If waiting an hour even after you made a reservation four days in advance doesn't bother you, then try this place. If having a waitress write down your order (from a holiday, prepared course menu) and then bring out food that is luke warm or meat that isn't even remotely close to the preparedness that you asked for all while bringing the wrong items, then try this place. Terrible service, bland food, and way overpriced. read more

Went here for the first time today after my sisters high school graduation. The food was good, however, the service was the worst I've ever experienced at any restaurant ever. We waited forever for our food and our server rarely checked to see if we needed anything. My husband ordered a 3 course meal and eventfully gave up on the second course because everyone had already finished their meals. When we asked to speak to a manager and rather than discounting our bill, they offered us an additional dessert. The food was good but the service completely ruined our experience and I definitely would not recommend this place for a nice family dinner. read more

My mother in law invited the family to join her for dinner tonight at Cafe 422 in Boardman. We sat on the patio, a little chilly but the atmosphere was great with a live band playing. We ordered the prime rib special and it was great. Service was very attentive and got everything right. I highly recommend to anyone looking for great meal at a reasonable price. I don't often take the time to review but while checking the place out last night I saw some bad reviews. I thought it was only fair to share my wonderful experience. read more

No. Just No. This location gives Cafe 422 a bad name and it's definitely no Rusty's (still so sad). My friend had her rehearsal dinner here the night before her wedding and it was just awful for her. They have a private room that you enter only by walking through what they improperly call another private room. My friend visited the restaurant several days earlier to go over details and ensure that her event was held in the farther room so that no other people were walking through her rehearsal dinner to get to their event, yet they still set up for her rehearsal dinner in the first room so all night during dinner people that we didn't know trying to get to the other event were walking through the room that we were in, opening the door to the other event and leaving it open letting their very loud seep into my friend's dinner. When we would close the door to the other party, inevitably moments later a guest from that party would walk out to use the bathroom and leave the door open again. It was very disruptive. From the circumstances that occurred that night when my friend complained of the error, it appeared that the restaurant knew just what they were doing when they swapped rooms, presumably with the thought that even if she complained they were still able to make enough money off of the other party that booked to make up for moving my friend's dinner even though she booked the other room. The service also left much to be desired. They were literally removing half-drank beverages and half-eaten dinners from us after my friend complained about the error. Rather than trying to right the wrong they tried to hurry her and her party along. And in terms of the food, it is "faux-talian" at it's finest. If you want food of this caliber I guess you could just go to Olive Garden where they won't be so rude to you. read more

So-so help, greeted with a ho-hum attitude. Sweet waitress, or a Saturday special and it (Fish) arrived under cooked. The next plate came out fishy- halibut is never fishy. The other dinner was off the menu, white fish franchises- wine lemon sauce was bitter and out of a jar. The cab wine was good. 75.00 without tip. Will not return. read more

We went to Cafe 422 with friends for a nice evening of good food with friends. One word pathetic the food was cold, tasteless and my wife's steak was served cold and way over cooked, the service was terrible waiting an hour for our entire then having some guy tell us he was sorry the kitchen was busy. We had to keep asking for silverware. A pathetic excuse for a pathetic meal and service. We will tell all our friends in Youngstown. Enough said! read more

I was at Cafe 422 tonight with a group of people, and everyone loved their meal. We had the hummus and hot peppers and oil as appetizers. It was the best hummus I have ever had! And everyone also loved the hot peppers and oil. I also had mahi mahi for dinner- it was delicious! I and several members of the dinner party have had dinner at Cafe 422 several times in the past, and we will continue going there. Everything was delicious, and the service was amazing! Jessica was our waitress and she was pleasant, attentive, professional, and a wonderful waitress! The owner stopped by the table and he was wonderful! I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

New management- not good anymore We have gone for past few Christmas Eve dinners. It was always good except this year. First, they do not have a full menu anymore. Second, they up charge the items they do have on the special menu. Example: Chicken dish was $23.95 on special menu; $14.99 on regular menu. Third, the chicken franchaise for my mom & sister were bone dry. Fourth, Appetizers were made in tiny portions. We had the "b" team staff as well. Sadly, my mom was looking forward to the Almond Crusted Chicken all month. Not on special menu. Lastly NOTHING came out at the same time. We all sat waiting for entrees missing, potatoes etc coming out in random ways. The rib steak was good but over cooked. read more

My family and I came for lunch and it was delicious! The staff were friendly and attentive. The bathroom was clean and that's always a plus for me! read more

We went around 2pm. Left at 4! The food was great! We had chicken cacciatore, greens salad, chicken club and the spinach artichoke dip and wedding soup. It took 45 mins to get our soup and salad, then 5 mins later the dip. Then food was another 15 mins. There was one other table so do not know why service was so very slow. We did not have cocktails, so don't know if would have checked on us more if had drinks. Then the waiter wrapped all the food but did not bring our check. Had to find hostess and ask her to get it for us. I would go back, but maybe pick a different time to see if service is better. read more

Food came out quickly and hot! Very tasty. Server (Pedro) was excellent. Wide variety of specials.

We have been to Cafe 422 dozens of times. My wife always orders the Parmesan Crusted Haddock. She LOVES it. I have had their strip steaks the last two times there. The last one was just bad. The strip steak I had tonight was worse. Probably the worst two steaks I've ever eaten. Never thought anyone could serve such bad steaks twice. Pasta Fajoli great. Bread great. Atmosphere pretty good. Steak horrible. I should have had them remove it from the bill but I figure Idid eat the other items. JN. read more

Went to 422 to have fish Friday and I felt like my server was rushing me. He was always walking off before I can even ask him for something. He was so abrupt and rude when I would ask questions. I think his name was Jose. I asked for the manager and they kept making excuses. Anyways, not coming back here again because of bad service. read more

I suggest everyone stop by 422 in Boardman Ohio for one of the most mouth-watering delicious ribeye steaks that you will ever have in the Youngstown area it is absolutely fantastic!!! read more

The Happy Hour Menu is Crazy Good for food and drinks. The wood fired pizza is Awesome, as well as the eggplant carbonara. As a matter of fact we've not had a bad meal here. My husband just had the pork piccata and Loved it! Leave those chain restaurants behind and get some awesome menu choices in a great local restaurant! read more

The restaurant had the worse sevice I have ever had. Took us forever to order, a table of 14 but never have I ever seen a restaurant not have bus boys oh ya one and he was new, no refills on water, dirty dishes still on the table, orders not taken etc and the Owner cld only say we're busy right now!!! Better skip this place, under new ownership and he doesn't know what he's doing!!!! read more

The best restaurant in the valley by far! I've only eaten in a couple in the country. That can mach the quality of food and service they provide! Very classy friendly environment. Great atlasphere! Great decor! The 422 staff are amazing!! I interacted with five to six different 422 staff. I never been treated so well! Like a king! The food is THE BEST!! Great prices. They definitely have the top Chef in the valley. I live 45 minutes away in sharon, Pa and have eaten at cafe 422 three times. Since going there for the first time five days ago. Thats how fabulous the food is!!! The owner came to the table and checked to make sure my wife and I were happy with everything. That showed me he cares about his customers. Definitely the best restaurant experience I've ever had! Gotta try the lamb lollipops unbelievable!!! Thank you everyone at cafe 422! You're the best in the valley!!! See you in a couple days! lol read more

Had no beer on tap. Claimed beer truck never arrived. Entrees came with a side salad that consisted of a dismal dozen pieces of lettuce & a slice of cuke. Bread served was dry. Seafood dish was requested with a white sauce but wasn't an Alfredo as expected just more like flavored water although the dish was satisfactory otherwise. Cajun broiled fish was thin, with a red sprinkle of seasoning but somewhat flavorless, side of overly browned fries. Atmosphere & decor is very nice however. read more

Staff does not know menu. Have ordered take out several times in the past, but things have been wrong or not as the menu described. Ordered a salad with hot peppers on the side, but staff failed to tell me that salad is marinated in them. I tried to eat the salad anyway, but I am very sensitive to hot and one bite of lettuce burned my mouth. I had to throw the salad away and go somewhere else to get something for dinner. We will not be eating here again. On a side note, menu says salad comes with kalamata olives but salad came with sliced black and green olives. read more

I've been to every restaurant that has been in this building since 1996, and I believe Cafe 422 has the best and most versatile menu of them all. But more importantly cafe 422 has the best ambiance and setup versus the rest. The interior design is great. I thought the staff and owner were super friendly. The pizzas were amazing. They were brick oven and crispy throughout, just like you find in Rome. Their cocktail list is extensive and delicious. Their pastas and daily specials are also impressive. I will be back again soon to taste the other pizzas on the menu. A bonus in the summer is the open patio too and the weekly entertainment. read more

The food is great here. We've eaten here several times, always delicious! The atmosphere is beautiful. Highly recommended

Stopping at this restaurant while traveling through the area. Would never eat here again. The food was ok not great and the service was terrible. There were 4 in our party and 3 entrees came out but the 4th didn't materialize until well after everyone else was done eating a good 30 minutes later. We were told another member of the wait staff had taken it so it needed to be prepared all over again. We were also told they would ask the manager about comping that entree. Nothing not even a complementary dessert or drink was offered. Would never go back here again. We travel to this area quite often and will be avoiding this restaurant. read more

During a recent visit the service was well below par. The waitress never brought our bread. It was probably an hour between our salad and our meals. The owner walked around asking customer who actually had food to eat how their meals were, but the nine times he walked by our EMPTY table he wouldn't make eye contact, let alone ask us how we were doing or apologize for the wait. At the end of our meal we observed the hostess attempt the get a couple who was waiting at the bar for at least 45 minutes for a table, but she was stopped by the owner in favor of seating some of what appeared to be his friends who had just walked in the door. The food was good, but not great. I attempted to post this feedback to their facebook page only to have it not only deleted but blocked from posting on their wall. So instead of addressing the issue they chose to block and ignore me. Apparently unless you know the owner personally you should expect sub par service. So if you are not friends with the owner I would advise going around the Corner to Carmella's. Better food, better atmosphere, and better service. read more