though we do think they've really cut down on the toppings and are getting a bit cheap with their portions. We got a large pepperoni pie last night, and while we were pleased, and there was an ample amount of cheese, we actually counted the pepperoni's and compared it to the pizza they have photo of on their Facebook page and there were 17 fewer pepperoni's on it. And no, the pizza on their page isn't an extra pepperoni (there's one of those a customer posted on their page, and it's easily got twice the pepperoni's of their photo), as we've gotten the regular, 1 topping pepperoni's many times, and had significantly more pepperoni. So that's a disappointment sometimes, not knowing if we will get a great pie or just a decent one. The white pizza with spinach, tomatoes and onions is amazing. Their hoagies are also very good and reasonably priced. My brother and I are also wing fans, and we're not real high on Cantoni's wings, but your mileage (and tastes) may vary from ours. That we don't care for the wings isn't so much an issue with us, as this is our go-to pizza joint, and close to our house. For the kids, there's a couple gum ball machines with trinkets, ala Pizza Hut (yuck) down the street, so there's something for the kids to look forward to. I would suggest adding a pinball machine, and we would probably dine a little more and buy some drinks. We haven't dined in for probably over a year, and probably would dine in a bit more if there were a pinball machine (just a suggestion!) and, well, the fountain drink machine they've seemed to have trouble with in the past as I recall, quality wise. All in all though we've always seen it as a clean and friendly place, fairly comfortable to eat in, and the food is quick and inexpensive. They have a few TVs as well and have accommodated us by putting on whatever ball game we wanted to watch when the Pirates were playing at the time we were dining. So again, despite my few criticisms, this is still Fairmont's best pizza, and yes, we have now tried them all, including Muriales. There's a little room for improvement, but Cantoni's is the only place I really recommend to people that just want a place to go get pizza, and maybe a little something else for the non-pizza person in a group. read more

Absolutely the best pizza I've had anywhere. If you're in the area, this is place to go for pizza. It is New York style pizza which is cooked perfectly in stone ovens with a tasty blend of sauce, dough and cheese. The stone adds a nice crispiness to the crust. The pizza is not greasy or heavy, so you don't feel like you've eaten a brick afterwards. Certainly a nice lunch time spot if you're craving something other than fast food. read more

July 15,2017 Order #10179 2:19 pm. Ordered 3 subs, one with the 'works', one with 3 toppings and 1 with tomatoes. 4 adults & 4 children at another table. 3 carry-out during our meal. Around 3:10 we were served. No toppings on one, lettuce on two. Asked Danielle what happened to the toppings and guy that served the subs said toppings were on them when he served them! By the way, mid-eighties outside, close to 90 degrees inside. Never again!!!! read more

Closest pizza to my NJ pizza compared with the rest of the local pizza joints. More beer selection is needed and air conditioning system in summer. Unbearable to eat there. read more

This is really good pizza at a good price. The crust is thin, with a wonderful chewy edge and is crisp on the bottom, not soggy. The sauce is not sweet like so many other chain pizzerias. I usually order Italian sausage, pepperoni and banana peppers. The Italian sausage is delicious and a very generous amount. Just a really good pizza. I would have given it 5 stars but the mushrooms tasted like canned mushrooms..yechh. The fix is not to order mushrooms, the pizza is so good that it doesn't need them. read more

Dirty, and gross. One guy scratched his privates through his pants kept making food, never washed his hands, another wiped his head and back of his neck with both hands and kept making food. Floor filthy, tables dirty. Pizza was cold, and burnt black on bottom. As i waited for wings to cook my pizza sat on top of oven for 20 minutes. Shocked at the carelessness. Just gross place. read more

This is the best pizza in Fairmont. As close as you will get to New York style. I highly recommend the garlic knots. The service is somewhat inconsistent and you can get cool pizza if you allow for too much time before you pick up your order. They do not offer delivery. read more