Everything they make is delicious! Makes most things from…read morescratch, bread, chips, pickles, you name it, and source almost all ingredients from local/area farmers. The small bit dedicated staff are delightful and courteous. It feels very homey inside too. Oh and they added an ice cream parlour outside during the summer. Literally nothing negative to say about Oldwick General store. I dine in and take-out every single time I am near.

I had an excellent pork roll, egg & cheese on a very fresh and 'homemade' roll…read more A generous and delicious sandwich! BLT and Pastrami sandwiches also got great reviews. Enjoyed our sandwiches on the picnic tables outside.

Food well prepared and tasty. It is a hidden gem. It is fun to eat at an old train station.read more

What a lovely place. And real trains outside. The food is exceptional. My tuna club, brimming with…read moreall the right ingredients. Think BLT but with added (really tasty) tuna. I am just thrilled to go again. Really close to home too. I know. It's the trains outside. But really. This is great food. Made with love. It's obvious.

There are many sub shops in New Jersey and some are really good. This many years old but young in…read morespirit sub shop is worth the trip from anywhere. Great bread frames the thumanns deli meat. Tangy vinegar is charming along with oregano and spices. I love this place

Hands down the best sandwich shop around! We've been going to the Sub Base for about three decades…read more Have never been disappointed ever. I have had sandwiches from the first owner (poor guy was a Jets fan) and Scott the current owner (a Giants fan). They both put a lot of love in a sandwich. I've had several varieties and they are all great, not to mention the chili and soups! I highly recommend!

Eh, it was honestly just ok. When I bit the sandwich at times it tastes like a 3 star, other times…read morelike no better than 2 1/2. But I lean towards 3 automatically because I prefer to see business do good. I ended up getting the tooth fairy on a whole sub. My friend had the chicken salad sub. POSITIVES: Bread was good & fresh just like the cold cuts & Cole slaw. They definitely take care of their product. Presentation from how the sandwich was put together, & the Turkey portion was THE BEST. Not too much where it only tasted like Turkey & pastrami, but just the right amount to make it a hefty sandwich where all the ingredients complimented each other. Wrapping & bagging is worthy of mention, great job. NEGATIVES: It was mostly Turkey with a tiny amount of pastrami, like one slice, MAYBE two. The Turkey did not taste like it was a good brand. It didn't have a bad taste, it just wasn't great quality. It would have been a better experience if the Cole slaw wasn't drowned in thousand islands dressing. Since the pastrami was so little it really doesn't make sense to put that dressing on it. Some bites the meat & cheese were nice & warm & other bites it was pretty cold, that inconsistency threw me off. As for the chicken salad sub, my friend had better & also gave it a 3. CUSTOMER SERVICE: The young lady did great in putting things together. Seemed to be a great employee as far as performance, she may need a little improvement with friendliness. Can't say she was rude but a bit stand offish. Friendliness goes a long way. Overall, when you compare the price for quality, I honestly wouldn't come back here again. This place is NOWHERE near a 4 1/2 in my opinion, but I hope they do well.

I had another few items from this spot once again…read more This time I had the Miss Malley sandwich. It was made up of turkey, bacon, melted Swiss, pepperoni, tomatoes, onion, and Shedd's sauce. This was okay. It was not as filled as previous sandwiches I had from here. I would have liked to see a little more pepperoni present. It was definitely an interesting combination, but it failed to meet expectations for me. The Shedd's sauce seemed to be similar to Russian dressing. The bread was great like usual. I also had two of their homemade cookies, oatmeal chocolate chunk and M&M chocolate chip. Again, these were alright. The oatmeal needed more chocolate present. The M&M one was too soft as it broke fairly easily. It did not seem like this particular one was cooked all the way. The taste was there, but just not executed to perfection.

Stopped here for Small Business Saturday, but they were closed for the weekend. So, my wife and I…read morewent the following week and wasn't disappointed. We made a quick stop here for coffee and and a breakfast sandwich. Didn't get a chance to walk around and check out the entire space, because the photos on here shows it to be nicely decorated. The staff was extremely friendly and very courteous. The service was quick and the food is absolutely delicious. I ordered the bacon egg and cheese sandwich and it hit the spot! We will be sure to comeback and grab a seat!

Charming cafe. Lots of refrigerated items. They can also heat them up for you. To-go items are a…read morebit pricey but everything seems fresh. When it gets crowded it does get loud. All the food options that I saw people eating looked amazing. I can say that the Mac and cheese was really good as was the summer farro salad and French fries!

Best deli around. Helen and Benny are the absolute best. Great food. Great prices. Helen makes sure…read moreto ask you your name and remembers all of her customers. They treat you as family members.

It's like sitting in the kitchen when I was a child. Helen and Benny are so warm and friendly it's…read morea pleasure to be there.

Chicken. Cutlet. Sandwich. If you want one you have to stop in to Defonte's. Make sure to have cash…read moreon hand because they do not accept cards, and if you're smart, you'll grab yourself some rainbow cookies before you check out. One long line for ordering but it moves quickly because they have a lot of staff. You order from your person and stay with them the whole time. They ring you up. Everything is fresh and so so good. No seating inside, but they have some tables on the side when you exit the building.

A little disappointed with my experience here…read more I ordered a hot roast beef with gravy and got a cold roast beef sandwich even after confirming with the lady at the register twice. My girlfriend has a sesame allergy so we asked for a roll with no seeds. They had no plain rolls but had a wheat roll. For some reason, the lady just decided to remove the seeds from the seeded roll and serve that. Those seeded rolls have seeds deep in the bread so we found tons of seeds in the bread still and couldn't eat them. Just feels very careless and these sandwiches ain't cheap. That said, the food was good, but how do you completely mess up the entire order like that?

You guys are sick! (In the best way possible) ... I ordered a "large" daredevil... the sandwich was…read more18 inches long and 3.3 pounds I live in NYC and have tried every viral sub.. longfellows in Morristown is the best -- and so old school they probably don't know what "going viral" means, and don't want to. In my opinion they're 1 of 1. That's all

I've lived in Morristown my whole life, and it's easy to know that some spots just become part of…read morethe town's identity, and Longfellow's is absolutely one of them. This place has been a go-to neighborhood deli for years, and it's easy to see why. It's a quaint spot that's built its reputation on consistently fresh, high-quality sandwiches and genuinely great service. People in town don't just like it, they respect it. It's one of those places locals will recommend without hesitation, and once you go, you get it. This is a small, classic deli where you order, grab your food, and go. Honestly, that's part of the charm. It feels authentic in the best way possible. Just a solid, well-run spot that focuses on doing one thing really well: making incredible sandwiches. Everything tastes fresh, the portions are generous, and the quality is exactly what you want from a true Jersey deli. You can tell they take pride in what they do. Places like this are getting harder to find, and Longfellow's has managed to stay a staple in the Morristown community for a reason. Whether you're a local or just passing through, it's 100% worth the stop.

My husband stopped in over the weekend to grab a few subs. Sandwiches were delicious! Grabbed 4…read moredifferent options. The staff helping didn't seem to know if they had prosciutto or arugula. They were quite young and probably new. I'm sure with time they will get familiar with the menu. Really enjoyed it and can't wait to come back to get more!! Keep in mind - Closed on Mondays

I was in town for training and had lunch here several days. Nice little sub shop/deli on a quaint…read moreMain Street. Staff was friendly and created their masterpieces quickly. Had subs 2 of the days and the bread was very fresh and they were packed with meat. No scales used here. Final day I decided to try the roast beef Sloppy Joe. Not what most people think of a Sloppy Joe (see pic). It was a great double decker sandwich with coleslaw and Russian dressing along with a few other items and a ton of roast beef(ok maybe slight exaggeration. If you are hungry and want a sub or sandwich this is a great place to stop. Make sure you are hungry or ready to take some home!

I would give this a 6 out of 5. I ordered the tres leches French toast. It was sweet but not too…read moresweet and it was the perfect amount for me. We were seated almost immediately and we really liked the overall vibe. Amazing experience overall!

He know and the staff are absolutely amazing and the food is incredible. Don't hesitate to visit…read morethis restaurant. You won't be sorry.