Solid classic Brooklyn style nyc slice. Margarita slice was reasonable in price but solid size. Service was friendly and ambiance is simple very clean and had a decent amount of seating inside and outside. It worth a stop if you're in the area read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 5 Margherita - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place is legit. Found myself in the neighborhood and needed a pizza fix. 2 slices and a Coke $13. It hit the spot. read more

The pizza is very good, the staff is very friendly and responsive when calling in an order not on the menu, have eaten in the cozy dining area. The tomato sauce used in the Margherita pizza is mildly sweet and spicy with generous amounts of mozzarella cheese, the medium thin crust has just enough chewiness. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 5 Margherita - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I just had a grandma pizza at it was solid: very crunchy crust and soft and airy dough. I'd definitely return. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great food!! I ordered online and had it delivered. The ordering process was easy, the food came earlier than promised and it was hot and delicious!! we ordered an upside down Sicilian pizza because it sounded interesting, and it was! The cheese under the sauce stayed so melty for so long, and the sauce is incredible! We also ordered the rice balls as an appetizer, they were delicious! And we had an order of Spaghetti Bolognese that was huge and so delicious! We will definitely be back read more

See all

Don't get me wrong Joe's pizza is good... But if you don't want to wait in line and a better pizza this place is the place to go! Best pizza in manhattan. read more

Confirmed per Dave Portnoy it's an 8.5 pizza. Absolutely loved it, went two nights in a row. Don't let the pizza sit in the box too long though or it gets soggy. Amazing pizza!! read more

The perfect place for lunch the pizza is delicious and they even have specialty slices which is amazing. It's really fast and there's places to sit so when you're on your lunch break, you can actually enjoy what you're eating. They got good music and the staff was really friendly and super helpful. This is definitely my go to pizza place for lunch. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The square vodka slice was amazing, absolutely delicious. The grandma slice was also delicious and you can taste the garlic in the sauce. However, the New York cheese slice was really bad. Too cheesy, sauce was forgettable and crust was not good. I had to stop eating it halfway because it was that bad. Then I take a bite of the vodka square and it goes back to delicious. read more

I'm visiting NYC and needed an authentic ny slice. I always compare pizza places based on their slices of cheese pizza. The cheese at Brooklyn Pizza Masters was incredible. Nice and hot, crispy, and perfectly foldable (as a slice of pizza should be.) I love this place and can't wait to go back and try their other pies. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 1. Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pizza has joined the list of foods with price increases, but the small vegetarian pie we had here was excellent, really terrific, and worth the money. Teen grandson, visiting from a Boston suburb, must have NYC pizza every visit. At the end of a very long day, traipsing from Fort Tryon Park and the Cloisters on the A train down to the Village, pastries and iced coffee on Bleecker St., over to the Hudson, up some of the Hudson walkway, on Little Island and some piers, you get the picture - by the time we got up as far as Chelsea we were exhausted and hungry. We hopped the E uptown and ate in our neighborhood at Brooklyn Pizza Masters. Walked into a very busy place, people coming in and quickly leaving with boxes, we grabbed one of the tables, decided what we wanted, and hubs got up to order the pie. 15/20 minutes later, we had a steaming hot, crisp thin crust, topped with zucchini, olives, and more, yummy cheese and tomato sauce, HEAVEN! Pizza heaven! Last summer we did takeout from here when a different grandchild was visiting, spinach and mushrooms, also loaded with toppings and delish. Highly recommend! read more

These guys really don't miss on anything they make. Fantastic pizza, delicious pasta, and I just tried a panini and it's phenomenal too! It's a bit steeper than your usual pizza joint but the quality is undoubtedly superior. My recommendations: Prosciutto arugula slice Penne alla vodka Meatball panini (the focaccia is perfect and isn't the scratch your mouth kind!) read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Grilled chicken Pollo Grigliato Panini - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Went into this spot just to grab a quick slice and mama mia! The guy at the counter told me in about 2 minutes a fresh pie would be out ! Worth it! Worth it! Worth it! Thin crispy crust with that extra sauce and perfect amount of cheese! I am hooked! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 1. Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is the BEST pizza I have ever had. I took my friend from Florida, and she also agrees. Fantastic slices, we had to go back in for more. We are currently debating going in for a third. 10000/10 read more

Omg this pizza is best pizza I ever had. Hands down born and raised in queens and now in midtown east. I love love love love this place and super good prices and super fast delivery. Top notch quality read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Small margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Their vodka sauce square pizza is my new favorite slice in the world. The workers are nice. The place is clean. And everything on the counter looks fresh. read more

This is excellent pizza. This is my go-to for both myself and also whenever I have out-of-towners visiting. Very underrated in my opinion, but selfishly hope it stays that way to avoid long lines. Very nice workers as well read more

When I inquired about a restroom, the guy pointed to a door marked "Out of Order" saying, "Never mind the sign, it's just for decoration." The star of the show, however, was not the 8.5 One bite score but the grandma pizza, which, against all odds, rivaled the sophistication of their fresh mixed mushroom and truffle oil masterpiece. It was as if Grandma herself, in a daring act of culinary defiance, decided to throw down the gauntlet in the face of haute cuisine, proving once and for all that love, when baked at the right temperature, can indeed rival truffle oil. https://youtu.be/qO1nGyMpbGg?si=C_T2-G59cBiyhYx6 read more

See all

One bite, everyone knows the rules. The 8.5 rating stand up. Great pizza, great crust, great taste. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Margarita Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Side note: Order directly from their website. It just runs better and there's less fees. Most sites suck outside of SLICE for delivering pizza so this should be well known. Also this isn't your traditional slice spot even if they make good one. Go over an avenue or across the street for that stuff. Anyway, surprised I never wrote a review for this spot. I went here several times while I was in the area. Sure it's pricey but the slices are massive and unique. My preference is their Prosciutto. This consists of Grande mozzarella, caramelized onions, goat cheese, and prosciutto topped with parmigiano reggiano and EVOO. The goat cheese added some tang while the onions add sweetness. One of their more "normal" slices is the Grandma (Grande mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, marinara, garlic, topped with extra virgin olive oil/EVOO, basil, and parmigiano reggiano) and it is quite tasty. The upside down Sicilian; a Sicilian pie with mozzarella on the bottom and topped with marinara sauce, pecorino romano, oregano, and EVOO; is also quite good. The pie is very messy but they have a good tomato sauce and it reminded me almost more of a very tomato focused bruschetta rather than a slice outside of it being hot. I also had the vodka slice once. It was quite good as well. I think remember having one other that I liked (presumably the bianco) which I remember liking a lot. They gave me once a zeppoli with nutella as they were closing soon which was very nice of them and it was quite delicious here. Overall they have great slices here. Never got a full pie. Only had pasta once which was fine (why would I judge however. It's a pizza place and why judge a pizza place for pasta.) Good pricey slice spot. Just get from their website. Mid 4. My preferred non traditional place along with the popular Romana on Lex but I prefer the slices here. Photos in case they don't attach https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/brooklyn-pizza-masters-new-york?select=-nmfm2hm3nfqEeprSY5LOg Prosciutto https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/brooklyn-pizza-masters-new-york?select=XmaGGrfOI6WKELV8zm1yTw Alt prosciutto https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/brooklyn-pizza-masters-new-york?select=08j_KxTY1waIZgtVdB1myw Upside down Sicilian https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/brooklyn-pizza-masters-new-york?select=YyJPG_EgT8V8QrQKTMZkWQ Chinotto drink (I believe they use a different brand now because of Covid but not sure) read more

Get yourself an upside down Sicilian pie and send me a thank you message later. It is one of the best pizza options in the neighborhood despite its $30 price tag. They also have a nice fried calzone called a panzerotti. A little greasy but a nice change of pace from the standard oven baked versions. read more

Flavorful, large slices. My only call out was the price per slice. I got two slices, no meat on either, and it was almost $11. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 8. Bianco Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Okay obsessed! The pizza is a great price and really delicious. My go-to is the cheese slice. It's thin, crispy, foldable and the cheese to sauce ratio is perfect. The bbq chicken is a square slice and was also really good. Highly recommend! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 1. Cheese Pizza BBQ Chicken - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Buffalo chicken - normally don't like chicken on pizza but this slice made everything right. 9/10, perfectly tangy Vodka sauce pizza - best slice I've had this week in NYC. 10/10 Pepperoni pizza - as great as you would expect from this staple of pizza. 9/10 Overall, the crispness of the crust was amazing - it was soft and crisp on all slices! Couldn't ask for much more when it comes to delivering on pizza expectations in NY! read more

See all

Not sure how pizza gets cold when it is delivered 1 block away. I ordered 3 slices they all came cold. The sicilian had no cheese! I ordered 2 sodas. They forgot to bring them. I even ordered an extra slice because of the "minimum". I don't think that I set my expectations too high but there are 5 pizza places in a 3 block radius so I'm good never ordering from here again. The worst part was when I called to get the soda and tell them about the cold slices, the women said something about next time I ordered..... seriously? read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I'm a huge fan of fruit + cheese on pizza, and Brooklyn pizza masters is the place to go for it! Pear and Gorgonzola is an absolute treat on the palate! That blackberry and ricotta though, is next level yum - this is the only pizza place I know of that has it, and it's just so refreshing and light. Excellent service. Love that there's plenty of seating - with some outdoor seating too. If it weren't $6 bucks per specialty slice, I'd be eating here more often, but as it is, it's reserved for "treat myself" days. Not really a place I would ever want to get the plain or pepperoni pizzas, because .... Why when there are so many other delicious options here that you can't get elsewhere. read more

See all

Pizza was great. I got two slices of cheese which were extremely crispy, slightly sweet and cooked sauce, and tasty cheese. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pizza is very good, and we absolutely love the food but I'd highly recommend getting individual slices OR picking it up rather getting a pie delivered. The couple times we did family pizza night, the pizza came with cheese all over the sides of the box, some slices didn't have any toppings on it because things moved all around. read more

Yyyyup! The reviews are true this is a great pizzeria. Grew up and live on the UES for 20+ years and this is the best NY slice I've had in the neighborhood. Crisp but not crunchy, well structured, thin but substantive and pillowy. Clearly comes from a good dough. Got a small vodka pie with extra sauce and threw some roasted red peppers on there, BOOM. This is no restaurant depot vodka sauce it's rich and flavorful. With this sauce, I think they could go viral on social media with a spicy vodka pizza/rigatoni dish. Think about it guys! Can't wait to try their pepperoni, margarita and grandma pizza. Ideally share a pie with someone else because it's addictively good. Whoops. read more

Best Grandma Pizza in the city. The sauce is best with garlic instead of others in onions. If you get it fresh right from the Master it's such a crunchy sensation that has to be experienced. Try it after a long day or trip and reward yourself. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Grandma pizza with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered delivery on a Wed night. Got their margherita pizza. It arrived pretty quick and hot, which was great. I felt I was eating mostly the same pizza that I'd be eating in the restaurant. The crust was quite thin so it was a bit soggy. The sauce was a little too salty, but overall it was a delicious, cheesy, saucy pizza with a decent amount of basil. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is the BEST damn pizza I have ever had in my life. It has been almost 4 months since I tried this pizza and it still haunts me. I find myself drooling sometimes out of nowhere just thinking about this pizza. I had the buffalo, black berry, white pie, and regular. The pizza bread alone has the perfect taste and texture that no other place can beat. That black berry though.... My bf goes to New York twice a month from Tampa. We are currently brainstorming how he's going to bring me back a slice next time he's there. I wish that this place would sell raw/frozen pies like a pizza place in Chicago. I once flew there, picked up a frozen pie and popped in the oven as soon as I got home and it was perfect! But one can only dream. Anyway, nice job, PIZZA MASTERS!! Best pizza in the world!!! PS. if you guys ever make a tikka masala pizza, I'll be on the next flight out. read more

Cozy pizza place with ample seating where you can get both slices and full pies. They have all of the fast-casual Italian staples in addition to pizza, including salads, panini's, and pastas. I got a slice of cheese pizza and a garlic knot, and both were huge!! The garlic knot was fantastic. The pizza had a great flavor, but the crust was a little too brittle for me. 8/10 read more

See all

I ordered a small pizza & it came completely all over the box, cheese stuck & off. Some slice had nothing. They also use the cheap sausage slices & not the crumbles. I called to complain about my order that was delivered by Uber eats & they just said next time order from us not our problem good luck! No, let us send you a new pizza & that it was pretty much my fault for ordering thru Uber eats. Needless to say I'll never order from there again. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Terrible pizza & look how it was delivered! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Tastiest pizza in NYC. Vodka slice is incredible. Fast service, shoutout to the guy and girl behind the register you are awesome!

I ordered a pizza that was supposed to have garlic on one half. It does not. Brooklyn Pizza Masters was very defensive and would not refund the $1.50 I was asking for. They absolutely insisted that garlic was on the pizza and would not refund the garlic. Photo is attached. There is no garlic. You can see that the entire pizza is the same. You cannot draw a line down the center of the pizza and distinguish the garlic side from the non-garlic side. They claimed the garlic is there, but it's just very fine. Ok, let's say there's some sort of microscopic invisible garlic on the pizza. My wife didn't want garlic, so if we can't see which side has the garlic and which side doesn't, then that's a problem in and of itself. Why would I order toppings on one half of the pizza if I can't tell which half is which? read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is an excellent pizza. Probably would have rated it higher if I didn't have to wait so long to eat it, since I grabbed this food on my walk to the hospital. The crust is everything you want in a crust, crispy exterior with just the right amount of chew. The sauce was excellent. Definitely will be back if I'm in that part of the city. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters has become my go to pizzeria. I was hooked on this place from my first delivery order. The Margherita Pizza here is insanely delicious and the garlic knots are one of a kind. Delivery is always fast and consistent. Try this pizzeria and you may never order from anywhere else again! read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 4. Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Shocklingly good. 8.5 from barstool and i think that is low. Best slice in UES without a doubt. Worth a stop and mention with some of the best read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - 4. Margherita Pizza 3. Large Grandma Pizza 14. Wild Mushrooms and White Truffle Oil Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Brooklyn Pizza Masters is the best neighborhood pizza in the Turtle Bay, Tudor City, Lennox Hill and beyond. Came here on a Friday before Valentines day with my girlfriend for our traditional around Valentines day pizza crawl and we were blown away. Super high 8.5 on One Bite, 9.1 in my book Frankie. if you are feeling a gourmet pizza (think gorgonzola pear or truffle mushroom) but want just a slice this is your place. But if you want a super classic delicious New York pizza slice this is your place too. You just can't go wrong. The service is super nice, very fast and efficient and super knowledgeable about the differences in their pizzas which is especially useful given that all their combos sound incredible and you are guaranteed to struggle with choosing your order. Oh and I forgot to mention they have enormous garlic knots and arancini... read more

Brooklyn Pizza Masters - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York