Food A+ Carmelita A+ Speed of service A+ Get takeout from here every month! Call ahead or stop in before grocery shopping. read more

I go here about twice a month. Gyro is top notch, as are the extra crispy fries (skip the regular fries, I'd say). Green chile cheeseburger is very good. Greek salad is generously portioned and tasty. I'd say there are better Cuban sandwiches elsewhere. Desserts tend to be fine, but not extraordinary. They cook orders fresh, so plan on ten minutes. There's some indoor seating but most people sit outside with numerous options. Service is polite but not effusive. The place is clean. I find the prices completely reasonable given the quality and quantity of the food. Check the hours because they are only open four days a week. read more

quality food, good fast service, prices are very reasonable. Many patrons also picking up to go meals and the pace of order completions was great!! read more

Perfect sandwiches to go. I like to get them and go to the brewery across the way. The green chile cheese burger is one of the best in town. read more

Carmelita's - Green Chile Cheese Burger - Greek Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

The best green chili cheeseburger so far and I've tried a bunch around Santa Fe. Fries were excellent too!

Good food. The gyro tasted fresh with a good portion size. Very nice people with friendly service.

Fantastic food! Enough said! There is not one reason not to experience is a very good restaurant.

The lamb gyro is soooo good! Lots of meat and good amount of salad items in sandwich. I feel fortunate to live nearby. Please keep the lamb gyro on the menu firever! read more

Carmelita's - a sandwich and a drink - Greek Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

A cute little shop in the heart of El Dorado's community. I have been craving Mediterranean so was excited to be introduced to this place. The food was fresh and tasty! The lamb was very tender. Great little shop to try out! read more

Carmelita's - Greek salad - Greek Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

Awesome food, think about trying another sandwich but keep ordering their hamburger & fries--the best!

Very tasty food, great service. The best green Chile cheeseburger and Greek feast. Good efficient service and consistency. Eldorado is lucky to have them here. read more

We are gratefully very spoiled right now by the delightful Mediterranean cuisine at Carmelita's. I have many favorites to rave about & recommend. My top favorite offering is the kale salad, featuring kale, mixed greens, roasted red peppers, beets, cranberry raisins, and more, with a lovely dressing. This topped with roast chicken, is one of the better salads I've enjoyed anywhere! I also love their gyros, featuring lamb, or the yummy roast chicken. Grab a few extra napkins for this one. Delish! They make a tuna melt on grilled panini bread, which is a very substantial meal in itself. I have enjoyed the burgers, and the Specials, including green chile potatoes au gratin. They serve up to-go French fries in both regular and crispy. I adore the giant serving of the regular fries. Fun to share. Rebecca the proprietor is masterful at running the small, lovely little restaurant. She's like the conductor of a small orchestra that blends and cooks yummy dishes that satisfy the taste buds, tummy, and soul. They bring a generous spirit to dishing up real and sumptuous cuisine. They bake delicious sweet treats too, from baklava, to iced lemon cake, to brownies! It's food designed, cooked, and served with heart. I feel good about supporting such kind, dear, professional local people! They even have gift cards, which make an awesome surprise for locals! Honestly, throughout these unstable crazy times and circumstances of the 2020's this little take out spot, has been a precious gem. Some of the dishes taste better than a big, fine dining restaurant! Eldorado dining offerings have been insanely unstable this recent 3 + years! Carmelita's is here for the locals, in the outskirts of Santa Fe, and Eldorado. I love that people drive out here from town, for this healthy, yummy, fare! Treat yourself and someone you love soon. You will be grateful. Also the portions are generous, indeed! Some days I've made a whole lunch out of those divine French fries! I've gotta say, I feel dearly mothered by the Spirit of Mediterranean food, Rebecca, and her winning team. Thanks to all of you, for all the little-things-mean-a-lot vibes and yummy options. We in Eldorado and beyond, are blessed and grateful for you and your offerings. Always a clean and trustworthy spot, too. If you want a winning meal or snack, I highly recommend Carmelita's. Great food, kind people, professional service, and sumptuous food that inspires repeat business! Yay! read more

Everything is always so fresh and delicious This chef brings a gourmet treatment to these fast food staples My only suggestion is that they offered a bigger variety of dishes read more

Carmelita's makes the best bacon cheeseburger in the area, and I will fight about it. The burger is perfect in every way for me... the bun is strong enough to contain the burger while tasting amazing, the veggies are fresh, and the patty is obviously high quality. Be sure to get their scalloped green chile potatoes too! It's a new special not on the online menu yet. Please keep it on the menu! read more

This is such a little gem in Eldorado, with great service and outside patio seating. It features scrumptious, old-fashioned cheeseburgers with optional green chile, sautéed onions or mushrooms, the most amazing crunchy French fries, Greek Feast salad w choice of protein, tuna melt, Cubano, daily specials and more. Very reasonably priced. Our weekly go-to! read more

One of the best falafel gyro's in town. The veggies were crisp and the tzatziki sauce was delicious. Worth the drive to Eldurado. read more

Carmelita's - Falafel gyro. - Greek Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

Excellent food, except for one thing. I really wish the owners would use environmentally friendly containers like cardboard. All their food is served in clear plastic containers, I did try to request a real plate since I was not getting "takeout" but they do not have any. The food is absolutely wonderful and you should definitely try it, I am leaving this review in hopes it will reach the owner since I don't see any other way to give feedback. I have mentioned it twice to the serving staff, but they don't seem to think it important, and I do not see a suggestion box or anything. read more

Gyros were excellent. Burgers are large and juicy. Fries great! Limited outside seating around mall courtyard. Service was excellent.

Fantastic!! Great burger flavorful and juicy ! Gyro is spectacular! So glad they are back ! read more

So glad to have Carmelita's in Eldorado--the gyros and greek feast are excellent! Pleasant space to wait for your order and pleasant staff members at the counter. read more

Good food. Usually go for the Greek Feast but the burgers are great too and the fries are nice and crispy. Only open Wednesday through Saturday however. Got to rest some time. read more

Fries have gotten a serious update. Actually crispy now and with a good flavor. Thumbs up!

John and Rebecca serve consistently great Greek food! We love the giro and the salad. We are regulars!

My first time in this establishment since it's opened and the gyro was fantastic! Soft pita filled with a mountain of meat with cucumbers lettuce tomatoes onions and a delicious yogurt sauce. The restaurant itself is very small, not much seating area but go for the food! Prices are very reasonable! Delicious! read more

Excellent gyro, great service. Had the 'extra crispy' fries which are usually called 'batter dipped. Served nice and hot. It is sort of in the middle of nowhere but well worth a visit. Apple pie was delicious. read more

Greek Salad Failure, masquerading as a Fiesta. Lots of lettuce, two (count them, two!) green olives (not kalamata), a pinch of feta (like a pinch of salt), one dolma, about 1/4 artichoke heart just plunked in there (would be better sliced into pieces). There were a few slices of very dry meat (shwarma?) and zero toasty pita. read more

Local made burgers and Greek. Fries and burgers are recommended. Staff friendly. Also has other small baked traits. Small sitting room but I usually get to go. Very reliable and consistent. read more

Wow, absolutely the best Cubano I've ever eaten, and I've eaten quite a few. The pork was off the charts and the bread, oh the bread. Fries were excellent as is, nothing more. That's a tough test to pass. Greek salad with superb dressing. A real winner! read more

Had my first lunch from Carmelita's last week. A GREAT green chili and bacon cheeseburger made fresh when I ordered. Will be back this week to try the Cubano -- I saw someone else having on and it looked marvelous. People were friendly and this is a great addition to the Eldorado community read more

Good local for take out burgers, giros, fries close to home prices are fair good call ahead service

Nice little takeout spot in Eldorado. The gyro is the big hit here. In my view, the burgers aren't quite up to par compared to what they were when they first opened. The owner is very pleasant and the rest of the crew prepare the food. We need to continue to support local businesses here in eldorado read more

I wanted to update my last review. I went back a week later and ordered a couple of entrees and told them about the missing fries from my last order and they couldn't have been nicer and made good on the missing fries. The food is outstanding!!! They are a great addition to Eldorado!! read more

There are a lot of good burger places in Santa Fe, but Carmelita's is one of the best! It recently opened in the Agora shopping center in Eldorado, and is a great addition to the growing number of small businesses in the area. The burgers are delicious, made to order and cooked to your liking. They include fresh tomatoes, lettuce, onions, etc., and come with crispy, homemade fries. I've also tried the Greek salad, and it was amazing- big enough for two people to share. The staff is friendly and the service is fast. read more

Salads are great, sandwiches incredible, sweets are delicious. Fast service for takeout read more

Carmelita's - Kale Salad add chicken - Greek Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

Fantastic service and excellent food. Burgers and gyro we're amazing! Great location. We stopped through on a road trip and had a dog that we took to the courtyard. Perfect stop! read more

Excellent food, reasonable prices, easy parking, and very friendly service. I recommend the Greek feast!

Their Focattia bread is way more greasy than I like my bread, but what's in it is excellent. Some of the things on their menu are items they never actually serve. Aside from that, friendly people and good food. read more

Food is average at best. Owner is ridiculously rude and told my young child she could not buy food there again, because her burger was charred so badly that we returned it twice out of several tries. Gyro meat was crispy, I thought there were peanuts in it. No, it was the meat! The owner told me this was how it was preferred by her customers. That happened once, and the meat was fine on the other occasions. Blah,,,,yuck! Go to Fina or Harry's for a burger instead! Tuna salad, you can make it better at home, trust me* Average is best it will be~ read more

They are still the best. I am so glad they have reopened!!! Eldorado is once again a food hub.

They are back - if you enjoyed Oasis in Eldorado, you will love the new Carmelita's. Good food at a good price. Wonderful salads, savory burrito. Next time I'm having one of the classic gyro's. -- Plus, you cannot beat the location - fast and easy to drive in and pickup. read more

Carmelita's - the menu for the restaurant - Greek Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

See all