When I was a kid, my hometown had a pizza buffet that I absolutely loved, and it was a crushing…read moremoment when it closed down. Pizza Buffets just aren't as popular as they used to be, and rare to come across. I was passing through on the interstate on vacation when we stumbled across this gem on Yelp and decided to stop. With a name like Best Pizza in Town, you have to assume it's good right? Price was reasonable and seating options were plenty - we chose the outside patio to enjoy the warm breeze. The salad bar was a bit limited, but this was made up with a strong selection of pizza options which rotated and were refreshed frequently during our visit. I was really impressed to see chicken wings as an option, something I don't recall seeing elsewhere. The wings weren't anything exceptional but they were decent. They were very mild, and while I understand doing that to be the option for the largest crowds, I wish they would have at least had cups of hotter buffalo sauce on the side for those of us who like it hot. All told, we had a very enjoyable experience here with good food, friendly staff, and a fair price. If I lived local, I'd absolutely come back here.

Upgrading my review, as my second visit here was MUCH better than the first. My bf and I stopped in…read morean hour before closing and the server made sure we were informed of how long we had to get fresh food. If something you want is not out, they can still make it for you! The guy behind the pizza counter was also super friendly & helpful and kept bringing out new pizza variations and fulfilled our requests. There is also a salad bar available & mac and cheese, plus other sides as well. The pizza also tasted MUCH better than I remember, was crispy and made well. Even the dessert ones! Unsure if they actually made changes, but everything was great this time.

I've already tried many pizza places around the area since moving here, and I will say it's been…read moredifficult to find good Italian food. I decided to order a Calzato, which I was happy you could choose your own filling, instead of the standard meat options. I chose tomato, onion, and green pepper. The ingredients tasted fresh, the sauce was great, and the dough was nice and crispy. The calzato was also big enough for me to save half for a second meal! Service is also quick, since it's a drive-thru, which is convenient. It's easy to use the app and order, while also earning points for future orders.

Want to thank Russel for making my order right after a miss communication ordering the first time!…read moreI am a food lover. I dont like pizza much but I am from Cincinnati, I grew up on Donatos and I absolutely love mariachi beef! Thanks Russel

Great pizza. Delicious and fast service Customer service got a whole lot better. Will be back.read more

Decided to give this spot a try without high hopes, as most pizza spots in the area are…read morelackluster-- that said, this place is absolutely fantastic! Service was great, and they have a nice dining room. We got a pepperoni pizza; crust was crunchy and flavorful but not burnt, sauce was light and they use good cheese!! We got the sampler as well, just to give them a full run. Wings were crispy, and spicy. Perfect size. Mozzarella sticks had a great pull Chicken tenders were crunchy, and fresh. Your average tender, but of good quality nevertheless. For dessert, I ordered my wife some tiramisu; she was thoroughly impressed. We think it's house made. I decided on the cannoli. I've never had one, but I certainly will have more in the future! I can undoubtedly say, this is my new go to spot for the 'goods'.

Fratellos is the best italian in the area! Food always so…read moreflavorful, delicious and perfectly seasoned. Service always top notch! Some of our favorites...Fried calamari, shrimp scampi and Linguine with white olive oil clam sauce. Love their cannolis as well!

Everything was delicious- the wings, the pizza, the drinks and the bread with butter all so good!…read moreThe waiter was extremely polite and welcoming and provided everything without asking. Will definitely come again! 10/10

I picked a to go large chicken tikka masala. Very…read moredisappointed with the pizza. For starters, they did not even slice the pizza, There is barely any taste to the pizza, i wouldn't call it chicken tikka pizza at all. Its just veggies and chicken with cheese and sauce. And the worst, i could smell the chicken and it had a weird taste... most likely not fresh. Overall, an expensive waste.

Raw pizza dough. Called to complain and they weren't any help. Didn't mute when explaining to boss,…read moreheard them laughing before I was hung up on. Won't eat here ever again. Used to be amazing place 2-3 years ago, since moving back to area we've had a hair in our pizza and raw dough

I've had Papa Johns a few times and didn't really think their food was that great, but decided to…read moregive the pizza a try and enjoyed it! Doesn't taste the same as I remember from my childhood, but better than frozen pizza. I wish the pizza was more crispy though, instead of chewy, but the sauce is good and they add enough topping. It's easy to order on the app and pickup, earn "papa dough" and there are always specials going on too, so you can get food cheaper.

Worst pizza I had in Boiling Springs. Very little toppings. No taste! Frozen pizza has more…read moretoppings!

Ordered a pizza to go and as we pulled into the parking lot, there were several people standing in…read morethe parking lot in front of Starbucks. I went inside to the counter and never acknowledged. They were busy but there was no one else in line. After a few minutes of waiting, some of the people that were out in the parking lot, including an employee, came in and was served by the employee that was out in the parking lot. Another customer came in and was served immediately after that. Meanwhile, I still haven't even been acknowledged. There are plenty of other pizza places in town so, screw it, keep your pizza, I'm going down the road.

Always friendly, always amazing. Had some small mistakes but they always fix them. This place is…read moreamazing and the pizza is incredible. I'm gonna make this review a bit short here by summing up some menu items. Onto the rundown.. Pizza: 5/5 stars! Amazing selection and incredible flavor. The sauce sings. Chain pizza that doesn't taste like chain pizza? Apparently it's possible. I'm sold. Cheese sticks: 4/5 stars Almost as good as their pizza. I can't help feel something is missing. Perhaps some extra seasonings to make it stand out from the pizza would boost another star. Steak & Cheese Sub: 5/5 stars Mayo, steak, cheese, amazing bread. Done. Can't believe I would go here just for the subs. Wings: 3/5 stars This is where they fall short. By short I mean small. Small wings. If they were fried to order and freshly tossed in sauce instead of baked they'd hit 4/5 but too small for anything higher - however the price is great and doesn't make you feel guilty about adding some to your order. There you have it. Forget about any worries, stop in and give them a chance and you won't regret it. You won't be able to tell they have more than one location around because unlike many chain pizza places, they've yet to sacrifice quality over anything else.

Waited over a half hour in drive through for a mobile order placed 15 minutes before arriving…read more Pizza was good. Never getting their wings again. They are actually disgusting. Very undercooked. Soft and chewy.

food has potential when it's done correctly. they have messed it up 6/5 times. drivers are…read moreincompetent when delivering, make pit stops and even deliver to the wrong address 3 times in one night. don't waste your time, spend your money elsewhere.