My husband works near here and this is a great, reliable place to grab a slice! I got the vodkaroni and my husband got the hot voddy and the good boy. All three were delicious without being too greasy, but still had that sought after cheese pull! This place is on the smaller side, but I've never seen someone waiting for a table. It gives a cozy kind of vibe. The staff are nice, friendly, and prompt. For three specialty slices and no drinks, it cost us about $14. read more

This is one of the many pizza spots around Midtown East, where I have primarily stopped for lunch, though I also had a slice as a snack. The place is rather small, and the service is a bit more curt than at some other places, such as the nearby Casiano's. For how small the place is, they have plenty of unique slices, and it's nice that the price includes tax. Speaking of which, the prices are an odd in-between compared to some other reasonable slice joints. They are a bit too high compared to some places, and not distinctly better enough to be worth it. The former place also has a combo at more reasonable times compared to here. Anyway, aside from all the comparisons, it has been a pretty good slice each time I've been here. Overall, the crust alone is much higher quality than La Pizza Italia, La Vista, or Little Italy, being nice and thin but not too much so. The sauce is also better with a bit of tartness, and it seems to be made with fresh tomatoes. I also like the cheese, and using fresh mozzarella in many of their slices is a good idea, as it is one of their definite highlights. The Fresh Mozzarella, at around $5.50, is the best slice here, as it highlights the cheese and sauce best. I haven't taken a photo of it, but it's very tasty. The plain slice, or as they call it, the Xeno, is about $4.25 and is solid. The Vodka here, which is a dollar or so extra, is solid, though I prefer the flavor at a few other places. I prefer a few other places, for deals or quality, but it's a good slice in an area that doesn't have many great ones. Mid/upper 3. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Vodka slice. Around $5.50 A bit pricey, but solid flavor - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I came here for a slice of pizza recently. The slice was on the pricey side but it was hot and fresh. There's so many different slices to choose from such as pepperoni, vodka slice, etc. They also serve garlic knots. The service was quick and professional. You can select from many different beverage options as well. I will be back here for pizza and possibly garlic knots. I dined when I came here. There's also a pizza special; two slices with a side for $8. read more

See all

Friendly people and a good slice. Small inside, but a decent slice to cap the day. Crispy crust and a little cheaper than other stops I've made. Worth another stop if I was back in NY. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pros: Friendly staff Delicious pizza Reasonably priced Busy Bright & colorful ambiance Cons: Zero read more

See all

Finally gave them a go... but, should have trusted my instincts. Upon first glance, you see that the cheese on practically everything behind the glass of their display case is cold and that their stock likely does not move much. Grabbed a chicken roll and 4 garlic knots. The garlic knots looked fluffy and fresh... but, looks can be deceiving.. which they certainly were in this instance. Though definitely garlicy, the consistency that bread was not ideal; sort of too firm even though they were light and airy. The chicken roll wasn't that much better. Served more like a traditional NYC pizzeria would a Stromboli... open ended and cut up into 4 pieces (IMO to heat up quickly) . The breading on the chicken cutlet was not very good. Thankfully I got two little containers of their marinara (which was a good bit on the sour end) that I was able to moisten and add flavor to these two items. I really wanted this place to be good so I could have a better pizza option while at work, but, sadly, it left a lot to be desired. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Garlic Knots and "Chicken Roll" - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Overall good pizza- nice quick service and classic slices. Can't ask for too much more- recommend d read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious! My son said it was better than the famous Joe's Pizza!! That's pretty impressive. read more

See all

Simply the best. Better than all the rest. They are better than anyone. ANYONE. Chicken Parm slice or bust. Excellent service. read more

Horrible, smelly pizza and pizzeria with tables that should be sanitized. I really hated this pizzeria and do not plan to return anytime soon. read more

See all

Very disappointed. While its undoubtedly a great chicken cutlet, this is NOT a chicken parm. I ordered the chicken parm over penne entree and this is what i got. I come here frequently for slices and enjoy them, so was excited to try and entree and was thoroughly disappointed. Updated: store owner reached out- this was a mistake by kitchen and will be refunded - Will try again in future! (Forgot to take photo before started eating) read more

Xeno’s Pizza - "Chicken parm" over penne - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

In NYC just for the weekend, so of course had to have some pizza! Too many choices near the hotel, so we figured it was best to ask at the hotel reception for recommendations, and they sent us in the right direction! Xeno's was a short walk from our hotel, small and modern looking, not busy at that time but they had a good selection of pies. We each tried a different one and were all very happy. I had the one with vodka sauce, cheese, and basil, and it was everything I envisioned. We sure got a good recommendation from the hotel staff. read more

See all

Awesome pizza shop in Midtown East off 52nd near 3rd Ave. It's clean with a few two tops of tables, quick service, and the staff is super welcoming and friendly. I ordered a slice of the Hot Voddy which was delicious, piping hot, had a wonderful crust that crisped up when reheated in the oven. The hubby got a slice of pepperoni which was so different from mine with the grease of the pepperoni but went really well with the tomato base. $12 for 2 slices and a soda. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Pepperoni and Hot Voddy - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I often stay at the Pod 51 hotel down the road, and so stopped by for a couple slices the other day. They were good -- nothing amazing, but solid NYC pizza. It's a well-lit shop. I also asked if they would fill my water bottle, which they were happy to do. I'll probably be back. read more

After a long meeting I decided with my friend to visit my favorite Pizza store in the area. As we walked they asked us very friendly what we wanted. of course I had my buffalo Pizza and the garlic knots. My friend had a pepperoni slice and an order of meatballs to go. Delicious food to the last bite. I wished we had a pizza store like that in our area. Keep up the excellent service read more

Great pizza! Love the crunch from the crust. I have been here three times and each time the pizza has been consistently delicious. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Great pizza for an okay price. Would come back. Seating inside and some outside. Buffalo pizza was a nice subtle Buffalo! Loved it. Garlic knots were my favorite. Water bottles available too. read more

See all

BLUF; fresh and delicious We were in DC for just a few days and looking for some genuine New York style pizza. Hard to find down in VA where we live now. Unfortunately our train got in late so we had to settle for something we could find quickly. I really didn't want to go into Xenos since it frankly looked a little too much like a chain restaurant. Wow. So glad we stopped. We got a Margherita pizza that was amazingly good. Fresh basil and cheese, crunchy crust, tangy sauce. We wolfed it down. Defintiely would go back. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

We ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza and 2 sides of meatballs. To start- the place is insanely clean for a pizza Joint. There were 2 guys making pizza and 1 guy who looked like he could be a vineyard vines model who was very attentive. At any rate, the pizza was good and the meatballs were shockingly tasty. We were all pleasantly surprised and not too full but nicely sated. read more

See all

Fast pizza with a crisp crust. We had the buffalo chicken, the ala vodka, the margherita and the sausage and pepper with onions. Tasty pizza with a thin crisp chewy crust. The 52nd and Lexington Avenue shop is small. There are two tables inside and two outside. We did takeout. The ala vodka and sausage were the tastiest. The sausage was a bit bland. The buffalo chicken needed more sauce and it was spicy but not really flavorful. Still a legitimate pizza. A decent selection of vegetarian options and the margherita could have used a tad more sauce. But I am all for helping a new pizza place find its footing. Give it a try. Kind and friendly staff. read more

See all

This place was so yummy. We saw the barstool one bite review and noticed it was close to our hotel so we walked over. The Hot Voddy slice was super yummy, but honestly the best bite we had there was the garlic knots though. Super light and airy but so much garlic goodness. read more

Hands down the best pizza I've had all week in this area (visiting from Virginia)! I love a good old slice of plain cheese pizza, but my companion pointed out the roasted veggie slice, so I had to try that too. The flavor was amazing! This is what I think of when I want a NY slice. The place was empty when we sat down, but it was packed by the time we left. Highly recommend this place. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Roasted vegetable pizza (red peppers, onions and mushrooms) with a balsamic glaze - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Worst meatball sub. Bread on bottom was sopping wet, yet there was no red sauce anywhere to be found. It was inedible. And on top if it, rude staff in the store. Next. read more

I really like this pizza spot--it takes me back to an old favorite I used to hit up in Brooklyn back in the day. The slices are hot, thin, and just the right length to remind you you're eating real NYC pizza. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is spot on, and the crust has that perfect crunch without being overly doughy. Plus, I just found out their lunch special is now offered all day, which is a total win in my book. Full disclosure: I usually go for the plain cheese because honestly, it's just that good. read more

Very good pizza!!! Very friendly place !! Clean also! customer service is great! Awesome read more

See all

Came in on a Friday night with some friends on St. Patty's day. We were headed to a couple more bars and I wanted to get something to eat before getting any more drinks in my system. The cashier was very welcoming. Served us very quick and the pizza was delicious. I think what differentiates this place is definitely the ambiance. On the inside you can see what looks like different routes on the train lines. With the proximity to the train station, I think it tied in very nicely as a theme. Overall cool spot to get a quick slice read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This was a very good pizza experience in midtown Manhattan, NYC. I visited on a Saturday night and to be expected there was an evening rush. After all, it is New York City on a Saturday night. What I enjoyed about this pizza is how large the slices are, thin the dough is, and the crispy crust. Everything you would expect from a traditional New York-style pizza. The cheese to tomato sauce ratio was very appropriate and standard. Since this was my first time trying this pizza I stuck to the basics and ordered one cheese and one pepperoni pizza. I was impressed with how they executed even the most basic pizza. They definitely take pride in preparing their pizzas and even on busy nights. I do recommend calling-in your order as I'm assuming it gets pretty busy on Saturday nights as was the case during my visit. But this is to be expected on at the height of the weekend. I will visit again when in the area. Give them a try. read more

See all

Bugs Bunny pizza is delicious! The balsamic vinaigrette gave the perfect amount of sweet and salty. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Bugs Bunny pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Worst pizza in nyc. Super wet and overpriced. Rude staff aswell they will overlook you and skip people who they like

I came here for a late dinner one night and loved the variety of different pizzas they had. Some had unique toppings too! They can be pricey though for the ones with the toppings. Definitely come during peak hours for the freshes slices. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Absolutely delicious. Great New York style thin crust and the staff was Super nice. I ate the meatball ricotta and also a slice of pepperoni. The meatballs were so tasty, sauce was sweet and pepperoni was perfectly crisp. read more

While I enjoy the pizza and garlic knots, the last couple of times I get the two slices of pizza squeezed in a paper bag with the garlic knots. The bag is not securely closed and greasy. So you know the aluminum that contains the garlic knots sticks on the pizza. Not to mention I am always the last person to receive my food, even when I order before others. Thought it was odd the first time, but starting to think it is not a coincidence after the second time. Management should have a discussion with your main guy that is there during weekdays at lunch time. read more

Xeno’s Pizza - Lady Margherita, Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The spot opened up right near my friends apartment, so I tried it on my way to her house recently and got a regular cheese slice as well as a buffalo chicken slice. The prices are pretty high per slice, and while I'm sure that's normal for this area the quality was just not there to back it up. The cheese was just mediocre and the buffalo chicken was kind of strange and didn't have a ton of actual flavor. It wasn't bad but personally I'd rather pay for a dollar slice somewhere nearby compared to this. It's so close to my friends apartment that I honestly may end up trying it again sometime so I will update my review if I do that. read more

Pizza is old, sits out all day....unpleasant workers. No idea how others recommend it!!

If you're in midtown, this if the place. They have a very good selection of sices to choose from and every single one we tried was awesome. The garlic knots are amazing. It's just a huge added bonus to get good food at under $10 a person in Manhattan and you don't need to wait in a huge line. I would recommend this place to anyone. read more

It's a good slice. Nothing great. I haven't tried the other stuff that looks pretty good but I planned to. If i could give it 3 and half stars, I would. read more

Asked if there was marinara sauce with the garlic knots he says yes it's in the bag. I got home and there was no sauce. Very disappointing

really great regular slice. flavorful cheese, they don't skimp. crispy fresh crust. better than other neighborhood slice shops. Thx Xenos!!!

Despite having great pizza, their cashier staff are, hands down, some of THE most rude, unlikable, ungrateful people I have ever crossed paths with. No further need to be insulted. I'll never go here again..... read more

Amazingly good slices - beats anything around the area. The char is just right and you can actually taste a lot of the different ingredients - there are no skipping corners here. The meatball and pepperoni are classics, but here they are way better; even the regular plain seems so much better, and this is coming from a native NY'er. read more