I have patronized Campagnia in Bay Ridge for many years. A friend wanted to try the Staten Island location during the holidays. Have to admit things are a wee bit different here. First, this location appears a bit more spacious, there is an actual bar ( loved the Christmas shakers adorning it). The mood was festive and we were seated earlier than our Resy. Second,, this location, I'll abbreviated Si( Island of Staten) served complimentary focaccia and a dipping sauce. Nice touch and yummy! We really were just craving calamari and pizza. The Calamari was utterly delicious, plentiful, nice sized portion and the marinara sauce was delicious. For the pizza, we ordered half vodka and half Margherita. I didn't taste the vodka, my friend loved it! I ate the Margherita which was delicious. For dessert, Cappuccino hit the spot on a very windy night. The service was on point and the staff were friendly, accommodating and professional, especially on a busy night. I really liked the vibe.. I'll be back... Campagnia is located on 1801 Hylan Boulevard Take S79 to Seaview Avenue, 3 minute walk read more

See all

Decided to do lunch with my Italian friend here. We was excited about coming here because of all the RAVE reviews . Sadly I was very much underwhelmed by the food. There's nothing "authentic " about the food here. Started with fried chicken wings and a focaccia. One wing was tasted and sent the rest back they were just not good . When I told the waiter we didn't like them instead of asking what was wrong he asked if they were cold. Which means they aren't made fresh . First red flag Focaccia came out and wasn't focaccia it was a thin crust pizza style very dry very hard not good . We picked at it but definitely didn't finish it . I wanted chicken parmigiana because I mean an authentic Italian restaurant can't mess that up right ? The food came out room temperature To about lukewarm which means the food isn't freshly made. I ordered roasted potatoes instead of pasta . The roasted potatoes had no flavor at all even after I added salt pepper and garlic it still was on the bland side . The chicken cutlet was ok the cheese was the best part . Food wasn't hot . My friend ordered a portofino sandwich minus the eggplant and fries . She stated the fires tasted like McDonalds fries and the sandwich was underwhelming. The prosciutto wasn't salty and there was extra extra peppers maybe because she omitted the eggplant. Either way the best part of this visit was the valet guy ! The restaurant is nice the decor is nice lots of tvs showing different things but the food isn't good and I can't see what everybody is raving about. Save your money or find a better restaurant. read more

See all

A friend of mine consistently goes to this place and absolutely loves it, and she says that everything she's ever gotten from here has been amazing. So I finally was able to try it with her. We went there in the middle of the day and we sat at the bar and got the lunch specials. The bartender was great. He was friendly and prompt with his service. We ordered the steak sandwich (without bread), and the Roma sandwich. I asked for my steak to be medium, but it unfortunately came out a little on the well side. I feel like it was smothered in the Swiss cheese and there was not much steak under it. The flavor was okay. My friend ordered the Roma and she loved it. I would definitely try this place again and try different menu options. The inside is very lovely and there's plenty of space to dine in or sit at the bar if you choose to do so. read more

See all

The atmosphere is bright and beautiful. They have seating by the bar. Dinning area or even by the windows where they're open so you have warm breeze. Prices or &8. And above. I didn't have any was too full but from plates around me their desserts looked delicious. They have different locations so I'll try the one in Brooklyn in Park Slope side. I happens to be passing through in Staten Island so I ended up at one of those locations. I honestly picked the wrong dish but I'll go back to try the desserts and something else. Their Italian egg rolls and delicious sauce they brought out was a first for me. Liked it. read more

See all

The pizza are a pretty good, you can taste the coal. Very thin crispy slices. Not to filling which is great for giving room to eat more. read more

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

We here recently for a private party. The staff are very friendly and accommodating, the menu is very food is great. The restaurant is spacious and clean. They have a good wine list and make really great cocktails as well as really great read more

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

What a great spot. There is outdoor seating, tvs to watch a game and beautiful chandeliers. The service was great and what we ordered was delicious. I had a sangria which was delicious. We would definitely be back. There is rooftop seating read more

See all

I called ahead and placed 3 to-go orders, which all were not fully consumed. They lacked seasoning, especially the Chicken Malfadine, which was so milky/liquidy. We called to ask if we can get a new order or refund but they kept going back and forth with me. Ultimately, they wanted me to bring the dish back and I got a refund for only the very milky dish. Would not go back, despite my first time being a delightful, delicious experience. read more

I was in the area and decided to give this location a try. I love the Bay Ridge spot it's absolutely amazing, especially when it comes to the service and management so I had high expectations. Unfortunately, I was a bit disappointed. The food here was mediocre at best and didn't quite measure up to the Bay Ridge location. The service also lacked the warm, welcoming feel that I've come to expect. This space is much larger and more grand, which I understand can make it harder to provide the same level of attentiveness as a smaller venue. Still, during our entire meal, no one checked up on us, which made the experience feel a little impersonal. One of the main reasons I go to Campania is for the impeccable, extraordinary service, so this stood out to me. The appetizers also felt noticeably smaller compared to Bay Ridge, which was surprising. On the upside, this location does offer a wider variety of dishes, which is nice to see. Would I give this place a second try? Maybe, if I'm already in the area and want to explore some of the different menu options. But as for the overall service and hospitality, it just doesn't compare to Bay Ridge. read more

Really disappointed at our most recent visit to Campania. The food was great - this review has no complaints on the food - all good there. This is about service. Having visited their location in Bay Ridge and their location in Eltingville and having great experiences we were looking forward to more of that at this location and we were left quite unhappy. We were a large group, and had made reservations nearly three weeks out. They knew we would have children, I told them and I requested two high chairs, and they placed our table in a location right near the only handicap entrance and door to their patio seating. It was simply not ideal having the door opening and feeling like we were in the way because we had two strollers with us -- which we would have happily moved but there was no place to put them and no help given. We asked and they were like do whatever you want. They did not want us there. It was an early evening dinner on a weeknight in the summer the restaurant was not crowded by any means. But they rushed us out of that place as if it was on fire. The server was fine, but the runners for food and drink and bussers for clearing literally took plates cups and utensils as people were actively eating. We had ordered several pies, most still with slices, and they kept coming over asking us what they could clear. We were not lingering we were in and out in less than an hour and a half with 10 people. When we ordered dessert they seemed clearly annoyed. They seemed unhappy we didn't order drinks and it was mostly sodas and waters. The whole experience was really uncomfortable and disappointing and I hope it was just an off night. Made our entire group feel unwelcome - and we all have been to the other locations and have never had an experience like this. read more

Favorite neighborhood restaurant with a rooftop! Love the food and service every time I come!! read more

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Alejandro, our superb bartender, and Humberto, superior manager at Campania Hylan Blvd, made our dinner a supreme delight!! They are beyond gracious and most professional. Campania is well designed, great price point, courteous and most efficient staff and delicious extensive menu! Great for cozy dinner or family, friends, or business dinners, Campania is a 10 star spectacular dining experience. Great Happy Hour too!! Be sure to make a reservation for dinner dining on weekends. Great parking area (valet) across the street. Outside and rooftop dining is also available weather permitting. Come and enjoy a feast!! read more

See all

Be wary of buying or giving a gift card from here. When their machine is down, they won't honor it.

Ambiance can be chill, romantic or family style. Service is great and the menu has many choices. Drinks were really good! I had the Porter House steak and it was amazing!! read more

Ordered a personal gluten free pie, probably the best gluten free pizza that I have found so far. Also ordered two margarita pies, everyone loved them. I'm from Brooklyn ordering pizza in Staten Island and I have to say this was a good choice. Would give you 5 stars but the receptionist had to put me on hold to check my address and see if we were close enough to drive. She doesn't know her area when we were only about a 1.5miles away. read more

I don't know who said to me that this place is budget friendly but it's not and if you order a pizza you can't eat on the top side top deck. The service is bad. Their attitude is horrific. Their food is just OK. read more

Came here on a Wednesday evening and it was crowded. They have two entrances, the side entrance has a ramp for people with wheelchairs and strollers. The services are lacking. We had to ask multiple time to refill water and they still didn't do it. I couldn't hear what the server was saying went he was tell me what type of drafts they have. It is a bit too noisy for me. The foods are a hit and missed. The pesto pizza and black linguini tasted delicious while the linguine with clams, steak, and shank was ok. I would definitely go back for the pesto pizza. read more

See all

We went there on a whim on Saturday for lunch. After we were seated and 12 minutes went by with no water and no waiter acknowledging us we walked out - we took it as an indication service was going to suck. It wasn't busy. The wait staff were focused on chatting with the hostess and not their tables. read more

A cheese pie and wings. $65 dollars. The pizza was stale. Probable one that was sitting around and re-heated to add the pepperoni. Never again. At these prices you would expect a fresh pie. read more

This was my first time visiting this restaurant, and I was impressed by the vibes--it has a welcoming and cozy atmosphere that made for a pleasant dining experience. *Margherita Pizza: 4.5/5 The Margherita pizza was delicious, though I felt it could use a bit more sauce. Despite this, the overall taste was good *Calamari: 4.5/5 The calamari was fried to perfection and remarkably soft (in a good way). It arrived quickly and was a delightful start to the meal. *Margarita: 4.5/5 The Margarita was solid, complementing the meal well. While the food was good overall, everything could use a little extra something to make it perfect. The pizza took 25 minutes to arrive after the calamari, which was a bit unexpected given how quickly the appetizer came out. *Service The service was okay, but our server could have been more attentive. If you're in the mood for a good basic pizza, this is definitely the place to go! Overall, I liked the food and the ambiance. read more

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Lobster ravioli, Americano pizza, truffle Mac and cheese. Campania is completely carried by their amazing food selection. The service is not bad but I often feel at this location there is some to be desired. That being said I still love to come here for their delicious food. read more

Went here for a family dinner. Made reservation for 6:15pm. When we got there they sat us to out tables. The staff are very friendly. The service was pretty. There was a bit crowd I guess it is because Christmas time. The place is big. We order different types of foods and it came pretty fast. It was very tasty and will definitely come back here again read more

See all

I could've been a better server if you threw me on there for the day then the people who actually work there. Drinks took WAYY to long. Ordered a pizza to go after finishing the meal and waited 40 minutes and had to remind them because they forgot about it. Don't get the hype read more

Superb dining experience. The pizza, the veal parmigiana, the baked clams all amazing! Service was top notch. Nice ambiance and cool vibe. Highly highly recommend this place read more

Food was very good as well as the service great seating on the rooftop too bad the view is just of some electrical wires other than that everything was very good read more

Loved the food at the Buel Avenue restaurant. The wait staff was great and the ambiance was phenomenal. Such a great lunch.

Ordered a pizza to go on 12/15/2024 at about 7:45 PM the lady who accepted the order confirmed that she received the order but hung up without telling us the wait time. We called back in a second and asked if the order is in she said yes and hung up again. We came to pick everything up in about 30 min after she hung up the phone second time and to our surprise the order was not in and we have to wait for another 15 min because the lady who supposedly confirmed the order actually never put it in. Do NOT go. read more

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The pizza was amazing, thin crust. The staff was super friendly and the service was quick. The place is very large and amazing with all the memories on the wall read more

This is such a cute spot to grab dinner. We were seated in the wine cellar portion as the restaurant was pretty busy for a Friday night. It was super cute with one wall decorated as wine barrels. The service was awesome from our waitress and the bussers. They made sure we had water and cleared small items before our meals got there. They immediately give you bread with this tomato mix. I cannot remember what it's called. We ordered mozzarella sticks, the apple salad with chicken, lobster ravioli, spaghetti, and penne vodka with chicken. The food came out relatively fast, but that also might have been because we were chatting away. We all got super quiet when our food arrived and it was the sound of deliciousness and enjoyment of our meal. I definitely want to come back and give other items a try. read more

Ordered delivery from here for a buddy just out of the hospital. They hand delivered it for him. Whole tray of Baked Ziti he said was to die for . Not dry a lot of sauce and fresh mozzarella Chicken Milanese tender inside and crispy outside. Chicken parmigiana tender with same fresh mozzarella Broccoli rabe cooked perfectly and super fresh So happy the food was top notch Want to that them for being so helpful helping us out helping my buddy. read more

See all

family returned for a 4th time. I found the menu disinteresting to me. Reservation made for 8 people, arrived a few minutes before and waited over 15mins at the door front, then we were ignored by our server for another 20mins or so. he never came over or asked if we were ready. basically our table was walked past by many bus boys and servers until we had to stop some bunch of servers chatting around to figure who was our server. Service gone downhill since our first visit, I definitely would not want to return again. Food are good. but menu has not changed in 3 years. special menu prices are expensive..over $400 plus 20% tips each time plus 3.95% credit card surcharge we could go somewhere has better service and new menu items read more

See all

We had a party of 25 for a big celebration and they took great care of us! Someone in our party had a severe allergy and they were very helpful in finding something for her to eat. read more

The service and food were horrible! As an Italian, I expected so much more. I would rather go to any other Italian restaurant. Even the pasta was overcooked. Management is so rude and unaccommodating. So unwelcoming, I would truly never go back to this place. read more

I ordered a white pie tonight through the Slice app. The driver went to the wrong address and then refused to deliver it to me. So I'm going with Ungaro instead. Such a shame. read more

Three of us went to have lunch at Campania today. The food was very good, but at times we were asked if we had finished what we were eating? Don't understand why since the individual still had food in their plate. The issue occurred during dessert, I had ordered Vanilla Gelato with espresso, I received two scoops of vanilla ice cream. When I told the waiter that this was the wrong dessert order, he apologized and walked away. A few minutes later another gentlemen came by and asked how everything was. I then explained to him what I had ordered and what I was given. He then asked me whether or not I wanted my originally order, I told him no. We noticed that he went over to the waiter and spoke with him. The waiter came over and explained that he was confused, and apologized for the miscommunication. The kicker here, that instead of be given this dessert for free he charged us for the more expensive. Excellent food, wait staff are running around to quickly and looking to clear your plate off the table, while you are putting in the last bite. The food is worth it, but make sure you rein in the staff quickly. read more

Campania Coal Fired Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Great service, great food Ali is delightful, David is great and Alejandro at the bar is exceptional. !!! read more

The atmosphere and food was incredibly delicious. If I were to rate the host staff and the guy who seems to be running the show I'd give 1 star. They were more interested in chatting with each other than waiting on customers. The waiter had too much testosterone and was banging stuff. The hospitality was fake. read more

Service was terrible. Food was good. Very noisy. Water costs $7. We thought we ordered tap water when the waiter asked if we wanted sparkling or still. Apparently not. We won't go back. read more

WoW! This place is more than just Coal Fired Pizza... it's a great tasting experience so come hungry. PLUS, handmade pasta!!! The staff here were very welcoming and engaging. Made the atmosphere of this place even more enjoyable. To top that off the decor is very stylish and trendy. The food here was on another level. It's not your generic Italian cuisines, and they added small touches to expand the quality of your experience. Check out the pics to see what I mean. This place has quality and ambiance all in one. If you are looking to be WoW'd then you'll need to try this restaurant out. read more

See all

I went to have lunch there today with a friend, the service was good but we both got food poisoning. I have been sent to the bathroom a couple of times and my friend has been vomiting at least 5 times. How can such a big restaurant not have good quality control? Unbelievable. Not to mentioned the most expensive dish was without any flavor just salty. I will never go back nor recommend this place. Hopefully that this review can give them the awareness of checking their food quality. read more