Capt'n Nemo's makes a good sandwich. Not great, not the best, but good. What I object to is primarily the proportions, not the quality of ingredients. There is too much meat and cheese for this thickness of bread, and not enough vegetables. You need the cool-and-crispies to balance out the warm-and-savories. And most importantly, a bread dense and broad enough to hold it all together. But I still keep them on the list for when I'm in the area and want a sandwich, especially to go. They have most of the usual suspects and some more interesting concoctions on the menu, but you can get them to make pretty much any combination of meats, sauces, and toppings. Surprisingly, this North Shore location has more grit and personality--and less space--than the Lakeview shop. The dudes behind the counter are cool, but inevitably about a third of the customers are dicks. read more

The high flyer. 2xs in 2 days. No regrets. Live your life and I'll live mine. Dat bread tho. Nom nom. read more

Small and cozy. Very personable service. Really old school. One of three locations. Their house special sauce CSS is great. Had the turkey and cheese hot one... Really good sandwich!!!!! The pea soup is also pretty amazing. They give generous tasting so try it and take some home. read more

See all

I started going to Captain Nemo's when I was at New Trier when it opened, and loved it as a student. It had been many years since I had gone and I hoped it would live up to the memory and it did! They still offer you a sample of soup which I was more than happy to accept. The Split Pea Soup was delicious! Another in my group got a full Minestrone and she loved it, said it was more of a vegetable soup but still very good. I studied the menu before I went because I did want to mess up this reunion. I decided to go with The Balboa (the fact it was created by a NT Marketing Class contributed to this) and I was so excited. While I was waiting for my sandwich to toast I chatted with my sandwich maker and he told me he had been with Captain Nemo's since 2000, I learned that the Lakeview location is all take-out and almost all soup, while the Winnetka location is all sandwiches. He then informed me that I was getting the most popular sandwich which I quickly found out why! First off, the sandwich is listed on the counter on a piece of paper, not even on the main menu. The Balboa is Ham, Turkey, Bacon, LTO, Mayo, Balboa Sauce and Captain's Secret Sauce. The Balboa Sauce is spicy flavor with the richness of bacon and the CSS is still so perfect in every way....but messy! I could have done with a 6" but I did the 12" which ended up being lunch the next day. The bread had the right amount of crunch where it was not soft and doughy or hard and crunchy like a Baguette. Captain Nemo's lived up to the memory! Yes, the parking was not ideal but we made it work. The place was clean when I was there and I hope to return soon for another smaller sandwich but try the famous Chili. If you are in the area or need something close to New Trier, give Captain Nemo's a try. read more

Capt'n Nemo's - the front of the restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Winnetka, Illinois

I used to love the seafarer ((tuna) sub at the Capt'n Nemo's on Fullerton in Chicago. I happened to drive by the shop in Wilmette and ordered the same sandwich and there was no comparison. The tuna filling was very skimpy, the bread was over-toasted, and the cheese was Muenster instead of brick (as was the original). These are the areas I would improve to make it a most delicious sandwich. read more

Awesome!! Had the Italian Swiss and it was wonderful! About 10 years ago i taught Physics at Northshore Country Day school down the street. Loved it then, loved it today. Read about the oowners death, so sad. But the sammches live on!!! Great sammich read more

I have never been able to make it to this place before their super early 7pm closing, until today! 6:30pm. Only because I was already in the area. ...Do people in Winnetka all just eat dinner at like 4pm or something, because the place was completely empty at what I thought would be prime dinner time... Their menu seems like they'd be your average sandwiches - toasted bread, deli meats, toppings, italian beef, etc. But oh man, the captain's sauce is so delicious. Totally takes the whole thing to an newer level. The lightly toasted bread was perfect and so was the meat/cheese/bread/toppings ratio. The liverwurst in the conquerer reminded me a lot of elementary school cafeteria food, but somehow in a good nostalgic way. I definitely scarfed that down way too fast. The half-sandwich, cup of soup, and drink combo is a great deal at $7. They are the only place I know where a whole sandwich is literally just two half-sandwiches and twice the price. So mix and match if you're stuck between two choices! But really, the half is an entire sandwich and perfectly filling on its own, especially along with some soup. The split pea was nice and warm and rustic but tasted only okay. Not gonna complain though since the sandwich more than makes up for it. Can't wait to come here again! Definitely a worthy stop if you're in the area. read more

We found this place on a whim coming home from a weekend trip in Chicago. We definitely were not impressed with the decor, but who judges quality of food on restaurant decor... there were quite a few sandwich choices to choose from. However, we were not delighted to find out there was no discount in choosing a whole sandwich. It was the same price as two halves and that's literally what it was: two halves. Why even put a whole sandwich choice up there if the price is the same and they make two separate sandwiches? The sandwich was pretty tasty and we would come back for a visit. Four stars for the quality of the food, but minus a star for atmosphere and friendliness (or lack thereof). Also, we paid more for a small meal for two people than we would have at a sit down restaurant. Too expensive for a sandwich shop. read more

Capt'n Nemo's - Balboa with Provolone - Sandwiches Near Me - Winnetka, Illinois

I fantasize about these subs they're so good. I can't physically drive past this place without stopping inside for a sandwich. The Mexicanne is out of this world and the Italian and Balboa are pretty great as well. Can't recommend this place more and have yet to find another sub shop in Chicago that compares. read more

Capt'n Nemo's - Mexicanne. AMAZING - Sandwiches Near Me - Winnetka, Illinois

In my opinion....LOVE the sandwiches.....Seafarer is the best! However, I was in line today for a pickup and there was a 20-something man also waiting without a mask, as required. Neither employee asked him to mask up, so I was pretty uncomfortable. We are still in a pandemic people. Mask up when required so we can all continue come to our favorite places. read more

The best fast food place in the north shore and definitely the best sandwich I ever had no cap. The northern Italian is the best but the balboa and super cheesy are so gas. This is the place to go in winnetka, 100p I spect this joint read more

THE BEST SUB I'VE EVER HAD IN MY ENTIRE LIFE. I've been eating sandwiches for decades now, and I've never had such a great experience at a sub shop. I was recently talking about good sandwiches in the suburbs with a woman. She told me that she and her husband love to eat at Nemo's in Winnetka. Always open to trying new sandwich places I stopped in at lunchtime and WOW, I was really surprised and overjoyed to eat Nemo's turkey club. Great flavor. Great bite and texture. Great everything about it! This is a sub I'd be proud to give Chef Robert Irvine if we had lunch! I can't tell you how rare it is that I eat something that truly blows me away. Usually the world is full to bursting with horrible chains run by people who must hate food, because they serve such incredibly nasty garbage to the world. I have a saying, if you don't respect yourself, how can you respect your customers. NEMO'S is run by people who have respect and love for what they do, and it shows very beautifully in the quality of their sandwiches. I feel I've won the sandwich lottery discovering this place! What a terrific sub! And the man at the register, he must be the owner, is one the coolest, friendliest dudes I've ever met. THIS is the way you run a sandwich shop! GREAT service. GREAT food. GREAT experience. I'd give 'em more stars if I could lol! Blessings, L.O. read more

One of the best sub places I've ever eaten at. The bread is so tasty, the ingredients are all fresh and the Captains Special Sauce just makes every sandwich. I always go with either the Northern Italian, which has great italian toppings, or the turkey club which i could literally never stop eating. I've only gotten the split pea soup when they offer a sample(which I love about the place) and its just like mama made it. Thick and soooo flavorful. Definitely Legendary with Epic sandwiches!!!!!!!!!! read more

My kids have all grown up with Nemo's since they all went to New Trier in what seems like many moons ago, but I tried it myself for the first time and really enjoyed the turkey with cheese sandwich. It was really tasty with the CSS (Captain's Special Sauce) which is not too sweet or sour, but just right! They use real turkey breast and you can taste the difference. Have the sandwich toasted...umm yummy. read more

I used to walk over here on breaks from finals during high school. There is nothing else within walking distance (that's affordable) so that's a plus. And of course its Capt'n Nemo's so you really can't go wrong with the subs. But, yes, keeping in line with other reviewer's: the place is a bit dingy. Also parking is horrible and it can get really crowded. Its nice to be able to get your Nemo's fix if you are in, around or going through the north burbs. read more

This was a complete and Utter disappointment. I'm not really sure but how can you call yourself a sub sandwich restaurant with the stalest bread I've ever had in my life- never going back It was not edible at all read more

I love Captain Nemo's! I usually visit here for a sandwich and their other quality comfort food. Every single time it is a good and awesome experience for me. Captain Nemo's has the best sandwiches in the whole area of Winnetka. Their sandwiches are phenomenal. It is so delicious, tasty, and unique. All of their food on the menu are freshly made, always up-to-date ingredients, and made to perfection. You must try this place if you are here in this area. It will change the way you think about ordinary sandwiches. This place is so huge, they have so many dining spots inside and outside the place, and their location is very easy to find and near. Very interesting place. They have so many great deals like promos, combos, discounts. This place never disappoints! You all must visit this place and you will know what am I saying about how great this place is. Captain Nemo's Winnetka is so great! They absolutely beat out all of the chains around the area. Highly recommend! Especially to all those people who really loves sandwiches, burgers, and other comfort food. Great place to grab a quick bite. Thank you Captain Nemo's for such a wonderful customer service. Also for giving us an awesome and unforgettable experience. Thank you very much to all of your staff who made the experience much better and happy. Thank you and kudos to all of you! read more

Quite possibly the most amazing Sandwich shop of all time. Every sandwich I, or my family has ever ordered has been a culinary delight. The staff is friendly and gracious, offering free soup samples and a welcoming attitude. They are notable for their soups and their sandwiches, the soups can also be purchased frozen. Personally, I recommend the Turkey Club. Don't forget the secret sauce! read more

Capt'n Nemo's - Sandwiches Near Me - Winnetka, Illinois

I LOVE CAPTNEMOS!! This place is an institution. Best sandwiches.I've been coming here since a kid and it still holds up. Make sure to ask for the secret sauce. read more

I was craving a homemade type specialty sandwich so I decided to check Captain Nemo's out. The outside looked very quaint and cozy - perfect place to chill in a non-corporate restaurant environment. I totally enjoyed my experience. All of the food there is excellent! read more

This place blows every other sandwich place I've been to out of the water. The split pea soup is incredible. Get the free sample while they make your sandwich. Delicious! read more

There is not a better sub shop in Chicago- Jimmy Johns & Potbelly pale by comparison. They've been around a long time, before I moved to Chicago in 1980. There are 3 locations still around I think - Rogers Park, Lakeview on Ashland and Winnetka. Best meats, bread and the captains secret sauce make these subs my favorite. Also, the soups are fantastic. Always busy but worth the short wait in line. read more

I really like Capt'n Nemo's! The storefront is very small and feels like a typical local establishment. I had the combo #3 with the balboa sandwich and split pea soup which came to about $8.50. The sandwich was delicious and very flavorful, and it complemented the pea soup very well. The service was very personable, but I wish there was someone at the front to invite people. I was waiting about three minutes until somebody came out of the kitchen to help me. I definitely rate Nemo's above all the other chain sandwich places in the area, and I will come again soon! read more

It's difficult to find delicious vegetarian sandwiches so the first time I ordered here I thought it would be another bad tasteless sandwich. Best vegetarian sandwich I've ever eaten! Highly recommend! read more

The waiting time was long. I guess there were handful of big orders, but for a person like me who wanted a one half sandwich, 20 minutes wait is ridiculous. However, the barbeque club roll sub was delicious. The BBQ sauce is surprisingly punchy and sweet, while not strongly tasteful. The meat was very juicy and easily bite-able. This place probably had the best sub sandwich I have ever tasted, so far. I definitely will come here again when I'm in Winnetka. read more

I had high hopes for the Italian beef sandwich. It started with learning that a half Italian beef sandwich costs $5. Then because of high beef prices they charge a dollar extra. So to get a whole Italian beef sandwich costs $12. Add a small 1oz bag of chips and a large drink and the total is $16. As for the sandwich the beef didn't taste that good. It was dry and without much flavor. As if they made tons of it one day and freeze it to use in the future. I have had way better sandwiches in the Chicagoland area b At least you get free refills on your drink. read more

Great subs, chilis, soups and Italian beef. read more

Capt'n Nemo's - So much better and such a better value than the chain sub places!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Winnetka, Illinois

The high flyer is like no other sub sandwich on Earth and worth driving from as far away as Des Moines for it. Personally, I only drive 1.5 miles from my house to get the sandwich because I'm in the north shore and work for a living but listen up people who ended up in Iowa get in your car and get ta drivin'. read more

If you take any word away from this review, make it Balboa. Repeat it again and again, so that when you step to the counter, you won't falter. Capt'n Nemo's is a great place. One of my favorite things about them is the subs that they provide for the North Shore Century rest stops, a ride sponsored by the Evanston Bicycle Club every September. They are a community-minded store that runs circles around the chains, and even work with the local high school to allow them to create and market new items in a real-world scenario. The Balboa contains turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato and buffalo sauce on a toasted bun. The bacon is slightly crisp and not thin-cut. They don't provide them to the North Shore Century, but that's okay. I can forgive them. Also, nice brownie and blondies, and they take their soups seriously too. It was one of the student creations that remained popular, and stayed on their menu. Go on in, ask for it by name. read more

I went here for the first time yesterday for lunch. I had a turkey sub and it was amazing. The sauce they put on every sandwich is delicious. "Secret Sauce" sooo good. The staff is super friendly and I got the feeling that it's the type of place where families go and the staff knows every regular's name. That is my favorite kind of place. Their vegetarian chili was also pretty good and everything was reasonably priced. read more

Delicious. I work about a mile away and I can't stop going back for lunch. The bread is great and the sauce on the sandwiches is awesome. I love the split pea soup, too. The guy at the register (who I assume is the owner) is very eccentric and you can tell he truly loves his life. All of the staff is smiley and friendly. I also appreciate their transparency in explaining why there are price changes. My complaints are that 1) there isn't enough seating during busy times and 2) holy cow, during lunch the kids from New Trier form a line out the door and I use way too much of my lunch hour waiting in line. read more

My favorite place to get a sandwich!!!! I love the Balboa and the Turkey Club.

You've not had a sandwich until you have had a captain nemo's sub. Small place with friendly service, quick and lots of variety. My favorite sandwich, the spectacular (liverwurst). I add the captains secret sauce (css) on a per-bite basis. Super high quality ingredients and lots of them. They also have soups. The soups are just as good as the sandwiches. The split pea is probably my favorite as it is as close to home cooking as it gets. Chili also available and guess what, it's great. Can't even compare this to a certain green and yellow competitor or the one that started the whole toasting thing. Although they do offer all the sandwiches toasted per request. Do yourself a favor and stop in for lunch you wont regret it. Parking is usually available right next to the store or on the street just paces from the door. Prices are are affordable and they have meal deals. They do charge a small extra percentage for using a credit card, understandable. read more

This local, hidden gem, is a restaurant that should be known by all. The ecstatic owner, if you get to meet him, is one you will not forget. The decor of the restaurant, as said by the owner, isn't what makes the sub-shop superb. The sandwiches are to-die for. Your sandwich experience is not complete until you have paired one with the fabulous, gluten free, chili. With reasonable prices, each sandwich is crafted with precision and altered to your liking. If you are going to stop by, definitely try out the famous Balboa Sandwich. read more

Capt'n Nemo's - Sandwiches Near Me - Winnetka, Illinois

Overall not a bad sandwich, but it's hard to get past the filth and grime. There are two employees behind the counter, one on a cell phone and the other making sandwiches. The place was empty when I came in on a Saturday afternoon, and every table was dirty and full of left over crumbs and napkins from previous patrons. The floors where disgusting too. Finally, the grime or grease dripping down the walls was simply gross. It made me wonder how dirty the other side (food prep) of the counter might be. I ended up grossing myself out after eating a few bites of the sand which and throwing it out. This place needs a health inspection again. read more

This is a great sandwich and soup shop. Absolutely kills on the chains (subway, jimmy johns, etc...). I've grown up on the split pea soup and, while I may be a little biased, it is easily the best split pea soup I've ever had. The staff is great and always offer a free sample of their daily soups. I also really recommend the minestrone, navy bean and turkey chili... The sandwiches are refreshingly fresh and delishhhhhh... I love the northern italian, turkey club, turkey and cheese, seafare light, and they have a surprisingly great italian beef (most underrated beef in the chicago). the bread is delicious and may be the main reason why captain nemos separates itself from the chains. My personal go to sub is the turkey club... the secret sauce is a great touch. Please dont be turned off by the outside or the out-dated interior, the subs and soups are GREAT! and if you are a italian beef fiend please dont over look nemos... delishhhhhhhhhhhhh read more

First time ever going to capt'n Nemo's and I am not diggin' it. I got a Reuben and the sauerkraut made the bread soggy. My son got s turkey club and the meat was poor quality (both turkey and bacon). We also ordered chili and it was bland. Overall, pretty disappointing. read more

The Admiral is a very good salad. The meat is great, special sauce as dressing, awesome!

Can't say enough about this place. First off, the sandwiches are unbelievable. I know a guy who comes into Nemo's almost every day and gets something different every time. Nemo's subs are that outrageous. Although I don't live in the area anymore, my first stop when I visit is always Nemo's. read more

Worst Ruben ever had. Their food is prepackaged in freezer .......then microwaved for 60 seconds......Bread to dressing was all in the microwave. I don't even use a microwave at home. I HATE when restaurants microwave your food. The famous soup ......sucked. It was very chalky. Probably reheated many times.....I'll bet friends of biz rated this place favorably or just high school fools that like microwaved food. ...Never again, blacklisted read more