Everything they make is delicious! Makes most things from scratch, bread, chips, pickles, you name it, and source almost all ingredients from local/area farmers. The small bit dedicated staff are delightful and courteous. It feels very homey inside too. Oh and they added an ice cream parlour outside during the summer. Literally nothing negative to say about Oldwick General store. I dine in and take-out every single time I am near. read more

I had an excellent pork roll, egg & cheese on a very fresh and 'homemade' roll. A generous and delicious sandwich! BLT and Pastrami sandwiches also got great reviews. Enjoyed our sandwiches on the picnic tables outside. read more

Nice place in a very nice historic downtown. We had excellent BLTs. Also good service. Will be back.

So ... just driving around enjoying the fall season when we 'stumble' into oldwick market. Cute Victorian home charm with a highly efficient kitchen. Staff is welcoming and accommodating as well. FOOD is extraordinary... best pork belly benedict of my life --- crispy juicy pork belly with little fat and homemade biscuits to bring it all together -- so good that the hollandaise sauce is completely unnecessary. We may take the two hour drive again just to try their lunch! ! read more

Just enjoyed a thoroughly delicious breakfast/lunch with wonderful food from Chef/owner Sam. Professional, cheerful service and great coffee. Crazy good smoked brisket/pastrami breakfast sandwich was epic. Btw, smoker was going out on patio this frigid day, which began the seduction before entry :) Dessert was on site baked croissant, And cinnamon rolls. All were best in class :) Our area is kind of a quality food desert.... Sam has made Oldwick Market a shimmering oasis of ambrosial food! Thank you. I will be back asap read more

Oldwick Market - Breakfast sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Tewksbury, New Jersey

See all

very disappointed in the service and food. I use to look forward going there the staff is not friendly and the food is nothing special and overpriced read more

The specialty sandwiches here are delicious and huge! Plus, if you order chicken fingers or fries, they wrap it in such a way so that they aren't a soggy mess by the time you get home. My family and I each try something different when we order. Not a single complaint and everything we've all had is waaaaay above average. I haven't had breakfast or pizza here, but have heard great things. A trillion stars all around read more

So glad this place is under new ownership. New openers are doing great. Good is great and they really cleaned it up with the renovation. No more funk. BTW the Nashville Chicken Sandwich is outstanding. Thanks ! read more

I used to go prior to renovations and let me tell you... they stepped up their game! I absolutely love the new look with the original wood beams, but even more importantly, the food is fantastic! I got a ham and cheese sandwich two days in a row. For what you pay, they give you a ton of meat. I also got a fruit tart and pasta salad that were also amazing. This area lacks in a lot of nice food places, but the Oldwick Market will be a new usual for sure. I can't wait to try the pizza! read more

Went today for lunch and was very impressed! It's been completely remodeled and looks amazing. It has a very cute, rustic farmhouse feel and is very spacious. I had a grilled chicken wrap with fresh mozzarella and hot peppers - it was the best wrap I've had in a long time!!! All of the other food looks delicious as well (pizza, shrimp creole, Parmesan crusted chicken, etc). I can't wait to come back and try these and more! The service was great, prices are reasonable, and the food was excellent. It's so nice having such a convenient, local spot right in town! I also love that you can dine outside in the shade or at picnic tables. This will be my go to spot for lunch from now on! read more

New owners, new name, new life! Good sandwiches and menu options for take out or dine in ( outside seating available). I have only ordered sandwiches but was happy with my selections. I am so happy with this new business, new area restaurant option and takeover (of previously underwhelming Oldwick general store) that is a breath of life to this establishment. I have heard from others that they have good pizza but have never tried it. This is a good local breakfast or lunch option. read more

Update - food has greatly improved, baked goods especially scones are delicious; now for why the score of only 3; Recent 4th experience - went in to pick up two sandwiches and some baked goods, staff very friendly (no complaints here); I noticed the owner talking endlessy to the chef - poor guy he didn't want to be rude to his boss - but people started to queue up for their take out; I was wondering why it was lunch time and the place was empty - when I looked behind me, there were about 4 people waiting - really I don't need to hear about the owner's personal life - no complaints about the staff and food it is great, owner whoever you are - your staff is doing an awesome job - you're the problem; if you have to indulge in conversation turn around and say hello to your customers; we're not interested in seeing your back and your chef stopping every 10 seconds to listen to you (it's a no brainer - BTW - you finally ended your conversation with the chef and then when I did get my order, you were in the parking talking again with someone else; when I drove out of the lot, your car was behind me and you had to squeeze up next to my car to make the right turn (I did hear you were in a hurry - guess what so were your customers!!!!) read more

This used to be the Oldwick General Store. New owners renamed it to Oldwick Market, and gave the store and menu a new look. The sandwiches are absolutely outstanding. I had the Roast Pork with broccoli rabe, and it was tender, juicy and flavorful. It was delicious. I've also had the avocado toast, which is fantastic. Two large pieces. My husband got the standard Taylor Ham (not trying to start a Taylor Ham/pork roll fight), egg and cheese, and it was not standard at all. It was excellent. Maybe it was the roll, but it was really special. Can't wait to try the pizza and prepared meals, like chicken pot pie and quiche. Highly recommend the refurbished Oldwick Market. read more

The wife and I stopped in for a late breakfast at 10:00 and opted for an early lunch. This place is awesome. Great food prepared by great people with an obvious passion for quality ingredients. The place is clean, comfortable, and the perfect setting for a fine meal. I had the best pastrami sandwich of my life here. Thick cut, juicy and perfect balance of fat and lean. The fresh bake roll was awesome and crisp pickle with dill flavor. Sounds simple enough but clearly done with an appreciation for flavor and quality. If you are anywhere near this place you should check it out. Well above the standard of food available for miles. read more

Best and pizza around. Nice and thin crust good flavor sauce. Place is very friendly good sandwiches as well and make some nice thing is it's my go to place They make us crazy breakfast pizza every once a while which is delicious read more

Best sandwiches ever ! They cure their own meat. I had turkey which was incredible and enough to share, although I didn't. Made to order. Great coffee too. read more

This shop took over the prior general store used to make an amazing grilled cheese on rye, baked goods and salads. What is there now looks good but very generic. Gone are the famous baked goods of smile cookies, jelly cookies and pecan bars. Replaced with prepakaged junk. The grilled cheese is just basic. Even a chicken parmesan was just tasteless reheated chicken. This is no longer a place you drive miles to go to. Again it looks nice inside but totally fails at what it once was. I miss the general store and hope they take this feedback to bring some of what made that place great. As of now their food is basically 7/11 level and really why are you doing pizza?! Very disappointed. read more

After visiting this place several times and being disappointed this is my final review. The service is beyond terrible. Disinterested. poorly trained kids who don't know how to use the register. 10 minutes to place an order another 10 to get your food if you're lucky. Where is the owner? We live b close by. Would love to give a positive review. Instead this is my last visit unless ownership changes. Fantastic location, only place in the area. Huge opportunity missed. read more

Oldwick Market - oldwick market on the corner of a street - Pizza Near Me - Tewksbury, New Jersey

I remember the glory days of the Oldwick General store. Great egg sandwiches, deli, pancakes, you name it. But then management switched. It drastically changed to a place serving overpriced food on paper plates without half the ingredients. Then management switched again. The Oldwick Market. That name has a nice ring to it. And a fresh start. The interior finally looked clean and decent. The staff was new and friendly. This is promising! However, after a few months time...the Oldwick Market was no different than the Oldwick General store. The staff is slow and the word friendly is not in their vocabulary. I called in an order for a sandwich last week and it took 45 minutes for them to complete. No apologies...just excuses from a less than inviting staff. Food is overpriced and very average...wont be going back! If you have an extra hour to spare and are okay with burnt and mediocre food... then this is the place for you! P.S. the grumpy staff are lovely too... read more

We had our first take out family meal for 4 tonight. We had the short rib dinner. I have to say it was delightful. A healthy amount of quality food for a more than reasonable price. It's not just for lunch anymore!! They deserve our support especially right now. So go....you won't regret it! read more

Always enjoyed the previous restaurant that was in this location . I was recommended to check out the new Oldwick Market and was very impressed. The renovations look great and the food and service was very good. I stopped in on a weekday to get lunch takeout. Lots of orders were being called in but I was helped right away and my order ready in under 10 minutes. I got a sampling of items including a salad, sandwich, slice of pizza, a cookie and some quiche. Everything was very good but the quiche Lorraine was the best I have ever had! The prices were very reasonable for the quality and portions. Look forward to returning and checking out other menu items. read more