Officially a top rated restaurant for my family! Pizza and pasta were both phenomenal. The…read morewaitress, Lily, was so great and our mint was even hand picked next to us. Will definitely be back again and again.

Atmosphere: Cute little place with a very eclectic vibe. They have everything from wall sconces, to…read moreblueprints, to neon signs, a giant moose head, and they have a piano in the front window for people to play. The bathrooms were clean. There was also a real sense of family? amongst the patrons, everyone sitting at the bar seemed to know each other and it had small town feel in a city. Service: Friendly waitstaff from the hostess to the server to the busser to the bartender. The young man working as the busser was literally on the go non-stop. He must have had 3000 steps in just in the time we were there. He filled out water glasses 3 times and we were really grateful for him. Drinks: We didn't opt for drinks this time but will for sure be ordering some during our next visit. The blonde bartender was SLAYING drinks. I've never seen someone so confidently make a cosmo and an old fashion within a 3 min. time span. She is a force and knows exactly what she is doing. Food: We ordered an appetizer and two entrees. I really recommend the calamari appetizer, great quality and the spicy sauce that came with it was delicious (I love the spice level it was perfect!). I literally can't stop thinking about the salad I had, it was so diverse in flavor profile and texture...salty, sweet, acidic, bitter, creamy, crunchy, and fresh. I have only one complaint, both of our water glasses on the table that we had to drink out of were dirty (dried food stuck on the outside of the glasses and a sticky residue). Instead of making a fuss we just asked for straws. I can't wait to come back here, I'm hoping it is sooner than later!

A fantastic spot in downtown Neenah for a great wood fire pizza. The Haley's Comet (added…read moremushrooms) has great flavor combinations. The chicken, bacon, artichokes and onions all play well together. Adding the mushrooms brought a nice umami/earthy flavor to already solid flavor profile. My only small criticism, the pizza could've used another 20-30 seconds. It would've given more crisp to the middle of the pie, and a touch more char would've been . I would recommend swinging in and giving Broken Tree Pizza a try, I will when back in the area.

I rarely give 5 stars. This place rates it. An unassuming little place in downtown Neenah Wisconsin…read moredelivers some of the best pizza I've ever had. Wood fired, with a delicious thin crust. Comes in one size only, 12". I had a "That's Life": house red sauce base, house blend cheese, calabrese salami, Italian seasoning, finished with arugula, balsamic glaze and shredded parmesan. My wife ordered a "Hailey's Comet": creamy garlic sauce base, house blend cheese, chicken, bacon, spinach, artichoke. Both were delicious *chef's kiss*! They have a nice selection of local craft beers. The place is neat, clean, and unassuming. The kitchen is right there, you can watch the wood burn in the oven. Great little place, service was quick and efficient.

We had a great experience here and Joe took fantastic care of us. Our kids came with and they were…read morealso treated well, which isn't always the case. We're excited to try the fish fry! Good pizza, fresh salads and AMAZING gelato (pictured).

We ordered a large thim crust pizza with green pepper, sausage, mushrooms. It was pretty good. I…read morethink the sausage was a little spicy, so I just picked them off. Do you have other sausage like mild or even sweet would be good? All in all it was good and also delivered in a timely manner. Thank you! Pam

Flat out no question my favorite pizza. But absolutely skip the buffet. Order what you like and you…read morewon't be disappointed. The buffet will load up with mushroom pizza, Hawaiian pizza and chicken with peppers trash and sprinkle in a sausage and pepperoni here and there. 5 stars for order what you want pizza and 2 stars for the buffet.

Pretty good pizza ice cream after dinner - staff managed our large party efficiently. Worth a try!read more

Beer and packers and Greenes And beer and packers…read moreAnd some nachos and a fish sandwich and a quesadilla All the food was great Lots of beer choices and bucket specials

Pretty good bar and pub! Food is heavy, but that's to be expected for a bar! Their Bloody Mary bar…read moreon Saturdays is a great deal and very tasty!

If you're not subscribed to their email list, go ahead and do that! You'll get a free coupon for…read moretheir soft pretzel breadsticks with cheese. This place was hopping when we got here on Friday night. I ordered their salmon blt and enjoyed it. There are several side items to choose from. I went with their tater tots. Our server was kind and fast. Batley's is attached to the Best Western hotel so imagine they get a lot of traffic from there.

Our family of six ate here for dinner on a Monday evening on our last day in WI. We had the sirloin…read moresteak, the pork chop, the meatloaf, the prime rib sandwich, the rye sandwich and the pecan salad with shrimp. It was all very fresh and prepared perfectly. The pretzel sticks were a nice appetizer and the Moscow mules were excellent. The place was very clean and looked great. The service was also excellent. We highly recommend this restaurant and we will definitely be back the next time we visit WI.

I stay at the Cobblestone in often, so this is a convenient place to grab a drink or dinner. If I…read morewere to rate the service alone, I would give this place 5+ stars. Logan, Kelsey, and Kat have now taken care of me twice and are so committed to me having the best experience possible. The food is hit and miss. I had the steak flatbread a few weeks ago and it was good. I ordered the salmon last night and found it to be a on the fishy side, the couscous on the salty side, but the asparagus perfectly cooked. I'll continue to come back here and try different things, mainly to say hi to my favorite waitstaff!

Food was terrible. Our waiter was good. Took 25 minutes to get a drink $450 for four people to eat…read moreand it totally sucked our cheese. Curds were frozen inside. Our steaks look like they were boiled not broiled. Prime rib was a half inch thick, terrible terrible terrible never going back ever.

Service-We drove an hour and a half for a medical appointment. We paid for a pizza ahead of time…read moreso we didn't have to wait. I told the girl wih multicolored hair we would be back at 630pm after the appointment. She asked if that was it. I told her we'd get drinks when we came back to eat. I paid, went to the appointment and we came back. We were told it was their policy not to allow carryout orders to eat in the restaurant. When asked why, the rude server said it was their policy. We took our pizza and drove home. It was the last time for us to enter this classless pizza place. Don't buy from this joint.

This may be a first, but giving 5 stars and I didn't really care for the pizza. The service was…read moregreat, speed was great, and the pizza was the type I like - the thin crust - and the crust was very good, good amount of toppings. But more of a personal preference, the sauce was way too sweet for my liking. Like one of the sweetest sauces I've ever had. Not gonna ding the restaurant for that, it's popular for a reason. More of a PSA for those who don't care for sweet sauce. I read the reviews first and saw some comments about it being "tangy". I guess you can call it tangy. I will call it sweet and it's just not my jam.

The wait staff was super friendly, fast and personable. I ordered the firecracker shrimp tacos and…read morewasn't disappointed. They had a live singer who was really good. It was an enjoyable experience

Renee was amazing and was very attentive to our table. I had the Cajun Bleu burger and it was…read moreawesome.