I'm a sucker for interesting pizzas, and this place has them. Cute little inside atmosphere with great food. Good location right downtown. What more can you ask for? read more

Awesome staff, nothing beats a coal fired pizza. They also have a nice selection of tap beers.

I rate this pizza in the top five that I've had in the past 10 years and I've been to Italy and around the United States during that time. The brussels sprouts were to die for even though they didn't have a salad which I was really looking forward to with my meal and I'm sure it's just because of everything that the food service industry is going through right now I would come back here all the time. You just have to try it and if you don't want something that is authentic ever woodfired oven just go to dominoes or Pizza Hut because you will never understand how good this pizza is. read more

Fancy personal wood fired pizza in a cool old downtown building. I will definitely be back. It was delicious!

Great pizza, fast service, downtown Neenah, wood fired so it's fast and has a great crust, many different sauces and combinations. It's our "go to" pizza for a fast and very satisfying meal. read more

One of the best pizzas ever, great verities of beer and warm staff. Queen Bee pizza was the best. Thank you guys. read more

Pizza is OK; not the best, but mid-range OK; buffet consists of different pizzas/toppings. Salad bar is small. Pizza is placed on warmer often. read more

Thanks to yelp I found this gem of a place 8miles away in Neenah. It did not disappoint based the reviews. The pizza was fabulous!!! The atmosphere had a cozy relaxing vibe. Staff was super friendly. I found out that they have live music on Wednesday and Saturday nights. If you follow on fb it tells you the artist & time I was told. There's an Ice cream shop connected. read more

See all

First time here! Had the lunch buffet - all you can eat pizza and bottomless soda for $8. A few of my friends also had the salad bar. They were really happy with how fresh the veggies were. It was a little busy, so we were worried about the pizza being stocked, but they kept on coming!!! Everything was really great and it was fun to try a bunch of different pizzas. Really nice atmosphere and great location. Friendly staff too! Can't wait to come back with the hubby and kids. Tip- head next door for a scoop of ice cream for dessert, very reasonably priced! read more

Great addition to the Neenah scene -great place, awesome service and delicious food!! Would definitely recommend it! read more

Broken Tree Pizza - Brick oven pizza fires at 900 degrees! Great food! - Pizza Near Me - Neenah, Wisconsin

I had to check and make sure I was at the same place as everyone else that reviewed. Maybe we came on an off day. We all have those from time to time. First off, nice atmosphere as far as being a pretty cool looking place. Not overkill by any stretch, just quaint. For the pizza buffet, salad and soda, it was $10. We didn't get the choice to not have soda, so I thought that was odd that you pay for soda even if you don't drink it. We like to drink water. The salad bar was $2 extra, which we paid for. Very bare choices available. Pizza was interesting and had some good flavors, but crust was undercooked and toppings were very sparse on every pizza. I got the impression they were in short supply of everything and stretching ingredients. No one was very friendly. Basically, what dyou want today? Menus are here, you can sit while you look at the menu, but order here. No eye contact, smile, small talk. Very impersonal. No one cleans your table of dishes while you're eating or speaks to you after you pay. No one said bye as we left. There were only 2 other people when we left, so not like they were busy. If they read these reviews, I would say, there's lots of places to eat in the Valley, good place to get pizza, be nice, make some form of eye contact, SMILE. read more

Great pizza, 12" only. A lot of choices. Thinner crust. A little on the expensive side. Decent choice of drafts and seltzer's.

Pizza was delicious. Each pizza is 10". Wood fired. Great crust and red sauce flavors. They recommend 1 person per person or each pizza is 6 smaller pieces. Would definitely go back. read more

Broken Tree Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Neenah, Wisconsin

We had dinner at Broken Tree last night for the first time ever and my family of three had very happy tummies! SORRY I didn't get pictures! They were pretty busy as just about every table was full. I immediately identified a table and it took some time to get it cleared. Once we sat, the manager/owner Johnny Pizza (LOL) greeted us quickly and took our order. He was VERY personable and friendly. Playful banter ensued. Drinks were brought out quickly, but our pizzas took quite a while to come out. Finally ours came out and they were simply outstanding! I had the Sweaty Pig and it was delicious! My wife ordered the Margherita La Salsiccia which she loved, but could have used more mozzarella. We understood that's just how that pizza comes. We're confident she could have ordered it worth more fresh mozzarella. When Johnny came back around with a to-go box for our kiddo and the Square device to pay the bill, more playful banter ensued and he explained that there's an adjoining bar that Broken Tree services which had a big group in and there were a LOT of boxes going out the back door. Johnny said it's not always like that and we believed him. Long story short, we very much enjoyed our pizzas. VERY fresh ingredients and the crust!!! We will NO DOUBT be back very soon! read more

Today was my worst experience so far at broken tree first they were 5 minutes late in opening their doors upon entering the cook running the oven was complaining to his coworker about not being letting go so you'll be returned by now in the past I have mentioned that if they don't keep the base of the grill clean carbon build up a nasty flavor on the bottom of pizzas however when the cook is diligent and keeping the base of the oven clean the pizzas are Supreme Management was extremely unreceptive to my feedback at this point I recommend avoiding this restaurant read more

Our favorite Neenah pizzeria. We love the margherita pizza. The crust is crispy with the right amount of chewiness. The sauce is tangy and flavorful. The staff is friendly. One of the best pizza places in the valley. They have a wood fire stove which gives the pizza a terrific char taste. Also as a bonus they have hand dipped ice cream parlor in the back. They are very family friendly and a great destination. read more

Ordered one of their pizza's and the center was cold! How do you screw up cooking a pizza??? Table wasn't cleaned either. But they serve the beer that is made a block away. And it was great! read more

Awesome ambiance, cool decor, great beer selection, and AMAZING pizza! Service was prompt, attentive, and courteous. read more

Broken Tree Pizza - Cool little pizza joint! - Pizza Near Me - Neenah, Wisconsin

Excellent pizza and great service. No complaints whatsoever. An enjoyable dining experience at a reasonable price.

Very good wood fired pizza (my favorite was the "Fun Guy". Pleasant atmosphere (was surprised to see a band setting up with all the families and little kids). If your waitress doesn't introduce herself, she's probably Cassandra (very pleasant). read more

First, customer service is EXCELLENT 5+ stars. We went during brunch and ordered a chicken and waffle pizza (along with the farmer's skillet, Margherita). They had already made the pizza and realized they did not have the waffle to top it with. They told us to pick out another pizza and it was on the house :) The pizzas had a good flavor but I wasn't a fan of their type of pizza. The crust is very thin, very crispy. They didn't taste fresh and it could have been because we ordered 3 pizzas. So, I would like to go back and try it again on a non-brunch day since there are so many great reviews. Side note: The creativity in the brunch menu was fun and unique! read more

Cute little pizza joint with delicious wood fired pizza. If you have kids, they will give you a ball of pizza dough for them to play with while you wait for your food (we usually have to ask for it). It's a great place to take a family. Service and ambiance are just alright, but the yummy pizza makes up for it. They also own a cute ice cream place nearby for dessert! read more

Ordered pizza while we had drinks at Lions Tail a few Saturday's ago. Had the pesto pizza with chicken and bacon on it, and some pepperoni sticks. Everything was fresh and hot and flavorful. Will definitely be ordering their pizza again. read more

I moved to the Fox Cities area about 9 months ago and have been searching and searching for a legitimate pizza place. Yes, there are plenty of decent places around offering Milwaukee-style pies, but there was no true Neopolitan style places around. Anyone that has talked to me for more than 45 second knows how much I love pizza, so It was promptly told about this place's opening. After looking at pictures online I knew this was the traditional pizza I sought. And I crossed my fingers. Today, they opened and I was not disappointed. This place is legit. I will break it down starting with the most important part, the pizza. Sauce: You can taste the tomatoes, with a perfect tang and just a bit of spiciness to it. The cheapo places use low quality tomatoes and balance out the bad tanginess with sugar. Here you get the bright, fresh tomato taste. 5/5 Toppings: All ingredients were fresh and seemed to be of pretty high quality. It's so easy to ruin a good base pizza with poor quality toppings. Not a problem here. 5/5 Crust: The place has a wood fired oven, which is exactly why I came. I saw someone checking the temperature with an infrared thermometer while I was there so that is definitely a good sign that they are keeping the oven running well. This shows in the crust. The bottom had a great char (not burned). The crust held itself pretty well but still had that perfect bit of chew in the texture. My only complaint on the crust was there wasn't a whole lot of air in the cornicione so it didn't get that great hole structure and crispiness, but that was not a problem for me. 4.5/5 Service: Any eating experience can get ruined by service. I usually have low expectations for new places, but this place was ready to go. The staff were moving smoothly and everything is set up pretty clearly. The staff were also all very friendly. Most importantly, everything was organized and running smoothly. Also, service is fast. You expect fast pizzas out of a wood fired oven and this is exactly what you get. I ordered my first pizza at 11:03 and was done eating it by 11:20. I say first pizza because toward the end of it I ordered a second one. I did this for a couple reasons. First and foremost, they were really delicious and I wanted another one. Second, I wanted to see how the oven was holding up after several other pizzas went through (my first pizza was their first order, second was maybe 6th or 7th). Third, I wanted to try a different, plainer combination of toppings so I could get a better sense of the sauce flavor. Last, I wanted to see how fast it came out when there were a couple people ahead of me. All aspects of that second pie were just as good as the first. Great crust, great flavor, and made quickly. Overall I highly recommend Broken Tree Pizza. I love pizza, I like to think I know a lot about pizza, and this is hands down the best I've had in the Fox Cities area since moving here. Additional info you may find useful: 1. Pizzas are only 10" personal pizzas. You might be able to split one among 2 people if you're not too hungry. 2. It's inside the marketplace building so it might not be super visible from the street. 3. I didn't notice wifi but the place next door has it and you can sneak onto that (shhh) read more

Pretty good! very classy decor, and love the wood fired pizza!! the workers are kind and it is very easy to veganize the pizza by asking for no cheese and lots of vegetable toppings to choose from. read more

Everyone was nice and the pizza was great! I'll be back!! Thank you for being respectful and the place was very clean. Keep up the great work. read more

We just tried Broken Tree last night. It was fantastic! My wife, one of our daughters and I wanted to try someplace new (for us) and headed to Neenah. Broken Tree is inside the Marketplace and the decor is not particularly special. But, the service and pizza far exceeded our expectations. We highly recommend the basil broken sticks as an appetizer. The pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven, have a tasty thin crust and a lot of choices for toppings. You can get a white sauce or a traditional red sauce as the base. The white sauce is olive oil base and has a great flavor. One visit and my wife said, "looks like I have a new favorite pizza in the Fox Valley"! read more

The atmosphere was amazing and the pizza was fantastic. They had many vegetarian options, which is a major plus! We would definitely recommend Broken Tree to anybody and everybody! read more

Um yum. I went with friends and didn't expect much but wow, honestly some of the most delicious local pizza! Their location is awesome in downtown neenah (there's extra parking in the back) and all their pizzas are so so good, and great service too. read more

Great service very friendly staff. Pizza was also great. Had our six year old granddaughter with us instead of crayons they gave pizza dough. Great idea she had fun. read more

I love their Queen Bee Pizza. Sweet and Spicy! It's a little pricy but totally worth it! Grab a beer at Lions Tail Brewery and order from Broken Tree Pizza right at the bar! Pizza and beer, one of the best combos! read more

Visited 6:45 on Saturday night. Short line to order. Our group tried 4 different pizzas and we would all order them again. Young man in charge of ordering was helpful, pleasant, and efficient. One suggestion: chalk board is difficult to read in low light - perhaps a few menus to look at while waiting in line? Could speed up order process too. read more

Excellent pizza and salad bar!!! My boyfriend and I just split the pizza since we each had the salad bar. The staff was the best as well. It certainly seemed like everyone worked so well together and that was something you just don't see much anymore. Definitely will be back read more

As a transplant to WI, I have been searching for pizza with a real crust (not this weird cracker crust going on around here). My search has finally ended! Using fresh dough and a brick fire oven, the thin crust comes out with a few bubbles around the edges and retains its flavor without being dry. The combinations are great as well (pig and pear or argula, white sauce and truffle oil). Great for lunch or a casual dinner, the interior is warm and inviting g. read more

Broken Tree Pizza - Craft beer selection. - Pizza Near Me - Neenah, Wisconsin

Football playoffs - and I wanted to feed a few friends with Pizzas and aps. First time trying....checked the menu on line - order six pizzas. Pick-up fast and friendly. These artisan pizzas...fresh, local ingredients, excellent crust (clearly home made) and wood fire cooked. All guests loved the different pizzas - will be back again and again read more

I had been waiting to try this pizza! I wanted it to be as great as Punches in MN or Pizza Brutta in Madison but if fell short. Not worth the price. If you have never tasted anything as wonderful as those other places I mentioned then this may be really good to you. read more

Broken Tree Pizza - Just too thin :( - Pizza Near Me - Neenah, Wisconsin

Great little pizza place in downtown Neenah. Friendly staff, quick service, pizza red sauce was a little on the spicy side - but excellent. All the toppings were really delicious. Prices were not out of line at all - very reasonable. They do serve a variety of craft beers, as well as typical beers like Miller Lite, as well as soda. I would recommend people take the time to seek this place out. read more

Broken Tree Pizza - They have a stone fired pizza oven. - Pizza Near Me - Neenah, Wisconsin

See all

Amazing wood oven cooked pizza and wonderfully helpful and charismatic staff My family and I look forward to our next visit!!!! read more

Great variety and menu at Broken Tree... Everything we've had has always been great. Kid friendly and if there is a wait the kids can run around in the building rather than attempting to have them sit still, which helps read more

This is the best place around that I've had brick oven pizza! They only have one size, personal, which was a neat concept to me. I was with a larger party and we ordered numerous different kinds. They were all delicious! Fresh ingredients and a very personable staff. I'll definitely be returning! read more

Broken Tree Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Neenah, Wisconsin