Carman's Ice Cream

(14 reviews)

11.6 mi

What a cute place! The staff were very friendly and attentive. There was plenty of covered seating,…read morenotably all outdoors. There is ample parking as well. I enjoyed a tasty peanut butter milkshake on a hot day, while listening to the music playing. I will definitely be back!

Amazing food and Ice cream, Service is great, very pleasant…read moreplace to eat at. I rate this a 10 plus,

Double cheeseburger

See all

Parking lot

Sweet Shack

5.0

(1 review)

5.7 mi

My first first comment! Very cute and very very tiny ice…read morecream shop right under Marco's pizza. It has it's own entrance which is behind Marco's and has it's own parking spaces. I've kept seeing them advertise on Facebook about it but just always forget about it since it's hidden behind the pizza shop. Went in to grab a slice with my daughter yesterday for Father's day while we were in the area and the lady that took our order gave us a coupon token for a $1 off a kids cone so we made sure to go check it out afterwards. They only have 1 round picnic table to sit at but you can also go up and sit in the outdoor seating area of Marco's too. My daughter got a scoop of chocolate and I got a peanut butter shake. I really wish we tried it sooner. We really liked this liitle shop, it's a great add on for Marco's.

See all

Mr G's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

This place is so cute and has a lovely seating area. Even with a line they moved very quick, we…read morealmost passed it up due to the line but they were fast! The ice cream its self was delicious! Our group has soft serve and homemade, both were equally delicious.

6/18/26 I had the Icecream here after my son raved about it. I think he overly hyped it. While it…read morewas good I wasn't blown away by it. The service was friendly and the icecream was good. I got a boring vanilla sundae with chocolate sauce whipped cream and a cherry and a bottle of water. It was over 8$. The place is very cute with soldier statues and a large ring game in the exterior. There are tables and picnic tables outside. It's very relaxing and a beautiful place to enjoy homemade ice-cream. S'coupe de Ville is the best ice-cream I've had, and Leibys is a close second.

Death by chocolate in a waffle bowl.

Front Entrance

See all

Reeser's Soft Ice Cream

Excellent food and ice cream best place for a milkshake except sheetz nice place to go after a long…read moreday at lake pinchot....

Reeser's is the best! Have been coming here for years and will keep coming back. Some of the best…read moreice cream in the area. It's absolutely worth the drive out! Great service and plenty of space for kids to run around. The food AND ice cream menu is huge here! They have specialty flavors different weeks throughout the year, so check the schedule. Highly recommend the Artic Swirl - you can customize it and fill it with whatever you like! Note: The line does get very long, especially after dinner hours, but it's worth the wait and usually goes down fast.

Fresh peach sundae prices

Reeser's Ice Cream.

Small peach sundae

See all

Sarah's Creamery

Oh boy was this good. Additionally they have Penn State Creamery available. Need to make one more…read moretrip while I'm still in town.

Very friendly atmosphere with a wide selection of products and a very helpful and friendly staffread more

Death by Chocolate (small cup)

See all

Selections

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

I stopped to get some ice cream on a recent visit to see my friend who lived in the area. Having…read moregrown up in New England, I'm always on the lookout for a good black raspberry ice cream. Their black raspberry was not as purple as what I'm used to, it was more raspberry colored, and it also tasted more like raspberries then a lot of the ice cream I've tried before. It was so light and refreshing, it almost tasted like a sherbet. It was really yummy! I will definitely make a point to swing by the next time I'm in the area to try some other flavors.

So many choices and they are also good. You really can't go wrong with anything that you get at…read morehandles.

Chocolate chip cookie dough and coffee chocolate chip ice cream in a waffle cone

Strawberry small dish

See all

Mulberry Thrill

4.8

(19 reviews)

18.3 mi

I can't see a better place to leave a review for the coffee shop inside, but I have to share how…read moreimpressed I was with it and the co-working space of The First National Bank! I had tea; my friends had specialty coffees. We had a pastry, muffin, and packaged fruit bar. Service was fast and friendly. And we visited in a relaxed space for a couple of hours. I will come back!

Pretty spot, amazed at their delicious nondairy ice cream: 3 flavors! Service is friendly too…read more Great vibe.

Individuals, small groups, and larger meetings all have comfortable options

The bank lobby. It felt like walking into a museum ... but it is welcoming and available for working in or enjoying a hot drink

See all

Conference room

Gigi'S Ice Cream Bar

As always the foods great and ice cream even better. Love this place! Bring CASH!…read more Make reservations for inside to eat. Outside there is seating. To order ice cream-order outside window.

How can you describe this little ice cream shop in the lost forests of Pennsylvania?…read moreVery inexpensive, huge quantities, amazing quality! A secret that people flock to when it's open 5-9pm each night. Amazing! Wait in line and you'll be blessed with amazing ice creams, No ambiance, this ain't that kind of place.

Sundaes are huge!!! You can get half and still huge. Love it!

Dusty Road Sundae

Updated menu 2024

See all

Bonkey's Ice Cream & Snoballs

What a great find for a delicious summer cold treat. They have tons options from ice cream…read moresnowballs milkshakes etc. really love supporting local businesses and this is a hit. The staff here are so welcoming and friendly. They are fast with the orders. It's a walk up window with some seating. The snowballs are delicious with soooo many flavors. The prices here are still affordable and excellent. Will definitely be back and recommend to anyone.

Unbelievable Ice cream and snowballs, delicious and unique flavors. Serious small town charm. Fresh…read moreWaffle cones made daily... not from a wholesale company. Quick service.

Window

See all

Red Velvet Grasshopper.

Collusion Tap Works

My friend and I were in York looking for a good place to grab a bite. I found this place on Yelp…read moreand we decided to try it. It was a clean, welcoming place with friendly staff. You order at the bar and they give you a buzzer when your food is ready to be picked up at the window. My friend was excited because they had bourbon and burgers, which hit the spot for her. She got a black and bleu burger with a side salad and raved about the burger. I opted for a gyro with fries, and a German pilsner. My sandwich was good, but I thought it needed more tomatoes and onions. The fries had a kick and were a very generous sized portion. If I'm ever in the York area again, I'd definitely stop back in.

Collusion Taproom at the Lititz T-Shirt Factory…read more . $10 wings on Sunday. Went with the bartenders suggestion of the Rei Rei Sauce (Combination of Mango Habanero Sauce, Thai Chili Sauce and a smoky BBQ Sauce as described by the bartender). Apparently they made it for a regular patron, and it was so good, it made it to the menu. . Wings were "naked" decent size and cooked rather crispy. I'm usually a hot and honey guy, so this was a bit more spicy than my norm, but it wasn't burn my butt off hot. Good mix of flavors in that sauce. Look forward to visiting again and trying the hot and honey. Beer list was also extensive and delicious! -- at Collusion Tap Works Lititz.

Chicken quesadilla . It had a really nice portion of meat and was filling and tasty.

Tap menu

Bar area

See all

Liquid Hero Brewing Company

Not only was the beer good so was their food specials. Started off with their Philly egg rolls…read more Love a place that makes food in house vs Cysco frozen. Had the Korean sliders.

I still dream about the schweet ale and tator kegs from here! And the staff was always SO kind…read more 10/10 every time i visited while staying in York!

See all

Pho Bistro

We have had pho bistro about 3-4 times now and the food is great! We've tried a handful of things…read moreand they were all tasty! One thing we were disappointed with was the banh mi sandwich. The sauce was so sweet and overwhelming and they don't have the pate, just slices of pork. Our favorites are A.10, S.6 (they use great quality meat, and for $15 you got a lot of meat in the soup! Worth it), C.6. Service is great but we prefer carrying out bc the location of the restaurant seems unsafe at night time.

I'm always happy to see Asian representation in small towns like York…read more Location: -close to downtown York -parking is street and depending on when you go can be a little challenging -it's a shop on the corner of the street Pho: -a little below average in term of quality, taste, amount of ingredients and size -I ordered a large but felt on the small side -I also order raw beef steak but it was already well done when it came out Mango smoothie -avoid - it is made more powder only and tastes very artificial. Not fresh as it claims on the menu Service -overall ok, but there was literally only 3 tables of people when I was there, I had to flag down the server to pay the bill Probably wouldn't come back do to the cons next time I'm in York

Spoiled tendon that stunk and tasted the way it smelled

See all

Corner entrance off of East Market St.

Maple Donuts

The donuts were amazing. We got a double chocolate, chocolate iced, and a Salted Caramel. All 3…read morewere great. Maple Donuts is one of our top 3 donuts in the Central Penn area! The donut selection choice was very limited. Usually going to the main location they have a ton of variety. Possibly the sale to Private Equity has changed their current amounts and overall products. We did go later in the evening, but that never seemed to effect the amount of Maple Donuts in the past. The main location gives you a nostalgia feel. Its still a great spot to sit down and grab a coffee and a donut. The staff was quiet and not too helpful with explaining what some of their donuts were. We will always stop and grab a donut when in York!

Best donuts in PA since 1946…read morestarted on Maple Street downtown classic donut & coffee spot Serves a light lunch as well Glazed bow ties are the best, along with the fastnachts before LentThe Service is friendly Ambiance is classic Americana

Double Chocolate Cake Donut

Outside!

See all

Carman's Ice Cream - icecream - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Carman's Ice Cream also viewed

Bonkey’s Ice Cream & Snoball’s

5.0

(9 reviews)

The ice cream my friend and I had was super! We both got two scoops and we both had the dark…read morechocolate. Very good but I know where there is better chocolate ice cream in York. My friend loved her mint with chocolate crunches in it and when I tasted it I thought, that's what I get in my next visit! My second scoop was a coffee and chocolate scoop and although I can't remember its name ( maybe mocha something?) it was SUPER! I gave Bonkey's 5 * because the gal was friendly and my ice cream was ready to go even before I'd paid, however, I'd like to knock off a star because they do not let you taste any of the flavors. I think they should. Although ice cream is one of my very best favorite foods in the world, I have come across flavors I don't enjoy. I do think they should allowed to give one or two tastes so that people can know before they buy. I'd prefer to give 4 stars because of this, but, it was delish. So 5 * from me today!

This is the best ice cream in Red Lion and there is no doubt about that. They have a ton of flavors…read moreto choose from and a lot of them are on of a kind. The line can get long on nice days but that's because it is truly the best. The service is good and always quick. They have a nice deck areas to enjoy the treat as well.

Half Pint Creamery - New Oxford

4.5

(30 reviews)

•$$

I've been supporting this business since day 1. I first tried them their first week in business at…read morethe original location in Mcsherrystown/Hanover. They always have unique and original flavors. I've never been disappointed in any flavor I've tried. Very clean on the inside and the staff are always friendly. Love the fact that the owners are hands on and still serve customers from time to time. One of the best local small business stories. Always grab a treat for the pup at home while here.

This is a small family owned business, which is simply outstanding…read more They have such an array of unique flavors along with your staples, such as chocolate, vanilla, etc., etc. Yes, they even have a corn flavored ice cream which taste like buttered corn. Can you imagine that! The staff is always welcoming, very friendly and the inside is absolutely spotless with plenty of seating and I'm sure this goes for all their locations . In their frozen cases, they have frozen dog treats, cakes, ice cream, cakes, and ice cream cookies and so many other items . trust us you'll find something you absolutely love and you'll be hooked on the ice cream.

Bonkey’s

4.3

(28 reviews)

Has happened multiple times, the first few times we let it go but after several times it's getting…read moreold. This is the only Bonkey's location that closes ridiculously earlier than advertised. Closing 30 minutes to an hour early and pitch black every time is unacceptable. Had enough time to DRIVE ALL THE WAY TO THE NEW FREEDOM location and order before they closed. What a joke !!!!!

I like going here when it's a hot day and I love it here service is very friendly The ice cream or…read moresnowcones are very good. and I just love it here

Ripleighs Creamery

(11 reviews)

Food is great service is quick and the price is a bit high would recommend two person that comes byread more

Finally got the chance to check out this ice cream shop located in McSherrystown, PA in a small…read morelittle strip plaza, next to Choice Family Pharmacy and Brothers Pizza. We decided on trying the Wild Thang, Freak Shake and let's just say it was well presented and very unique and a nice size. The chocolate cake that topped it was amazing in itself and the milkshake was in the money. They had a staff of three working and it was just a bit slow but efficient, needs a little refinement, especially with the volume of people waiting in line, it did move along .... Staff was extremely friendly and accommodating. Very unique twisted ice cream flavors, there is such a nice assortment to choice from, they have various shakes, waffle sundaes, all are extremely unique ! This is a really nice family owned business and it's highly recommended to stop in here and get your ice cream fix in. You will enjoy it Side Note: Not sure what food service protocol is in PA, but in our opinion the workers should wear gloves and hair protection, neither being used by staff and it could be a violation since they are reaching across ice cream containers and standing over them ! Also, did not see any Food-Serve Certifications ? * This was the reason of not giving a 5-Star, 3-Star is warranted due to improper food handling

Ben And Scooters

(10 reviews)

If you want a good quality & delicious sweet treat this the place to go!…read more Its family friendly ! It has multiple ice cream options from snowballs to simple soft serve ice cream , so many options to choose from! !

Sugar-free snowball flavors, delicious varied menu. Something for everyone! Just visited for the…read morefirst time recently, will be a steady visitor...

Penny's

(5 reviews)

Carmen and David's was a weekend tradition for my daughter and me. We were crushed when the…read morelocation downtown closed. So imagine how excited we both were when walking through the Park City Mall only to see the C&D stand filled with all the ice cream flavors we know and love. The strawberry, butter pecan, and cherry vanilla have always been my favorites, but really you can't go wrong with any flavors. The prices are reasonable and the staff we've met so far are friendly. The old location frequently had long lines, which is not the case at this location, but even if it were, the ice cream is worth the wait. Go ahead and grab dinner at any of the restaurants in and around the mall, but head here for dessert. You won't be disappointed.

Very cute and cozy ice cream parlor. Irish Cream ice cream was delicious! Definitely worth the stop…read moreof passing through!!

York Street Treat

4.0

(20 reviews)

Nice treats. Local favorite. Great for the whole family…read more Descent price. Picnic tables behind building. Order at the counter.

This place is a To Go ice cream/ sandwich shop . This location has a long standing in the Hanover…read morearea. This place serves breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches in the morning. Service this morning was great and helpful. My order came out in good time. And a major plus here is they do take credit cards.understand this is a walk up to stand. It's not set up for inside dining. And never was to be. Food quality for the price. ... was really good. I easily recommend this place for the setup and for what they offer.

Mr G's Old Fashioned Ice Cream

4.6

(215 reviews)