This business is amazing and the food is delicious. Come out and support and it's a great pizza stop off I40

Couldn't find a single picture advertising their business or pizza. Only way I saw what their pizza looked like was from customers bad reviews. read more

Food is good staff not to friendly , the lady at the counter has no personality, rude unprofessional

I'm sorry but it was the worst Pizza I ever had no toppings and no cheese. The crust was good. They need to do better, didn't have any change when I went maybe i will give them another chance. It's sad , it's so close to my house read more

Pizza was amazing and arrived fast delivered by the sweetest girl. Win, win, win! Ten thumbs up! read more

We need more small businesses like this one! The love and care put into making this pizza shows in the taste!

The pizza was ok, not great. It was undercooked and could have benefited from cooking another 5-8 minutes. The delivery service was good, no complaints there. read more

Every time I eat here I have a good experience food is good esp the Italian(Chicago)beef calzone so yummy. Owner is extremely helpful and always makes you feel welcome. And the cannolis are amazing! read more

People love to complain on yelp... this place is atleast 4 stars. I got the deluxe pizza and the pepperoni calzone and it was really good. Will be back read more

Not sure if it's a one off but I can't believe this pizza left the kitchen. The crust was black so we couldn't eat it. We've been on the road for 12 hours so I am just going to eat what I can and go to sleep. Hopefully they are better than this regularly. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Receipt for burned pizza, so disappointed. - Pizza Near Me - Moriarty, New Mexico

See all

They're ok. Pizza Barn is way better in my opinion. Service is okay, not the best but not the worst. read more

I understand with COVID that places are Struggling but damn. These wings are nasty, rubbery and slimy. Need to try harder. Plus delivered to a hotel and did not include napkins or silverware. Website is a joke. Cannot order on line. The pizza is ok but not great. I travel for a living so I eat out all over the country but this is the last time I order for Buttercrust pizza in Moriarty New Mexico read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Nasty garlic parmigiana wings. Rubbery and slimy. - Pizza Near Me - Moriarty, New Mexico

Meh! It's fair. The staff are to be commended for working hard. The owner can be commended for knowing how to hire cheerful and helpful staff. read more

It was our first time there, we live in Edgewood and wanted to try their pizza, there were 2 employees in the back, and no other customers at all. They saw us, both ignored us for 10 straight mins. When we finally left I said"thanks anyway " and one of them had the audacity to say "you're welcome " Rudest place I've been to in a long time. We tried Shortys BBQ instead, very nice, attentive employees and yummy food. read more

On way back to Arizona from Iowa we stopped by to spend the night and found this place. Not sure why all the negative reviews we had a great experience and meal. We ordered the garden salad, we shared that, it's big enough. Also ordered the cheese bread. Very tasty and cooked well. Finished up with the Gluten-free Veggie pizza. One of the best GF pizza we've had. Has great flavor and crust is almost like a thin regular dough one. Take some time and stop by if you are in Moriarty NM. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Gluten-free Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Moriarty, New Mexico

Food isn't really all that great and service is typically pretty slow.. if you order delivery order at least an hour ahead of time because it will take that long. read more

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Don't confuse this place with pizza9, not affiliated at all. Their flavors are great, the many crust options are perfect, I highly recommend visiting. This place deserves more business, the butter crust is no joke! Best pizza! read more

Food and services were amazing! fresh hot pizza and wings, no complaints here! staff was extremely friendly to us and constantly checking in. Absolutely recommend! read more

Where's pizza in New Mexico, not here this is the worst pizza ever made. They use frozen crust which taste like cardboard and sauce that's directly out of a can. read more

Love their pizza. Friendly workers. Love their green Chile stuffed crust. Clean restaurant.

Great food, even better pricing, great staff and fast delivery times! Will eat here again.

I ordered the dexter and order of wings! Pizza was good. I would eat that again! The wings I'm not sure how they cook them but they didn't have any crisp at all. It was almost like they boil them, kinda rubbery! I didn't enjoy them nor would I order them again. They aren't fried I can tell you that ! But over all pizza was the star of the order. read more

So over priced for what you get, the people on the phone are wonderful, kitchen staff doesn't seem to understand what "extra cheese" means deliver staff always accommodating read more

Tried for the first time last night. Worst tasteless pizza ever! Ordered pepperoni, mushroom, green chili and it had no toppings! Ravioli Tastes like it's out of a can! $27 down the drain! read more

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and it took more than an hour to get a status but only after I called multiple times. Then all I got was excuses about why it was late. Wouldn't recommend ordering for delivery unless you ask about staffing to ensure you get your order in time. read more

I keep trying this place hoping it will get better. Guys you have a great idea, excellent sauce, and great toppings. I really want to love your pizza, but the crust needs work, badly. It's doughy and not at all flavorful. Please up your game! read more

We ordered 2 Chicago Italian beef sandwiches to be delivered to our motel room. The person we spoke to on the phone had a really hard time understanding what to do. It turned out this was her first day on the job. This is not how you should treat an inexperienced employee. With patience we got our order placed. The delivery was prompt and the food was good, not quite like Chicago, but good. read more

I ordered a specialty pizza and two topping pizza and it cost 34 dollars that was a little much and the pizza wasn't to bad I will order again if there is a special. read more

Formerly known as Pizza 9. I was concerned that the name change would affect the quality of Pizza. It did not. This place has THE BEST green chili too. They are very stingy with the portions served for desserts- for a one by one square of Tira Misu- about five bucks- no exaggeration- and you have to be sure to ask them what ingredients they have for the chef salad, sometimes they run short. All in all, good food, nice people, good service. read more

Order from here twice already. They are on the pricey side as far as pizza goes but it is worth it. We have ordered the loaded breadsticks, all meat and Hawaiian pizza- they were all very good. We will order from here again read more

Road trip and we needed a quick bite. Husband, 9yr old son and I were very pleased. Got a large half pepperoni/cheese. I tried the pepperoni and it had a little spice to it, yes I am wimpy. As for the cheese, I could of eaten all by my self even though it was pan. It had just enough sauce and a good amount of cheese. The crust underneath was a perfect crisp. They have salads, calzones, hot sandwiches, pasta wings and desserts. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Half cheese/pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Moriarty, New Mexico

See all

Rude customer service . Girl in front playing with hair. No hat on. And then touching food. Gross very rude and all customer service went out the window when I put 0 in the tip because she didn't wash her hands. Pretty much threw my receipt at me. My family and I will go somewhere else, and you should too. read more

I had the worst day of my life and let the f word slip and they hung up on me. I called back and they said they don't have the sandwich I was wanting and hung up on me. I tried to call back multiple times and got hung up on multiple times and supposedly it was the owner that was behind it so never again!!! I order from them every other day but not no more!!!!!! List a solid customer due to horrible customer service!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

This is our first pizza from Buttercrust. Loved it. The crust is really good. The sauce, toppings...everything is surprisingly very good. We'll definaltly be reordering. Glad to have a great pizza nearby! read more

Family friendly environment. Good Service. Clean restrooms. The food is delicious. read more

Buttercrust Pizza - Menu at counter - Pizza Near Me - Moriarty, New Mexico

Buttercrust has THE BEST PIZZA!! I decided to try the Chicken Alfredo tonight In addition to the Pepperoni/Beef and Deluxe pizzas that I normally get. It is amazing!!! The staff is amazing! They never disappoint me! Kudos to all Buttercrust staff! You all are AMAZING AND SO IS YOUR PIZZA! read more

Food is very fresh. Customer service needs work and delivery time. Online website has major issues in ordering. Sometimes it tends to choose in incorrect location when selecting the correct site. Inside the restaurant is fantastic. read more

My kiddos like the pizza better now. We love that they deliver to McIntosh, and I love the wings! You should post an online menu!

This used to be the best pizza place in the east mountains. Not sure what happened but now the food is bad and the service is worse. The last order we got, the egg in the salad was moldy. Not just a little moldly. A lot moldy. read more

Horrible place to eat. There rude. We got gift cards for Christmas and they dont even accept gift cards. How can places sell.gift cards in the same town at stores but you cant even use them. Very disappointed in the money I spent. Especially when we live 40 miles to the other pizza 9's read more