If you come to this restaurant, you have to go all out and order the lobster. You can taste the time and preparation that went into it. They serve the biggest tails which translates to bigger flavors. The butter that is under the lobster has amazing flavors. It is served in a way for easy consumption. The miso salmon is recommended for the younger pallet, however the grouper with hollandaise was not the combination for me. The tanks in the place were beautiful to see. The servers were helpful. read more

See all

The ambience is old-school 1970s, in a fun way. The service was excellent, very attentive. High quality seafood prepared in traditional ways that did not fit the price point. We don't recommend the coleslaw -- raw onions and heavy mayo. But, save room for delicious dessert options :) read more

Excellent food and service. Seafood and fish are fresh and delicious. Prices are moderate. This is an institution that has not betrayed its customers in Miami. That is why it continues to be so popular and successful. Congratulations! read more

There are maybe a handful of places left in south Miami and Kendall from the "old days" in Miami which for me is the late 70s and early 80s. Kind of pre Miami vice if you will. This is one of those few places still standing the harkens back to Miami of old. It is a simple old school fish house. The bar is always full of locals - Kiley if you took a vote it would be a parrot head convention. It's just what it is a simple place to get a piece of fish that's locally owned and been there forever. The food is fine. They have narrowed the menu a bit I think. But it's one of those places that should be protected at all costs for the Miami that is almost extinct. read more

Well, Captains Tavern needs a facelift. I find it too dark and dated. It's a pity because service is good and the food is good also. I usually order lobster which is offered in 3-4 styles. I just like it with lemon and butter but my friends have ordered thermidor and said it was very good. read more

I took my father here for his birthday day. Made reservations 4hrs prior to arrival time. I even called 2hrs ahead of time to confirm reservation, when we got there our table wasn't ready. Service was horrible from beginning to end. The decor is this place is outdated and falling apart. They definitely need to do some maintenance. The food lack flavor, every single thing was bland. The dinner rolls were so hard you couldn't even eat it. The lobster was bland and the fish was bland and overly fried. $600 dinner and we left still hungry. Our waiter was an older gentleman that was slow and wasn't very knowledgeable when it came to their wine list. Asked for recommendations and got a blank stare. read more

Captains Tavern - Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Miami, Florida

See all

As you walk in through the front doors at Captains Tavern, you're immediately transported back to the 1970s. The decor in here looks like it's probably the same as the day they opened, and I love that about it! As you walked to your table, you can't help to feel the awesome family restaurant vibe. The place is always packed, and it's definitely a neighborhood restaurant, as you often see regulars greeting each other. The staff is friendly and the service is excellent. The food is always perfect. I've never been disappointed with anything I've had. I love their seafood medley, the lobster bisque is top notch .... and my favorite dessert is the banana cream pie!! read more

Captains Tavern - Banana cream pie .... GET IT!!! - Seafood Near Me - Miami, Florida

I have driven by this place for years but never dined there till today. Good to know I wasn't missing out on anything as the food was terrible . It was packed with older people and the only reason I can think of is because the pricing is affordable. We tried the macadamia crusted fish and the dijon fish which we were told are 2 of there most popular dishes. Both were flavorless and I was expecting a chunky crunchy macadamia encrusted fish and instead I got a sad looking filet that appeared breaded and fried. The dijon fish was horrible. I have cooked delicious Dijon fish so I was shocked that a seafood restaurant made this flavorless, and very fishy tasting dish. Even the presentation was sad, and the fish looked unappetizing. We ordered asparagus that was basically raw and undercooked. Baked potato was dry and overcooked and served in aluminum foil as if this was a mess hall. They couldn't be bothered to cut it open and put the butter and sour cream in it. No pride in anything they serve here and it shows. The only good thing I had was the coleslaw. I would never return here and laughed out loud at reviews saying this is the best seafood. It's Florida, there are endless fresh seafood options and so many way better than this place. Do yourself a favor & skip this place! read more

This place has been in business for a very long time and three generations of my family have eaten here. Nicolas took amazing care of us the entire time we were here. We got fried calamari and escargot to start and both were amazing. The main lobster, snow crab, and pan seared grouper. Everything was phenomenal I cannot recommend it enough!! read more

Food was so good and fresh. I ordered the 2 pound lobster. My friend took me out for my birthday. It comes with salad or Cole slaw and yellow rice or baked potato. I had the Cole slaw and the baked potato. I had also lychee martini very nice and the escargot it was very tasty. For dessert I had the bread pudding with rum. Very good. This place I give it 5 starts is very much worth it. The service was on point. Definitely, will come back. read more

Captains Tavern - 2 pound lobster - Seafood Near Me - Miami, Florida

Last time was very disappointed. Both entries were not as good as previous occasions. The waiter seems to be in a hurry to brush us out. Maybe the official chef was off that day. read more

A local legend, Captains tavern is delicious- beautifully decorated & a journey back in time. This restaurant feels like stepping into the nautical 70's .. decor is upscale but cozy & service is nothing short of five star You can't go wrong but the crab cake appetizers are worth a second order! Fluffy and decadent paired with their own secret sauce myself and my dinner date of the evening recommend you pair these crab cakes with a seafood pasta! Although all their dishes are scrumptious, the seafood pasta is creamy, fresh & filling! If you're not into a fishy fish, ask for the pasta you won't be disappointed. Cocktails are also quite popular and well poured. This is simply a no brainer review and restaurant- you want amazing sit down sea food? Get out of the sun, off your feet and come back in time to captains tavern where upscale food meets nautical yacht vibes read more

On Saturday, I decided to treat my family to stone crabs and placed an order for five. I spent $355 on large-sized stone crab claws, along with mustard and cocktail sauces. We enjoyed the crabs earlier this afternoon while celebrating my wife's birthday. However, I was deeply disappointed to discover that many of the claws were not large, as advertised, but small. As you know, large-sized claws come at a premium price, while smaller ones are significantly cheaper (refer to the attached picture). To make matters worse, the claws were not pre-cut for easy consumption. Instead, they mixed claws of various sizes, left them uncut, and carelessly packed them into a plastic bag--all without informing us. This experience has left me frustrated, and I will never purchase from Captain's Tavern again. read more

Captains Tavern - Seafood Near Me - Miami, Florida

Been excited to come to this traditional Miami restaurant. The Hostess, Claudia, was awesome to our group of 7. Our server, Shianne did a good job with our big group. The food was fine; Escargots, Crab-cakes, Stuffed Mushrooms and Raw Oysters are all good. The cocktails are on the weak side; had to ask for Aperol Spritz to have more Aperol and Server made sure Bartender improved the 2nd round. Wine by glass was a good value @$6. The lobsters (stuffed and tail) were fine. The FL Lobster tail @$48 is not a good value and a bit overcooked/dry. The fishes; Branzino and Snapper were fine, as well as Cajun Scallops. Nice but expensive desserts and good Espressos. The group was happy. read more

Great improvement over the past several years. Great staff and the food is truly the best seafood in town.

Had such a lovely birthday dinner here. Melanie was our server and was absolutely pleasant and patient with us. I love how this restaurant has been around forever but the service and food remain great. Service started with drink orders and complimentary hot bread and butter. Appetizers we started off with the conch fritters that were tender and tasty. Went perfect with that Dijon honey mustard sauce. Next was the new England clam chowder that was not to thick but had the perfect consistency. I just wanted a simple lobster dinner and ordered my 2 pound steamed happiness. Alongside I chose a house salad with garlic dressing (loved this dressing) and sautéed spinach (came with mushrooms). I devoured this with no shame. Parents had the sea bass (with requested lemon caper sauce) and a side of fettuccine alfredo. The alfredo was extremely rich and filling. Other dish were scallops (lemon caper atop) and sweet potato fries. Dish was very light yet tasty. For dessert I wasn't sharing so I had my birthday slice of key lime pie and enjoyed every bite. Perfect tang and sweetness here. Mom had the bread pudding. She closed her eyes upon each bite. I had to try and the feeling is so mutual. Next time I think we'll start with dessert first because omg it was heavenly! Thx for a great birthday dinner and the singing of my non-sharing key lime treat..lol read more

See all

I'm an old guy but it seems like this place was here before I was born. Classic is the word I would use to describe this place The freshest quality seafood, a huge list of species cooked anyway you desire. The service is a 10 plus the attention to detail is always there. Old school, you millennials wouldn't appreciate a place like this - dark wood aquariums classic cocktails. Thursdays is lobster night. Go see Mark in the bar. read more

See all

Amazing place. The staff and menu items are phenomenal. Go have a bottle of Justin isosceles, order some of their really good oysters, then get Hog snapper macadamia which is my favorite and finish off with banana cream pie. Ask for Nico, you'll love his service. read more

Food was delicious and service was excellent. We went to celebrate my sister's birthday. The place is still the same as far as quality of the food and the service. We highly recommend the fresh seafood. The portions were plentiful- we had salmon and sea bass, baked Potato delicious, and the key lime pie and brûlée. We went early so we didn't have to stand in line. The only disappointment was that they had sold out of the banana cream pie! read more

My favorite seafood market in Miami, Ft Lauderdale. Stuffed shrimp and stuffed lobster to die for. The restaurant is also phenomenal. I have visited this place for 30 years read more

Service wasn't so great, but our server was very nice. Stone crabs were a bit dry. Ambiance takes one back to the 70s. We know people who used to go here all the time, but not so much anymore. Don't think we will be back. read more

Casual locals only spot. On any given night you'll find the place packed with families and retirees getting their seafood fix. During stone crab season it's one of the best values in town. read more

Amazing service. Ambiance can't be beat. Old school nostalgia. Always lovely to go there

I was shocked to see that this place had an average rating of 3.5. I've lived so close to this restaurant and this is my first time here. The interior is absolutely amazing. It transported me back in time to my younger years. I'm not a seafood fan but the family is so I'll take one for the team. The restaurant did not smell like a fish house. The waiter (Anthony) was absolutely great. He was very honest and took his time explaining all the dishes and their accompanying sides. We ordered Churrasco, Trout, Lobster & Oysters. All the food was fresh, delicious and large serving size. We loved the atmosphere and decor. We have to come back for crab season. Well done Captains Tavern!!!! We'll definable be back. read more

See all

got sick from food last night. Never happened before. Let them know. Chuck Ruffner, Miami

Best seafood in town. Great ambiance and an old time seafood restaurant experience. Been coming since the late 70's for the Tuesday night lobster special and always to treat guests from out of town. No place like this left in Miami! Best seafood anywhere! read more

Hello everyone and I really hope this review finds you all doing ver well. So you are thinking about checking out Captains Tavern right? Well all I have to say is great choice! Captains Tavern has been a seafood staple in the South Florida area for many years. They are located in a sort of hidden strip mall right off of US1; however, there is plenty of parking available and very easy to get in as well from both South and North directions. They have a variety of seafood choices covering shellfish, all sort of fish items, raw bar and everything in between. That said though, if you love Oysters well then they have a wide selection in including Bluepoints which are my personal northeasterly favorites. We have been coming here for years and they have never disappointed on either the food or the service. They do tend to get busy so you may want to try them early but the wait is never very long from what I can tell. Friday and Saturday's tend to be pretty busy but again, well worth the trip and the time if you ask me. Ambiance is pretty laid back and the place does have a 80's vibe / decor but hey it works and is actually pretty interesting. Service will not be a problem either as they are very attentive and will provide any recommendations if you are new to the menu as well. Freshness of the seafood is awesome and really this is where the rubber hits the road in my humble opinion. So if you find yourself in the mood for some seafood and happen to be in the Dadeland Mall or The Falls area you may want to give them a shot. Enjoy and Bon Appétit! read more

We went for Valentine's Day, yesterday. Service was kind and fast. Food was delicious and well priced. It would be great if they had music. The place can use some updating but I highly recommend it. read more

Great seafood the service was awesome have been going there for years all of their seafood is fresh

W O W. This place a family favorite and one that I've visited several times over 10 years and for my parents for the last 39 YEARS! The owner and truly made this an awesome destination with an amazing assortment of surf and turf that is both visually arresting and delectable. The Snapper over coconut rice was superb as were the oysters. Every plate in our 6 person party left their plates bare - no way of making a wrong choice. Now the desserts truly top things off. I highly recommend the Chocolate Mousse which is served on limited occasions but is a must do for chocolate lovers. You won't be disappointed! Bon appétit! read more

Have 't been to Captains Tavern in years but stopped by for a cocktail or two to sit out traffic. Got in just after opening, there were the local likkur lovers at the bar already. Interior hasn't change at all since my last visit 10 years ago but clean old school '50s. Ordered cocktails which were very good, menu wasn't too bad, prices were up a bit to be expected. Ordered Curry Shrimp & Scallops, Cajun Scallops which lacked enough spice but tasty. Portions weren't too large.Dining room eventually began to fill with regulars, very busy. Service was still good no complaints, our server Christina great, made sure we had refills, etc. Even has sushi now. Still a good neighborhood place for dinner, drinks, won't break the bank. read more

The food, as usual was excellent. The appetizers, main courses and dessert were all out of this world. The service even better. Kevin took really good care of us 4. We sat at the bar area, where the ambiance was exceptional. The couple from California that came with us said that, if they have a place like this where they live, they would go 2 to 3 times a week. Kudos to the Chef/Owner and to Dean the bartender. read more

We enjoyed a savory dinner with the best server, Amanda. She was attentive and through throughout our meal. She displays a very friendly and positive demeanor. She was very knowledgeable about the menu and gave great recommendations. if you come to Captains Tavern, ask for Amanda, and you will not be disappointed. read more

Being going there for years . Menú has changed . Loved their lightly breaded steamer Clams etc but no longer on menu . Wish they'd open for lunch again . We miss Bill read more

Went here with a couple of friends on a Saturday evening. My friend's family has been coming here for years. When you go inside, you feel like you stepped back in time to a cozy old-fashioned seafood restaurant, circa 1970's or 1980's. I liked it. I ordered grilled branzino. It came with a choice of baked potato, french-fries, or rice. This was in addition to either coleslaw or salad. Many of the seafood entrees were around $30. I loved my meal. It was delicious. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is the server. He seemed to be newish, and I asked if I could get a substitution for one of the sides. He said he doesn't think so, but will check. He just delivered the meal with the original side and no response. So, would I come here again? Heck yeah! read more

See all

Amazing selection of fresh seafood, and a very romantic ambience in the dining room taking you back to a better time. They are very attentive and the service was excellent from our server. Definitely coming back very soon. read more

Ok so my mom worked here many many years ago and also told me how great it was. 10 years later I went and she was so right. Everything was so yummy. Service was exceptional. I wish I knew the servers name I don't remember her mentioning her name but she was great. By great I mean we had a toddler with us and she so accommodating. All I remember is she had a necklace with a P on it and I believe a nose piercing. Anyways she was great. Food, now food was delicious. Literally from The complementary bread to the margarita to the crab cake to the stuffed shrimp to my son's sundae. Just great all around. You must visit. And the vibe is great too. It's a vintage fish house with great food and an amazing staff. read more

Captains Tavern - Seafood Near Me - Miami, Florida

We live in Dunedin, Fl and always make a point to have dinner at Captains Tavern. tonight was extremely disappointing. we ordered the macadamian yellowtail. the fish fillet was pretty much the bloodline of the fish. (the fish scrap). we returned the fish and asked for a soup. the restaurant also seemed a little slow for a Saturday. we paid our bill. my husband as a courtsey asked for the manager. the manager express little to no acknowledgement and euro customer service. hate to say it but this landmark of Miami's top fish restaurants might be going down. read more

This is old Florida! Like taking a step back in time and it is amazing!! The food is exceptional and fresh. The drinks are on point! full bar! read more

See all

If you're looking for a laid back, old school spot with excellent service, a throwback ambiance, and awesome dishes. Check this place out ASAP! Been several times and it never disappoints. read more