Cafe Pomodoro

Food - so very good! Everything was hot and fresh and house-made. The gnocchi were little dumplings…read moreof pasta numminess. Yes, nummy. The chicken picatta was so, so good- just the right amount of lemony goodness. The Marsala was my husband's favorite- he's said it's some of the best he's had. My daughter said her veal was delicious. Get the cannoli- even if you don't normally like cannolis. My daughter loved her gooey snickerdoodle butter cake topped with ice cream. The decor and staff are everything you want in a family-owned Italian restaurant. There was Sinatra music playing and My Cousin Vinny on the TV - it was great. There is indoor and outdoor seating. It is a small restaurant with limited seating. If you are pressed, make a reservation. Don't go here, if you want quick, impersonal service. Street parking, just a heads up.

Service was quick, informative, and polite. First time, will be back. Especially to try their…read morehomemade desserts!

2025 Inside - Walls painted and new floors, pictures going back up on the wall

Calamari

See all

Cafe SiTALY

4.3(257 reviews)

12.4 mi

After reading the reviews, we decided to give this place a try…read more Upon entering, the restaurant is small and casual, with plush black booths lining the leftmost wall and tables seating up to 2-4 people sitting by the window. The walls are red with a black wainscoting paneling and framed pictures, sconces, and a small wine rack can be found on the red part of the wall. The ordering counter is also nearby and has a display case with pizza pies in it. We were immediately seated after arriving and ordered the following: Medium holiday veggie pizza, which has mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, ricotta, green peppers, and diced tomatoes. We didn't realize that the pizza didn't have red sauce but we still liked it. Hubs said that he needs to read the menu closer next time when ordering pizza. This wasn't the first time we accidentally got a no sauce pizza. LOL. Daughter and I shared Vongole, which is linguini tossed with 12-15 little neck clams with your choice of white or red sauce. She chose red sauce. We also got a choice of soup and she chose pasta fagioli. She liked the clams and said that the entree was nice and saucy. I prefer white clam sauce, though. So, I will try that next time. Fried calamari- calamari golden fried squid with side of homemade sauce. I liked that the calamari wasn't breaded. This is my favorite type of calamari. We should've ordered linguini on the side and this was Hubs' favorite dish of the night. The place filled up quickly after we arrived. Hubs had been wanting to try Italian food in Delaware. This place is located in a strip mall so there's plenty of parking. We were expecting it to be a fancy restaurant when we saw the exterior and were pleasantly surprised that it was a pizzeria. The place felt very homey and we loved it. Service was quick and friendly. Will definitely return when in the area to try other items on the menu!

Great little spot! Always good food and great service. It's small inside and they do a lot of…read moretakeout orders. They have a couple tables in front, and a row of booths along the wall. We've enjoyed their pasta and pizza, and the garlic knots are a must. It can be hard to get a table during peak hours and there isn't really room to wait inside. If you have a choice of booths, I'd recommend heading toward the back, as it's further from the takeout pickup area and the front can get chilly during the cooler months from the door being opened frequently. Additionally, they have wine though it's a limited selection.

Long hots

See all

Shrimp , scallops and salmon with broccoli .

La Pizzeria Metro

4.2(203 reviews)

8.7 mi

LaPizzeria Metro in Whitehall recently opened has great Pizza. Friendly staff and a nice local…read morerestaurant. Give it a try sure you won't be disappointed.

Popular place, casual, laid back atmosphere. High quality ingredients and intriguing recipes are…read morethe main reason(s) to stop in. They also have an interesting beer selection. I wouldn't bother trying to call an order in. They ignore the phone even when they have time to answer it. They do not seem to want you to order a pizza customized your way judging by the fact it costs $3 per topping for meat, vegetable, or otherwise. If you want mushroom, onions, and olives that's an extra $9! The pizza and stromboli are interesting, it looks well done but it's really soft. So I would ask for it crispy if that's how you like it. If you are in the area give it a try. The service is ok. One waiter could have held the door for me since I was holding a pizza, a stromboli, a soda, and a slice of cake. The place does seem pretty clean. All in all, it's good. Could be better.

Browntown pizza

See all

Nachos!

Mazzella's Italian Restaurant

4.0(244 reviews)

10.7 mi

Good food. Good people. Good ingredients. Good times…read more We ordered 30 mins ahead at noon. The parking lot and the restaurant were both packed but our food was hot, ready, and waiting for us Can't beat a fresh pie straight from the oven paired with their finely chopped antipasto

The food is always good and you get good portions. Very casual dinning. Plus it's my #1 for a…read moreslice of hot pizza!

Dining area

Antipasto

See all

Outside

V&M Bistro

3.8(150 reviews)

11.0 mi

Had a 70th birthday party for my wife . It was a private affair. The food was fabulous with…read moregenerous portions . The owners and staff were on point with everything. Couldn't be more perfect. I would recommend this business to anyone. It was fabulous

We picked up some Cioppino for a classic Italian Christmas Eve dinner and my goodness, this was…read moresome of the best seafood I've had in Delaware and was even better than some of the seafood I've had in Italy! The fish was tender and just the right amount of salty. The red sauce was flavorful and hearty. It was everything I'd look for in a seafood dish. The quality of fish used was also notable. We paired it with some Chardonnay, which was lovely. We had ordered 3 trays of Cioppino and ate 2.5 of them, amongst 3 people..it was that good! It was $38 per tray, which I feel is really reasonable for the quality. Pickup was quick and easy and staff were so kind. So thankful and appreciative of those who are spending their holiday making it more carefree for others. This really made our Christmas Eve!!

Limoncello Martini

Timballo - a lasagna style pie with meat and pasta, covered in a red and cream sauce. Pair with garlic knots!

See all

Tasty garlic knots!

Cafe Napoli Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.9(166 reviews)

2.7 mi

Good pizza and the best chicken parm. The staff is always nice. The restaurant is inviting and very…read morecomfortable.

Aye there 3 weeks ago menu very typical Italian restaurant. The food comes out very generous…read moreservings, most have to box up half of the entrees and take home for another meal. The staff very friendly and attentive to your needs. Ambiance is a little dated, pricing is good.

Gnocchi with meatballs

Tortellini with prosciutto

See all

Barcelona Pizza

4.3(38 reviews)

4.0 mi

I always order from this place & never fails. Price is reasonable & food quality the best around…read more Service always fast enough that i get home & my food still hot. Will definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a fresh italian meal.

We ordered a Philly cheese steak and side salad tonight. Both were top notch! Cheesesteak had ample…read moremeat and cheese, onions, mushrooms and sweet peppers. You customize what you want. The side salad was large enough for two. We got delivery from Barcelona itself. Speedy and efficient. highly recommended

Barcelona roll

Buffalo Bites

See all

Trattoria La Tavola

3.8(97 reviews)

7.0 mi

It was our first visit to Trattoria La Tavola and it certainly won't be our last! We arrived early…read morefor our reservation and were sat immediately. Our server was fantastic and highly attentive. Food was amazing from appetizers to desserts. We're new to visiting Kennett Square and we look forward to another dinner at La Tavola soon!

My parents and I took a trip to Trattoria La Tavola prior to the annual Christmas parade in Kennett…read moreSquare. This is a beautiful and unique, earthy and classy space with ample seating. Our waiter was kind and attentive, which was impressive given the obvious crowds during an especially busy day. We ordered some bruschetta to start, which is divine with the a nice bite of cheese and sweet tomatoes. We also ordered some mushroom soup, a staple of Kennett Square, which was SO good. This might've been the highlight for me. It was rich and flavorful without being heavy. For my entree, I ordered the seafood pasta special, which was gorgeous and colorful with shrimp, clams, and mussels in a lobster cream sauce. It was creamy and the fish was very fresh. I didn't pay this time, but it was a bit on the pricier end with entrees ranging from $25-$35. I really loved it here.

See all

Sicily's Pizza

4.5(13 reviews)

6.7 mi

Food here is pretty good. The mozzarella sticks are the standard kind you get from any takeout…read moreplace. I don't think they're actually made fresh since they all taste exactly the same. The Italian stromboli was really good. My one complaint is that it came with onions and peppers, which weren't in the description and normally aren't on strombolis unless you ask for them.

The pizza is good. Never have to wait. Someone is always there to take your order. I haven't tried…read moreanything other than the pizza.

Pepperoni Pizza Slice - could use more pepperoni

I had to move fast my family was on it

See all

IL Granaio

4.6(818 reviews)

13.5 mi

•$$$

Always a great dining experience! Staff is always wonderful. The food is amazing! The atmosphere is…read morecasual and relaxing. We've been coming back for years!!

Service and food are top notch. Always enjoy our time out. Would recommend to anyone that's looking…read morefor great food.

The bar area

Bread

See all

Lemon cake

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Heather L.

9 years ago

Had an awesome late lunch/dinner (linner?) here yesterday!!! Great pizza with a total NY style pizza restaurant vibe. OMG try the Crispino!!! Love it! There's also a full Italian menu + Beer+Wine for anyone who wants something more than pizza. I also did a couple apps off the dinner menu. I tried the Shrimp over Broccoli rabe, which was excellent. It was shrimp sauteed in a garlic wine sauce served with broccoli rabe. Perfect for low carb/paleo although you could easily order pasta on the side if you wanted to make it a dinner. Absolutely delicious! The Timballo Di Melanzane also off the appetizer menu could easily be a dinner. It was thin slices of eggplant, fried and then layered with linguini and mozz in served in a blush sauce. So yummy!!! The restaurant inside is adorable and the outdoor seating area will be awesome come the spring. This place just opened the other day and is in the same shopping center as Tylers and Piree's. I think it's the same owners as Cafe Sitaly in N. Wilmington. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area and I think it will become a Pike Creek hot spot. Can't wait to go back and try more dishes! read more

chegg c.

5 years ago

Favorite go to Italian restaurant. Has amazing food for a cheap price. Huge portions as well. Look forward to it every time I go!

Chuck Y.

7 years ago

Great food and great, personable service with reasonable prices make this one of my favorite restaurants.

Millz N.

3 years ago

pizza was great...perfect balance!!!

Cafe Pomodoro - sicilian - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Cafe Pomodoro also viewed

Cafe Napoli Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.9

(166 reviews)

Good pizza and the best chicken parm. The staff is always nice. The restaurant is inviting and very…read morecomfortable.

Casa Italia Pizza & Pasta

4.1

(29 reviews)

The food is absolutely delicious…read more The customer service is exceptional! If you have not given them a try... It's time to experience deliciousness.

Upgrading my rating to 4 stars for Casa Italia. We really enjoyed our most recent visit. The pizza…read morewas delicious - excellent crust with the perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The staff is efficient and friendly, and the atmosphere is casual and comfortable. And one of our favorite parts - it's a BYOB, so of course we brought a bottle of red. Looking forward to our next visit!

Trattoria Di Napoli Ristourante & Pizzeria

3.8

(105 reviews)

We ordered lunch from Trattoria Di Napoli via DoorDash. We were impressed with flavor, freshness…read moreand portion sizes, but disappointed by a few things: 1) we requested a side of fresh parm for the spaghetti and meatballs, but none was to be found in our delivered order, 2) no napkins nor plastic cutlery was included (our delivery address was to a hotel which inherently assumes these items are needed), and 3) the margherita flatbread was delicious, but cold (I'm guessing it was warm when picked up by our DoorDasher?) The tasty order of spaghetti and meatballs could've fed a family of four so we had leftovers to try and fit in our hotel fridge [bad problem to have, right? ;)]. While the side salads were fresh, they were mostly iceberg lettuce with a single slice of tomato as well as a single slice of cucumber and a few pieces of red onion. The flatbread was really good, but would've been better warm; again, likely the result of third party delivery service. Hubby enjoyed the cannoli and would order again. Next time we are in the Newark area, we'd likely order from here again, but maybe dine in versus delivery.

Great food and service! We were a large party with dietary restrictions and they were terrific with…read moreit. 8 of the 9 of us had a different meal. We all loved and they were huge portions!

Little Vinnie's Pizza & Pasta

3.9

(96 reviews)

Good food, decent service, but the former is declining a little. The french fry recipe (probably…read morevendor) changed: no longer is it the coated fries, FYI. Pizza is good if you like thin and crispy. Put too long in the box and it loses the crip, and it doesn't start with too much sauce and cheese, so just be aware this is what you're in for. I personally like it when it's fresh.

DO BETTER Little Vinnie's…read more Recent review of multiple items: Slice of cheese - just look at the pic. BURNT, no cheese pull, very little flavor Penne pasta with garlic and oil - absolutely bland Spaghetti and meatballs - watery sauce no taste Chicken & Spinach on roll - 4 pieces of diced chicken. This was more of a "roll" sandwich the a sandwich filled with the goods.

Luigi's Cafe

4.1

(99 reviews)

Found Luigi's after our favorite spot was closed for Sunday. There were 8 of us so we called to…read morereserve a table. Its a small place, so many coming in for take-out. Luigi is great! Loved his sense of humor. Food was hot, delicious. We now have a favorite spot!!!

Disappointing Upside-Down Pizza…read more I ordered a plain upside-down pizza last night, and unfortunately, it was a very disappointing experience. I was expecting an upside-down pizza with a generous layer of tomato sauce that would add moisture and flavor to each slice. Instead, the sauce was extremely thin and appeared to have been spread over the cheese in little more than a dried-out smear. There simply wasn't enough sauce to provide the flavor or moisture I was expecting. The crust was another major issue. It was hard and dry throughout, and when I bit into it, it literally crumbled into pieces. The combination of the dry crust and lack of sauce made the entire pizza feel unusually dry. Based solely on the pizza I received, I would have to rate it as one of the worst pizzas I've had in quite some time. That said, I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. It may have been a one-time occurrence or simply an off night in the kitchen. However, if this is representative of their typical upside-down pizza, I would strongly recommend taking another look at the recipe and preparation. I certainly hope this was an exception, because when done properly, an upside-down pizza can be excellent.

Tony's Cafe

4.0

(114 reviews)

Tony's Café used to have some of the best pizza in the Newark area truly authentic New York-style…read morepie. Unfortunately, since the ownership change, the quality has dropped significantly. The crust now tastes like a store-bought shell, the sauce seems overly sweet, and the sausage, pepperoni, and cheese blend feel noticeably lower quality than before. What's disappointing is that Tony's already had a winning formula. Changing a product that built such a strong local reputation doesn't make much sense from a customer perspective. Sadly, this shift has lost my family's business. If I want that type of pizza, I can go to chains like Domino's, Pat's, or Seasons. For quality local pizza, Cacciatore's will now get all of my business.

EASY to get to from I95! Great place to stop, get a fantastic meal and get back on the highway…read more The food was excellent!! Being, from Brooklyn. I know a good New York style pizza. Waitress was very attentive and the prices were reasonable. Good acoustics , comfortable seating. Bathroom could be updated.

Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta

4.3

(68 reviews)

If you're originally from the New York or New Jersey area and you want pizza that tastes as close…read moreto home as possible-make this your new spot. Imagine this: pizza with delicious savory toppings and a generous amount of cheese than isn't greasy, light airy crust, large slices and the option of personal pies so it's not just a treat but an actual meal...that's what I had. To be more specific I had the Michaelangelo personal pizza 10" which had tender chunks of chicken and roasted peppers as a topping. My husband had a slice topped with buffalo chicken. We both sat and ate in silence which for us is a sign that it tastes really good. The decor inside is simple but cozy, clean and inviting. Although they offer pizza by the slice that they make beforehand, but the personal pizzas and most other items on the menu are made to order. My husband spotted the guy working his magic with the dough for my pizza. When they brought our pizza to the table the aromas were a pleasant signal of what we were about to have. We will definitely be back to try one of the many other menu items like the hot subs or pasta dishes that all sound very tempting. Come show them some love-great spot!

Great thin crust pizza in many different varieties. Clean with plenty of seating. Service was…read morepleasant and food arrived quickly.

Dom's N.Y. Style Pizzeria

3.8

(139 reviews)

Love Doms and the neighborhood vibe of the place. It never disappoints. Staff are friendly and food…read moreis yum!

Service is always great! The antipasto is excellent with plenty to take home. Great pasta, pizza…read moreand sandwiches. We've never had a bad experience.

Gallery Pizza

3.6

(19 reviews)

Now Amalfi II but still great pizza by the slice or the pie. Friendly staff always a great deal.read more

Best pizza around! We get pizza virtually every Friday night and it is absolutely delicious. You…read morecan taste the yeast in the dough and the dough is the perfect ratio of crunch and chewy. The sauce taste homemade, whether it is or not I don't know, but it certainly taste fresh and homemade. The multitude of choices they have is off the charts. You can also make up your own toppings and they will handle your request with pleasure. Great job Gallery Pizza keep up the great work!

Pizza by Elizabeths

3.9

(280 reviews)