Best NY /east coast style pizza in south Austin. I'm a pizza snob and usually get Pedrosas or Smalls pizza for top shelf New Haven style pizza. However when those guys are too busy or closed, I'm a pinch I'll door dash from Brooklyn Pie. It always hits the spot, sometimes I wish it was just a little bit more well done and less greasy, but overall they are my go to spot in south Austin for NY styled pizza. read more

So I've been going to this place for years, but I've noticed recently a steep decline in service and quality. But tonight was the worst! After a very rough week, all I wanted was a large extra cheese pepperoni. What found out I got when I got home was a large extra cheese only. Now one would think that when I called in to say "Hey you guys forgot the Pepperoni, can you remake my Pizza?" that a normal customer service high quality place would say "Absolutely! We are very sorry for our mistake. Come on back and we will take care of you!" Not Brooklyn Pie... first the woman on the phone didn't believe me until she checked and then said "oh your right, but we didn't charge you for the pepperoni" [so this was a 27.50 large extra cheese? okay whatever] So I tried to calmly explain that I spent my time and gas getting over there and back to my house and didn't have what I had ordered. To which they responded "Well we aren't going to make you a new one since we didn't charge you for the pepperoni" So after some more arguing, something I hate doing and shouldn't have had to do, they finally agreed to correct their mistake, but we so utterly indignant about it and demanding I bring back the mistake pizza [which sure thing, it's not like I was trying to get a free pizza from these jerks], that it makes me question if I'll ever go there again after being treated like garbage for THEIR mistake! Poor treatment and overpriced mid-teir pizzas - So if you do go there, check your order before you leave oh, and their garlic knots are sloppy, gorss trash now, so avoid those entirely. read more

I don't know what to say except this food has no Italian soul at all. I ordered a giant pepperoni slice and garlic cheese bread that came to about $20. The cheese bread was super bland and the garlic butter they used was seemed like the imitation goo used at papa John's. The pepperoni slice was like cardboard and flavorless. I also noticed that the cashier was also the food preparer and never washed his hands or put on gloves. The order came out fast but I ended up throwing away 75% of the food after a couple of bites. The store is right next to lil Woodrow's so maybe drunk people don't care about taste but there are many better options for pizza nearby. Culture Club, Via 313, even Jets that give you better value and flavor. Don't waste your time or money here. read more

The amount of pepperoni is sad! The worst part though was that it was a soggy slice and did not taste good. Wanted to give this place another shot as it's been a while, but I'll just continue to stay away. Over priced and not even worth it. Eat somewhere else because here you'll just have a bad experience. read more

Brooklyn Pie - Soggy Pepperoni slice with a skimpy amount of pepperoni. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

The pizza was above par. It was tasty, extraordinarily large, and worth the price. The staff were kind and I could tell they were hard workers and nice to each other and customers. read more

Don't go on a slow night! The food was not fresh at all. It was slow and the parking lot was almost empty. I am sure we got old food. I paid $90 bucks for old pizza and wings. We are regular customers, so I called in today just to speak with a manager and the lady on the phone advised manager left but no set hours, so I'm leaving this review! The wings were hard and cold with an old taste. The pizza seemed reheated after our toppings were added! That was cold too! The staff basically tried to trick us but we eat there enough to know it was not fresh! They have lost our business! Do better! read more

amazing and friendly staff, great food, and partnered along with Woody's makes for a great time!

As Italian, my pizza standards are pretty high. I have to admit that this pizza is very good! Some friends and I ordered pizza to spend the evening together and I was surprised right away! The dough was perfectly thick, and the taste was just like the one you can eat in Italy. The tomato sauce was excellent and I personally love that it wasn't mixed with garlic (which I've seen done in other places) And the cheese was not too greasy. Overall I really enjoyed it and I definitely recommend it! read more

Our pager died while we were watering so that was a bummer but incredibly helpful and nice staff. Got the fried ravioli and churro cheesecake. Fried ravioli was AMAZING. Six pieces with marinara, so delicious! Churro cheesecake was also amazing. Good size and delicious. read more

Didn't feel like ordering our normal dominoes, and went against the 3-star reviews on this joint. So glad I did! We've actually ordered by Uber Eats and Door Dash. The first time, order was perfect. Second time, they added the wrong sauce to one of our pies. But the pizzas arrived hot, crispy, and great! I want to try eating in-store sometime, but so far we've been very happy with our deliveries. Similar to the pizzas I had in NYC. read more

Good enough pizza and salads. 3-star, average experience. It's a pick-up only, small place. You could sit next door at Little Woodrow's and grad a drink and eat. It's not exactly welcoming, they are pie slinging and kind of yell at you when you walk in as opposed to a normal "how can we help you" welcome. Order through them and pick up, so you don't get hit with the overage/fees. read more

Really good pizza but the toppings price on uber eats is kind of out of control. This has been my go to pizza place since i moved to south Austin and dont feel like going to homeslice. read more

Brooklyn Pie - $5 per topping? For all toppings. Not trying to pay $10 for bell peppers and onions - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

Worst Restaurant! Don't go there if they can't read the instruction related with Allergic food... I think they are doing that on purpose since its not first time happened and last time I ordered was last year and SAME ISSUSE as 10/07/24 and I called and BITCHED at them why they cannot read the request to be asked and followed and they choose to ignore and sent with allergic food in it as it SHOULDN'T be in the food!! I told them they were doing it on PURPOSE by killing me with that allergic food in it!!! They wanted to remake and I SAID HECK NO NOT WITH YOUR RESTUAURANT EVER AGAIN!!! DONE IS DONE! HORRIBLE Experience! read more

Pretty basic pie. The cheese is reaaaal cheesy, and well everything is just basic. Dough doesn't have too much flavor, I would say the food is more or less a filler, something to soak up the drinks you get from Little Woodrow's. I will say their buffalo wings have a bit of a kick, and are super saucy, so if thats your thing give it a go. read more

Ate here with my boyfriend the other day, we go to woodys often. Bought two sandwiches the chicken panini and the turkey. Somehow the total was almost 40 dollars. I left a small tip and I have no idea how two sandwiches with no flavor or sides or a drink can come out to that much. Never going back. I would give zero stars if I could. read more

AWESOME!!! Delicious. Great NY style crust. Fresh veggies, sliced sausage is the best. Found my pizza place...I'll go no place else.

This pizza is awesome New York style pizza!! Great flavor and texture! Go to pizza joint. Prices could be more reasonable.

My coworkers and I ordered Brooklyn pie for lunch and were really excited as two of my coworkers are from NY. We ordered 2 pizzas, 3 garlic knots, and 2 salads via doordash. When the food arrived, the pizzas were cold and were smooshed but tasted fine, the garlic knots were cold and unflavorful BUT we are not at the worst part- my coworkers salad that she was eating had a literal beetle CRAWLING in it!! This is absolutely disgusting and completely unacceptable. This makes me question the level of cleanliness at this business and I will never go back. See photos for reference. read more

See all

What a good pie... specifically a Classic New York Pizza Pie, small size (don't tease me, stuff is expensive enough nowadays!). This pizza was very good and brought back memories of the last great New York style pizza I had (which was Davinci's in Charlotte, NC). I'm not from New York and I may not know what authentic is-- but I know what I like, and this was delicious! Even the crust was nice and soft and wonderful, just like I like it. I could snack on just the crust! They forgot my request (online ordering w/Grubhub) for no sausage-- but I swear that this sausage wasn't bad at all. Very mild and nice tasting slices of sausage. This was one time that I didn't mind a mistake on my food. Based on this first experience, I will definitely be getting more Brooklyn Pie Co's pizza! It's not easy finding pizza I like here in Austin. read more

This has been our go to NY style pizza for the past 7 years but things have changed. Lately, the pizzas have been soggy, lacking any sauce and the crust is now thin and flat at the ends. I have no idea why you have changed your recipe but bring back the real authentic pizza PLEASE! read more

Brooklyn Pie - Soggy pizza with almost no sauce and thin tough crust at the end - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

See all

Love the giant slice (and I'm from a few miles across the GW Bridge from Manhattan)! Negatives - Very little seating, opens an hour later on weekends (noon) so forget about picking up pizza before the NFL games start, and no free water. read more

This is my go to place for pizza on fight nights. My friends and I have been coming to the bar next door for fights for months and I always order from here. I order the margarita pizza with no cheese and they always make my order right, which is a rarity nowadays. Their pizza is always hot, fresh, and delicious and their homemade marinara is outstanding! The service is friendly, the pizza is good, and the location is super convenient. 10/10 would recommend. read more

One word: disappointment. Took an hour for the pizza to be done. Disappointed. Charged me for RANCH? Disappointed. Pizza was not impressive. Would not recommend read more

Good ole pizza. Can't go wrong. Don't understand why the reviews are so low. We ordered 2 pizzas for pickup and they were ready on time and better than doninoes. They're also huge and pretty reasonably priced imo. Honestly my biggest complaint is that I wish they had breadsticks or something. But Definitely will order again. read more

Ordered carryout. Simple phone in order. Huge ass slices and delish crust. Not doughy and great flavors! Got a large pepperoni, sausage, shrooms , and jalepenos pie and it didn't disappoint! Located next to Lil Woodrow's in Southpark Meadows. read more

Brooklyn Pie - Pepperoni, sausage, shrooms, and jalepenos 18" - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

Honestly, pretty good! The pizza slice is insanely big and a great value! I always order my pizzas well done and highly recommend other doing so. This is a no fuss, great pizza place! read more

Look, Texans don't like good pizza. That's why every NY style pizza you'll get in this city is woefully undercooked. Brooklyn Pie is no exception. So here the hack if your hankering for a good NY style pie. Order from here take it home and finish it properly in your 500 degree oven. It's elite pizza when you get the crust crispy on the bottom. If people down here liked proper pizza I think they would sell it this way, so I'm not holding this against them. This goes for their competitors too (Yaghis, Home Slice, etc). You can maybe try asking for it well done (aka done properly). read more

pizza was massive wasn't expecting such a big slice! Been to a lot of places that say they have big slices but Brooklyn Pie lives up to it. The sit down area is beautiful and cute especially on a nice day. They served the pizza hot and were super cool too. Definitely a hidden pizza gem read more

Had Brooklyn a couple of times recently through both delivery and takeout. There's no place to sit here, unless you opt for drinks at Little Woodrow's next door. Wife loves Brooklyn's fried ravioli bites (~$8), and they've been our favorite appetizer here so far! I think they do a pretty authentic thin, New York style crust, and I'd recommend asking them to leave your pie in for an extra few minutes. We typically share a large pizza (~$20) and have a few slices leftover for another meal. They have a massive selection of fresh toppings (including Kalamata olives, fresh garlic, artichoke hearts, gyro, and meatballs), but if I had one request, I wish they would add sun-dried tomatoes to the menu! We'll likely be back again soon! During COVID, this has been one of our favorite places to try every month. Thanks to the staff for staying open and staying safe. read more

Favorite pizza in Austin, pizza just like the east coast Takes likes in back home in jersey read more

I stopped in to get a slice of pizza. The slices are huge, and I guess NY style, but it was super greasy. I was not able to finish because it was messy. They had some other things on the menu that sounded good, but I have not had a chance to return. There is not a lot of vroom to wait, so I recommend calling ahead. read more

I got a calzone from here. While it was large in size, it has no flavor. It's bland, and the shop is oddly small, and the music is too loud for you to hear. The lady was nice, but after 15 minutes of driving, that was a 4 minute drive. None of the addresses are correct, save your money for either mod pizza nearby or anything else. read more

Pizza was excellent. Delicious combination was awesome. The wings were awesome. Five star.

We tried Brooklyn Pie for the first time last weekend and never will again. The pizzas had little or no flavor and the wings were dry.

Too bad this place gets such a bad wrap on Yelp. I've had food from here on a few different occasions and every time it has been great ! I don't think I expected much the first time , as it is a small spot and right next to a bar , but seriously this place has some tasty food packed in this little spot ! I have ordered pizza and wings to go a couple times and most recently, I tried a slice of pepperoni pizza as big as my head !! It was $4.50 , made fresh and pretty quickly. I took some hot Buffalo wings to go and a meatball sub for the man friend . The wing sauce was awesome and just hot enough , ordered the wings extra crispy but would have liked a little crispier... pizza was AWESOME and I know my pizza ! Sub was delicious too. Service was friendly and the shop was busy. I'm not sure I would order delivery from this place only because it seemed a little unorganized but that comes from years of running a pizza joint experience .... based on taste and service I would recommend this place if you're in the area !! read more

Brooklyn Pie - Slice as big as your head! - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

Closed at 9... disappointing considering you are connected to a bar that stays open until 2am... weird

Wow... this pizza is awful. The day an actual east coast pizzeria comes to Austin these knock offs that taste like fake cheese out of a bag are done. Greasy, way too sweet, is that even cheese? I guess one star for being cheap? I promise, Box pizza from the grocery store is better... such a let down read more

One of the best spots in town to get a decent slice. Beware if you order the pepperoni slice it will be greasy! Just make sure to grab extra napkins to help soak up the extra grease. I love their fried ravioli! Coming from the NYC area it has been a challenge to find decent pizza, but Brooklyn Pie gets the job done. The only seating options are at Little Woodrow's next door. read more

I'm a picky NYer and I usually hate pizzas that claim to be authentic NY style because no one gets it quite right but BKC is the best effort I've had in the south so far and that's an accomplishment! We got a large pepperoni delivered and a 4 count of the garlic knots - the garlic knots were DELISH! Super buttery, lots of garlic and herbs, good crust on the outside fluffy on the inside! The pizza was great, thin but sturdy crust, perfect for folding and dipping in ranch IYKYK. The sauce was a little on the sweet side for my liking but not enough to be a detractor. If you're looking for a great NY style pizza, for me this is it! read more

MOST GIANT PIECE OF PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD. I was a bit frustrated when my fiancé ordered the pizza, they stated it would just need warmed up and would be out in 4-5 minutes... We ordered at 8:08, 8:30 comes around and we still haven't received our pizza. I went inside to check the status, it wasn't even in the oven yet. They ended up giving us a refund AND once the pizza was actually in the oven it really did only take 4 minutes. It was delicious! read more

Brooklyn Pie - Giant Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

See all