Wow wow wow! Went here for the first time a few months ago just to see what all the hype was about. I'm a huge fan of chocolate cream pies so of course I had to try it. One of the best chocolate cream pies I've ever had, so it's made its way to the top 3 best ones of all time! I always saw them posting about their bite sized jelly donuts so of course had to try those too! So fresh and filled with a good amount of jelly inside. The workers were extremely friendly. The inside of the bakery is small, but they've been very intentional on how to use the space. I must go back and try other things! Cash only. read more

Galloway's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

See all

I finally stopped in! It was my first time here. Love this place! Of course, I had to try the jelly donuts, and I went home with a pecan pie and a Keylime tart and a couple of black-and-white cookies. Everything was delicious! The jelly donuts were nice and soft like pillows. There's quite a selection of treats to choose from. The people who worked there are really nice, and I will be back. read more

See all

Cute neighborhood spot that gives classic feel as soon as you entered. This spot is cash or check only, only street parking, and no seating. We got the almond danish and onion bread; danish was outstanding while the onion was average though we paid $24 for both so its pretty good value. Would come back again to try the jelly donut! read more

See all

There was a time that this weekenders lines being down the road was justified... Now is not that time. I've been totally underwhelmed with some of the baked goods I have received from there, including their Easter, breads, and Sunday buns.... They were average at best and certainly not worth the wait of the line. Not sure what has changed over the years, but it certainly has not been a change for the better and I'm sad that it's not what it used to be. It's not worth the struggle for the parking space. Hope it turns around again! read more

Galloway Bakery is a classic neighborhood spot with old-school charm that's hard to find these days. It's a long-standing bakery that focuses on doing things the traditional way, and it really shows in the quality of their baked goods. The pistachio pound cake was excellent--moist, rich, and perfectly balanced without being overly sweet. You can really taste the pistachio, and the texture was spot on. Simple, comforting, and done right. Good to know before going: cash only, and they're open Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. Definitely worth planning a visit--I'll be back to try more. read more

Love this bakery. Everything is fresh, homey and delicious. I come early when they first open, to make sure they don't run out of my favorite items like the jelly donut holes. So, I've never had trouble getting my items. Our favorites are the donut holes. Jelly is our favorite because they are so fresh and fluffy, with generous amounts of jelly. The glazed are really nice, light and fluffy. All are best the first day. Whenever my kids come home for a visit, they ask for these donut holes. Second favorite is the banana cream pie. This is also another very popular request at holiday get togethers. Hint: these freeze very well, so if I have leftovers, I can eat a little at a time so I'm not overeating. Other good items: rainbow cookies, and the rye pumpernickel bread. Both were delicious. The bread in particular was so fresh and perfectly chewy. read more

Pies are good and not too sweet! Their most popular item is the jelly donut but I'm not a jelly donut fan (cuz of the sweet jelly part). The donut part was delicious 10/10 though, so I'll definitely come back for other donut flavors. The only item I wouldn't get again are the cinnamon rolls. They don't use cream cheese frosting and it had a very flowery flavor rather than cinnamon-sugar. More like a monkey bread with icing on top. Will come back to try strawberry shortcake and maybe coffee cakes next time and regular donuts. read more

See all

Legendary Bakery, Only open Weekends, Crumb Cake is awesome, Apple pies , the best jelly doughnut bites in existence, love this place

One of the best cakes I've had in a long time. Beautifully frosted and decorated. The staff is very nice and helpful. Cash only and plan to order well ahead of your celebration of event. read more

We bought several pies for Thanksgiving and they are pretty good but not outstanding. They are a bit pricy at $25 to $30 per pie and you are paying for its name & reputation; but at this price range, you will have a lot of choices. It is also cash only. I am reluctant on the recommendation. read more

My wife grew up going to this bakery so I wanted to get her some cinnamon rolls as a Christmas morning treat. After being warned that there may be a line to get into the bakery, I was pleasantly surprised there was no wait, the staff was friendly and most importantly the rolls were delicious! read more

Pumpkin pie was like purée from a can and apple pie no taste and crust was raw. To think my husband paid $30 a pie, I Hope they make it right. read more

Galloway's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

These are the doughnut you're nostalgic for: absolutely simple, absolutely classic, executed perfectly. Such friendly service too! They gave my son a little treat while we were waiting. Recommended! read more

Galloway's Bakery - Doughnuts - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

It's flooding all over and I went in to grab a delicious pie and Patty gave me some delicious donuts on top of it. Very nice place with very nice people and delicious pies and donuts! Great black and white cookies too! read more

Galloway's Bakery - Chocolate cream pie is so good. - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

The jelly doughnuts are so good. I've only gotten the doughnuts so far but definitely want to try their pies. I saw the line was out the door right before thanksgiving! read more

Galloways, where have been all my life? Open only fri-sun and this place churns out business, so you know it is the trufe! Supposedly they make the best banana cream pie and around the holidays there is a line out the door. I needed to outsource the labor for a cherry pie and they delivered. There were so many other things I wanted to try from there. Heard the jelly donut holes are a thing of beauty. My kids are picky, so I got the butter cookies that have chocolate on the back and look like little men - delicious. The mini pecan pie was amazing. I was sad they likethem because I wanted them all for me! Anyway, it is cash only, but they have an atm inside. Parking on the street. read more

See all

Family owned and operated. Yummy pies. Fabulous jelly donuts! Cash only. ATM in store.

This review has been a long time coming. Galloway's is a staple in Westchester. In a time when corporations dominate every aspect of life Galloways is one of the last family owned mom and pop bakeries that I know of in the area. Quick advice prior to scheduling a visit; Galloway's is only open from Fri-Sun (holiday hours are different). It also can get VERY busy, so I'd recommend coming over, earlier as you can beat the rush. Immediately upon waking in, I am greeted not only by the lovely smell of fresh baked goods, but also by the entire staff with smiles brightening up my Friday morning. The inside is exactly what one would think of when it comes to a family bake shop; warm and welcoming with no frills. I highly recommend their donuts. The jelly and glazed are my particular favorite. They're absolutely out of this world. To the point where I have coworkers asking me to bring them extra or ask me to pick up a separate order for them. A close second for me is their almond melt away. Though, you can't go wrong with any of their baked goods, honestly. I cannot recommend Galloway's enough. This will forever be my spot for baked goods. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

Picked up the GREATEST poppy seed rolls here. Get the rolls. They are the fluffiest, densest, sweetest, freshest rolls I've had in my life. The jelly donuts come in second and just bursting with jelly and just-made goodness. Skip the banana cream pies and chocolate pies and get the crumb buns and rainbow cookies - superb. I'll see you again soon, you adorable shop, you! 5 stars!!!!! read more

See all

Love love love their jelly donuts. Haven't tried anything else yet but will have to try more. The people that work here are nice and always smiling. Love the aroma when they are baking reminds me of Stella Dora back in the day. read more

Stopped by for lemon tarts. I bought both lemon and lime. Was a little disappointed as they did not have much lemon or lime flavor. The crust of the tart and the meringue were good, but the custard had no flavor. read more

We're hooked. I wish they could be open on weekdays. My husband is hooked on the " famous " banana cream pie. Nothing compares.

Today I was gifted a banana cream pie from this place and my life will never be the same. I stopped at my in-laws to give them half the pie before trying it and that was a huge mistake. I should have saved it all for myself and my husband because I don't think he's going to the see half that is almost finished! Didn't even get a plate - fork in the pie tin and into my mouth - super fantastic!!! read more

Galloway's Bakery - Banana blast deliciousness - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

They have certainly "nailed" the art of pie making! Every pie is absolutely delicious and they have a HUGE assortment of both fruit pies (with and without crumbs), and Cream & Merengue pies. Some of my family's favorites include: Peach & Berry Pie and Coconut Cream Pie. Don't leave without a bag full of Jelly Popems! They are to die for! read more

Pure yumm and classic family desserts Occasional hours but fine Need to work out more to have more of the delish choices!! read more

I read about their famous jelly doughnuts and I'm a fan! It's definitely worth going even just for these melt in your mouth treats. So good!! read more

Galloway's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Decided to try this spot out for the first time since moving here. There was a long line out the door the day before thanksgiving. I went with the apple crumb pie. The apples were tasty, just a little bit tart and not too sweet. The crumb was very tasty however too sweet for me personally. Overall one of the better pies I've had but the price point is a tad steep with this pie going for $30. read more

Galloway's Bakery - Apple Crumb pie - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

This establishment is racially biased and I do not recommend potential Black customers to patronize this business. They are cash only and have a machine to check the legitimacy of bills, but do not use the machine consistently. My mother and I have gone there to purchase pies during the holidays for the past couple of years and notice that the only bills they check while we're there with white clients are ours. As black women, we are unfortunately adept at noticing inequalities and difference of treatment while being serviced. We confronted the manager about this but she fiend ignorance and claimed we were making it up, but it's happened more than once. Needless to say, I won't return given their blatant racial discrimination. read more

Very over rated over priced independent rude people who think who they are. Open only some weekends as they are rich and own the store real estate. read more

Enjoyed another best pies from our area for this weekend. My favorite is though Strawberry Cake, winter is time for pies. Today's choice is Banana Cream Pie. Cream is so fresh and not too sweet and custard cream mix with chunks of bananas. With a mug of coffee I can eat half of this whole pie. Yummy!! This small shop takes only 3 customer at a time because of Corona. I feel much better with this policy. Watch out for their open days. Only weekend and Cash only. Another best pies from our area for this weekend. My favorite is though Strawberry Cake winter time is for pies. Today's choice is Banana Cream Pie. Cream is so fresh and not too sweet and custard cream mix with chunks of bananas. With a mug of coffee I can eat half of this whole pie. Yummy!! This small shop takes only 3 customer at a time because of Corona. I feel much better with this policy. Watch out for their open days. Only weekend and Cash only. read more

See all

Kidding me! These Pies are outrageous. Coconut, Key Lime, banana. We were blown away. Gotta get the raspberry donuts as well! I wish there was a way they'd make sugar free and gluten free versions! read more

Best in westchester! Only open 3 days a week. That's when you know a bakery is good. When they don't even NEED your business lol. Highly recommend the meltaways and the sugar donuts and the glazed, donut holes and the cinnamon roll with or without raisins. Actually, everything's amazing. Oh and I live up the block so it's dangerous for me but great if you're in the neighborhood. read more

I really love this bakery. You can tell everything here is made with love. The rainbow cookies are one of the best I ever had. I also love the fluffy donut holes they sell. My favorite thing to order here are their cupcakes. The icing is perfect and the cake itself taste homemade. I look forward to every trip I make to this bakery. read more

Galloway's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

If I could give Galloways 10 stars for their jelly donuts I would! They are the best!!!! The most incredibly delicious melt in your mouth, just the right amount of jelly and the most luxurious delicious powdered sugar 1,2,3 a dozen is just not enough!!! Thankfully they are only available Friday Saturday and Sunday! read more

Galloway's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Scarsdale, New York

Good old fashioned pies. Great assortment. Wish they weren't only open on weekends. Very old school in a good way !!

Galloway's is the definition of old school. A family-owned business just north of NYC, this bakery consistently delvers the goods every time I patron them. The bakery is only open on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays - but really their products are so good they probably don't need to be open more than that. While they serve a variety of baked items, for me the pies are the star. The cherry crumb is out of this world - one of the best pies I've ever had - period. The chocolate cream pie and apple crumb are other standouts for me - but in reality almost all of the pies are top drawer. Another standout item are their doughnut holes - the best has to be the jelly ones coated with powdered sugar; I can pop those like potato chips. They also have a good variety of rolls, muffins, and danish which are also high quality and tasty. Come for the old school bakery feel, stay for the superb pies and doughnut holes. This place is a special treat that is a star amongst its peers. read more

As soon as you enter you know this place is the real deal! Great cookies, cupcakes, and danish rings. Unfortunately I didn't get to try the donuts but they looked really good! I brought home a blueberry crumb pie for my parents and they commented on how they got a grape taste from it. They still enjoyed the pie though! read more

This place looks like a local favorite and always crowded with soccer moms and teenage girls. That's not a bad advertisement and not saying that's the only two groups that crave sweetness ;-). Place apparently carries all home made items, with family members at the counter. Usually they are very eager to sell and friendly, though if you ask their recommendation on what to get, you are responded with confused looks. Not very helpful, but if pressed they do help you out. Not being too harsh here, but indicating that it is family run, so be nice to them. Have tried their pies, which are A-Class. Cookies are ok and banana cream pies along with cup cakes are good too. read more

This place is a gem! Delicious, fresh , family run for many years . I Absolutely love it ! . Everything I've ever tried from there was delicious . read more

Costumer service was great! the young women who took my order was a sweetheart. I purchased a Key Lime meringue, onion dinner rolls and corn muffin. The pie was delicious but the corn bread wasn't good and the dinner rolls were just ok. I'll definitely come back and try more pies read more