Came for lunch with a party of 16. We called ahead to let them know the party size and they had a table waiting to accommodate us! We ended up ordering a variety of the lunch specials. The food was seasoned well and everyone enjoyed the experience. I found the garlic knots to be a little doughy in the middle which I was not a fan of. If I were to go back I would re-order the wings and pinwheel. The staff were friendly and the food was ready in a timely manner. Would definitely recommend trying this pizza place out! read more

Pizza was not a NY style that I'm used to. The service was vey impersonal. Not worth the price. Helan Back wins as NY style pizza.

These guys brought Brooklyn to Crestview!!! Pete and Amir are dedicated to bringing the best pizza to Crestview. The customer service is amazing and they are very helpful. The ambiance made me feel I was actually in NYC. Home away from home. Keep doing the best. High recommend Brooklyn pizza. read more

See all

Great crust after I cooked it for 15 minutes in my air fryer after it arrived undercooked, soggy and inedible. My kids even spit it out. Flavorless, and too much cheese. No seasoning whatsoever. Would not recommend. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - 12" Ham and Pineapple. - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

Great pizza and staff. Such friendly and fast service. Order our pies extra crispy and they were perfect. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - 12" buffalo chicken ranch pizza. Delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

See all

So good!!!! Amazing pie! We ordered the Sicilian pie, half Brooklyn meat and half marargarita. Omg sooo sooo good!! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Half Brooklin, half margarita in the Sicilian pie. Omg so good!! - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

See all

Had a pepperoni pizza and it was pretty good. Had a nice crust to it. Had a friend pick it up therefore, I couldn't rate the service or ambiance. read more

BOMB!! My husband and I were doordashing earlier and the smell of the order made us come back for a bite to eat. 10/10 my husband worked at a pizza joint as a chef and I'm a chef as well. The crust on the pizza is the perfect level of crunch and airy fluff, perfect amount of cheese without being too stringy, great sauce, not too greasy but still so flavorful. Our slices were piping hot and you basically get 2 full slices per "1" slice. Great family owned joint. You can tell these guys know what's up!! Such a shame they're a hole in the wall I feel like they'd do so much better in a city setting but this place is amazing. Will be returning and recommending! read more

I love this. Right across the street from the Tesla Superchargers. DONT throw your money away on Panera !!! This is authentic NY Pizza !!! Ridiculous to find North of Destin Can't wait to eat it again Spinach pizza amazing. Just ordered all meat too and a Philly Steak Roll ! Mmmmmmm read more

Brooklyn Pizza - All the stuff. AUTHENTIC!! - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

Great pizza if not a little expensive. Probably all I will ever have there though. Also worth mentioning they are always nice. Problem though, Decided to dine in last week and ordered a Philly cheesesteak with meat, cheese, and mayonnaise. Must have put a whole quart of mayo on it though. Had to throw most of it out. Thought I would give them another chance this week. Only didn't include mayo this time. Asked repeatedly for just meat and cheese this time. Sandwich came out with barely enough meat to get a taste and no cheese. Bread was basically burnt. Accepted the meat as it was, but questioned the no cheese. They took it back and put a small slice of cheese on it. In whole it was terrible. Ate about half, got no flavor out of it and threw the rest away. With sandwich, fries, tea, and tip, over $22. Will order pizza again, but never anything else. read more

Highly recommended because the food is delicious especially the pizza. I'm a big fan of the lunch specials slice pizza, salad drink Hospitality, freshness is right on target. Thanks guys! RG1 read more

Brooklyn Pizza - The Menu of wonderful foods - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

See all

Really good pizza pizza is good. Everybody's friendly great place to get a piece of pizza.

I'm not from NY but will say I've had my fair share of Brooklyn style pizza over many years. This place is the real deal. We can argue back-and-forth and say "it's the water" (and yes maybe for bagels) however for pizza I believe it's using top ingredient's that matter. Having the right sauce and cheese speaks volume. Crust texture was right on. Not a thick crust, not a thin crust, but just right. I'm sensing Goldie locks vibes here. Service was good a the ambiance as well with tables that nostalgically teleport you to NY. Stop by and see (and taste) for yourself. Kudos Brooklyn Pizza! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pepperoni and "say cheeeeese" pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

We chose this pizza place off yelp due to location in our travels and food. The Brooklyn special was the best pizza I've had in a long time. Money we'll spent ! Crust toasted perfectly and the portion of ingredients left me full with one slice. If I was a local this would be my go to. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Brooklyn special full of goodness - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

This is good pizza. I grew up eating real NY pizza and I'm happy that Crestview has this place. It's very good. Pizza and calzones are great

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. We ordered the Brooklyn Philly and the Crestview. Both were amazing read more

UPDATE 3/16/24: today I tried the Pete's Philly for lunch. OH MY GOD! I've never tasted something so delicious. I almost cried it was so good. It's gooey from the melted cheese, it's spicy from the jalapeños and red peppers, it's tender from the sliced ribeye, you get extra flavor from the pepperoni. OH and the garlic bread as the vessel for it all was the perfect pairing. Literally one of the best subs I've ever had in my entire life. My new favorite menu item read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Brooklyn Special, no mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

See all

We tried for the first time and got a pizza to go. It was delicious! We've tried several places in town looking for a good pizza and will definitely go back. Service was friendly and fast... read more

We've been here 3 times in the last few months - each time has been wonderful. Food is always fresh & hot - and most importantly delicious. We've tried the Crestview Pizza, spicy hot wings, garlic knots and baked cheese ravioli. Each items has truly exceeded our expectations! Everyone here has always been very sweet and helpful. Ambiance is very NY as well! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

The Greek salad was simple but incredibly tasty. I'd come back just for that. Our party also ordered a veggie calzone which was great. It was a huge calzone filled with tasty veggies. I definitely recommend. We also had the cheese curds; they were overly greasy, but that was the only negative regarding our food. The inside was clean and the staff were very friendly. read more

Loved this place! Quick breakdown for this newly established pizza joint: Customer service was GREAT. The young lady at the register was sweet but a little soft spoken, and kinda hard to hear but she was very nice. One of the dudes came around to ask how everything tasted after you'd had a bit to try the food. He even overheard another customer say it was his birthday and without making a big deal, the same dude brought birthday boy a piece of cheesecake. Class act! The food. We ordered: - Fried ravioli - Pepperoni Twists - Meaty Calzone - Brooklyn Philly Pizza Fried ravioli was great and so was the marinara. Personally, the pepperoni twists weren't for me but that's a personal opinion. They came in a flat bowl with butter garlic sauce in the bottom of the pan. I didn't really care for that but if that's you, go for it! Meaty calzone was awesome! It was a little cool in the center but nothin to throw a fit about. Many places make and refrigerate these ahead of time and it makes since. The outside was very hot but just a little cool on the inside. Would order again. My boy ate the pizza and absolutely loved it! All in all, this the food and drinks plus tip was about $50. A steal for the quality of service and food. #1 takeaway that will bring me back is the quality of ingredients! This is a sticking point for me and they nailed it. The mozz was great, pepperoni had a lot of flavor and the sausage in the calzone was delicious. Off to a great start and good luck to the owner(s) and employees! Last note...the music playing was on point! read more

See all

The service was amazing and the owner was very nice This place neeeeeddsss business big time !!! Very underrated!!! You got to check this place out ! Buffalo chicken salad was the BOMB!!!!! My husband got the chicken Parmesan sub !! And everything we got was affordable. Amazing lunch deals and the place was really cool to sit and have a little lunch date. Definitely a big family spot to bring your kids ! And enjoy ! read more

Ambiance is a total NY vibe :) reminds me of Brooklyn and queens ! Everyone was so nice and I'm excited to try more items on their menu. I was stoked they had glass bottle cokes and an eggplant sub ! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Eggplant parm sub - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

When you are at a 4.5 star on Yelp, you know you are doing something right. The pizza here is great. Really everything on the menu that I've tried is great as well. Service is outstanding. Very friendly staff. Highly recommend. read more

Ordering is a little slow as the girl is new and learning, she will pickup speed as time goes by. I ordered a 18 inch pepperoni onion garlic and oil Pizza. It was perfect. Cooked just right, the crust was thin and tender sauce is better than I have ever had. Could not have had a better Pizza. Just like what I remember of New York Pizza right from New York. I always recommend to add olive oil to any Pizza, try it you will be hooked. I went in 3 times when they first open wait was so long I left. Really glad I returned. Don't have to drive to Pensacola now for original New York Pizza. The owner is real nice and he really care about what he is doing I could tell by watching, he love what he is doing and it shows. Will be back for sure. Highly recommend going early 11 am. Congratulations read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Pepperoni Onion Garlic olive oil - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

Had to leave a review because this is the BEST pizza in Crestview. Very good New York style pizza!!

I have never been to Brooklyn Pizza before but my pregnancy craving told me I had to try it... but my toddler is sleeping so I had to door dash it. IT'S SO GOOD. I was confused about the lunch special for "pasta, side salad drink" because when you go to select a drink option it wants to charge you more. I didn't make a drink selection but I left a note on the special instructions and simply asked if it came with one after all. Wasn't sure if I was going to get one or not but the order got dropped off with my Dr Pepper. I am so impressed. Not only with how good the food is but they did right and sent a drink with my order too. Might have to make my husband take me for dinner tonight also because if it's this good delivered it's got to be even better fresh at the restaurant. I can't wait to try more!! 10/10 will be coming back. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

See all

Food is great, service is always good!!! We love the Mama lasagna pizza and cheese curds.

Absolutely delicious! First visit this afternoon and will definitely be back. We had a small extra cheese and pepperoni pizza, Brooklyn Philly sandwich, and pizza rolls. We didn't take the time to take any pictures before digging in, didn't take one of the cheesesteak at all. The pepperoni ropes were my favorite thing with the awesome garlic butter. Everything was hot, fresh, and delicious. The owner (I think?) was super friendly and welcoming. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pepperoni & Extra Cheese Pizza (12 Inch) - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

See all

Came in after furniture shopping with the whole family and it was better than we ever thought. Highly recommend read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Amazing food and people - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

Hands down, my favorite pizza place ever. Everything on the menu tastes good and is fresh. The staff is always friendly and helpful to save you money on specials or to pick out something new to try. read more

Service was fast and friendly ! Good prices but pizza was greasy and not good ! Great specials as well

Delicious pizza and fast and friendly service! Tried several different slices. We loved the chicken spinach deep dish!

The flavor of their dough is perfect! Very unique! Service was fast and friendly with a family diner atmosphere. You really should put this on your must dine experience card. read more

Had the baked Manicotti this time. It was super good as always. The service has always been great imo. A small diner atmosphere. I love it!

Ate a pepperoni pizza from BP the other day and it was pretty good. Not my favorite here in town but one of the better places.

A great stop on our way back home from tournament this weekend in Panama City! We had the Meaty Calzones and the Brooklyn all meat pizzas, plus some cheesy garlic bread! Everything was fresh, hot and quick service! Definitely recommended! Oh and the kids said the Ranch was really good! The restaurant had tvs going and great music! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Meaty Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Crestview, Florida

Brooklyn is the only place within a 100 mile radius that delivers an authentic pie! Thank you for bringing us this!

Highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza. The food is so good. If you want a NY pizza this is the place.

I ordered the homemade lasagna and my boyfriend got the calzone with jalapeños, bacon, and cheese. We both thought the staff was friendly and attentive, the prices were reasonable, and the food was amazing! Loved the calm atmosphere and the menu had a lot of options as well. Highly recommend if you've never been! Such a hidden gem in crestview! read more