Great pizza! We stopped in early today. Easy menu to navigate in the small counter space area. We ordered 2 small and one large pizza. Crust and flavors - nailed it! The crust was soft on the inside and had great crunch outside. Charred perfectly! The gentleman who took our order and made the pizza brought them out to us along with plenty of plates and napkins. Outside Brickside Pizza there is plenty of places to sit. There is a great new coffee/tea/houseware shop that is worth checking out while you're waiting for your yummy pizza. read more

A nice night to grab a pizza before heading in to see a show at Ivoryton Playhouse. We ordered at the counter and the waitress/ hostess brought our pizza to our table. It was a nice night to sit outside . Our soppressata pie had a sweet honey on it so it was sweet and spicy. I wish the crust was a little crisper on bottom and there was enough grease to soak up two napkins. However the meat generously coveted over the entire pie and had a good flavor. read more

Brickside Pizza - Sweet and spicy pie - Pizza Near Me - Ivoryton, Connecticut

I love this place!! I was born and raised in New Haven and this little pizzeria makes me feel like home. I moved I to the woods oof Deep River and lost all hope of finding something that was even remotely edible. This is my weekly spot. read more

Very yummy food! The pizza and stuffed bread are delicious! Staff are also always very nice!

In CT, we are so lucky to be blessed with a million great pizza options- Brickside Pizza is among them in this area for sure! Great little takeout spot with big flavors! We got the Sunday Dinner with meatballs, ricotta and sauce. We also tried the prosciutto arugula pie as well! They are stocked with plenty of fox on park sodas as well to grab on the way out! read more

See all

Best hidden secret for pizza in Ct. I've had a lot of different pizzas in my lifetime but what makes this pizza so special is the brick oven flavor, homemade sauce and fresh slices of mozzarella. The first time I had it I was in shock. No one made pizza like this. It's a little pricier than other pizza shops in the area but the ingredients substantiate the price. If you want a unique delicious apizza head to the Brickside in Ivoryton, a small borough of Essex. A little off the beaten track but well worth the ride. read more

Best pizza in CT. I've been to Pepe's and Sally's but this local business is better. It is small, but it's wonderful. Also the owners and workers are the best people ever. read more

Hole in the wall (as all greats are). Take out only, should be cash only with weird hours, whatever they want. Brickside might be the best pizza outside of New Haven in CT. read more

Authentic wood fired. Sauce is superb! Love the char! If you aren't near by, it's worth the drive.

If you're looking for quick and delicious this is your pizza spot! It is take out only but that doesn't take away from the taste of the delicious pies. There are so many options of toppings to choose from. I think the Brickside pie is one of my favorites and the white broccoli! read more

See all

The mashed potato pizza is our favorite- call early since they get really busy on the weekends. No place to eat inside. All takeout .

The pizza was good. Not blow your mind the best pizza I've ever had. That said it was a great combination of quality ingredients that made me appreciate how the chewy crust was made from 000 flour no doubt. The sauce was good but the reason why I didn't give it five stars was it was a bit dressed up with spices. Simple San marzano tomatoes with a touch of fresh garlic is all it really needs. Let the cheese and toppings do the work. I highly recommend canceling your trip to New Haven and give it a try. read more

This is pizza. By comparison, all others are an English muffin with ketchup and a slice of American cheese.

By Laura Williams You've heard us throw the words "slightly charred" and "chewy" out there when describing a pizza's appeal. Well, we've found another pie that fits the bill. Brickside Pizza opened in late summer in the Ivoryton village. They had us at the header of the menu where they declare, "Hand Crafted, wood fired pizza baked well done. Charring is to be expected.". Despite the effects of a steamy September afternoon and a bazillion degree brick oven, co-owners Paul Capezzone and Will Nuss were welcoming and informative. Veterans of various shoreline restaurant biz and pizza joints, the pair imported a brick oven from Italy and combined their experience to create this little gem of a shop. The rest of the interior consists soley of a pickup counter, a cord of wood and a fridge full of Foxon Park sodas. Although the menu offers both standard and a handful of curious toppings like mashed potato and shrimp scampi, I figured if they can get the Margherita and the White Clam right, then I can trust these guys. As soon as they took the bubbling White Clam masterpiece out of the blazing oven, I knew it was a winner. Freshly shucked, sweet clams are tossed atop a thin crust with garlic, olive oil, oregano, Pecorino Romano, then cooked to caramelized perfection. This was the best clam pizza I've had this side of New Haven. The Margherita was a close second. Yummy tomato sauce with a perfect punch of fresh flavor, basil ribbons, Mozzarella, more Pecorino, garlic and olive oil. This place is strictly take-out. No seating. Take your picnic to the gazebo or the beautiful town green just across the street for an idyllic dinner. Call in your order and they'll give you an exact time to pick up. Open at 4pm. (860) 767-2555 read more

Brickside Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ivoryton, Connecticut

See all

Ordered two pizzas on a Friday night and the wait was over an hour. I don't think that's a bad wait for a Friday night, but when I picked up my pizzas they were cold. I ordered a white clam pizza and a mozzarella pizza. The white clam was good, lots of clams and garlic. The mozzarella pizza was so burnt I ended up throwing it out. I do understand with the type of stove they use the crust will be black but, the taste was burnt. I'm very disappointed because I've heard good things, I will not come back and will keep going to Otto in Chester or Centerbrook pizza. read more

We LOVE Brickside!! Not only are they super nice, and always give an exact time for pickup, but they have the best pizza! We eat here as a family almost once a week. They make a consistent pie with a perfect crust...not too crispy, not too chewy, not too bready, just the most solid all around pizza crust we've been able to find in the region. (It's even good cold the next day!) They always load up the toppings perfectly and it all tastes fresh. The owners are friendly and community oriented, hosting fundraisers and drives for local causes. We love their calzones and mashed potato pizza, and the kids love their red sauce with broccoli! Give them a try...you won't regret it! read more

I just recently ate a Brick Side and been going there since they open and by far there pizza is the best. It is mostly take out but now have picnic tables on the out side. They never disappoint. If you like New Haven style pizza you will love this place. We who live in CT don't know how lucky we have as CT pizza is the best. I also live in NC it is so hard to find any good pizza. I highly recommend the sausage and mushroom,simple the best. read more

I don't know which New Haven pizza you Yelpers are comparing this pizza to but perhaps your understanding of it isn't exactly the same as mine. First off, having a wood oven does NOT make it New Haven style pizza. I can't think of one famous New Haven joint that uses a wood oven. Not one. Secondly, the type of pizza made here is more like artisan style pizza. It's more like the associazione verace pizza napoletana certified pizza (for those that know what that is). So that means it's not greasy, oily, soupy, or have lots of stringy mozzarella (all things I love by the way). Yes, they do char the crust a little bit (not a lot) but that by itself hardly makes it New Haven style. Come to think of it, this pizza is more like Otto's pizza in Chester. So perhaps it should be called Chester pizza. Anyway, now that I got that off my chest. Yes, I like their pizza. It's not bad. I don't think it's worth the high price though and it could use a few improvements in my opinion. It could use some more sauce and more olive oil, particularly on the outer crust (outer crust is way too barren). It could use some more cheese too and also cut back on the salt. Yes New Haven pizza is very salty, but these guys are piling it on by the truckload in their sauce. If that's not salt then it's some other type of seasoning I can't recognize. By the way, I noticed they get some of their ingredients from Napoli Foods of Cheshire. The dead give-a-way is the Napoli logo printed on the underside of the box. I'm usually not a fan of Napoli foods. However they're like an Italian mob boss that rules southern Connecticut with an iron fist. It's hard to find a pizza joint that doesn't have their influence in one way or another. Unfortunately, the end result is that pizza from these joints ends up all tasting the same. There's no table seating. No problem there. This business has take-out only. read more

Brickside Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ivoryton, Connecticut

See all

I am a bonafide NYC pizza snob - nothing can compare EXCEPT this place. This pizza is legit. I highly recommend this pizza if you can try it!!! Delish! read more

Opening day today. Stopped in and was their 3rd customer. I opted for the meat. A very solid pizza, wood fired oven so it's the New Haven style crust. A very welcome alternative to the greasy or sweet crust pizzas we have in town All the best of luck boys. read more

See all

First time here At brickside pizza, pizza was Excellent, highly recommend. you must try will be back. FIVE STARS

The best pizza in the tri-town. The soppressata is world class and the crust is the best in the area. The best pizza on the river of near the shoreline and worth a drive. read more

Paul and Will make great pizza and are always willing to talk pizza with me. It's like my favorite thing to talk about as well as eat. They do have outdoor seating. This is a great place to grab a bite before a show. read more

Pizza is out of this world. Tried tons of combinations, all amazing. By far the best pizza I've ever had.... Must try. Typically I don't eat the crust...OMG, I ate every last bite. read more

Brickside Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ivoryton, Connecticut

Meh. I've have plenty if pizza, both good and not. I used to live near New Haven son an familiar with that as well as artisan pizzas made by various restaurants throughout CT and RI. My neighbors were racing about this place so I figured I would try it. Fresh ingredients and a New Haven style crust were promised. Maybe my expectations were set too high. I really wanted to love this pizza but it just doesn't live up to the hype. The toppings were super stingy. There was barely any cheese on it. I specifically was looking forward to that golden, nutty flavor of fresh mozzarella that other local joints won't provide. I couldn't even taste the cheese. There were only a couple of shrooms on it and the sauce was barely there. I felt like I had ordered a burnt crust with a side of sample toppings. Wish I took a picture of it. I can't say I am inclined to return. read more

We've tried this place twice since they opened and their pizza is AMAZING!! Probably some of the best pizza I've ever had. I'm so glad it's right down the road from us. There's only one oven so the wait times are a little long but totally worth it! read more

Brickside Pizza - Bacon, Hamburg and Pepperoni pizza. AMAZING! So much flavor! - Pizza Near Me - Ivoryton, Connecticut

See all

Love this place. I've tried their mozz, sausage, and their clams casino. Never been disappointed. The wood oven makes the crust perfectly charred (not burned as another review suggested). They're take out only so keep that in mind. read more

So Brickside opened on Tuesday and I went on Thursday after I heard they ran out of dough their first night open! Now brickoven pizza should be a 10 minute wait, max, however we had to wait 35 minutes. Since this is their first week, we'll let it slide. However, expecting improvements in order time within a few weeks. Will definitely be back, but call your order in ahead. I had the Brickside pizza with basil, tomato, smoked gouda, pecorino, and prosciutto (a bit pricey @ $15 for a small and $20 for a large)...worth the wait! read more

Brickside Pizza - Brickside Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ivoryton, Connecticut

I received the pizza burnt on all edges. I love fire pizza but this was too much. It was also not very hot, but because I like my pizza not too hot it was OK with me. I have met both of the owners and they are awesome and passionate! What they have to pay more attention to is detail. They are so talented and love what they do. I wish them so much success! BTW The delivery person was awesome also read more

The best cheese pizza I've ever had.. honestly. And I work at a pizza restaurant! I've tried a few of their specialty zas, but there's something about their basic cheese that is unreal. Great job guys! Looking forward to trying each pizza on the menu! read more

Great pizza spot and not because of lack of competition in a small town. This wood fired pizza joint would more than hold its own in a big city. Great service, and variety of different pizzas. Highly recommend!! read more

I would love to find New Haven style pizza closer to home than New Haven and I thought this might be it. Not bad but not awesome enough to make a special return trip. Really stingy toppings. Need a magnifying glass to find the sausage and mushrooms. Pizza takes on a bit of the wood burning flavor which is interesting but a thing. Some charred areas took up alot of the pizza which if eating black burnt bits is what you like-there you go. This place has potential but not there yet. read more

Very impressed! Delicious crust, good sauce, fresh mozzarella. Very happy with first visit. Will be coming back! Some of the best pizza in this area for sure! My son thinks the plain mozz he got could've used more cheese (we'll ask for extra next time for him). I got the Margherita - was delicious! Not quite Pepe's (my favorite) or I'd give it a 5-Star. read more

I think Joe C's review is the most pretentious thing I've ever read. It's pizza (for those who know what that is). I'm surprised he even got a look at it with his nose so far in air. (anyway, now that I got that off my chest) It's a good pie. Support these guys, they do good work. read more

I may be wrong, but I do not like burnt pizza. Also, when someone orders a veggie pizza they expect to see veggies on the pizza. Instead there was eggplant the size of a penny, no exaggeration, and the spinach was dried and crispy. I want to support my local businesses but this was just not good pizza. My advice: cook the pizza, do not burn it, and then put roasted veggies on after the pizza is out of the oven. You have a brick oven so making roasted veggies should be easy, and put a good amount of veggies on there. $20 for a medium pie with not even a normal serving size of veggies is not good. Sorry but this is my second time at your place, I thought I would give it another chance and I was disappointed again. I cannot go back for the third time. read more

I live one mile away.I just finally tried a pizza from them.Very good ,got a Margarita pizza.I suggest they start to deliver because Deep River Pizza is the closest place that will dilver and they only deliver Thurs thru Sunday. read more

Love love love this pizza place! Best brick side pizza in the state. Primarily take out, but they have a few tables outside where one can eat in warmer months . Pizza is always thin crust, ingredients are always fresh and flavorful, and menu is large and varied. Be sure to try their Buffalo Chicken pizza. Also their namesake pizza, Brickside - mouth waters just thinking about it!!!! read more

Brickside pizza is great. Their pizza is delicious and is by far the best around Essex and ivoryton. This will always be my choice. The owners work here everyday and are extremely friendly and helpful! Delicious pizza and great service, you can't beat it! read more

Today we ordered a cheese pizza and got a sauce pizza with hints of cheese. Love the idea of a brick oven style pizza, but my family and I have orderd pizza there three times and it's undercooked and not to flavorful...worst part it's under cooked yet still burnt on the crusts... basically buying burnt dough... yum tasty... read more

i almost rate a 5, but have a slight hesitation. Saturday afternoon and it was quiet. The restaurant has ONE table inside which was fortunately available. If not, there would have been a dilemma, where to eat ? The two owners are GREAT. They are striving for artisan pizza and take great care in the preparation and cooking process......very caring and focused. On this quiet afternoon, they were engaging, but not obtrusive, totally enjoyed them. The standard meatball, roasted peppers, cheese was very good (half with spinach). Ample toppings assembled with great care. They are fussy and it shows. The crust was slightly charred from the wood fired oven, cooked PERFECTLY. So, the crust was flavorful with good texture, the toppings were very good, enjoyed the pizza very much. On a whim, added a white clam pizza (Fresh Clams) and it was AWESOME..........Loved it. All in all, the food and experience was great. I will have issues with the table not being available and that is a concern. ***With such a limited menu and obscure location, I see issues. I will definitely return for pizza. I think they should expand the menu slightly to offer grinders ( meatball, cold cut, ham, roast beef, veggie ) to satisfy those who may not want a whole pizza. I think their customers and people nearby might enjoy the option. Fun experience and will return. read more