Order Brooklyn Water Bagel Takeout or Delivery
Brooklyn Water Bagel Photos
Business Info
Brooklyn Water Bagel Popular Desserts
BROOKLYN WATER BAGEL ATMOSPHERE
What's the vibe?
You might also consider
More like Brooklyn Water Bagel
Recommended Reviews - Brooklyn Water Bagel
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Great soft bagels and friendly service Parking can be tricky as it's a busy plaza, but there plenty of spots - you may just have to walk a little ways. The inside is small but clean with a huge selection of coffees and accoutrement. My favorite part are the frozen coffee ice cubes they use so your coffee doesn't get watered down! I had the pastrami egg and cheese on everything bagel and it was fantastic. Could have had more meat, but it was a fluffy bagel with fresh egg so I can't complain. There's a nice large patio shared with the Mexican restaurant next door. Great for my dog and I! If you love bagels and or coffee - definitely com here
I recently returned from NYC and immediately began my spiritual pilgrimage: finding an Orlando bagel that even remotely compares to New York's finest. My standards? Astronomical. My expectations? Realistic. I knew they probably wouldn't be met... but hope is a powerful thing. I showed up Sunday at 10:30am fully prepared for a line out the door. To my surprise, the majority of the people were a swarm of Uber Eats drivers. God bless them.Delivering to the masses while also blocking those of us who physically made it out of bed. The place itself has plenty of seating inside and outside, which I appreciated. Service was... okay. I got a kid at the counter who looked like a deer in headlights. Sweet? Yes. Confident in anything happening? Absolutely not. it was just a kid. Maybe a little more training wouldn't hurt. Now, the important part: the bagel. I ordered the sourdough everything bagel in an egg sandwich and grabbed a Black Russian bagel to go (I think that's what it's called -- if not, forgive me). And honestly? Solid. Respectable. It came close. Not quite NYC-level but ok. The coffee, however... no. I ordered one where the ice cubes are made of coffee Unfortunately, it had a mysterious aftertaste that I'm still trying to identify. Burnt? Bitter? Existential disappointment? Hard to say. The place was clean, and there were plenty of staff walking around making sure everything looked good, which I appreciated. Would I come back? Maybe. It's in the running. But my Orlando Bagel Quest continues. The perfect one has yet to reveal itself.
Believe the word on the street these guys do have the best bagels. Is it the water? I don't know, but these are the best. Their spreads are pretty good as well even though pricey. Honestly the highlight of their breakfast sandwiches is mostly the bagels. They are not bad but after trying a couple I find myself coming back only to buy bagels. Their onion , Everything and asiago bagels are something else! They do have some interesting drinks that may be worth checking out. Those are in my to do list. The service is generally speedy though the employees seem to be droning about without much motivation. For the most is a bit loud and crowded but its to be expected of this type of shop. In summary Great bagels Worth checking out. Be warned, might ruin all other bagels for you.
Being from Brooklyn, I'm a little hard with this review lol First, let me say that I thoroughly enjoyed this bagel. It had the same thickness and texture of a bagel I'd get from home. I've tried a few bagels from here and I'm never disappointed. This time, I tried the bacon, egg, and cheese. Immediately, I was a little sad about the wrapping, simply because the paper gets stuck to the warm bagel and it was extremely hard to pick off. However, the sandwich was tasty and I enjoyed it. Did it taste like a baconeggandcheese from the bodega? No. But I'll take it. I ordered my sandwich through UberEats this go round and I was a little disappointed that adding butter to the toasted bagel on the sandwich was an additional $1.20. Otherwise, I'll definitely visit again when I'm in the mood for something that makes me feel closer to home.
I love this spot for a quick breakfast. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese bagel with a side hash brown, and putting the hash brown right inside the bagel makes it an unbeatable combo. The kitchen was running a bit slow and my food took a long time, but the staff handled it perfectly. They gave us a free coffee and a muffin to make up for the wait. That is exactly what great customer service looks like. Highly recommend.
I'm a sucker for smoked salmon on a bagel, and Brooklyn Water Bagel is always so generous with the amount of salmon in the Williamsburg! I upgraded to scallion cream cheese this time, but it's my favorite menu item by far. The staff is always welcoming, and I love that you can see the bagel making equipment as part of the aesthetic/decor inside. The bagels themselves are really delicious too.
Damn, I love their iced coffee. I'm glad I forget about it from time to time because, otherwise, I'd want it every morning. And that's way too much caffeine for me! More places need to take notes and offer us coffee ice cubes. I mean how perfect is that concept for summer in Florida?! Genius. The bagels are good but not too different than other bagel shops I've had around Oviedo/WP. Also, why are bagel sandwiches so pricey now? It's getting ridiculous. I want to make breakfast at home to save money but the coffee keeps me coming back.
Always love coming to Brooklyn Water Bagel! Felicia was incredibly kind and took the time to give me great bagel recommendation! Her friendly attitude and excellent customer service made my visit even better! Thanks, Felicia!
These bagels are very good, but they are not exactly NY bagels. They are generous with the cream cheese, which makes me happy. The sandwiches are very customizable. Just keep in mind that the price of toppings can quickly add up. The service is great, and the line moves quickly. I love that they have coffee ice cubes for their iced coffee. The coffee itself is pretty basic, but it's nice that it won't get watered down as the ice melts. I would definitely return if I was in the area and craving a bagel.
Friendly and quick service, perfectly crafted bagels that remind me of home, and a tasty selection of fun spreads!
Came here for a quick breakfast. This is close to where I live so I figured I'd revisit since it had been a while since I'd stop to eat here. This place is located in a Publix Shopping Plaza so there is a parking lot (always a plus). I ordered a breakfast sandwich and added chicken to it for a little heartier of a meal. I did get the order to go, but there is some limited seating inside and some additional seating outside. The bagel sandwich was good. The service was pleasant. As for ambiance, it is a bagel shop so it is what you'd expect. I'll have to swing back through here and try their coffee, as I noticed they have coffee ice cubes which I think is smart. Long story short - food was good and solid when you're needing something to eat and be on your way.
I've always passed Brooklyn water Bagel everytime I drive on Goldenrod and finally decided to stop in. Walking inside it was smaller than I expected but spacious enough to sit down and eat. I ordered at the counter and the worker was really nice answering questions and making suggestions. I ordered the Hot Honey Bacon Egg and Cheese with an orange juice and my husband ordered the Brooklyn Sandwich. Both sandwiches came out hot and stuffed which is always nice. We both enjoyed how the bagels were fresh and soft. The sandwiches have good flavor and are filling. We really enjoyed our breakfast and will be back. My husband ordered the Iced Coffee Cubsta and he really enjoyed that the ice cubes were also made out of coffee so that your drink doesn't get watered down when it melts. I'm not into coffee but after tasting the Cubsta I might have to order one next visit. Overall service was great and the sandwiches were worth the price, can't wait to come back and try a different sandwich.
Long time customer - left and came back to give another shot. Bagels don't have enough cream cheese on them. Bagel $1.99 CC $2.30- Brooklyn bagel no longer gives you a respectable portion of cream cheese. Returned the food and was told that "not everyone likes a lot of smear"- however for a very long time 1 bagel had enough smear for 2 bagels. Disappointed and finding a new bagel spot.
4 months ago
Enjoyed a nice breakfast at Brooklyn Water Bagels. We tried their new sourdough ET bagel. It was very tasty and filling. The amount of ET seasoning on the bagel was perfect. I do wish the bagel was more toasted with more of a crunch to it. It was a little too soft. We also ordered a bagel sandwich. It was very tasty. Lastly, we also ordered their iced coffee. I love that you can fill your own coffee and then go back for refills on the same visit. The coffee is ok. I think it used to be better back in the day. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Jennifer! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed our new…
2 months ago
Business owner information
Christi B.
MacEy, we appreciate you sharing this. It’s disappointing to hear…
22 days ago
This is one of my favorite bagel spots. This service is quick nice friendly atmosphere. It's always crowded. They're absolutely delicious. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Pamela, it’s wonderful to hear that even during busy times, you can…
Great soft bagels and friendly service Parking can be tricky as it's a busy plaza, but there plenty of spots - you may just have to walk a little ways. The inside is small but clean with a huge selection of coffees and accoutrement. My favorite part are the frozen coffee ice cubes they use so your coffee doesn't get watered down! I had the pastrami egg and cheese on everything bagel and it was fantastic. Could have had more meat, but it was a fluffy bagel with fresh egg so I can't complain. There's a nice large patio shared with the Mexican restaurant next door. Great for my dog and I! If you love bagels and or coffee - definitely com here read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Todd! We truly appreciate your feedback and are glad to…
I recently returned from NYC and immediately began my spiritual pilgrimage: finding an Orlando bagel that even remotely compares to New York's finest. My standards? Astronomical. My expectations? Realistic. I knew they probably wouldn't be met... but hope is a powerful thing. I showed up Sunday at 10:30am fully prepared for a line out the door. To my surprise, the majority of the people were a swarm of Uber Eats drivers. God bless them.Delivering to the masses while also blocking those of us who physically made it out of bed. The place itself has plenty of seating inside and outside, which I appreciated. Service was... okay. I got a kid at the counter who looked like a deer in headlights. Sweet? Yes. Confident in anything happening? Absolutely not. it was just a kid. Maybe a little more training wouldn't hurt. Now, the important part: the bagel. I ordered the sourdough everything bagel in an egg sandwich and grabbed a Black Russian bagel to go (I think that's what it's called -- if not, forgive me). And honestly? Solid. Respectable. It came close. Not quite NYC-level but ok. The coffee, however... no. I ordered one where the ice cubes are made of coffee Unfortunately, it had a mysterious aftertaste that I'm still trying to identify. Burnt? Bitter? Existential disappointment? Hard to say. The place was clean, and there were plenty of staff walking around making sure everything looked good, which I appreciated. Would I come back? Maybe. It's in the running. But my Orlando Bagel Quest continues. The perfect one has yet to reveal itself. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Hi Robert,…
Believe the word on the street these guys do have the best bagels. Is it the water? I don't know, but these are the best. Their spreads are pretty good as well even though pricey. Honestly the highlight of their breakfast sandwiches is mostly the bagels. They are not bad but after trying a couple I find myself coming back only to buy bagels. Their onion , Everything and asiago bagels are something else! They do have some interesting drinks that may be worth checking out. Those are in my to do list. The service is generally speedy though the employees seem to be droning about without much motivation. For the most is a bit loud and crowded but its to be expected of this type of shop. In summary Great bagels Worth checking out. Be warned, might ruin all other bagels for you. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Angel! We're thrilled to hear you think we have the best…
Being from Brooklyn, I'm a little hard with this review lol First, let me say that I thoroughly enjoyed this bagel. It had the same thickness and texture of a bagel I'd get from home. I've tried a few bagels from here and I'm never disappointed. This time, I tried the bacon, egg, and cheese. Immediately, I was a little sad about the wrapping, simply because the paper gets stuck to the warm bagel and it was extremely hard to pick off. However, the sandwich was tasty and I enjoyed it. Did it taste like a baconeggandcheese from the bodega? No. But I'll take it. I ordered my sandwich through UberEats this go round and I was a little disappointed that adding butter to the toasted bagel on the sandwich was an additional $1.20. Otherwise, I'll definitely visit again when I'm in the mood for something that makes me feel closer to home. read more
6 months ago
I love this spot for a quick breakfast. I ordered a bacon egg and cheese bagel with a side hash brown, and putting the hash brown right inside the bagel makes it an unbeatable combo. The kitchen was running a bit slow and my food took a long time, but the staff handled it perfectly. They gave us a free coffee and a muffin to make up for the wait. That is exactly what great customer service looks like. Highly recommend. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Cameron! We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed your breakfast…
8 months ago
I'm a sucker for smoked salmon on a bagel, and Brooklyn Water Bagel is always so generous with the amount of salmon in the Williamsburg! I upgraded to scallion cream cheese this time, but it's my favorite menu item by far. The staff is always welcoming, and I love that you can see the bagel making equipment as part of the aesthetic/decor inside. The bagels themselves are really delicious too. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Corrina! We're thrilled to hear that you love our smoked…
1 year ago
Damn, I love their iced coffee. I'm glad I forget about it from time to time because, otherwise, I'd want it every morning. And that's way too much caffeine for me! More places need to take notes and offer us coffee ice cubes. I mean how perfect is that concept for summer in Florida?! Genius. The bagels are good but not too different than other bagel shops I've had around Oviedo/WP. Also, why are bagel sandwiches so pricey now? It's getting ridiculous. I want to make breakfast at home to save money but the coffee keeps me coming back. read more
4 months ago
Always love coming to Brooklyn Water Bagel! Felicia was incredibly kind and took the time to give me great bagel recommendation! Her friendly attitude and excellent customer service made my visit even better! Thanks, Felicia! read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Yariliz, Felicia is fantastic! We love that you always enjoy coming…
These bagels are very good, but they are not exactly NY bagels. They are generous with the cream cheese, which makes me happy. The sandwiches are very customizable. Just keep in mind that the price of toppings can quickly add up. The service is great, and the line moves quickly. I love that they have coffee ice cubes for their iced coffee. The coffee itself is pretty basic, but it's nice that it won't get watered down as the ice melts. I would definitely return if I was in the area and craving a bagel. read more
2 years ago
Came here for a quick breakfast. This is close to where I live so I figured I'd revisit since it had been a while since I'd stop to eat here. This place is located in a Publix Shopping Plaza so there is a parking lot (always a plus). I ordered a breakfast sandwich and added chicken to it for a little heartier of a meal. I did get the order to go, but there is some limited seating inside and some additional seating outside. The bagel sandwich was good. The service was pleasant. As for ambiance, it is a bagel shop so it is what you'd expect. I'll have to swing back through here and try their coffee, as I noticed they have coffee ice cubes which I think is smart. Long story short - food was good and solid when you're needing something to eat and be on your way. read more
I've always passed Brooklyn water Bagel everytime I drive on Goldenrod and finally decided to stop in. Walking inside it was smaller than I expected but spacious enough to sit down and eat. I ordered at the counter and the worker was really nice answering questions and making suggestions. I ordered the Hot Honey Bacon Egg and Cheese with an orange juice and my husband ordered the Brooklyn Sandwich. Both sandwiches came out hot and stuffed which is always nice. We both enjoyed how the bagels were fresh and soft. The sandwiches have good flavor and are filling. We really enjoyed our breakfast and will be back. My husband ordered the Iced Coffee Cubsta and he really enjoyed that the ice cubes were also made out of coffee so that your drink doesn't get watered down when it melts. I'm not into coffee but after tasting the Cubsta I might have to order one next visit. Overall service was great and the sandwiches were worth the price, can't wait to come back and try a different sandwich. read more
6 months ago
Long time customer - left and came back to give another shot. Bagels don't have enough cream cheese on them. Bagel $1.99 CC $2.30- Brooklyn bagel no longer gives you a respectable portion of cream cheese. Returned the food and was told that "not everyone likes a lot of smear"- however for a very long time 1 bagel had enough smear for 2 bagels. Disappointed and finding a new bagel spot. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Hi Michele,…
8 months ago
I'm a HUGE bagel guy, and I gotta say these are some of the best bagels in town. I ordered the Leo this time which featured smoked salmon, eggs, onions, and som cream cheese. This would be a 5 star sandwich if there was some seasoning on the egg, but it was still really good. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Sergio! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed our…
My partner bought bagels home for lunch and it was great, I picked the salmon cream cheese, red onion on an everything bagel. The Bagel was toasted, firm and had a nice flavor. Salmon was pretty basic but overall, really great, tasty! Quick easy lunch on a busy work day! read more
8 months ago
Great breakfast sandwiches that are a great size. My personal favorite is the Brooklyn on an everything bagel which has ham, sausage and bacon. Their chicken salad is also a repeat purchase of mine, a little pricey but great deli style chix salad. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Lindsay! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoy our breakfast…
9 months ago
It's all about the water! Brooklyn Water Bagel has quickly become my new favorite spot in the Ovideo, Florida area. I am always greeted immediately and with a smile upon walking in to the restaurant, and receive my food fast every time. Their bagels are always amazing, and are a great choice for breakfast! If you're looking to be in and out in under 5 minutes, give Brooklyn Water Bagel a try. 5/5, can't wait to come back! read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Gracie! We're thrilled to hear that Brooklyn Water Bagel…
6 months ago
Business owner information
Christi B.
Hi Dea,…
6 months ago
No onions or capers which makes the entire sandwich, so that's was pretty disappointing. The main issue however, is that the salmon, is so tough and stringy, it's sadly inedible. As for the $8 coffee, I learned my lesson. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Hi Jane,…
7 months ago
Ordered Pastrami Egg & Cheese and I'm trying to figure out where the meat is, mind you the sandwiches are 9$... I got it when I pregnant and it was loaded with meat so I'm confused. I tried to call and they sent me to vm 3 times read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Hi Adjowa,…
Bagels were amazing with a range to choose from. Their coffee was amazing too, where one can serve themselves as much coffee along with other add ons like milk or creamer when have bought the cup where the ice is coffee cubes! Seating is provided inside and out, the only downside is that it is kind of seen as "dirty" to some. Bagels can also be bought in packs such as buying 6 individual bagels if wanted for later. read more
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you for your positive review! We're thrilled to hear that you…
9 months ago
They charge $2 for the bagel, then an addition $2+ for the cream cheese. All in a $5 bagel is way overpriced but the worst part is paying $2+ for cream cheese and they barely put any cheese on your bagel. Where's the rest of the $2 I paid for? read more
5 months ago
Business owner information
Christi B.
Hi Don,…
10 months ago
Business owner information
Christi B.
Thank you, Linda! We truly appreciate your kind words and are…
11 months ago
Good bagel sandwiches! They offer gluten free plain and everything which are made in house which is so hard to find! They are very busy so be prepared if you go to wait a little bit! read more
11 months ago
2 years ago
Solid bagels for Orlando! I like the bagels far more than the coffee here. Friendly service as well. They could do a better job of keeping it clean in my opinion. read more
2 years ago
Came in while doing a Girlscouts booth with my daughter. Bagels are made fresh you can see them making the bagels from the window. They have so many options! The service was good they were so nice even gave us a discount. read more
3 years ago
It's the Cubsta for me that tips Brooklyn over the edge. Dont know how everyone has not adopted that. If you don't know, BWB offers frozen coffee cubes instead of regular ice to keep your ice coffee from getting watered down (now you know). Their bagels are distinctive. If you're looking for an extra soft and chewy bagel, this isn't it. Their everything bagel seasoning is legit and they scoop out some of the inside of the bagel to make room for their delicious schmear (get the scallion cream cheese and thank me later). I usually go everything with scallion cream cheese and an iced coffee or the Williamsburg (seen in photo). read more
3 years ago
I guess if you go to a bagel place, a bagel should be your first choice on bread. Not that there was anything wrong with the rye toast that cradled my tuna salad, it just looked flimsy, even with the help of the leaf lettuce and sliced red onion to help bolster the look. Sandwich didn't come with chips or a pickle. Chips are an up charge and the pickle lost and forgotten. Table was not full of crumbs but not freshly wiped down either. Music was tad loud but not inappropriate for the college lunch crowd waiting on their orders. read more
1 year ago
Stumbled upon this place on vacation and it did not disappoint. Staff was nice and patient since I was a first timer. I ended up ordering two everything bagel sandwiches with bacon, egg, and cheese. The bagels were nicely toasted and packed with the toppings. The bagel itself was really good, not too heavy like some bagels can be. I also ordered an iced coffee for my bf. I liked that they use ice cubes made out of coffee so it doesn't get watered down. read more
Being from the northeast srate of New Jersey, I grew up surrounded by great bagel places. Having been raised in New Jersey and in the shadow of New York City, it seemed that there was a never-ending supply of great bagel shops, whether it be in the Garden State or in New York City itself. When I move to Florida, I was both saddened and dismayed to learn that great bagels we're not the norm for the Sunshine State. In fact, what I wanted to get my bagel fix, I would be forced to resort to a place like Panera Bread or Dunkin' Donuts you get what could be at best a mediocre bagel and certainly nothing like the great bagel shops that I had growing up. That is not to say that Brooklyn Water Bagel offers a life-changing bagel. It certainly does not. In New Jersey, it would be mediocre. However, as Dorothy found herself and a different land when she ended up in Oz, I certainly realize that I am not in New Jersey anymore. So, while Florida has some great food, Brooklyn Water Bagel is one of the better places that you will find to get a bagel down here in Florida. This particular location is conveniently located and a shopping plaza with a Publix for an anchor store. So, since it is in a shopping plaza, parking is not an issue. It is also pretty conveniently-located. It is located on the corner of University Boulevard and Goldenrod Road. The bagels here are good, especially when you consider that you are in Florida and the service is friendly. I would definitely recommend here. read more
9 months ago
9 months ago
Page 1 of 12
More info about Brooklyn Water Bagel
4026 N Goldenrod Rd
Winter Park, FL 32792
Directions
(407) 681-4011
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
https://www.brooklynwaterbagel.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Brooklyn Water Bagel Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Brooklyn Water Bagel
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
20 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
12 years ago
7 years ago
4 months ago
4 years ago
7 years ago
1 year ago
11 years ago
10 years ago
4 years ago
13 years ago
8 years ago
6 years ago
10 years ago
4 years ago
6 years ago
7 years ago
11 years ago
12 years ago
