Some of the best food we've had! A hidden gem that seems a bit overlooked? Our family had pizza (the crust was perfect), penna Al la vodka (perfect), lasagna (the best), Gorgonzola gnocchi (balsamic drizzle- genius, and chicken limoncello (delicious). Every single thing tasted so good! Happily took home left overs. The service was great and friendly. It was a bit warm in the restaurant so it would have been nicer if the air was down a notch but it didn't ruin a good meal. We loved it! read more

After reading the reviews, we decided to give this place a try. Upon entering, the restaurant is small and casual, with plush black booths lining the leftmost wall and tables seating up to 2-4 people sitting by the window. The walls are red with a black wainscoting paneling and framed pictures, sconces, and a small wine rack can be found on the red part of the wall. The ordering counter is also nearby and has a display case with pizza pies in it. We were immediately seated after arriving and ordered the following: Medium holiday veggie pizza, which has mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, ricotta, green peppers, and diced tomatoes. We didn't realize that the pizza didn't have red sauce but we still liked it. Hubs said that he needs to read the menu closer next time when ordering pizza. This wasn't the first time we accidentally got a no sauce pizza. LOL. Daughter and I shared Vongole, which is linguini tossed with 12-15 little neck clams with your choice of white or red sauce. She chose red sauce. We also got a choice of soup and she chose pasta fagioli. She liked the clams and said that the entree was nice and saucy. I prefer white clam sauce, though. So, I will try that next time. Fried calamari- calamari golden fried squid with side of homemade sauce. I liked that the calamari wasn't breaded. This is my favorite type of calamari. We should've ordered linguini on the side and this was Hubs' favorite dish of the night. The place filled up quickly after we arrived. Hubs had been wanting to try Italian food in Delaware. This place is located in a strip mall so there's plenty of parking. We were expecting it to be a fancy restaurant when we saw the exterior and were pleasantly surprised that it was a pizzeria. The place felt very homey and we loved it. Service was quick and friendly. Will definitely return when in the area to try other items on the menu! read more

Awesome food!! Best pizza in Wilmington! Good service. Be sure to try the pasta dishes. Can't go wrong

Great little spot! Always good food and great service. It's small inside and they do a lot of takeout orders. They have a couple tables in front, and a row of booths along the wall. We've enjoyed their pasta and pizza, and the garlic knots are a must. It can be hard to get a table during peak hours and there isn't really room to wait inside. If you have a choice of booths, I'd recommend heading toward the back, as it's further from the takeout pickup area and the front can get chilly during the cooler months from the door being opened frequently. Additionally, they have wine though it's a limited selection. read more

See all

Love their food; especially the Chicken Francese! I can't get enough of it. This is definitely a hidden gem located on Naamans Road. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Chicken Francese - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

A pizza shop, with 5 booths, 2 tables. Very busy but service is quick & friendly Over abundance of food, enough for another meal the next day ! Extensive menu. No bar, wine & soft drinks available. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Braciola with fettuccine. Sauce was amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

See all

The moment you open the door, your mouth waters. Then you are greeted by a friendly face and a glass case of really yummy looking pizza. I ordered a turkey and cheese wrap and 2 cannoli's to go. That wrap was stuffed with fresh ingredients and so tasty! But those cannoli's guys... they were -So-Good-. *chefs kiss* The service was excellent, and the food was delicious. 10/10 recommend. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

See all

Total Saggymasters they twirl the pizza in mid air singing Avi Marie' what a presentation then March around the restaurant singing Elvis and Beatles these Saggymasters are top notch the women dress as the Virgin Mary total Saggymaster action read more

AMAZING!! No seriously, everything we ordered was literally outstanding! A group of us visiting here from upstate NY ordered from here based on the number of positive Yelp reviews. I don't recall the last time everything ordered was so good. We were all tasting some of what the others got, and couldn't believe it. Also, this place is the real deal with authentic NY style pizza crust.Try the red pepper and artichoke pizza, it's to die for! Can't wait to order from here again next time I'm in town! read more

The BEST ITALIAN FOOD!! It's my go to place for indoor dining and also takeout I have recommended Cafe Sitaly many times and keep getting rave review from my friends. The service is very good and the food compliments the service. I just purchased gift cards for family members & some friends. read more

First time trying ! It was so good ! Real pizza ! I DoorDash so I don't know about service but it was done rather quick. Looks like a nice place. read more

best pizza to-go; service in-house is great- such a warm space for dinner - Eggplant dishes are always tasty!

Really great! Pizza is delicious and service is fast! The place is dim lit & intimate.

Ordered 3 dishes and they tasted so so sooo good! Love the food from this place! Had the chicken Marsala for the first time and it was really good! Love the salad as always!! read more

See all

Always my go to for the best slices of pizza in Wilmington, however, got the linguini vongole (clams in white sauce) and it tasted absolutely rotten. There was no "sauce" it tasted like warm dirty sink water with rotten garlic and clams. The clams were clearly old as heck and there was more sliced RAW garlic than there were clams by far. My boyfriend got the chicken Caesar wrap which he also threw away because it tasted sour. Appetizer (mozzarella sticks) also got trashed as they tasted like fish. My guess is they were fried in the same very old oil that the fishy calamari is fried in over and over. So disappointing. I'm out $40 and still hungry read more

One of the worst pizzas ever!! It was so horribly chewy. Couldn't even rip a piece from crust. Was like eating chewing gum. Yuck. And the mushrooms were canned. They had the rubbery texture and sour taste of canned. Really?? Saddest part was I asked if they could do well done crust- and they said "Absolutely". Well done us crispy- not chewy. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Rubbery crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

See all

Stopped in with three companions on a summer Friday night-I had only been here for takeout previously and every time they were jam packed-fortunately, they weren't crazy busy, as I guess there are so many people on vacation. We were seated right away by one of the two waitresses and we ordered drinks, which were served quickly. She did apologize about the temperature and explained that their air conditioning had gone out, so it was a bit warm inside. We were given given warm bread with butter for the table while we waited for our food. The food came out quickly and everything was good. Pizza was a little pricey, but if you know Delaware you know that good pizza is hard to find, and this is one of the good spots! Broccoli bites were very good, mozzarella sticks were good, as were the steak sandwich and Caesar salads. A good meal at a good price and would definitely recommend and return. read more

See all

Weekend nights are busy, but it's worth the wait. Pizzas, salad, and garlic knots are yummy. The staff is great. There's lots of options for your pizza. Wings are also pretty decent. read more

Went to Cafe SITALY for dinner the food was great the service was good the service that was on on Monday 9/15/2025 was wonderful she was very pleasant person she had a lot of people there and took care of everyone there The food I had spaghetti and I had a chicken soup that was wonderful and the spaghetti was great. The food is very nice and priced was reasonable and they give you a nice amount. read more

The food is so tasty! I have never been disappointed. Starting with a chicken pastini soup - homemade and delicious. Followed by chicken francese and angel hair pasta with meat sauce. You are on food heaven but wait there is more... the bread!!!! Ask for extra butter, it is the best! This whole meal was $21. The desserts look amazing but I am usually too full. One negative - the white options are crap. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Chicken Francese - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

Food is incredible. Pizza is absolutely delish. Everyone is super friendly and attentive.

Very cute place, homey feeling. Went on a Sunday at 3:00 pm and it really started hoppin' about 3:45 pm. Had the blackened triple special and it was so tasty. Enough for both of us. Hope to return. read more

The meatball Stromboli is the real deal. Small size is a large and will definitely put you to sleep. Do not eat at work. I repeat, do not eat while working. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Meatball Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

Wonderful catering! I ordered for 30 people for a party. Every year we get basically the same order from different restaurants and it's always been just fine. This year, we ordered from Cafe SiTALY and we will ALWAYS order from here again. Everything was more than delicious! We ordered a Penne Vodka, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Cacciatore, Eggplant Parm, Tenders and Garlic Knots. Again, EVERYTHING was delicious! Well done! read more

Food excellent. Pricing good for the quality of the food. Interior is small, clean but very dated. I'll be back for sure. Took my 87 yr old Mother and she really enjoyed the lunch. read more

Love the penne vodka! My absolute favorite!! Buon appetito Service is incredibly efficient read more

We love cafe sitaly! We live about 2.5 hours away but when we drive to Philly we make a stop here on the way back for dinner. Generous portions and amazing food!! read more

I stopped by this cafe and had some pizza, It was excellent! I live in the mid west and miss east coast pizza, cafe Sitaly's pizza was great, the crust was tasty and allowed for folding pizza easy. A very good amount of sauce and cheese on the pizza. For a guy who misses east coast pizza, I highly recommend this place. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Rack of various pizzas from cafe Sitaly - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

See all

Great food. I haven't really had anything I didn't like. Some things are better than others but we've never been disappointed.

I've ordered from Café Sitaly many times, and each experience has been fantastic! From the classic Chicken Parmigiana and Meatball Sandwich to the Italian Stromboli and various pizzas--Cheese, Pepperoni, Bacon Chicken Ranch, Buffalo Chicken, and Sicilian--everything we've tried has been fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. Café Sitaly is our go-to spot for Italian takeout, and we're already looking forward to our next order! read more

I enjoy coming here to eat with my gf. We both love the food here. I normally order a couple of different platters. I recommend this place.

I thought their reviews conveyed that their food was amazing, but instead of authentic Italian cuisine it just tasted like takeout to me. I ordered an Italian personal Stromboli and it was the greasiest Stromboli I ever had. I thought the garlic undertones were nice, but it was too much for my stomach. My mom had the garlic knots and she only ate one. I had one and thought they were ok. Maybe I'm missing something, because I don't understand the rave reviews. I wish I had tried their pizza, but now I'm kind of turned off to this establishment. Side note: I did see a few reviews that claimed this establishment was racist, but I don't think that's the case. I just thought it was awkward that when I entered everyone just stared at me and there wasn't a warm "hi" or "welcome". I don't think I was discriminated against, but I don't think they're the friendliest either. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

See all

My wife has gluten problems and when they brought pasta it was spaghetti. My pasta was suppose to have marinara sauce and it had oil. If anyone understands gluten problems it can be dangerous for a person to eat regular pasta. My son-in-law ordered chicken parm and the portion was very small. They never offered anything for our dinners being ruined. I feel at this point I will never go back. read more

We ordered take out. Food itself was very good. Only issue was that I ordered a plain chicken steak (no cheese) the person taking the order typed it in correctly however the kitchen staff decided to add cheese anyway. I didn't know this until after getting home so we had to make a trip back for the corrected sandwich because they said delivery would take over an hour. The corrected chicken steak was very good. We also ordered fries, a pizza steak, garlic knots, a hamburger, onion rings and meatballs. Everything was a 8/10 and we'll definitely return. I'll just check the food before leaving the restaurant. read more

Great pizza, delivery was still too hot to eat when it arrived! Nice pieces of sausage instead of crumbles.

What a fabulous little Italian place!!! Don't let its small appearance fool you - they've got some delicious grub coming out of this joint! I took my three daughters and grandson to Café Sitaly for dinner recently. We chose to go there upon my oldest daughter's recommendation - she said it was wonderful, and she was absolutely right! We all loved our dishes - I had the Fettucini Carbonara (I'm not Italian, but it wasn't exactly a true Carbonara from what I can tell - to me it was more of an Alfredo type sauce - BUT it was delicious, so Café Sitaly can call it whatever it wants!). Two of my girls had chicken dishes - one had the Francaise and the other had the Limoncello (both were very similar but the Limoncello was a lot sweeter) and my other daughter had a vegetarian pasta with lots of broccoli in it. Everything was really good and it was so nice having fresh pasta for a change. We also had the bruschetta, which was perfect, and the complimentary rolls were delicious as well - I could eat those every day. My grandson loved them too. The place is small but cozy, and luckily we didn't have trouble getting a table. The service was spot on. Overall, it was a very nice dinner and I can't wait to get my husband back there so he can try it. read more

See all

We eat here often each and every time we're in Delaware the state. The food is always great and wonderful the service is excellent also. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Shrimp topped with crab meat on cheese ravioli in a blush sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

See all

The smell that these babies put off is unreal. I'll be honest, I haven't tried much else but the Strombolis are the best in town. Great flavor and a perfect distribution of ingredients. read more

Cafe SiTALY - Stromboli l-r: pepperoni, broccoli & spinach, and cheesesteak. Amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Wilmington, Delaware

AMAZING pizza - BEST around. We stop here on our way home which is another hour away, anytime we can. This is the Crispino Grandma Pie with Sausage, Broccoli Rabe & added onion. The garlic notes are the best. Its hard to find an authentic Grandma Pie, and this place nails it! read more

See all

A hole in the wall with great food and service. The pizza and pasta were both good. No "flop" and a with a One Bite score of 7.5.