This location has both Carvel and Subway, but the experience was disappointing. The Cookie O'Puss ice cream cake was $49.99 plus tax, while other locations charge around $34 for the same cake. The Subway sandwiches were also overpriced and the quality wasn't good. Overall, not worth the price. I wouldn't come back. read more

Carvel reminds me of my childhood. Support small businesses especially now! I got $5 off by using my Amex during small business month. Of course I love their soft serve and ice cream saucers. read more

Carvel - a hand holding a cone of ice cream with chocolate sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Yonkers, New York

We came here on a weekend evening. Carvel's soft serve ice cream is reliably great and fairly priced (they do give you quite a lot). The woman working there was polite and worked quickly. The store has a large varity of types of ice cream and packaged items you can take home. There is a little bit of seating (maybe 2-3 seats), but it is a small location as compared to other Carvel locations. read more

Treated my toddler to an ice cream cake she wanted for her birthday, designs are beautiful and the staff is very nice but the cake n especially the icing just tasted like chemicals I don't think this is good quality especially for young children. Probably the ice cream or the ice cream sandwiches are the best way to go without the colorful but disgusting icing. read more

Store looked nice but having had Carvel cakes for 50 years, this was sadly the worst ever. Carvel has standards so that a Carvel cake is basically the same at every store. Well, not true here. Look at the picture. There were barely any crunchies in the cake and the ones that were there were thick and chewy. The chocolate and vanilla was uneven throughout the cake. And it was abnormally small. Not coming back to this store. If I'm going to overpay for a Carvel cake, I expect it to taste like a Carvel cake! read more

Carvel - a piece of cake with blue icing and sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Yonkers, New York

I stopped by the Carvel location last Saturday. I was looking for a Cookie Puss cake for my mom's 92nd Birthday. I looked in the display case I did find a Cookie Puss cake but it didn't look like the usual Cookie Puss cakes. I couldn't quiet figure out what was different. Then it hit me instead of the cone in the center like all Cookie Puss cakes have, this cake just had some squiggly things where the cone usually sits. Then I look at the price it was 48.99!!! That is absurd.... I have been buying Cookie Puss cakes for many many years. As a matter of fact for my daughters I used to special order Cookie Puss cakes with specific ice cream flavors and have never paid anywhere near $48.99. I walked right out of that store went to Carvel in Tuckahoe. There I found the correct Cookie Puss with the ice cream cone nose and it was $31.99 and the owner and his wife were extremely friendly. Needless to say I will never be returning to the Carvel in Yonkers Central Ave location. Highway robbery.....I wish I thought to take a picture of that "bogus" Cookie Puss cake. read more

Best ice cream shoppe around!!! Perfect day for delicious cookies and cream!!! # soft serve Wednesday's read more

Carvel - Perfect day for sweets at Carvel with delicious cookies and cream !!! Soft serve wednesdays!!! Yummy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Yonkers, New York

Just walked in to get ice-cream, there was. VERY snotty girl working behind the counter. she clearly saw me standing there for 5 minutes, then decides to help her friends that walked in after me. When I told her I was waiting, she gave me a huge attitude, and I walked out. As I was leaving I heard he say. K bye. She should be fired! read more

My first visit to Tom Carvel ice cream store was as a younger guy. I remember his commercials on TV. They still make a mean ice cream cake but the likes of stone cold and Hagen daz has transformed Mr Carvel's ice cream coes and sundaes/ a bit of a more mediocre experience IMHO Carvels has been around for many many years and they still make the best ice cream cakes for the kids and the prices are better than the aforementioned ice cream shops, so Ill give them 4 stars! read more

A good quick stop for some icecream. The place is hard to spot but they stay open late

So, here's the general gist: it's Carvel so the ice cream is GREAT! However their selection is quite limited thanks to the small size of the store. But what they do have is always great. The other thing is the workers. Almost all of them are wonderful to deal with. However, there's this one girl... one stuck up annoying little shit... who will ruin your experience there. Try asking for a hard ice cream shake. This little entitled bitch will hem, haw, and do everything possible to tell you soft ice cream is exactly the same in a shake, which everyone on the planet knows isn't true. And she WILL fight you on it. She also doesn't know how to drive as I learned one time trying to let people out of the parking lot before I went in. She is absolutely the worst employee they have, which means she's probably the boss's daughter. read more

As a displaced New Yorker living in the Midwest, a trip to Carvel is a trip home. This location is great. Clean store with very fresh tasty ice cream. A great treat. We went back for a cake a few days later. As delicious and artistic as ever. The manager/owner was so friendly and we spoke for a while about the history of Carvel and the difficulty of getting it in the Midwest. A wonderful experience. I highly recommended this Carvel location. read more

Carvel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Yonkers, New York

See all

I always go to this carvel on Wednesday's or whenever my partner wants a milk shake since she loves them so much ! So I went on Mother's Day to purchase two vanilla milk shakes and they tasted just like watered milk ! So I went back on Tuesday to explain to the young lady that was helping me about how the milk shake was missing something cause it tasted like watered down milk , she says "we always ask customers if they want vanilla extract " I have been coming here for a long time and was NEVER asked " what ingredients I want in my milkshake? So I asked if I can be compensated in some way cause I bought two shakes for $15.00 and she was very RUDE in her reply ! So I said thank you and walked out ! I will never step foot in that establishment ever again!!! It's a shame that this young lady doesn't have the proper etiquette to deal with the public ! And her name is "Amber " read more

Do NOT go here for Wednesday buy one get one sundae. They skim on the ice cream. It just about makes the top on the cup while the picture and all other Carvel stores add about 50-100% more than this one. We stopped going here a while back because of the skimming. We came back to try again because it was very close. But looks like we won't be coming back here again. I cain't image paying full price of $12 for 2 cups with maybe 2 ounces in them. If you do go here look at the picture of the Sundae and the one they give you. read more

So clean and the owner is the best. He is so nice , friendly and accommodating !! I would recommend this carvel over any of the rest !!

i know its still cold outside, but in the mood for double cone of vanilla and chocolate soft ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and the memories come back . on central ave in yonkers, which was a big cruising strip back in the day. we would hit carvel after a night of hanging out and doing useless stuff.the ice cream cakes are still popular and the soft ice cream has always been my favorite. you can go with a cone or cup, try a shake, malt, flying saucer, also frozen yogurt and birthday cakes and other treats. the place looks dull and plain, but thats what keeps it authentic .you can park in front or the small dark parking lot is an option. the workers are usually teenagers or young adults and are friendly and prices are still better then the other over priced brands. a few tables to enjoy your sundae or order and leave as most do. carvels ice cream has been around a long time, and still having this spot around, only brings fond and yummy memories. p.s. on wednesday buy one sundae, get one free. enjoy and say hello to fudgie the whale. read more

SORRY I had a hankering for Carvel today and went hereOrderd two medium cones and both were VERY drippy and almost melting right out of the machine. Would have told the guy to forget it but my husband wanted his, melty and all. The guy, a fat middle east looking snot said to my husband cash or credit..my husband asked how much is the order? To which the snot YELLED at my husband, cash is one price, credit is another. As my husband had a $10 dollar bill and needed to know the price as if it was more than ten he had to reach for his cc's as he is holding the leaking cones. Why the drama and yelling and nastiness ? NEVER will we set foot in that DUMP again.BTW,sign on restroom read EMPLOYEES ONLY , DO NOT ENTER. If serving food and have tables to sit MUST have restroom available to customers. Fatty, stick that meting crap your overpricing up your ass along with your non personality. CUSTOMER SERVICE at its worst. Buy a whole carton of Friendly's ice cream for $2.99 instead , better tasting than this shit that we paid $ 12.85 for. read more

The strawberry ice cream is amazing! !!!! Ill be here all the time....didnt get the workers name but he was really nice. Dont be scared of the broke down parking lol.... just pull right in read more

Yesterday was my first time in this carvel. It was a reopening. You know get your free ice cream. I got to see Fudgie the whale and Mike Spano. I love seeing Fudgie all the time. Music and everyone having a great time. I purchased 2 large strawberry milkshakes and have to say I girl who made it put too much milk. I will not be discouraged but I will give this one a another try at a later time. Had a blast... read more

If I could give this carvel 0 stars I would! I went to get a milkshake and it was basically water! They're clearly did not know what they were doing. When first entering the store you have to wait for employees to get up from sitting down to actually help you. I will never go to this carvel location ever again! read more

I came here because of the munchies and had a pleasant down to earth experience with my server. He made my icecream look as sexy as a can be, and delicious to boot read more

Carvel - Amazing creation, you can tell this was made with love - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Yonkers, New York

I love coming here for the clean, happy, friendly environment. The workers are always available to help, and are very good at getting you to try new flavors of ice cream. There is one female worker who knows how to make a mean Nutella shake. She has me hooked. The music is also good, which is interesting because most Carvels I go to play either the top Pop 100 or Country. I would totally suggest going here. read more

Exceptional service and the ice cream is always my favorite!! Would definitely recommend to anyone who loves very kind people and ice cream. Not to mention there's a Subway next to it so best of both worlds! :)) read more

Tried to go here the other day not realizing it was a Carvel and a Subway in the same space, thought they were next door to each other (was across the street when I saw it, and from the view I got, they looked separate, plus, when I looked it up online, it was simply advertised as a Carvel). I walked in and the smell was overpoweringly Subway and made me lose my appetite for the Carvel I was trying to order. Like who thought Carvel and Subway was a good combo? I can see Carvel and Auntie Anne's or Cinnabon, but Subway and Carvel? I don't happen to be a Subway fan to begin with, but it smelled extra awful in this particular one. Ice cream and sub sandwiches should NOT be in the same small space. Parking was also awful. Did not actually purchase ice cream here due to the awful unappetizing smell so I can't actually rate the ice cream. I went 3+ miles down the road to the standalone Carvel further north on Central Park Ave in Hartsdale/Greenburgh/whatever town that is. Seriously. Carvel and Subway???? They do not mix. read more

Went in with my three children. My son who ordered the big wafer cone got one scoop where as my other two children and I got soft serve and she gave us an enormous amount even though each of us had different sizes. You may ask, why complain about more? Well, when you have a young child who will have trouble eating it and make a huge mess as well as not be able to finish it, it's not a good thing. My 5 year old had to throw most of hers away even though she had gotten a small it was the same size as my medium. The server got each of our orders wrong in some way. I had to keep correcting her and she threw a whole cone away because I told her it was the wrong order even though I said I'd take it because I didn't want it to go to wasted, but this is not the worse of it. My oldest son and I who both had chocolate soft serve with chocolate sprinkles, we both got food poisoning. I knew it was the ice cream because I felt sick soon after eating it as did my son. My poor son complained of the worst stomach ache of his life. I shudder to think of what may have caused the food poisoning. If it was the machine or the server. Just awful. Also my son who got the wafer cone threw away his because he said it tasted funny. Overall an awful experience. I was happy to have found a new place for ice cream for our family but will not be returning to this one. Currently up at four in the morning taking care of my sick son after being sick myself in the evening. Get ice cream here at your own risk! read more

I signed up for the Carvel "e-club" which emails you Buy One Get One free Sundae coupons for your birthday. Yesterday,I presented the coupons at this store and was told I needed identification to prove my date of birth. I went back to the car to get my drivers license and presented it to two teenage clerks who started studying my license and my printed email like I had some how forged these documents on my backyard printing press. I asked the manager if he was going to accept the coupons and he said "no,he would not". I will not shop at this Carvel location again. They get a minus F for not honoring their own promotion and for being ignorant assholes. read more