Gotham eeked its way up to four stars. Can't beat the $6 lunch deal: two plain slices and a can of soda. Since returning to the city, I've expanded my taste in pizza. I wasn't originally a fan of thin crust -- still wouldn't necessarily be my first choice -- but now I'm kinda liking it. And the pizza we had Friday, with the cornmeal crust was pretty good. If it was $10 I might be more critical. But $6 ...... ! read more

Gotham Pizza - $6 lunch special - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This was surprisingly one of the best slices I've ever had. The crust was flaky and not too doughy and the Buffalo chicken was very flavorful. The customer service was great and the staff was friendly. The restaurant was quiet and clean. I was so tempted to go back for another slice if I only had an extra stomach to fit it lol. Update: I went back for the BBQ chicken pizza and it not not disappoint. The crust is nice and crunchy and has bread crumbs in it. read more

Gotham Pizza - BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The afternoon lunch special of two cheese slices and a soda has gone up to $6 but it's still a good deal for a cheapie meal.

First Impressions - N/A I've been ordering delivery for the last several pizza parties at work. The Noms - margaritas used to be my favorite, but recently I fell in love with their Grandma pizza. The rest of my coworkers really like it too... that probably explains why we've ordered it five times in the last month... we used to order Famiglia... but ever since try and Gotham pizza, it has become our default place to order for any occasion... students last day of rotation, coworker's birthday, a party managers to distract the peasant staff... and the food is so good, there's almost never any leftovers. In conclusion - 10/10 would recommend. The pizzas are a little pricey. But ultimately worth it. If you split it between a few coworkers, it's really not that bad. The portions are pretty generous. read more

See all

Good pizza! This is NY pizza with a cornmeal crispy crust. The margherita is fresh and toasted perfectly with a great crust. The pepperoni slice held its own as well and similarly to the margherita slice, was toasted perfectly in the oven with a nice crisp crunch of the pepperoni layered on top. I'd stick to the ones with toppings as the ones without are surprising a little bland and keep that garlic/oregano shaker handy if going plain. This isn't a destination or the best pizza in NYC but it's certainly an option if in the local area. There is some seating out in front but it may be best to grab some to go and head to the nearby park benches to savor. read more

Gotham Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Slice & Margherita Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Scumbags, gabagool, Pokémon cards etc - 10/10 (Good pizza but don't use their bathroom) read more

Great lunch special for $6... two slices and a can of soda. Their regular thin crust is excellent, just want I want from a NY slice of thin crust. When I'm in this neighborhood, this is my regular go-to spot for a quick, yummy, cheap meal. read more

Another great NY pizza place. I'm definitely a pepperoni gal, so that's the flavor I'll be comparing between all of these places. The pepperoni pizza here has a great taste, and I tend to love pizza with a little bit of that grainy cornmeal texture on the crust, which this pizza has. The crust is thin and crisp, so if you're looking for something really doughy and bread-heavy, this probably isn't the pizza for you. It's a great price, though, about the same as Roma Pizza. So glad it's just a block and a half away from my place! read more

Gotham Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

So they no longer do any of the flavor-infused crusts and I would say that consistency needs to be a virtue. One of our pies was excellent - perfectly light crust with just the amount of chew and the crispiness you come to expect from Gotham - and a week later, the crust was a bit too crispy with no chew. The pies here are solid but not as amazing as they used to be. There is still a place for Gotham in the UES pizza rotation but not sure they will be my top pick each time now. read more

Got a Buffalo chicken slice that was good. Place was efficient and they accept credit card. Solid slice and the prices were fair. Solid pizza spot for a pie or a slice. read more

Gotham Pizza - Buffalo slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

My new go to neighborhood pizza! This is so so good, the pizza is always perfectly cooked. I e tried a couple of their salads and they have been fresh, even the garlic knots are good! The service is always quick and easy. I've only order to go so I don't know much about eating in but they do have a pretty good size room full of tables. read more

Hands down my favorite pizza store anywhere. Perfect crust, made as you like and many custom options. Via basic slice NEVER disappoints!

Good pizza. thin cooked with a delicious crust. what I liked is that its not over cheesy like other pizza places.

If I can give this place ZERO stars I would. Today was my first time ordering from this place on seamless. And it was the worst experience I've ever encountered. For one my order arrived late and my pizza was extremely burnt. That's not the worst part. I paid for my order online, but always tip in cash. Instead of saying "hello" and handing over my pizza. The delivery guy who has the meanest face and nastiest attitude says "where's my tip" "You didn't leave a tip with your card" " I'm not giving you your pizza until you tip". I immediately felt vexed. For one I had the cash in my hand to tip him. But my 8 year old daughter wanted to hand me the pizza and give him the tip. But he made the experience so difficult. At this point I refused to tip him because he was basically demanding a tip that in all honestly no one is obligated to pay. (Although I always tip as common curtesy) but this guy didn't deserve it. He then proceeded to call me a white b*** in Spanish which little did he know I am a Latina woman. I felt so violated and disrespected especially the fact that my child witness this. I open the pizza box to give my daughter her slice and her regular cheese pizza was so burnt the cheese looked black and it was extremely hard and cold at that. Immediately I called Gotham and who ever picked up which was today March 10th at 1130 pm. The person who answered sounded like he didn't Care and it was as if he knew already my pizza was burnt. And I also complained about the delivery service. His response was "What do you want me to do" I requested a refund and asked when will the owner be in. He hung up on me. 10 mins later the delivery guy calls my phone blocked and says "Fu*k you, cheap b***" And hangs up. I was extremely taken aback. I can't wait for tomorrow I will definitely make Sure who ever owns this place knows what type of People they have working for them. Such a disappointment. This was once my favorite pizza shop growing up. It has now turned into a nightmare. Never ever again !!! read more

Gotham Pizza - Burnt hard and cold pizza. Disgusting!!! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Looks like I'm not the only one here saying the staff behind the counter aren't friendly. I came in ordered my slice and it went in the oven. The guy got on the phone before I could tell him I didn't want it too hot. I asked nicely and rudely he came back and said I'm on the phone. I said wait... Isn't this a business and this is how to talk to people? Really? Looks like it's time to hire new staff Gotham for better customer service, ratings and business. read more

So i came for a $6 special for two slices and a soda but ended up paying $9 just bc i wanted to add pepperoni topping - shame on Charlie for the hustle (if that is really his name!) saw flies too !! read more

Always great. Always on time or better. Something about their chicken pie... not NY, but it satisfies. For 15+ years.

Delicious pizza. Very quick. Really good grandma slices. Nice crust on the thin side and really tasty.

Pizza was ok . Service to be desired. Breaking my usual diet I decided to go in. I ordered two cheese slices with extra cheese.The " Cook" behind the counter grabbed two handfuls with his bare / un gloved hand . Since the staff has a rep for being difficult I decided to let it go . My rationale was the heat from the pizza oven would kill the bacteria. read more

My go-to place for ordering pizza with friends! Crust is crispy on the outside but with a chew. The flavors are all there, and they give a good amount of cheese. I love their buffalo chicken by the slice (too expensive to get a whole pizza of it!). Good amount of toppings! The seating area inside is small and always a little dirty, but that goes for just about any pizza shop in the area. read more

Gotham Pizza - Delicious buffalo chicken pizza to go! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I just bought 2 slices for $8. I gave the guy $20 and just put the change in my wallet without counting it. I realized when I got home he gave me $8 change instead of $12. I know it's my fault because I didn't check before I left. I called them, and of course they denied it. BEWARE!! Count your change read more

i was totally dismayed today when I went into Gotham Pizza and spoke to one of the workers today. i had picked up a pie the other night and a side salad. When I got home, I opened the pizza box and there was a huge cockroach sitting in the corner of the box. I called and they said they would issue me a credit for the next time I called which I thought was fair. I go there often. When this afternoon, the head worker (same person working the night I picked up the pie) said something about giving me a $5.00 credit or maybe 10% the next time. He said a replacement pie was out of the question and I should have brought back the pie with the cockroach inside. Susan W. read more

I am so incredibly disappointed and insulted by the quality of food and service my family and I endured today at the hands of the staff of Gotham pizza. I ordered a fresh pie and was given a rejected pie that was not picked up by its original owner. The pizza maker and staff insisted that it was just out of the oven. Of course it was dried out no cheese and the sauce was the only color the pizza had. When I told them the pizza was dried out they refused to make a new pie for which I ordered and paid for. The Mexican staff was commenting in Spanish that they would have had a wasted pizza if they didn't insist I had it because it wasn't picked up. They all banded together to laugh at the whole thing. I let it go because no pizza is worth upsetting my children. I was served an old pizza and then laughed at for saying something. The disregard and taunting I received from the entire staff has to be the worst behavior I have ever witnessed in any establishment. If I were a male I am certain they would have given me what I paid for. Never ever go there. The worst food and service I have ever witnessed. NEVER AGAIN SHAME ON THEM!!!!!Cheese Pizza read more

See all

Gotham pizza has become my go to pizza delivery spot. I order their pizza off UberEats, and it usually comes pretty quickly. It's some of my favorite pizza I've had, because it's not too heavy with tomato sauce/cheese, and had a delicious crust. My favorite toppings combo is sausage, onions, mushroom. The only reason why I didn't give 5 stars is because it's quite pricey for a pizza spot. read more

I stopped by this place after walking around for a while looking for lunch. One of my favorite things about New York City is that there are usually so many options for all types of food in a 3 block radius. Surprisingly, this was one of 2 pizza places that I found. I was craving pizza so I went ahead and stopped here. The staff was really nice and the pizza was okay. Nothing spectacular as I have come to expect from the way New Yorkers talk about pizza! read more

One of the best pizzas in town! So perfect and crunchy 10/10! If you're looking for a perfect cheese NY slice of pizza.. this is it. read more

My friend wanted some pizza while we were returning from a long walk on the upper east side and Gotham pizza was the closest pizza joint and they have limited seating which is good cause its starting to rain .nothing really fancy at this pizza joint as it has the typical pizza shop menu and my bud and I just want regular slices and a couple of sodas. The guys behind the counter look too serious , don't talk much , and don't seem friendly with the customers but thats ok cause its likely a one and done visit at this pizza joint .pizza was ok and it was well done which I prefer but nothing to sing about as I bet there are about 6 or more pizza shops in the area they have better tasting pizza. Overall 2.5 stars and the extra star is for letting us sit inside to eat. read more

It's a very straightforward pizzeria. It's a tiny place with about 6-7 tables, 2 two sweaters and 4-5 four seaters The food: Grandma Slice- I thought the flavor of this was good, the sauce had a nice pop and you can see chunks of garlic and pieces of basil throughout. The bottom also had a nice crunchy bottom. Plain Slice- this was good but not as good as the grandma. The plain had a very unusual bottom to the slice, it had these mini craters on the bottom but it was nice and crunchy. read more

The grandma pizza here is my favorite in the city! I always get delivery from here when I'm craving pizza and have friends over. It is a hit every time. I usually get a regular pie, but opted for buffalo chicken the last time I ordered from here. Wasn't the best buffalo chicken pizza I ever had, so I would just stick to regular or normal toppings like pepperoni. There regular pies are great too, the crust is some of the best in the city. They have breadcrumbs baked into the pizza crust that gives it that extra something. Delivery is always on time. read more

Gotham Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is the last time I'm going to order from this place ever again. We always order from seamless online and always write in the memo area to read carefully as they always always always get the order wrong. Order a small pizza with a side salad with mozzarella cheese for +1 extra with Italian dressing. Why did we get a salad with no mozzarella and with Caesar dressing? Especially when you write in the note area? The pizza is fine they just can never get an order correct which i don't want to say sounds like the person can't read because it's printed right in front of you!! We called and someone said they will call us back on to handle this, take a guess no call back. Please people be careful, some people don't take jobs seriously and hurts the business. read more

Should have known by it's name. Commercial grade pizza. Sweet. Light on cheese. No oil. Too thin crust. In other words, this ain't New York pizza. Maybe popular in Gotham. read more

One bite. Everyone knows the rules! Gotham pizza has the looks, the feel, and the crust. Nothing better than a quick slice from here to cheer you up. What not 5 stars, Krouse? Well, I am not a huge fan of their seating area. It was quite dirty when we sat down for a slice. Overall, dynamite pizza, but needs to clean up their act! read more

Was en route to my residence in midtown east (don't stalk me) from UWS when the bus driver dropped me off on 1st ave instead of 2nd. I was pissed but acknowledged that it was quite possibly my fault that I missed the stop. You don't care, anyways, walking to 2nd I notice a Gotham pizza and decide to snag one of their slices for dinner instead of the bowl of peas I was planning on. Place is pretty decently sized with plenty of tables. There weren't many pies left (it was almost 8pm on a Sunday) but both the marg and cheese caught my eye. Decided to go with the classic. Slice was $2.75. I don't know what the going rate for pizza slices in NYC is but that seemed pretty reasonable to me. After the schlep to my place, I throw this bad boy in the oven to reheat. The crust was my favorite part, it was PERFECT. So thin I had to almost eat the pizza New York style (folded). Paper thin crust is NY pizza ladies and gentlemen. Go to Chicago if you want it thicker (or just another pizza place around here I guess). Cheese/sauce ratio was ideal as well. I enjoyed the cheese but in a PERFECT world the sauce could have had slightly more flavor. It was NOT bad by any stretch but I'm talking about perfection here. Would definitely return/order a pie from this joint. read more

The absolute WORST SERVICE I have ever received in Manhattan period. Ordered ONE pizza to be delivered (via Seamless)--- two hours later, the pizza had not arrived, we had been hung up on 3 times by workers who could have cared less, and we had 6 hysterically crying (hungry) children. Do yourself the favor and order from any other Pizza joint but this one- they don't care about their customers or their reputation. read more

Ordered on uber eats because the delivery time was allegedly 15 min. Now an hour later calling the restaurant multiple times they are giving some incoherent communication "order is out, give driver a minute". Clearly lying. I asked 5 times, does it mean the driver has the pizza. Response... "umm yeah the order is out". Trying to blame the driver. Impossible to cancel the order. read more

The pizza here is amazing. I mean, let's be honest, ALL new york pizza is pretty damn good but Gotham Pizza hits the spot. And what lady doesn't like something that hits the spot? Moving along, the crust is super thin, just the way real NY pizza should be. They don't sell anything fancy. It's pizza and a soda or pizza and a water, and that's it. The prices are reasonable. Very very tasty. read more

What took me so long to wander over to Gotham Pizza? Super thin crust with a nice crunchy rub on the dough, so the bottom can't take a hint of sogginess and adds a great texture. I had a plain and Sicilian slice. I liked the Sicilian better because of the rich sauce, chunky tomatoes, and excellent balance of cheese/crust. Add some hot peppers and a fountain Barq's Root Beer and you've got a recipe for a dy-no-mite snack. Guy at the counter made some relevant small talk, always nice to go to a place where people care about the customer and have pride in the food. Not a whole lot of table space inside, I think I counted 4 small, and 2-3 larger ones. read more

Gotham Pizza - Plain slice + Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I went in for the lunch special which is two slices and a soda for five dollars. It would have been a good deal however the pizza was just OK. It was cooked correctly, there was a good sauce to cheese ratio, and it tasted the right amount of spicy, but it was nothing exceptional. Also the man at the register wasn't memorable, he was kind of robotic. I do not think I'll be returning as there is another pizza place nearby that to me is superior. read more

Gotham Pizza - Two slices and a coke $5.00 lunch - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is one of the best pizzas I've had in Manhattan. I like to eat at a different pizza place every time, but this one is so good that I will be returning often! read more

Gotham Pizza - Regular Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The pizza is good but the staff is extremely rude. I just moved into the UES and this place is almost right across the street from me. I've been here 3 times and the pizza is always consistently decent. Something needs to be done about the dude who works the register (probably late 20's to mid 30's age, hispanic looking fellow). I came in on Sunday the 12th around 6:30/7pm in case the boss see's this review and wants to do something about it. Anyways the "manager" took my order, put my slice in the oven and charged my card. Slice comes out and he still hasn't given me my card back... I'm literally standing at the register eating my pizza. After about 2 full minutes of this I politely ask him, "Can I can have my card back please?" He goes, " Don't you see I'm busy? Here take the card, you don't need to sign it. Careful on your way out, it's cold out there tonight." I said, "Are you seriously telling me to leave for asking for my card back?" He looks at me again and says, "Yup, it's cold out there stay warm." What a tool. Your pizza aint that great. I hope you finally get fired. I wont come back until it happens. read more