Tried to get in on a Friday evening without reservations and it was over an hour wait, so we left. I made reservations for the following Saturday evening outside. The atmosphere on the outdoor patio is nice with umbrellas during the day and string lighting for the evening. We started of with their soup of the day, corn chowder. Plenty of roasted corn, just the right amount of potatoes and an oh so creamy chowder base. Simply delicious. My wife had the grilled mahi mahi with pesto butter and grilled asparagus. The fish was cooked perfectly and the presto butter complimented the filet nicely. I had the grilled mahi tacos with shoe string fries (I will try their chips next time since the were out during this visit). The tacos were delicious with huge smokey flavor from the grilled fish. The fries were crispy and flovorful (I had to fend off my better half's invasion numerous times). To round off our great meal and evening, we split a key lime pie since I'm a sucker for this delightful dessert. Hands down, this is one of the best key lime pie I've ever had. I actually contemplated a slice to go but I'll save that for my next visit. Oh, I forgot to mention our waiter was excellent and BYOB is welcomed which is awesome. This place is a hidden gem in our area and we will definitely come back. read more

Excellent! My favorite restaurant. Super clean, staff is excellent, and the food is phenomenal. Highly recommend the California Tuna bowl.

Great food , nice atmosphere , friendly staff- will be returning for sure ! They do have some gluten free options and old York cellar wine (or you can BYOB)! read more

Sitting outside it was so cold and we are eating cold food after 5 minutes. Take out has been okay but it's about 30 minutes before you get to your meal. Not worth the $75 meal. No indoor dining. read more

I'm not sure why I haven't reviewed this place yet. It's been in Flemington for a such a long time and has become a staple dining location in my family. Overall, the food quality has been increasing over the years. We love their pesto butter and the way you can mix and match your protein with sides. We really enjoyed the tuna "nachos" today, which were crispy wontons with spicy ahi tuna. You can bring your pooch to sit on the porch in the summer! read more

See all

The food is fantastic and the service is excellent!! Love getting there for a quick lunch!!

The food and service just isn't what it used to be. I have seen some hard-working bus people and pleasant hostess, but servers don't refill beverages (last 2 times i was there, different server each time). Don't clear plates when you say you are finished. Used to be a go-to place, now just so-so. read more

Had a nice lunch here! Got the fried calamari and fish and chips and grilled pineapple. Fried calamari was pretty good and standard. Wish it came with red sauce and not tartar sauce. It also seemed to come with a combi or other fried things like peppers. Was good ! Fish and chips was actually one of the best. There is just something about their fries that is sooo good. It was like a sugar paprika seasoning that was amazing. The fish was light and flaky. The grilled pineapple was okay. Seemed not particularly ripe and was very smoky tasting. I dont think I would get it again but it was good. Parking lot available but it was packed when I was there so I opted to park on the street. Looks like there is also an outdoor patio when it's a bit warmer out. Would come back ! read more

Love this place. It's always great. Staff is friendly Food outstanding. Soup is super

The food was exquisite!! The waitress was amazing. Overall great experience. They opened at 3, I had to wait 15 minutes to get in and get seated, which is better than a lot of other places. I really enjoyed the experience around the whole Area. Highly Recommend! read more

Blue Fish Grill - Fried Calamari, Ahi Tuna Bowl - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Consistent and a great menu. They've never disappointed us. Tacos are a must, as is the fried calamari and wet burrito.

I treated a friend to dinner this week by ordering takeout from here. The food was absolutely DELICIOUS!!!! I ordered the CaliMex burrito and it looked like a football--it was massive! My friend ordered off the ala carte menu and her salmon was perfect--and the soy/ginger/garlic sauce was out of this World! read more

First time eating here and had to try after reading the reviews. I concur with all the 5 stars. I definitely recommend reservations. The Mojo Mariscos was phenomenal. The sea scallops were tender, shrimp were cooked perfectly, and the mussels in the broth brought the dish together as a while. Use the grilled bread to sop up the broth when finished. You won't want to waste one bit. Kareem was our server, very funny and a professional!!! For him, "Go Pats". I highly recommend this restaurant to all who are in the Flemington area!! read more

If you ever find yourself in Hunterdon be sure to add BFG to your itinerary! The food is incredible and menu staples (like the Cali mex burrito) never disappoint. Do yourself a favor and order the plantains...but make sure to order at least two orders because trust me you won't want to share. The outdoor patio is great for eating outside and the upstairs space is nice for parties or larger gatherings. Ask to be seated in Karim's section! read more

New menu is great, service is always fantastic. Have been going for years and will continue to. Now we take our two young kids and they enjoy the kids menu very much. read more

My wife and I really enjoy the food here, especially for the price. BYOB. They have multiple seating areas...downstairs is the livelier area, upstairs a little quieter and they also have outdoor seating. There are a lot of seafood based dishes like fish tacos and tuna bowls which are all excellent. The tuna nachos app is delicious. Love the value...great food reasonable prices. read more

Went here with my family today and enjoyed a lovely lunch. My parents are on some weird fad diet where they can't have nightshade vegetables, dairy that isn't from the UK, nuts, legumes, grains and most things that make food taste good. Despite Blue Fish Grill being a super tasty restaurant that likes to serve food that tastes good, they were able to accommodate these crazy people. My grandma and I enjoyed the crab cake plate and my husband loved his mahi-mahi tacos. Everyone left full and happy! The service was very slow(an hour and half lunch with no dessert) but other than that our experience was great! read more

Very cool spot. Got takeout and they were quick and the food was amazing. The tuna nachos were a hit and the crab cakes were bigger and better than expected! Definitely will visit again when I'm back in town. read more

3 words: Ahi Tuna Nachos... Imcredible. Everything else on the menu is excellent as well, and the service is always friendly and efficient. The menu is constantly changing with innovative takes on traditional dishes. You won't be disappointed. read more

We go to blue fish every couple of weeks, one of our local favorites! Always fresh, great food. Service even better. BYOB! Sitting outside in the summer is great there. read more

This is one of the few nice places in Flemington that doesn't close between lunch and dinner, which is why my pal and I chose to meet here (and its high rating). The food and service were both great. It's BYOB, though they do sell half and full bottles of wine from Old York Cellars. (No cork fee if you BYOB.) read more

See all

What the f*ck Bluefish. After 20 years you changed your fries. I can no longer eat here even though I enjoy your restaurant immensely!!!!

Food and service we both great here! I ordered the Mahi Mahi Tacos and we had empanadas as an app. Both were different, but very delicious. The empanadas has plantains inside. The tacos had a nice slaw on top of the fish, and you also had the option to grill or fry the fish. I opted for a side salad and was not disappointed with that either. Our server was funny and very knowledgeable. I would definitely come here again! read more

Dinner on the front deck was just fantastic! We were a party of six... four adults, one five year, and one three year old... with hungry bellies after some serious hiking nearby. We were greeted warmly and immediately felt at home. You can tell this restaurant has worked hard at making everyone feel safe and hearing so many people say hello by first name - I instantly knew this was where the town came to eat dinner. Tom, our server was fun, and gave us good advice on what the local favorites were. We tried a little of everything and it was all amazing!! Our five year old even said (after eating all three of his chicken tenders) that when he gets older he wants to come back here and get these chicken tenders again. This made us all crack up!!! But we also thought the same thing after tasting our food as well...we just have the advantage of getting in our car and coming again whenever we want - which will be as soon as we can! We live an hour and a half away but this is now our favorite spot for sure!!! Thank you Blue Fish Grill!! read more

See all

Good food, casual atmosphere, friendly servers. My only complaint would be a bit pricey.

They have great food and great service! The only thing my friend, who is English, didn't care for was that she thought the bread was too sweet. But if you know any English people, they all think that American bread is too sweet! Other than that, we had a wonderful time!!! read more

What else is there to say... Our favorite local spot! We've done celebrations, regular days, d date nights and have never been upset about it read more

Cute place. We dined outside for dinner. Great service. A little pricey but I would go back.

I visited Blue Fish Grill again last night and sure enough, it was just as good. I'm glad we got there relatively early (around 5:15pm) because the restaurant got packed within the couple hours we were there. Pretty much every table was occupied and it was only a Thursday night! Service was good. Our server was very knowledgeable about the specials they were offering. I wasn't too hungry so I ordered off of the kids menu. Other restaurants have given me a hard time about this in the past so I was relieved when they told me it wouldn't be a problem. I ordered the popcorn shrimp which came with fries. The portion size was surprisingly large. My meal was really good... the fries might have been the best part! I also love that the restaurant is BYO. If you forget to bring your own alcohol, don't worry because they sell wine from Old York Cellars as well! read more

Blue Fish Grill - Kid's meal: popcorn shrimp and fries! - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

I have gone several times and it's always so salty. The outdoor area is nice, and it's a BYOB which is always good.

Amazing food as usual. Staff is attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. Great specials.

My husband and I have been dining here for YEARS! It is hands down one of our favorite restaurants and now a favorite of our three children: 9, 6, 2 since this place was always our first out to dinner meal each of them were born. The food is amazing and I love the staff. The energy is so inviting and the casual, yet clean ambiance is just what we look for when dining. When we asked our 9 year old where he wanted to celebrate his birthday with the family he picked you:) And we are not around the corner..about 30 minutes away, but so worth it! read more

Blue Fish Grill - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

Used to be one of my favorite fish taco place, but unfortunately their menu changed. My go to was always the BFG tacos, which were seriously one of the best fish tacos ever. Apparently, they took it off the menu the day before I came back to town for a visit. Previously fries and chips came with the fish tacos and sandwiches. Now you have to pay extra for them. I tried the Latin Mahi bowl, since my usual BFG tacos were missing. i'm not one to leave food on my plate. If I do, I usually pack it up. In this case, I didn't want to bother bringing the dish home. The fish was really dry and the beans were bland. The redeeming factor of the dish were the caramelized plantains. Those were delicious at least. I wish the restaurant would return back to its original menu and quality of food. Now, the food isn't as good and the prices are higher. This could be due to the fact that they moved from their original location to a larger building with two floors. I guess they need to cover the expense somehow, but I would have been happier had they stayed in their original location producing the high quality food that I had always attributed to them. read more

The food was absolutely amazing and the service even better. This place is the place to go for a delicious seafood and burger meal in a quaint and comfortable atmosphere. Definitely visiting again! read more

Okay, where is the water, beach, sand, and seagulls? Feels like this place should be at the shore and if it was it would get an extra star. The Baja Tacos I ordered were good though the fish was a little tough yet not dry or greasy so go figure that one. I love the thin fries and service was great. If the weather is with you the outside tables are a great feature -- just missing the view! read more

WOW what a great meal. I am SO happy we ordered the Mussels. They came in this DELICIOUS coconut curry tasting broth. Excellent. I ordered the Latin Mahi Bowl, loved it. The Mahi was so so good, perfect flavor. The Black Beans, Rice, and Plantains were done well. My friend ordered the Grilled Shrimp, Asparagus, and Rice and it came with a side of Pesto Butter. I tasted the Pesto Butter, YUM! I saw them bring out some amazing looking salads and sandwiches, can't wait to come back and get that. Atmosphere: Perfect blend of Industrial, Casual, and Stylish. Wish I didn't live an hour away, but I will be back soon! read more

See all

Favorite restaurant in flemington. Have to get the tuna nachos every time. I have been going for years and have never had a bad meal. Service is always excellent. read more

I still absolutely love this place. They have a new location and I love it so much more than the other place, why? Well I hated that other parking lot and this one is so much easier to get in and out of. I know that sounds like an absurd comment but really it is so much better! The inside is really clean and nice, I love the lamp jars, I notice the little details. It doesn't seem to have any more seating than it used to. It is more open and looks much nicer. I did not see any outside seating, but this also could be due to the new location and it not being super warm yet. There is a bigger waiting area in the front. Food is just as good as ever. The menu changed a little bit. I was nervous when I didn't see the Calamari Po-Boy on there because I also turn that into tacos. If you love calamari then I would definitely suggest that. NOT the one with avocado, the one with coleslaw and tartar sauce. It's heavenly. The french fries are still amazing and I love getting extra seasoning for it. The owner is super nice and friendly, always remembers my boyfriend and the waitress even remembered us. Great people and great food. read more

Blue Fish Grill - the new sign at BFG! - Seafood Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Fabulous lunch, awesome service by Karim. Every dish was delicious and bursting with a variety of flavors. We started with an appetizer special called Campechana which was terrific. I had the Mahi tacos with homemade Kimchi, my wife had the California Tuna Bowl and my daughter had the Big Fish Bowl with salmon. All of the fish was super fresh and cooked perfectly. Can't wait to come back. read more

Our go to spot for sure! We love it here! The tacos (all varieties) are delish and my husband loves ya the bahn mi sandwich