I stopped in with a friend on a weekday afternoon on a very hot spring day. We were the only people inside! The space feels classic. Not many frills. A bit of promotions. Only two seats in the window in the front. (We snagged them!) There's a good amount of variety but even a ton more to-go stuff along the window. We got a kid size of cookie monster flavor, which was very blue and solid. The pre-wrapped cone was meh, but that was just a poor choice on my part. Convenient! read more

Carvel - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

The owners are rude and stingy with the sprinkles and servings compared to the one on Mill road. Don't go to this one. Go to the one on mill road service is friendlier and you get more value read more

Carvel is carvel .. yummy. Get fresh one o got one with freezer burn and tasted funny so it was a waste!!

Great service. The owners are always welcoming when I go. If you're undecided about a flavor, they're quick to offer you a sample. I'm not sure of Carvel sets the prices in all their stores or if they're independently set, but the cost is a little steep. 2 vanilla cones & 1 Heath Dasher cost $13+. The store is located on the corner in Depot Square. After you get your ice cream, you can walk over to the square center and enjoy your ice cream on the park benches. read more

Carvel - Heath Caramel Dasher! Best thing ever. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

See all

Bad customer service and limiting the Wednesday sundae special to only syrup toppings

Good ice cream, a little steep in price though. Come on they have Fudgie the Whale!!!! read more

the staff here are super nice and generous with their portions! i love coming here for ice cream :)

I love carvel and I always go out of my way to get some of their delicious soft serve ice cream. This particular location is nothing to write home about. I sampled the Nutella and thought it tasted good but I couldn't really tell because the sample was so stingy. I ordered a large because the portions at carvel are almost always stingy. This portion was not stingy at all. My large weighed 17 ounces. The taste however left a lot to be desired. The owner did such a poor job swirling it that it didn't look like soft serve ice creamy very much. It looked like a regular scoop of hard ice cream. It melted very fast. This was the poorest quality carvel I have been to. The store also looked old and in need of an update or at least some air conditioning. Toppings were standard and boring. 3 stars only because it's carvel. read more

Carvel - Large Nutella - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

The people working tonight we're very nice and friendly. If you're in the area come here. Got a Coffee & Cream malted and a chocolate with crunchy. read more

Carvel - the front of a store at night - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Tuckahoe, New York

My family and I love coming here for ice cream. The people who work here are very friendly and always sweet to our kids. Ice cream is consistently good, and we get all our birthday/celebration cakes here as well. Very convenient location to grab a sweet treat on the way home! read more

The only carvel in the area that my family and I will go to! The staff is extremely friendly and always welcoming. The ice cream and ice cream cakes are always fresh and delicious. Compared to other carvels in the area- this is by far the nicest one around. read more

Waaay overpriced, sooo skimpy on toppings, and went in today amidst corona virus only to find them NOT wearing gloves even when preparing the ice cream, but on top of that they used their BARE HANDS to throw some m&m's that dropped onto the counter back into the toppings container! So not sanitary. Not happy. read more

This place is not a nice place to get ice cream. 1) The ice cream is not good. It tastes very processed and artificial. 2) The prices are very high given the portion sizes and the quality of the ice cream. 3) The store is plastered with signs about all the extra charges and rules for things. This, combined with the high prices and small portions, leaves one feeling mostly ripped off and dissatisfied. read more

Horrible place. I had a coupon for free ice cream and the guy was being an asshole and asking me for ID. Since when do you need ID to get ice creaM? read more

This store is a scam. We wanted a cake for my son's birthday and called up. They assured us that they could do it and suggested we came in to see all their designs. The price was $40. We turned up and they were very nice. My wife picked out a design and asked if they could make it in cookie dough. They said no problem--but it would be an extra $6 because it was a premium flavor. WTF! I have been buying ice cream for more than 40 years and never paid extra for a special flavor. And why is cookie dough premium? Every ice cream store and supermarket offers this flavor for the same price as all the other flavors. Don't waste your time or money here as the owners a looking for ways to get extra money out of you. FYI, the store on Central Ave does not charge extra for "special flavors". Next time we will just go down the road to Haagen Dazs which charges the same for "special flavors". RESPONSE Carvel responded within an hour. Good to see they back up their product and quality. FYI I will never eat there again!! Hi, We do not handle the Carvel stores. They are independent on their own. I do apologize that you had a bad experience with them. You may want to direct your comments to the store manager as they need to be aware of your experience with this location. Thank you, There is no point getting in touch with with store manager, since they were the ones who served us. Looks like Carvel will be next to go out of business. read more

They are unreasonably stingy with the amount of ice cream that they give. It's a standard Carvel, but I ordered a small sundae, a medium sundae, and a cone. The cone was average size (could have been bigger). But the small and medium sundae were only half full! Soft serve ice cream is incredibly cheap, and charging $5-6 for each sundae is fine so long as you actually give me some ice cream. I had about 4-5 spoonfuls and I was done. That's like $1 a spoon of ice cream. Unacceptable! read more

Best Carvel around! Big, bright, clean, and very friendly service. I disagree with the reviewer who said that the portions are small. I think they are typically very generous! Glad I live nearby! read more