Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Captain Cookie

    4.2 (46 reviews)
    Open • 10:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Captain Cookie Takeout or Delivery

    Captain Cookie Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Captain Cookie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Nicole L.

    A tasty treat located in Transfer food hall with ice cream sandwiches, ice cream, cookies and edible cookie dough! Great for a sweet treat after trying lunch/dinner from another restaurant in the food hall. We tried the vanilla ice cream and an ice cream cookie sandwich with a chocolate chip cookie and peanut butter cookie with butter pecan ice cream, the flavors of ice cream and cookies were all very mild. The worker there let us know the cookies were fresh and needed more time to cool for a sandwich, so that was very helpful!

    two cookies and a soda
    Quiana H.

    First time trying the cookies here and they were just ok. I got a chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, and double chocolate. The chocolate chip tastes like raisins and was a little salty The snickerdoodle was decent - not too sweet and not bad at all The double chocolate was recommended by the cashier and tastes like a chocolate brown but was very good! Unlike insomnia cookies these aren't hot but all in all worth a try!!

    Ashleigh F.

    Captain Cookie is located in the Transfer company food hall with multiple other businesses. They offer edible cookie dough, baked cookies and other treats. I ordered a half dozen cookies for sharing. I chose the oatmeal and chocolate chip cookies. Chocolate chip cookies are typically my favorite cookies but I really enjoyed the oatmeal cookies at this business. All of the cookies were soft and chewy even days later. I will def be back to try more flavors.

    Valentine's Duo
    Dani N.

    Located inside the Transfer Co Food Hall, at the front and to your left, Captain Cookie is exactly what you'd think it would be. They have fresh baked cookies in all the common flavors, sold individually or in price bundles. A popular option is an ice cream sandwich where they take two of the somewhat large cookies of your choosing and stuff a generous amount of house ice cream in the middle. Because the portions were so generous I decided to just get one cookie with a scoop of ice cream which came out to a little over $5. So worth it! I got the valentine's day pink funfetti cookie with, of course staying i on theme, strawberry ice cream. It was everything I wanted it to be and more. I had just had a dank burrito from next door and could only get about half way through the mound of ice cream, so i'd recommend sharing with a friend if given the chance. I love cookies. And i love common cookie flavors. Sometimes you don't need to reinvent the wheel when it's just that good. I appreciate this business and i appreciate their affordable pricing. I also appreciate how freaking kind the guy behind the counter was. If everyone was that nice the world would be full of a lot happier people. I'm very thankful for the great Captain Cookie experience and would come back again for dessert if/when in the area.

    Choco chip + vanilla ice cream sandwich
    Mike B.

    Raleigh's 2nd food hall. Smaller in size that its' cross town competitor but the same trendy, hipster vibe. As the name infers, it's an old warehouse building, refitted in modern industrial chic.  Plenty of seating at bench tables inside plus an outdoor patio.  On-street parking was easy to find. Not too crowded on this Sunday afternoon. For dessert we slid over to Captain Cookie and the Milk Man amd grabbed a scrumptuous ice cream sandwich.  A big scoop of vanilla ice cream in between 2 fresh baked chocolate chip cookies.  Creamy rich ice cream, fresh soft cookies. Worth every calorie! Plenty of other things to try, so will be back!

    Jackie H.

    Can never go wrong with an ice cream sandwich! Made a day trip to Raleigh and checked this space out inside Transfer food hall. I love that they offer different types of cookies with different types of ice cream so you really can customize it to whatever you want. The staff there was friendly but seemed like they were a little overwhelmed when the line got long. Will definitely stop by again when in Raleigh.

    Ice cream sandwich
    Kristen C.

    We decided to get a dessert after dinner at Transfer Co. Captain Cookie was the logical choice. The fun about this place is that you get to pick not one but two different cookies, and then you get to pick an ice cream of your choice in between. There are about 7 different cookies you can choose from and about as many ice cream flavors to pick from. I chose the snickerdoodle and chocolate chip cookies then put cupcake batter ice cream in the middle. The overall product was overwhelmingly sweet, but that's to be expected given the flavors we picked out. The service was friendly and the portions were generous. However, the price still feels a little bit high for a dessert.

    Ice cream sandwich
    Kierstyn M.

    Perfectly delicious ice cream sandwich! I ordered and ice cream sandwich and this wonderful woman loaded me up! She put that first scoop of ice cream on the cookie and I was thinking "looking good!" Then the second scoop was put on it. I was excited! Then she went for a third scoop, I about died. She doesn't hold back on the ice cream. Then, she knows her clients well "you need a spoon?" Well, I didn't think I did but looking at this monstrous ice cream sandwich, I probably need one. She was right. I needed that spoon. That ice cream sandwich was pure perfection. I mean, you can't go wrong building you're own ice cream sandwich. Just saying. Pure perfection.

    Cookies & Cream w/Chocolate Chip Cookies
    Lori R.

    This ice cream and cookie place sure made the guys happy! Husband said the ice cream was especially good. Cookies & Cream in between a couple good-size chocolate chip cookies. Bro came back with not one but two scoops of butter pecan in a cone and said it was very good. Gotta love having this place in Transfer Co. Food Hall!

    Chocolate Chip Cookie - Peanut Butter Cookie combo with cookies and cream ice cream
    Logan L.

    Definitely an experience if you have a sweet tooth and love super huge, soft cookies! These were so good but they're huge so plan on saving some for later!

    Roger K.

    We are all entitled to our own opinions, right? Well here's mine: Parking: 4 Location: 5 Decor/ambiance: 5 Customer Service: 5 So excited to see a cookie shop on this end of Downtown Raleigh! Captain Cookie (CC) rocks! We stopped by one late Saturday night and I was surprise that they were still open. They are located inside of the Transfer Food Hall. The marketing and decor is super eye catchy so I was drawn. My wife and I grabbed two cookies to go. We skipped the ice cream because it was so cold outdoors. The cookies we purchased were amazing! I grabbed a snicker-doodle and a red velvet. The snicker-doodle was my fav. I spoke with one of the reps working the counter asking him what was his fav. He confirmed that his fav was the chocolate chip and Snicker-doodle. There was a young lady working that night as well, she stated that the Double chocolate chip was her favorite. The size of the cookie was great for the price. The service was perfect and the ambiance was cool. Parking isn't that big of a deal and the Transfer Co. is super cool.

    Holly K.

    Pretty delicious! I love that they bake all their cookies from scratch. They also have a great selection of cookies, I think they had at least eight different options from chocolate chip to funfetti. They live up to their Captain Cookie name. My husband went with an oatmeal raisin cookie and really enjoyed it just as is. I went with a cookie sandwich of snickerdoodle cookie, funfetti cookie, and strawberry ice cream. It was pretty delicious! This is going to sound odd but I wish the ice cream wasn't as cold. Since it was so cold/hard when you bit into it the ice cream just kind of squished out of the cookies and didn't stay in the sandwich. Most people in front of me just ordered ice cream in cones so I imagine that is why they keep their ice cream at such a sturdy temp. I'll be back, but might just stick with cookies and milk next time.

    See all

    Photo of Josh W.
    0
    143
    32

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Captain Cookie

    You might also consider

    Fresh Local Ice Cream

    Fresh Local Ice Cream

    4.4(395 reviews)
    6.7 mi
    •$$

    My family loves Fresh. Their locally made ice cream is fantastic with a lot of great flavors to…read morechoose from. Tonight I went with Carolina Crunch which has their Honey Salted Caramel ice cream mixed with Heath bars and Butterfinger. They use a lot of local ingredients here and this ice cream was made with honey from Mike's Bees in Raleigh. My wife had the banana pudding ice cream and it was excellent as well. You really can't go wrong with any of the flavors here. Very creamy with a silky texture. This is better than the vast majority of places you'll go to for ice cream. Service was very friendly and patient as my family practically sampled every flavor on the menu. Lots of outdoor seating here which was perfect on a comfortable, moderately cool summer night. Fresh is one of the best ice cream places in the Triangle area. Definitely Stevie K Certified Legit!

    This is my favorite place to get ice cream in North Carolina! It's so delicious. They are always…read morevery nice and patient. Whenever I have questions about the flavors they always give detailed explanations and don't rush to move onto the next person. My favorite flavor is the banana pudding. I've been to this location more than I can count JUST for the banana pudding ice cream. The other flavors are just as good. The picture attached is the bananas foster and the brookie. So good on a hot day! There's lots of outdoor seating and the bathroom is convenient if needed.

    Photos
    Fresh Local Ice Cream - Butter Pecan beauty taken by my wonderful photographer (sis)

    Butter Pecan beauty taken by my wonderful photographer (sis)

    Fresh Local Ice Cream - Waffle cone cookies and cream ice cream

    Waffle cone cookies and cream ice cream

    Fresh Local Ice Cream - Storefront

    See all

    Storefront

    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams - Dairy free ice cream

    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

    4.1(50 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    •$

    A fantastic location of probably my favorite ice cream chain. Located in Cameron Village, this…read morelittle shop offers a ongst the best ice cream one can get. While the shop itself is small -- offering no indoor seating, though there are a couple small tables outside (and you can always just walk around in Cameron village -- the ice cream is expansive in both options and the flavor it packs. With a mix of classics and more unique flavor options, I have never once tried an option I did not truly enjoy, if anything they have often been amongst the best of that flavor I have even ever had. The ice cream is just so good, the texture, creaminess, and flavor profiles all incredibly well balanced. The shop itself is clean, well decorated, and inviting with a semblance to what you'd expect and desire from a classic ice cream shop. They even pay attention to the details, like using these fun metal spoons for tasting (highly suggested) instead of the typical flimsy plastic or wooden ones common in other shops, which are available for purchase. The staff was friendly, service was efficient. There is also some cool merch which is fun if you're into that stuff. Personally, I am not the biggest fan of their naming scheme for the options, instead of just having a single, double, or more straightforward menu options, they have names like "standard" which is actually 2 "half scoops" (quotes cause they're just small scoops), and then a single which is a single full scoop, or a trio which is 3 half scoops not full scoops, just overall a tad confusing and not straightforward in how much ice cream you are actually getting, though it does allow one to get multiple flavors more easily I guess? The prices are definitely leaning on the higher side, especially for pints, but I feel that is to be expected of "gourmet" ice cream shops, especially nowadays. Overall, I highly recommend for any and all ice cream lvoers, and will absolutely be returning myself.

    I always love Jeni ice cream so when I am down South, I am all for it! I got the eggnog ice cream…read morewith waffle cone. The staff was supper accommodative! Busy place with tables inside and outside of the place!!

    Photos
    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams - Brambleberry Crisp in a cone

    Brambleberry Crisp in a cone

    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
    Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

    See all

    Bittersweet - Bubbles and cupcake special

    Bittersweet

    4.4(484 reviews)
    0.4 mi•Fayetteville Street
    •$$

    What a fabulous dessert shop! Perfect place to grab an after dinner cocktail and dessert and…read moreconveniently located near St Roch Oyster Bar which is where we had dinner. Service was top notch with friendly folks greeting you the moment you enter the doors. Our bartender was so sweet and so welcoming. Had me a $10 Paloma cocktail that was just right and went to town on dessert. Everything was just delicious. Fresh made whip cream, perfectly balanced sweetness with the desserts and cute atmosphere. Loved my first time here and it won't be my last!

    Bittersweet has amazing desserts and drinks. I've been several times and each time I enjoy what…read moreI've had. A solid go-to is their s'mores sundae which is sooo good! The chocolate brownie is thick and rich, but not too sweet, and the marshmallow cream is divine, especially with the ice cream. A lot of their drinks and gin based, which I'm not the biggest fan of, but I always find something I can enjoy. The service is great and relatively quick, and everyone I've met there is kind and willing to help. The inside is a bit small, so smaller crowds are better and it does tend to get crowded later in the evening and on weekends. The outside street sitting area is nice too and hopefully will be fully fixed soon. Overall a great places to stop for drinks and desserts after a nice meal! And the menu rotates seasonally so you'll always have the chance to try something new!

    Photos
    Bittersweet - Chai espresso martini

    Chai espresso martini

    Bittersweet - Derby Pie and Gin n Tonic

    Derby Pie and Gin n Tonic

    Bittersweet - Pecan pie

    See all

    Pecan pie

    Captain Cookie - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...