Martine's apparently owns the block in Scarsdale, with a bakery on the other end of the lot and this pup as of last year or so maybe two... time has lost me and I have lost time. But who is Martine? Who is Mimi? How is the Gelattttt? I and my team of reports answer this and more for you below. Martine is the counter to the manly man name of Martin. It is of French and Latin descent as well as of French and Latin decency. It originates, of course as a dedication to Mars. Extraterrestrial in a sense. Outside of this, my team of young buck analysts couldn't cook me up anything else. Zippo. Absolutely no information about Martine. Don't know anything about Mimi either but they summate that she "must be bussin FRFR, Gelatosss next to the train station so niche, slayyyy." Real bang up job losers. It's Gelati. Nepo hires. Summer interns. Obviously not getting full time positions. On that note, if you're interested in working for a leader of the industry, find your way to my DMs. Don't be afraid of your idols. So sick of this shite but I'll continue because I'm a professional. You see this Yelp!!! Consummate pro. Spot is cute, nice to walk to after dinner on a double tiered Scarsdale downtown. Various flava flavors, not sure how many of them are real and how many are just flavoring. IYKYK. Snobs UNITE. But good texture. Little pricey. I like da ideaaaa, and the execution is good enough to earn it a round up to 4 stars. read more

Mimi’s by Martines - Gelato - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Best ice cream in town! This place truly deserves a 5-star rating -- 10/10! Service is great.... read more

Mimi’s by Martines - Pistachio and giandvia - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

This place is great. I had wanted to try this gelato place for a few months. I was in the area and walked over to try it out. The line was out the door, but it was worth it! I love gelato, and I'm so glad I came here. I ordered the chocolate gelato. It was delicious. I'd try more flavors next time. But, chocolate is always my favorite. I love the ambiance here, and the lighting. There are tables and chairs located inside and outside of the shop. But, it is limited. If you're nearby, I'd recommend stopping here! read more

See all

The gelato here has a lot of variety and is always very flavorful. This is a go-to spot and they even have a bakery across the street for more goodies. This place always has long lines and for good reason. Their most popular flavor is the Dubai chocolate one. read more

If you are looking to have an amazing and delightful ice cream or gelato, you must visit mimi's by Martines. It is one of the best ice cream I've ever had. Despite the long lines, it does moves fast. Excellent service! I can't wait to go back! read more

Mimi’s by Martines - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

The portions are very small and overpriced. I overheard the way management treats their workers and it is not pleasant.

This is not a review about the gelato the gelato is good here. Great even. This is about their out of control ordering system. They notoriously have long wait times but the amount of times I got pushed around today by kids and entire families of 7 or 8 trying every single flavor of gelato there's no system for the line. They need to add a divider to show how the line works or someone could yell out that if you have your gelato in your hands don't stand around eating it blocking everybody else. The staff is nice but they allow their customers to bully other customers. The waits are excessive but it's the process more than the wait that I'm upset about. It's a small space, put a sign at least that says if you're done with paying and got a gelato in your hands, GO OUTSIDE! No eating in the tiny store. Absolutely ridiculous experience and since they've been opened they haven't done a thing about it. Also the tasting is excessive, they should only allow customers to taste 2 flavors at a time. I have witnessed people tasting every single flavor in sure it's costly for the business too to allow so much to be tasted. Love Mimi's but I've experienced this one too many times to not write this review. I'm hoping they ads at least a divider to make the line more civilized read more

See all

Mimi's has taken Scarsdale by storm. They built out a tiny location at the Scarsdale train station, right across the street from their main business- Martines. Martines offers coffee's, pastries and prepared items- all of which are excellent. They applied their high standards to Mimi's which offers a dizzying array of flavored gelatos- all delicious. The location is ultra modern in design and they service you quickly and pleasantly. It just goes to show that there are opportunities all over- you just need the right idea and strong implementation. Value is fine for the experience and they have large to go containers- sure to be a big hit a Westchester dinner parties. Congrats on this new positive addition to the Scarsdale dessert scene. It's amazing to me to read the other reviews of Mimi's as many sad and unhappy people will somehow find something to complain about..... read more

Mimi's gelato is five star! Authentic, variety of flavors. One of the best around since Panne e Gelato in Eastchester closed. Tonight, I walked in 5 minutes before closing and my server was helpful and conscientious. I ordered 2 cups to go for $17. While she was finishing the order, I walked over to the collective tip jar and put in a dollar. After I paid with my card, I decided to put another dollar in the collective tip jar for good service. When I left the store, there were 2 employees folding up chairs from the outside cafe area. As I walked past them they were giggling and one girl came up to me and asked, "did you take a dollar out of the jar?" WHAAAT? I replied, "you're rude, I'm a customer." I should've gone back and taken the $2 out of the jar to give to my server rather than leave it in the shared tips!! Management needs to work on employee customer service training. read more

Amazing Gelato. This place just opened tonight. Some of the most amazing flavors I have ever had. They currently have gelato and sorbet. They will have Belgian and American waffles. And Italian crepes. Ratings: #1: Kookies & Caramel #2: Cantaloupe Sorbet #3: Shakerato coffee-hazelnut (vegan) They make a great use of space and it is a welcome edition to the area. The service was exceptional. I came back a second time and actually got a full helping of the Kookies & Caramel in the cone. The cone was way better than any waffle cone I have ever had. All I could say was OMG!!! read more

See all

I've eaten a lot of ice cream/gelato over the years (ok weeks) and Mimi's is as good as any I've tried...including Italy. It's right above the train station so great little place to stop in when you're waiting for the train. Allow some time, it was very busy when we went. read more

Gelato was ok as we have visited Mimi's over 6 times at least. One day though, we noticed a hair in the gelato in the case. A worker proceeded to just pull the hair out and continue serving the same gelato as if nothing was wrong. So if you like gelato with hair or perhaps anything that it may have touched then this is the place for you. read more

Mimi’s by Martines - Worker who removed the hair and then served the rest of the gelato. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Went today with my husband and son. After we paid and turned around to leave a girl worker rudely shouts "are you planning on paying?" After I said "we did" she asked us who checked us out. I didn't remember the name of course so she asks all the other girl workers until one finally admits she checked us out. The one who rudely accused us of not paying just replies "no worries". No apology for HER wrongdoing. Gelato was good but they need to fix their customer service for these prices. read more

Their gelato is generally excellent and we've gone many times. However, they recently started adding some sort of bits to the chocolate sorbet that feel very artificial - not chocolate bits that melt in your mouth, but more like - dare I say - plastic bits. Please go back to the chocolate sorbet without the bits. Thanks. read more

I'm honestly surprised it took me this long to try Mimi's! My friends and I were out to dinner nearby and decided we would walk for gelato (we were full of pasta, so it was good to get some steps in). There had to be at least 20 flavors to choose from, if not more. I decided on hazelnut and I'm so glad I did. If you like Nutella, you need to order this flavor! read more

Mimi’s by Martines - Hazelnut - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

This has been my go to place for delicious gelato. I went there again today and picked up some gelato for my wife and friends. This place never disappoints read more

I got ripped off--$14.63 for a single scoop of coffee ice cream! I strongly recommend everyone to always ask for a paper receipt. read more

This is more of a WARNING than a review. They don't have anything and mean absolutely nothing marked for allergies. Which in most places isn't necessary an issue and common sense can be used but here they have tree nuts in flavors like plain chocolate, caramel and even mint. The chocolate syrup has tree nuts in it which you would think would be clearly marked but it's not. There is a small generalized sign about allergies that every food service establishment has but when you ask the workers what has certain allergens they all start to stare at each other then look around and then look towards the back as if someone back there knows the answer. It's good gelato but not worth dying over. read more

Delicious! Not many options for dessert in the vicinity. But, this one is worth the wait! The line may look long, but, moves fairly quickly. I had the passion fruit cheesecake (sooooooo good) and gianduia (just like Ferrero Rocher) and it did not disappoint! BIG cones and cute wafer to top it off! read more

Mimi’s by Martines - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

Delicious gelato with special flavors! Friendly staff who keeps the lines moving! This is a must try!

Soooo delicious! A small place right next to the train station with fresh gelato. They had a full staff so the very busy place moved at a good pace. Everything was clean and well thought out. The flavors were incredible and smooth. There's outdoor seating available as well. The staff was super friendly and helpful let us try samples to make a decision (the hardest part lol) overall great experience can't wait to come back! * we got pistachio, hazelnut, and marshmallow read more

Mimi’s by Martines - Pistachio flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Samples the mango and wild berr sorbet. Both were very good and tasted very natural. I hate going to corporate store as they always have an artificial after taste. The little waffle waffer top was delicious as well. read more

delicious gelato! only complaint was that the store is small with limiting seating and was crowded when we arrived. will definitely return! read more

Mimi’s by Martines - kookies & caramel small cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

The gelato here is very low quality, you know because mint is glowing green and the banana is yellow (it should be cream color, we don't eat the peel!). The flavors don't taste rich or rounded, there's some flavoring in them. So excited to have a gelato place but huge disappointment. Why not use higher quality ingredients? read more

The gelato is excellent and there are many different flavors to choose from. Tiramisu is my favorite. The staff is friendly and the place is cozy. read more

delicious food and wonderful employees who are diligent in what they do. love the cookie on top

Coming from the city, none of us were expecting much. This place blew those expectations out of the water. The gelato here is significantly better than Amorino's, and also more affordable than Grom, Arte Del Gelato, or Eataly. If you want solid, fairly close to authentic, not too overpriced real gelato, this might be your best bet in Westchester. It's also at the Metronorth station, so it's super convenient to boot! read more

Popped in on a Friday afternoon and it wasn't too busy. Small store but still has seating. The gelato was absolutely delish. The server was very kind and allowed us to try many flavors. One better than the next!!! A delicious little Mimi's wafer cookie tops the treat. Will definitely be back! read more

So delicious! Amazing unique flavors and normal flavors + everything in between! Great service and cute lights

This is our new favorite ice cream shop. My family and I tried 6 flavors in total and each was better than the last. My absolute favorite was the wild card! So good. read more

Stracciatella was called vanilla Stracciatella. It did not have any pieces of chocolate in it. Tested very bland. Chocolate hazelnut and pistacchio were good but not great. Need to add chocolate To the Stracciatella or don't call it Stracciatella, call it vanilla. read more

Place is a mess and definitely stay away if you have any food allergies. Staff is not knowledgeable on allergies and a bit rude

Very tight shop with such a long line, no place to sit. Waited so long to finally get some gelatos for my toddler. Their flooring and chair choices are very poor for a gelato shop. Floor is hard rocky style and chairs are without proper backs and no arm support. My toddler fell through the back of the chair and had a terrible head injury due to their hard rocky floors. No kiddy chairs were in sight and it turned out to be our worst night! Later when we asked them for ice to cold compress our baby's injury they said they don't have any. We will never return. read more

amazing ice cream! great quality and I am in trouble :) Had the cherry and hazelnut ice cream and will go back soon. read more

UPDATE! I reviewed this cute shop shortly after it opened and at that time I was very unimpressed. I was reluctant to return to small portions and gelato that did not look fresh, but I decided to give it a try since I had seen it written up in magazines and articles recently. I'm happy to report that I'm happy I gave it another chance! We stopped for a treat after dinner last night and it was truly amazing. The flavors were fresh, the pistachio was more of a tan/brown color and the flavor was amazing, just like it should be. The fruit flavors were excellent, and everything looked fresh. The servings were a bit more generous, which I appreciated given the price. This is the real deal! I will be back again. read more

Skimpy scoops of gelato, when I asked the staff to add more they said this is how it comes. Wouldn't go back again.