Sir Cricket's is great for what it tries to be. I think that some of the people who haven't liked…read moreit were just expecting something different. It is an extremely casual counter service restaurant that focuses mostly on fried seafood. They also serve other local staples like clam chowder and a lobster roll that I did not try but is very reasonably priced. The service is good and I was surprised (it was actually pretty cool) to hear some good reggaeton from the early 2000s be the music of choice. If you're from Miami you know what I mean. The fish n chips is very good. Of course, it's on the heavy side (you habe to be okay with that) but tastes great. The fisherman's platter is rather large and the fried scallops are particularly delicious.

Lobster Roll was about half the size of the photos & there was shell still on the meat…read more The the coleslaw does not taste homemade at all. Fries were good; hence, the twi stars. Casual ambience, small interior. No table service. Disappointing after all the hype; I'm hoping this was just an 'off day'. I will give them a chance to redeem a negative review, (without them knowing, of course), when I stop into the fantastic Bird store next door, and post an update thereafter.

This seafood joint that displays as a fast food spot impressed me, not just with the delicious…read morelobster roll but the amazing onion rings. I haven't seen thin, crispy onion rings in a minute and they paired so well with the roll. You can definitely sit and eat here as well but it's the perfect establishment for a quick grab and go meal

The burger was cooked very well, nice sear. The flavor of beef really comes through and isn't…read moremasked by anything. The got dog was also really good and had a good sear. The fried were good but in my opinion the onion rings are without a doubt the way to go. Their onion rings with some ketchup or dipped in their burger sauce is close to onion ring experience perfection. We also had a chocolate shake which was very good. It's not pictured because we decided to get it as we were leaving. The chocolate flavor was bold and it didn't come from a low quality syrup. Eating this outside made it that much better! This place gets a 4 only because it's not a top 3 burger or overall experience I have had at places similar to this. The quality and freshness is very good though!

Similar food but a little more upscale than a typical fried seafood shack on Cape Cod…read more The food at Cooke's hasn't changed much in the past 30 years. They have the typical fried seafood players and lobster rolls that you would find elsewhere. They do have a large air conditionied dining room (you order at a cou ter and they bring your food to you). They also serve beer and wine

It was very easy to call in my order for fish platter. I went to pick it up and was eating it as…read moresoon as I got in the car. The order was right on time! The fish was delicious, the fries are tasty but when they get covered by the fried fish pieces, then the fries aren't crisp anymore. - That happens at most take out places.

Far and away the best sandwiches on the Cape. Not just saying that. Small place, but worth it to…read morestop and try Basco grill. Hot sandwiches and chicken sandwiches are standouts.

Wow -- SO delish, and I am PICKY!…read more First, the coleslaw was rockin' good! Fresh, flavorful, and made in-house. This is NOT that super-sweet coleslaw drowning in mayo. It was just a tad creamy with a touch of vinegar and the perfect amount of seasoning. Seriously, so good! I had the cold lobster roll and it was soooo darn delicious. My friends had the warm lobster roll and loved theirs too. Both had a really good amount of lobster -- they definitely didn't skimp! It's a small, casual café with simple café tables. Nothing fancy inside, but it was clean. You order at the counter and everything is served casually -- no glass dishes or anything like that. Probably not where I'd pick for a fancy date night, but if you're looking for a GREAT lobster roll and really good food, absolutely worth it! Lobster roll was something like $34 I'd definitely come back.

Sitting by the Water is rare in Orleans, this place is the best!…read moreFood is great. It is a treasure for sure.

Excellent food, service and atmosphere! All 9 people in our party were very happy and satisfied…read morewith the appetizers and their respective meals.

Outstanding pizza Excellent service…read moreHands on owner, customer focused Good price point!

Best burger weve ever had! And get the wings! And oh my gosh the stuffed dates were incredible!…read moreEveryones pizza looked good so I ordered the margarita pizza - not prepared the way Im used to so maybe try another. But the crust was good. Ron at the bar was so great, attentive and funny! He made a great cocktail too. Very comfy bar atmosphere. Cant wait to go back!

Ordered the Scallop roll…read moreCup of clam chowder Burrata salad with Watermelon Two cheeseburgers Large side of fries - All the food was great, portions solid and prices are very reasonable- do something for yourself- order from Cobie's

This little hole-in-the-wall seafood and ice cream spot feels so homey, and according to the menu,…read moreit's been around since 1948--wow! I love the variety of options here--you can get everything from lobster rolls to pizza to ice cream. I ordered the lobster roll with corn salad and it was delicious. We also tried the clam chowder bowl, and it was sooo good. I really liked the little sauce bar and that it's all outdoor seating. It was a bit tough because of the heat and humidity, but overall it was still a great experience.

Fish, lobster and other seafood is always fresh! Good selection of other products also. I always…read moreorder my take out cooked lobster from here !

If I could give zero stars I would. Last day of vacation, wanted to maximize time on the beach…read more Thought this place closed at 7, arrived at 5:55, they close at 6. I get it, it's Friday, every one wants to go home. But 6 is 6, not 5:55 and how long does it take to weigh out 1/2lb of scallops? Disappointing, because the guy that sprang to lock the door as I had my hand on the door was delightful the other day.

We had a nice dinner at Caroline's. It's a beautiful restaurant inside and out. The ambiance…read moreoutside is really nice despite being next to rt 6. You pretty much forget that it's there. Service was very friendly. The food came out incredibly quickly. Almost too quickly. I wouldn't have minded waiting a little bit to have more time to enjoy my wine and the ambiance. There was bread service which I enjoyed because a lot of restaurants have stopped offering bread. We had a beet and arugula salad to start which was delicious. For dinner I had the scallop dish with a seafood demi glacé and mushrooms. It was very rich with umami and paired well with the sweetness of the scallops. My husband had the grilled swordfish which was good, but not very special. The piece of fish was a little thin and slightly overcooked. The buttery caper sauce was good . Our lemon meringue tart was tasty, but the tart crust was tough and nearly impossible to cut through. Overall it was good, but not great. It was also very expensive. My dish with 4 scallops was nearly $50. The total with our food and just two glasses of wine plus tip was nearly $200 which is quite steep, even for the Cape. If we were to return next year I think we're more likely to come for a lunch.

A 4.5 star review, rounded up because the owner was so kind in helping us find the perfect table…read more We showed up at Caroline's as a referral from Connor at our hotel, the Eagle Wing inn. There are multiple different seating options, everything from an outdoor patio to high top bar seats, tables, and the indoor booth seating which is what we selected. The dining room is comfortable, and with open windows it provided a nice breath of fresh air. We started with the seafood sampler, a wonderful combination of fresh and delicious shellfish (clams, oysters, shrimp and a lobster tail). We then split appetizers instead of entrees, having the tuna tartare and the Chatham mussels, both of which were excellent. There was some minor room for improvement - after we were done with our seafood sampler, we sat for about 10 minutes while our server Danielle seemed to be in an enthusiastic conversation with Caroline out in front of the restaurant. It provided for some interesting dinner theater, but with so many other employees standing around, it probably would have been an ideal opportunity for somebody else to chip in and take over. Also, the mussels came in a wonderful wine / garlic sauce - some bread would have been a thoughtful addition to soak up that wonderful broth. Fortunately the quality of the food and the vibe of the restaurant more than compensated for a couple of service issues - we visited in late May, so hopefully by the time this restaurant hits the busy season, they'll have the issues worked out. Overall, I would certainly not hold back from referring this restaurant.

We arrived at Arnold's at ~4:30 on a Saturday afternoon. There was a line out the door but it moved…read morequickly and the weather was sunny and warm so we didn't mind the wait. My wife ordered the fish and chips and I ordered the whole belly clams basket. You order at the front counter and then you can sit at a table (it's a big place so there are lots of places to sit) and they call your name on a loudspeaker. My wife's fish was ~6 kinda small pieces that at first I thought were chicken tenders but they were indeed fish and she said they were very good - tasted fresh and had a nice light coating on them. My whole belly clams were a very generous portion of clams on top of a good portion of French fries. Since my stop the previous week at Surfside Seafood in Orleans (already reviewed on Google and Yelp) with a paltry portion of puny strip-like whole belly clams I was a little nervous about ordering clams even at a different restaurant but the serving at Arnold's was very large - absolutely no complaints from me! Very large clams, nicely fried and they all tasted great! I wasn't crazy about the fries - they were those twice-fried frozen fries that I've never been a fan of - I don't understand why restaurants don't make their own fries, especially if they have a good sized kitchen to do it in. The coleslaw was very good - maybe the best I've had on the Cape! They even put cranberries in it which added a fabulous texture to the slaw. Not overly wet with liquid, which is just the way I like my coleslaw and since my wife doesn't like coleslaw, I was able to have hers! Anyway, the food was very good! There wasn't any grease on the bottom of either of our plates, which is testament to their fryolators being clean and the oil being new and hot. We sat way in the back in the tent area and there was a nice young lady there who was cleaning tables as needed and she came by and asked if she could take our plates when we were done with our meal. Prices were reasonable - ~$65 for our two meals which as anyone who has eaten at a seafood restaurant on the Cape knows, is not bad at all. Besides the fries being very ordinary, I really enjoyed Arnold's and we will definitely be back. They have a very large parking lot and as others have noted, it's a cash only restaurant (they do have signs at the front counter indicating that there are two ATM machines on the premises). The entire staff there was friendly and welcoming and worked to make our visit an enjoyable one.

When I mentioned to my friend who lives here that we were eating at Arnold's, his response was…read more"Worst food on the Cape." I don't know about that because I'm only visiting, but it was certainly not worth the line or the price. Long wait, but then a very nice employee took our order. The food is meh. The outdoor tables are SO sticky. Tip jars everywhere, even after we already tipped well at the register. Lucky we had that much for the cash-only policy. It's not cheap & it's not good, so why go here?