Our first time here. The store is clean and bright, and there is a lovely selection of bagels! Lots…read moreof varieties of cream cheese available. The counter help was smiling, helpful, and efficient. We ordered breakfast sandwiches on bagels of course, and they were great. I'm looking forward to stopping in for a half dozen next time we're in town!

Pale, underbaked, raw inside non bagels. Flat, oversalted. Not chewy or crispy. So bad I don't know…read morehow they can call a low gluten, underbaked, under developed, non boiled bagel a bagel. Bagels must be boiled. They are made with a high protein flour. They are risen. They are baked until golden brown. Someone here needs to learn what a bagel is and how to make one.

Not impressed, overpriced for minimal meat and cheese portion. Does not look like the pictures on…read morewebsite at all. Doesn't come with fruit or served on a plate, comes in a paper bag. Def not the place you're looking for if you want to try incorporating protein.

Always like trying to stop here when traveling. The bagels are always tasty and we like that they…read morehave a wheat option some days. Daily varieties of the bagels vary, so check the calendar if you're looking for specifics. The veggie cream cheese has become a favorite as it's packed with thick cut veggies. All of the sandwiches we've tried have been pretty satisfying as well. They also have a freezer section and fridge section where you can find soups, bagels, cream cheese, and other desserts. There are locally made products like jewelry, jams, honey, and dishes. The staff is very friendly and there are plenty of tables and couches to lounge and eat. It's interesting that they're located in a fitness center, but this hidden jem is worth checking out. They clearly have a group of regulars!

Had an enjoyable breakfast with my friend. Amber was a great server who made fresh coffee for us…read more Wonderful food and service!!

Service is soild, can be a line at times but absolutely love the bagel sandwiches in the Morning or…read morefor lunch

Quick service, delicious food, cool crowd. Swung by my favorite bagel spot in GB after a short…read moreweekend and was not disappointed.

Quick service! There was a line that moved fast, the store is spacious, and everything was…read moreperfect. A great place to stop for great bagels and coffee especially if you're on the run!

Not many places have $5 BEC sandwiches anymore. Stopped by on a work trip. Quick friendly, with…read morelots of tables to sit. Enjoyed my bagel and worked a little bit. Definitely stop by if you want a local bagel spot.

A large selection of fresh bagels to choose from. I was greeted with a smile ( that means more than…read moremost servers think). The breakfast sandwich I got was very good, the only thing I didn't care for was the amount of cream cheese they put on my Bagel. Next time I will ask for less. Others might like extra cheese. The restaurant looked clean and well kept. I will be back. Thank you.

Very unorganized for a place that serves breakfast items. 7…read moream, upon opening, no bagels in baskets, she was scrambling around saying "we have them all they just are not out yet"? Really, how unprepared for a business that serves early clients breakfast. Not pleasant to me at all. ordered a simple bagel with cream cheese, person from kitchen was asked to come out to make mine. She does, hands me the bag and turns around like I was an inconvenience. This place has gone downhill in the last 3 years for sure. Very, very unorganized. Should come in sooner to make sure you are set up properly and you can give your clients professional service. I gave two stars only because the bagel was good.

Atmosphere: Located in a strip mall so there was ample parking. The inside was really clean…read more Service: Professional and they were pretty fast too. I don't know what people are expecting when they come here, I mean these guys are probably making minimum wage, if they aren't all cheer and sunshine can you blame them? They were nice enough and did their job well. Can't believe how bucky some of these reviews are about the service not smiling enough or being gung ho about getting them coffee and a bagel. You don't see people demanding that kind of enthusiasm at a McDs. Coffee: I got a mocha and my friend got some blended freezy coffee, both were good and reasonably priced. Next time I'm back I am looking forward to trying a smooth and grabbing a muffin or bagel.

Rarely am I taken aback by quality customer service on its own - but walking into the bakery, I was…read moregreeted with a wave of warmth and kindness that seems hard to find these days. Had a lovely conversation with the owner and staff - so refreshing to walk into a place that feels like an extension of the community - not just another mundane commercial transaction. I'm from out of town, but if Fon Du Lac is looking for positive ambassadors for to represent the small business community, my experience at Bagelmeister wins my vote. All this before I even tried the bagel - which was unsurprisingly incredible. Thank you to the whole team! I'll be back next time I swing through!

Great bagels with cream cheese but stingy with the cream cheese amount. Ordered a bagel with…read morecream cheese and husband enjoyed his but we had to order it with and pay for extra cream cheese to get an approximate amount that was enough for the bagel. Iced latte and almond milk hot latte were excellent. The strawberry banana smoothie was BEST he'd had. Lady making them and the coffees was very happy and friendly. We will be back next time in Fondy and order the "extra" cream cheese.

I mean, why would I expect to get a fine ass bagel from SHEBOYGAN??!…read more After a failed attempt at Covid Harry's, we went here for a quick bite. Boy were we surprised. The bagels? Crisp and crackly on the outside, soft inside. These are the fucking lightest bagels I have ever shoved in my mouth. Their breakfast sandwiches? Cooked to order using real ingredients. That egg was fluffy and eggy, that sausage nice and juicy. Even better? They are taking covid very seriously. Masked staff, they poured your fountain drinks themselves, tables were clearly spaced and labeled as sanitized. I'm a fan. We ate in, then bought some more bagels to go. Even when they got cold they were still chewy and delicious.

According the website, they're open from 630a-3p. Currently sitting outside their Sheboygan…read morelocation at 830a and they are in fact NOT OPEN. Won't be going there anymore. Service definitely needs improvement.