Excellent little ice cream shop with fast lines and great service. Parking is limited and line can…read morebe a bit long but overall had a great summer experience as we ordered our cones and listened to some live music outside. Ice cream was very good, and would recommend for your next ice cream fix.

Love me Some McNulty's ice cream! This place is a staple in…read morest James and a great place to take the kids to get ice cream in the summer. This place is always packed and they have a great selection of home made in house ice cream that a blow your socks off. Very good and no cutting corners making this amazing ice cream. If you're looking for a cool place to bring the kids for ice cream and want a do something different then carvel! McNulty's is the spot and you will not be disappointed! This place is a made house and always busy but the line goes fast. Great place with lots of history in the neighborhood.

Mia's Ice Cream was so good!…read more Vanilla Peanut Butter Cup -- delicious, smooth, perfectly cold. Mint Chocolate Chip -- just the right amount of mint and chocolate chips. They also have adult ice cream flavors with alcohol. The girl working the counter was so friendly and patient with everyone wanting samples. While we were sitting and eating, she even came over and offered us a taste of the Cherry Amaretto after we tried the Coconut Rum flavor -- and no worries, you can still eat and drive lol. The owner came over and talked with us for a while too. Super personable guy who clearly loves creating new flavors. I requested a future flavor with coconut, almonds, and chocolate chips -- basically an Almond Joy ice cream -- so hopefully he gets on that, lol! I'd give the overall experience a 9/10 only because I could see seating being tough when it gets busy, but the ice cream itself is definitely 10/10!!

Their adult ice cream is amazing!!! Not overwhelming not to light. I had the banana foster and…read moreadding caramel, perfect!!! Service was good, they let you try the flavors if you are curious. Like all the best ice cream shops, you can get pints to go as well! Seating is extremely limited, this is more of a to go spot, but you can get a spot if you are lucky.

Strong Island Ice Cream is one of those places that keeps you coming back. From the moment we…read morewalked in, the smell of the fresh-made bubble waffles filled the shop, and we knew we were in for a treat. We loved everything we tried. My favorite was the Bubble Waffle Sundae, while my bf is always a fan of the Peanut Butter & Jelly Milkshake. You can really taste the quality because everything is made in-house--from the rich, creamy ice cream to the warm bubble waffles and even the whipped cream, which I was absolutely obsessed with. What really made the experience stand out was the people. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and happy to answer questions. The owner was working in the shop when we visited, and he was incredibly kind, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about what he does. It's always nice to support a local business where the owner is so involved and takes pride in every order. If you're looking for homemade ice cream and desserts on Long Island, Strong Island Ice Cream is definitely worth the stop. Great desserts, great service, and a great overall experience. We can't wait to come back! By the way, there is plenty of parking, the walls are very insta-worthy if you want to take photos with your beautifuly constructed sundaes, and there's some seating, and very clean as well.

Homemade ice cream in the heart of Nesconset. Finally came by tonight and got a few ice creams to…read morego. Got the Burgundy cherry, Reese's cookie dough and cookies and cream. Very good ice cream but not a very strong flavor profile. The Reese's cookie dough was definitely the best out of all of them. Definitely worth it to check them out!

If you are reading this review instead of getting on the line to order you're already wasted too…read moremuch time. I didn't know what to expect when the suggestion came up to come here, or if I thought I could find anything to satisfy my ice cream fix from the looks of the old school store front. But I'm so glad I was 100% proven wrong, because this is a hidden gem and needs to stay that way to keep lines from forming. As soon as you walk in you could tell there were too many delicious choices to narrow down into an order including pralines and cream, banana nut crunch and bartman. And if something doesn't quite fit your fancy, you can choose to add toppings to your mix from the large variety of options. The line moves fast, and the friendly staff are super helpful and ready to answer questions. The menu also provides favorite concoctions and sundaes. The interior may seem small, but you don't need much room to get in, order, and get out quickly. The only problem is I only had two hands to hold my order as I wanted to try everything.

Don't be fooled by the outdated and small look - this is the most delicious ice cream you'll have…read moreon Long Island! Living close to this place is very dangerous, as we already went back twice in 1 week. From ice cream to pup cups to nostalgic candy, this is the perfect spot for someone with a sweet tooth. We tried the Mint Cookies & Cream (I usually never order mint) but it was perfectly flavored and not overly minted. Everything is homemade fresh - highly recommend!

Very cute ice cream shop with a lot going on!…read more We came after dinner for a sweet treat, I can't help it! I had their rocky road and cookie dough on a cone, kept it simple. Loved both to be honest. I never see a chocolate based rocky road and it was great. My boyfriend had a coffee ice cream shake he said was good except they didn't give him a lid at first and it spilt all over the place ultimately making more of a mess for the poor girl working, ALONE, on a Saturday night. Otherwise will definitely come back. I want that rocky road!

are you serious ?? went there because Snowflake was closed for holiday.... Soft serve, chocolate…read moreand then you have Dole pineapple and Dole strawberry, really ? you can see the containers right by the machine, ok so clearly it's not homemade, then the hard ice cream ( wasn't many choices) looked icy old and melty.... ok let's say you don't care about any of that, 2 small soft serves with sprinkles $ 14.64 and their small is like a kid size ... for $10.94 you can actually get homemade GREAT tasting homemade ice cream at Snowflake... and size small is actually huge in comparison... Just a icky place with icky tasting ice cream for an outrageous price.. just sayin !!! lessons learned ...

I drove 30 minutes for this place a it was definitely worth it. The ice cream was baked to…read moreperfection and I don't even know how you bake ice cream. Cookies and cream was great. I mean who doesn't like homemade ice cream! And if you don't you're a psycho just like me (however I like homemade lce cream it's just some people are born psycho )Only complaint is that the lights are barely on so you can't really tell if it's open until you get in. But besides that the ice cream was greatly appreciated.10/10

What a cute place. Super nice staff and very good ice cream. Price was also very good. Highly…read morerecommend!!!

It was and is amazing and extraordinary service, great ices and flavors and a great owner!read more

People working there have horrible vibes. They should not be working with people if they don't like…read moreto. Going there for a treat just to leave in a bad mood. Save yourself go to a different Ralph's

Finally got to stop by this local ice cream shop. It was nice not having to track down the truck…read morethis time. The store itself is simple, with no seating inside. There's a small merchandise area where they sell hoodies, T-shirts, and even a toy ice cream truck. I noticed they had a large selection of ice cream and really appreciated the assortment of cones available. The prices were a little higher than I expected, but the customer service was good. They also offer a BOGO sundae special on Tuesdays, which I definitely plan to take advantage of in the future. For such a nostalgic company, though, I do wish they had some seating so people could sit, talk, and enjoy their ice cream with family and friends. Overall, it's a fun stop for a sweet treat, but adding a small seating area would really make the experience feel more complete.

Here's the Scoop! We all remember the Siftee ice cream truck…read morecoming down our block or at the park. Well now you can go to the store. It's located on Carlton Avenue in Islip. Oh boy the choices are delicious and so, so good. I ordered a waffle bowl with soft serve vanilla, nuts, black cherries and whipped cream topping. Yum, yum, yum!!! So happy I don't have to wait until summer to listen for the truck. Definitely check them out. Fast service and reasonable prices.