Best beef rib I've ever had, with a very delicious green sauce. Very soft and tender meat. I would like to find more contact information of the place. read more

Carnal - a plate of meat with guacamole on it - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

This is the only thing that I always get at the Smorgasborg. Yes, the wait is long, and the price is high, but it's worth if you love beef ribs and meat in general. Given how expensive everything else is at the Smorgasborg, you do get a fair amount of meat for the price, imo. Pro-tip: get to the Smorgasborg right when it opens and place your order at Carnal to avoid the insane lines read more

I got both the ribs and the pork shoulder sandwich. Both were excellent and didn't disappoint. My favorite was probably the pork sandwich, you can get ribs everywhere but not pork sandwiches that taste this good! Lastly don't be dissuaded by the long line. It moves pretty quickly and only takes 5 minutes to actually make your order. read more

See all

For sure the main highlight of the Smorgasborg - the 30 minute wait to order and eat this big hunk of beef short-rib was well worth it. Smothered in bone marrow and topping with a fresh salsa relish, this massive beef rib is a meat lover's dream. My girlfriend and I were visiting from San Francisco, and it was our first time at the Smorgasborg. The moment I saw the huge clouds of smoke and heard the sounds of big pieces of meat being grilled, I knew I had to try this place. The aroma emanating from the grill was also intoxicating - I just knew I had to wait for this. After waiting for so long and getting our beef short-rib (props to my bae for waiting with me), we walked down near the sand and began feasting on the mighty piece of meat. The first bite was one I will remember for a long time. The beef short-rib was so tender and rich. The oozing bone marrow that was shimmering over the beef short-rib coated my entire mouth. The freshness of the relish brought me back to reality. This was the perfect bite. Of course, being the good gentleman I was, I then politely handed it over to my girlfriend for her to try. She was in agreement over how delicious it was. We devoured the whole thing within minutes, and we're completely satisfied and ready for a nap. I still remember eating at this place like it was yesterday. The experience of being at the Smorgasborg, waiting in line for something that you know will be delicious... makes me want to go back one weekend just to order 2 or 3 of these beef short-ribs. Until then, I will keep dreaming. read more

This was first visit to the Smorgasburg in Williamsburg on my birthday, so me and my girlfriend decided to try at least 12 things in a little over 3 hours. As I was walking past Carnal, the queue was one of the longest and I decided to stand in line too, after taking a look at their menu and presentation, given that they're serving ribs, which isn't exactly something on a fine dining menu. An almost 30 minute wait till I could order the beef short rib & bone marrow (with tomatillo, serrano chile and papa lo). Another 10 mins and I heard my name called out, and I walked back to my girlfriend, delicately holding the rib, feeling like royalty. Carnal is easily one of the best options at the Smorgasburg. The ribs were extremely well seasoned, a slight crisp on the outside, immensely juicy on the inside, and the tomatillo relish on top was an excellent complement to the fattiness (would have loved some more of it though). I do regret not trying the (48 hour smoked) pork shoulder sandwich, but we already had had a few things waiting in line for the ribs. At $14, this is VERY reasonably priced since the portion is more than generous, and it's also one of the tastiest items at the Smorgasburg IMHO. It would be amazing if this talented team opens up a more permanent establishment and continues to impress us! P.S. We managed to try 13 different things, and also had dinner after 5 hours. read more

Carnal - Beef short rib & bone marrow, with tomatillo, serrano chile and papalo (some more of the relish would have been even better) - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

Visited Carnal at the Smorgasburg in Williamsburg this past weekend. I ordered the beef short rib with bone marrow, topped with a cauliflower and papalo mixture. The rib was SO good. The meat slid right off of the bone, it was tender and delicious, and the topping was a nice compliment. Definitely worth the wait and the $16! read more

Carnal - Beef short rib & bone marrow - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

I came to the smorgasburg on a hot summer saturday afternoon and knew Carnal was on my list. Its a must no matter the hefty price tag ($18) or the long line. But HOLY COW! Wow this short rib was bigger than my hand! No exaggeration. The relish they top it of is sweet savory and tangy. The meat was soft and juicy which reminds me, dont forget to get extra napkins! This short rib was incredible to say the least. read more

Carnal - Beef short rib - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

The best smoked pork shoulder I have EVER HAD!!! It was so great that I can't wait for next weekend to try the ribs! The pork shoulder is severed on a crispy toasted bun with a sauce and mint!! Just writing about it make my mouth salivate. It's seasoned to perfection with just the right amount of everything in one bite. The pork itself is moist, tender, and juicy inside-- the outer layer is crispy to perfection and not burnt like some places do. I highly recommend this place!! I will keep you posted on the next mouth watering adventure of the ribs!! read more

See all

This place has the biggest line in shmorgusburg, and rightfully so. I promise you that you will not regret standing in line for this meaty heaven on a bone. The meat is flavorful, soft, and absolutely delicious. We got the beef short rib; which was topped with bonemarrow with garlic and brocolli mixture. It was out of this world delicious. I remember visiting the place when these guys just started out, and the price was $16 than just like it is now. I think that they would have the same line if they would charge $20, but I'm glad they stay with the same price. These guys work hard, and don't sit for a second. Hopefully they will continue with their cooking goodness, because people will surely continue coming. read more

See all

Experienced the absolute mastery that is the Carnal Short Rib at smorgasborg. You might wonder why it costs so much - until you bite into it. Umami deliciousness to the max. You'll be dreaming about it for months to come. The toppings and sauce they put on it add an excellent balance to the meat. Drooling just thinking about it. read more

Carnal - The Sampler - the short rib is the best. - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

You can smell the smoke from carnal in almost a quarter of smorgasborg! The menu is simple: you have the option of either a beef short rib or a pork shoulder. You can't go wrong either way! We tried the pork shoulder sandwich. The pork had a beautiful smoke ring and was superbly crispy. I'm not entirely sure what type of greens were on the sandwich, but they added a pleasant element of refreshment to the sandwich. The bun was perfect! It was thickness enough to hold the content together and absorb the pork juices, but it wasn't too thick to the point where the bread overwhelmed the ingredients. read more

I wish they had a restaurant but for now, we have to settle for finding them at local events. Their beef short rib is truly the best out there. It's very large, extremely flavorful and super soft -- the meat flys off the bone and the spices are damn good. The bone marrow on top is a great touch. It will set you back around $16 and while some people think it's a hefty price tag, I believe that they should raise the price to at least $20. read more

See all

A MAJOR shout out to the lovely Carnal family!!!!!! My munchkin and I for years would travel all the way from the Bronx every weekend to salivate while we wait and then indulge and fight over who gets the last bite and bone! Lol ... they are immensely delicious don't you dare try to share! Your still the best of Smorgasburg... Sha & Kemistry read more

So I came here on 4/30 and as usual there were a ton of people. We waited 30 mins in line for a piece of meat! The grill master was impressive and if I didn't have as much food prior to having this as my last dish, I probably would have enjoyed it more! My fiancée had a piece of the juicy meat and stated that even though shes full, she couldn't waste this delicious piece of meat so ended up eating the whole rib we were sharing! Perfectly cooked juicy meat. Definitely a great value since they give you a huge rib for $13. Best bang for your buck in Smorgasburg! read more

Carnal - BBQing away - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Best short rib ever at smorgasburg!! If you haven't already gone to Smorgasburg in Brooklyn you should try it out...it is highly recommended! read more

Had the pleasure of checking out some smells at smorgesborg and i was NOT disappointed. Though only offering 2 items.. Between a beef short rib and a 48 hour pulled pork shoulder with smoked lard and avocado..aaahhhh...u can't go wrong. I tried the short rib. The guy is out there on the grill just hook line and sinkering the crowd into line with them smells. Though the line was long, it was quick... And the 15 minutes of waiting for food prep well worth the wait. The short rib on bone... So juicy and tender with a crispy layer crusted over a nice delicate layer of mouthwatering fat over the beefy goodness of the rib. The pineapple salsa added a sweet coolness which really complimented each bite. I will get this and their other item again.. And again.. And again. Actual rating would be closer to 4.75 for me. read more

See all

Juicy, chewy, beefy deliciousness. The salsa topping the short rib cut through the fatty meat and made the experience all the more ethereal. read more

Carnal - Beef short rib with bone marrow, spring onion, and black pepper - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

The short rib was pure deliciousness. The guys would even cut out the fat to make a leaner cut. Smaller pieces of ribs are compensated by an extra piece of meat for fairness. The topping added freshness. read more

Carnal - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

Oh my goodness! Their short rib is one of the most tender pieces of meat I've ever had. And with pretty great flavor, too! The pineapple sauce it came with was fine, but it didn't really need it - the meat speaks for itself. I visited them at Williamsburg Smorgasburg one weekend in July. The line wasn't terribly long to place my order. But I probably waited for at least ten minutes. Worth it! I would totally consider ordering this again, even with the price tag if $14. read more

Yo, this place BLEW MY MIND. The meat was so flavorful and tender and juicy. I think I'm drooling just thinking about it again. It's the kind of meat that will haunt your mind and create unrealistic expectations of all other beef short ribs you'll try in the future. The toppings on it gracefully cut through the meat and are a fresh addition. Please don't get scared off by the $16 price tag or the long line. It's HUGE and will totally be worth it. It definitely a must-go at Smorgasburg. read more

Pricey, but good. The largest ribs I have ever seen or eaten. Lean meat, well seasoned and tasty. Loved it and easy to eat on the go. read more

See all

The $10 pork shoulder took an incredible amount of time despite zero line (as smoke billowed out, assaulting the lungs of everyone on that half of Smorgasburg), and they're cash only. Not a great product, either. read more

See all

I'm a foodie from the Bay. I've been to all types of food markets all over the world. I've had my share of great food, BUT Carnal's beef shortrib is easily my most favorite thing I have ever tried at any food market. Don't be intimidated by the $16 price tag because after biting into the rib, you'll want to give them all your money. Lol. It was tender, fall off the bone, AND packed a whole bunch of flavor. Definitely give it a try! read more

Carnal - Barbeque Near Me - New York, New York

Went to Smorgasburg last Summer. My roommate and I ended up getting the ribs since we're starving. As soon as I bite it I started to love it!!! The marinate is great. The meat is soooooo soft. Will definitely come back for more. But I do hope they'll start a restaurant in NYC. Cause I can't wait til April to have the beef short ribs. Definitely will recommend it to all my Carnivore friends. That's why I gave them 5 stars. read more

Every year carnal never disappoints me. Their short rib and pork sandwich is toooo die for!!!!! If you have to choose only 1, I would have to say get the rib! It's worth the money and the wait! read more

Very nicely prepared sizable meat at a reasonable. What more could you ask for!!!! Waiting in line for ten minutes only made it more delicious. The toppings change every time and the one we had (carrot, nectarine) was subtly sour and complemented the rib perfectly. read more